Among my Defining Moments are those I categorize as Ghosts I Bear Onward; wise elders and mentors whom I knew personally and who shaped me and left upon me their mark of strangeness.
We choose as our companions through life those who represent qualities and figures of human being, meaning, and value we wish to integrate in our becoming; those who perform roles we wish to step into.
Herein I number the conversations and personal relationships with those who became informing, motivating, and shaping sources for me as figures to grow into; first among them an influence of my childhood, Edward Albee, as I watched my father direct his plays and listened to their conversations.
From him I internalized an image of America as a network of systems of oppression and legacies of history we must escape and bring a Reckoning and change to through reimagination and transformation of how we choose to be human together, and of the universe, Absurd, meaningless, and often hostile, as an imposed condition of struggle.
With a title taken from the song Who’s Afraid of the Big Bad Wolf? in the 1933 Disney short film Three Little Pigs, where two of the pigs are convinced they’re safe from the wolf in their straw and twig houses, you know that threatening truths will undo the house of illusions George and Martha, emblematic founders of America, have built around themselves.
As written by Ben Brantley in The New York Times; “Mr. Albee has unsparingly considered subjects outside the average theatergoer’s comfort zone: the capacity for sadism and violence within American society; the fluidness of human identity; the dangerous irrationality of sexual attraction and, always, the irrefutable presence of death.”
In Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf, Edward Albee has given us the Great American Play, a mirror in which we see ourselves as we are rather than the illusions we have spun around and through ourselves as a defensive mask. It is about the historical and political consequences of a lie we told at our founding about freedom and equality in a government designed to leave structural power asymmetries of wealth, race, and gender untouched; about the human cost of dysfunctional relationships, and about the implications for meaning and being when the personal and political realms of action collide and change each other. This play is a masterpiece, and I think we should all watch the film in school before we go to vote for the first time.
In this context I think of America as represented in Edward Albee’s iconic play, Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf. My father directed some of his plays, and I listened intently to their conversations during rehearsals from a center front seat in the theatre, which interrogated Albee’s direct influences and references among his fellow Absurdists Samuel Beckett, Eugene Ionesco, Jean Genet, and Harold Pinter.
The line of transmission of Absurdist elements in literature originates with Fyodor Dostoevsky, Lewis Carroll, Nikolai Gogol, and Franz Kafka, diverges from the limits of Humanism with Antonin Artaud, Eugene Ionesco, Witold Gombrowicz, Albert Camus, Albee and his ilk as previously cited, diverged from the main tradition as Nihilism in Samuel Beckett, Thomas Ligotti, and Kobo Abe, and continues today in the works of Haruki Murakami, Kurt Vonnegut, and Elif Shafak.
Of my adventures as a theatre brat I shall recount here only one; during my father’s direction of The Sandbox my mother asked Edward Albee if she could have a picture taken with him, whereupon he pointed to the gallery along the theatre entrance and said, “Let’s take it in front of the Jackson Pollock; it looks like Martha’s mind.” For Edward Albee, whose works were among those I could recite verbatim at the age of four, literally as I used to sit in at rehearsals and give the actors their lines if someone forgot, the failure of order in both political and psychological terms was a symptom of Sartrean bad faith.
Here also Albee leads us through a labyrinth of mirrors, a funhouse of distorted images, both comical and grotesque, images which capture and reflect, assimilating or robbing us of our uniqueness in infinite regress to steal our souls, which through his magic of seeing our true selves becomes a Hobgoblin’s Broken Mirror as in in Anderson’s The Snow Queen, fragmented images which multiply our possibilities of becoming human.
I particularly like the following lines from Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf, laden with satire of our falsification through invented histories and authorized identities, and influential to Jean Baudrillard’s theory of simulacra;
“Martha: Truth or illusion, George; you don’t know the difference.
George: No, but we must carry on as though we did.
Martha: Amen.”
Do see the iconic 1966 film adaptation starring Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor; I used to show it to high school students on day one of American History.
And I would say in preface to the class; Here we see images of the history from which must emerge to become human as self-created and self-owned beings; histories which we drag behind us like invisible reptilian tails, with legacies of unequal power and multigenerational epigenetic trauma.
I want you to seize these images and reclaim them for your own. Always there remains the struggle between the masks we make for ourselves and those made for us by others. This is the first revolution in which we all must fight; the struggle for ownership of ourselves.
We are gathered here to study literature and history and our place in it, and to interrogate our informing, motivating, and shaping sources as stories, to perform the four primary duties of a citizen; Question Authority, Expose Authority, Mock Authority, and Challenge Authority, and to be what Foucault called truth tellers.
So, I have a film for you which models how to perform these roles, and this is where we will begin our study of American History, with the Original Lie which founded our nation. This is who we are, and it falls to each of us to make a better future than we have the past; to become a fulcrum, and change the balance of power in the world.
Such was my annual speech in preface to the study of American history.
Also informative and insightful, Stretching My Mind: The Collected Essays of Edward Albee, includes his ideas about Samuel Beckett, Eugene Ionesco, and Sam Shepherd, as well as autobiographical writings about his own life, work, and worldview.
Finally, written four decades after Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf, there is his last and greatest work, displaying the final form of his political psychology and an evolution of all the themes that have come before in his long career as a playwright, like a summa theologica of our time; The Goat, or Who Is Sylvia?
The Goat, or Who Is Sylvia? is a Greek tragedy in structure which employs the methods of comedy to subversive ends, about the uncontrollable, totalizing nature of love and passion as a bringer of chaos and renewer of the world, sweeping all before it like a tidal wave.
Nowhere in his cannon of work is Edward Albee’s intention more clear; to empower and liberate us both personally and politically. As an examination of Keats’ ideal of Love it is insightful and superb; as an extension and interrogation of the themes of Thomas Mann in Death in Venice and his reinterpreter Vladimir Nabokov in Lolita it is a brilliant satire and political fable. Herein he restates his primary insight; that life is a struggle for control and ownership of identity, the persona or mask that is worn in Greek theatre, between ourselves and our society.
As written by the Edward Albee Society, On The Goat of Who Is Sylvia?; “The play is about love, and loss, the limits of our tolerance and who, indeed, we really are.” Indeed, while bestiality is one of the many topics addressed in Albee’s play, the playwright’s main objective is more aligned with imagining ourselves “subject to circumstances outside our own comfort zones.”
In an interview with Charlie Rose focused on The Goat’s 2002 New York premiere, Albee stated, “Imagine what you can’t imagine. Imagine that, all of a sudden, you found yourself in love with a Martian, in love with something you can’t conceive of. I want everybody to be able to think about what they can’t imagine and what they have buried deep as being intolerable and insufferable. I want them to just think freshly and newly about it.”
Even the play’s title echoes this sense of multiplicity in terms of its meaning. Albee said in his interview with Charlie Rose, “A goat is two things. A goat is the animal, and, also, I believe a person can be a goat, the butt of a situation.” Florescu offers a more symbolic definition of the word goat: “Sylvia is everybody’s goat, ready to unleash our wildest desires, potentially dissolving, or, at least, diminishing the ravaging effects of our gregarious, unhealthy regimented selves.” Zinman suggests that the use of the term “goat” could also refer to “scapegoat”: “The goat is wholly innocent, victimized by Martin’s obsessive love and Stevie’s murderous revenge.” Yet, in an advertisement created by The Philadelphia Theatre Company for their production, a picture of a goat “with a snapshot of the play’s characters hanging out of its mouth, suggesting that a goat, who will, notoriously, eat anything, has devoured this family alive,” suggests the personification of the goat and, thus, Sylvia’s own responsibility for the events that take place. In addition, the name Sylvia, Zinman argues, references Shakespeare’s pastoral vision in Two Gentlemen of Verona.
As stated by Esbjornson, The Goat is ultimately meant to be a tragedy. Even the set he and John Arnone collaborated on had columns to provide a “classical quality to it, a Greek-tragedy quality.” Zinman states, “In ancient Greek tragedy, the hero, at the height of his happiness, often complacent in his smooth fortunate life, undergoes a sudden reversal of fortunes.” Indeed, once Martin confesses his affair to Ross, his fate is no longer his own. According to Aristotle, he must then “‘fall from a great height,’” which Martin does; he is reduced from an award-winning architect to a mere sexual deviant. Whereas Martin acts more as a tragic hero, Ross, on the other hand, takes the place of the chorus “representing the vox populi and of setting the wheels of tragedy in motion.”
Albee thinks a play can be called political only if “…it makes people think differently enough about things so that their life alters including their politics.” In order to make a difference in a contemporary society so accustomed to debunking generally accepted restrictions, Albee had to “…go even further afield than Nabokov to find a taboo still standing.” In Zinman’s opinion, Albee’s view is that sexuality is “…more complex, far wider, deeper, and less governable than we generally think.” Albee’s use of bestiality is meant to parallel society’s view of homosexuality which “appear[s] normal by comparison.” Gainor furthers her argument by stating that it is through bestiality that Martin “literalizes his extremity of alienation and longing.” By experiencing prejudice for his own sexual proclivities, Martin must “accept his son’s desires with equanimity, applying his newly gained insights on dominant and marginal practices.”
In this way, Martin and Billy can seek to rebuild their relationship. Robinson writes of The Goat: “Albee’s play insists that it is about something beyond a domestic crisis that can be cordoned off and concealed from the world – though it is about that too. We see that the personal is political, yes, but also something more: that what is private about our lives only comes to have meaning as we enter the public sphere and this public sphere enters us.” Ultimately, as Robinson states, The Goat is meant to affect both the micro and macro levels of society in a way that encourages progressive thinking even in uncertain times. “
And on Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, also from the EAS website; “George and Martha revel in the dissection of the truth and illusion that have kept them bound in their fiery marriage. The illusionary component of George and Martha’s relationship is best symbolized by their imaginary son. George, jarred by Martha’s breaking of their rule, decides to kill off or “exorcise” their son, thus explaining the significance of Act III’s title. Adler writes, “…George exorcises the child not only to kill the illusion and live in reality, but to destroy one reality—that in which he has failed to exercise the strength necessary to make the marriage creative even without children–and create a new reality to take its place. George, through mapping out for Nick and Honey the way to redirect their lives, achieves for Martha and himself a radical redirection of their own.” Unlike Martha and George who are universally acknowledged by critics as having married for love, Nick and Honey’s marriage was only initiated because of Honey’s pregnancy coupled by her father’s wealth. George tries to steer Nick and Honey away from the fate that he and Martha are currently battling: the use of illusion as a weapon against each other. Martha, too, as Hoorvash and Porgiv comment, “…senses that something is lacking, not merely in her marriage or her life, but also in the lives of everyone else.” Paolucci further asserts: “The younger couple mirror our own embarrassment and own public selves; Martha and George, our private anguish.” In an interview with Rakesh H. Solomon, Albee comments on George and Martha’s imaginary son as a metaphor for this profound discontentment: “There is a distinction between the death of a metaphor and the death of a real child. And the play for me is more touching and more chilling if it is the death of the metaphor.” George’s shattering of the illusion of his and Martha’s son is his answer to Martha’s desire for him to “…assert his strength” against her “…many masculine qualities…[which] feeds off of George’s emasculation.” The duality of George’s personality allows for a breadth of interpretations for actors. Albee comments: “‘Once you’ve played George in my play no other role with the possible exception of Hamlet will challenge you quite as much as far as magnitude of text, complexity of language and the challenge of working on many planes at the same time.’”
George and Martha’s inability to conceive also plays into the extended metaphor of Albee’s play, suggesting that “…sterility and fertility are simply metaphors for social stagnation and progress, respectively. George’s solution, rather, is closer to a religious one, which has always been part of the American ideology” Albee’s inspiration for Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? was the tumultuous state of American society during the 1960s. Dircks writes of Albee: “Albee saw an American society as sustaining itself on national illusions of prosperity and equality; here too, the situation demanded an honest confrontation of problems and a heightened state of communication.” Zinman, too, states, “Albee’s political and cultural agenda is woven into the characters’ preoccupations, and thus into the dialogue.” Thus, there can be no mistaking Albee’s allusion to George and Martha Washington, the first couple of the United States. Still, other critics attribute Albee’s inspiration to not just American politics but also to Virginia Woolf, herself, and her short story: “Lappin and Lapinova.
Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? remains an impactful script that speaks to universal conflicts each generation must face: Who are we? What do we represent? and What will our futures hold?”
Among the many funhouse mirror images which I have claimed as my own, my second in historical order and most sustained influence must be my great teacher whom I called Sifu Dragon, of martial arts, Chinese and Japanese languages, calligraphy, and poetry, the strategy game of wei-chi or go, Chan or Zen Buddhism and Taoism, with whom I studied for sixteen years from the age of nine, and who was my window to a larger world. As a result I grew up with four souls or voices and thinking in four languages, as I also studied French from seventh grade.
That last reference bears interrogation; during seventh grade I tested out of English classes through senior year of high school on AP and SAT exams given to me specially and IQ tests arranged by my parents and teachers who conspired to force me into and through high school and then to university early, which I absolutely refused as I felt I was being cast out for being a freak, but for one class, where I traded seventh grade English for Freshman French Literature and Language, a chance I fell upon with ravenous delight. The French teacher was a blonde goddess, and here think Miranda Richardson’s character of Rita Skeeter luring Harry Potter into the closet with the words “Youngest first!”, who motivated her students by offering a trip to Paris, with her, after graduation from high school for the best senior French student each year; competition for this honor was fierce, and I was a very, very good student. Thanks for the soft landing in high school, Miss Starling.
How I met Sifu Lung, my teacher of Chinese and Japanese language, literature, Zen, go, and martial arts, happened like this; I spent recess at school during fifth grade either playing chess with the Principal or experimenting with the chemistry set in the classroom, which doubtless seemed odd, unfriendly, and aloof to the other children whom I failed to play with. Someone retaliated by putting gum on my seat, which I found insulting and disrespectful, so during the next recess I poured some chemicals marked with skull and crossbones on the bottles down the spigot of the drinking faucet, reasoning that water pressure would let them pool in the u-tube just below so that everyone who went for a drink of water after recess would get a dose. That afternoon half a dozen kids were outside throwing up, and I felt not triumph but horror, because I realized I could have unintentionally killed everyone. I told my father about it that night.
To this my father replied; “You have discovered politics; this is about fear as the basis of human exchange and relationships. Most importantly, it is about the use of force.
Fear is an unreliable servant and a terrible master; those who use it to subjugate others are motivated by fear themselves, and if you can show them you do not fear them they will be afraid of you, and you can use it as a lever to win dominance. Fear is a ground of struggle. Fear precedes power. So, whose instrument will it be?
Fear, power, and the use of social force are balanced with the need to belong. Sometimes its best to do what others do to fit in, but it isn’t always best, and it can be very wrong. Best is to discover what’s best for you, no matter how different that is, and find belonging on your own terms and no one else’s. Even if you have to create that community yourself.
What you need is a way to confront people directly when you’re upset with them that doesn’t cause more problems than it solves.”
This was 1969 and he arranged for me to study with a Taoist priest, scholar of Zen Buddhism and traditional arts who had just escaped arrest during the Cultural Revolution in China, around the time the mob nearly dragged Chou En Lai, officially the leader of the Cultural Revolution and a friend and ally of my teacher since 1920 at the Whampoa Military Academy, into the street for execution.
I called him Sifu Lung, Teacher Dragon, because of a story he told on the day we met, a version of Plato’s Allegory of the Cave; I had been startled by the sudden fluid movement of his enormous shadow, like a flight of silent birds, in the still room of his study through moon gate doors which like a gaping mouth opened into the chasms of darkness of a gorgeous pillared temple illuminated only by the many incense sticks which glowed like eyes of fire. And I asked, “Why is your shadow so huge? And it moves.”
“Once we were dragons,” he began, “we were vast, without end or beginning, and we filled the universe. But when humans came there was no place for them, and they could not see us all at once; so we became small, lost our greatness, and found ways to share our world. We abandoned eternity and the rapture of the heavens for the stewardship of humankind, who refuse to venture out of their cages and discover what lies beyond their boundaries.
But you can see me because your cage has not yet been built, and because we are alike in our powers of vision and illusion. This suggests possibilities. So I will teach you how to fight as you wish, but also how to grow beyond your limits and find your greatness.”
Next would be the family storyteller and unofficial uncle of my boyhood, William S. Burroughs, with his bizarre tales of magical battles, adventures in strange realms, and of monstrous and wonderful beings, a friend of my father who was an underground theatre director in San Francisco and a collector of unusual people.
Of Burroughs I have written in celebration; a pivotal figure of my youth, one of my father’s Beatnik friends who among the writers, artists, musicians, and film and theatre people he collected was all of those as well as a magician and scholar of the occult, and a wise and kindly mentor.
An encyclopedic and phantasmagorical body of work, full of dark satire, science fiction tropes, chaos, magic, songs of anarchy and freedom, and a beautiful unbounded transgression, William S. Burroughs wove revolutionary socio-political insights together with the glorious madness of Dionysian ecstatic vision.
Combining in his person Existentialism and Surrealism, his work is driven by two great themes; rebellion against Authority and the dream quest of a magician to become a god.
The first of these themes being Sartrean Authenticity and a Promethean rebellion versus Control, a personification of all forms of thought control and normalcy, referential to Camus, Genet, Nietzsche, the English Romantics, de Sade, and most of all Georges Bataille, whose post-Freudian analysis of sociocultural forces and institutions, developed within the theoretical framework of Levi-Strauss and structural anthropology, indict Authority as a means of dehumanizing and shaping us into the tools of our own governmental, religious, and economic enslavement. The influence of Bataille on William S. Burroughs cannot be overstated.
His second major theme is ecstatic vision and transcendence as a path of liberation from the material world, a sublimity achieved through the derangement of the senses; sex, drugs, violence, and the pursuit of the extreme and the bizarre. As in the early novels of his direct model Jean Genet, a major theme in this is the seizure of power and authenticity through transgression of the Forbidden.
This includes the many magical subterfuges and arcane disciplines he practiced, first among them being the cut-up method of randomization to reveal hidden truths invented with Brion Gysin and intended as a ritual of prophecy derived from the I Ching, the inspiration for which Burroughs once told me was Leibniz’s famous claim to have invented binary mathematics when reading the I Ching in his hunting lodge in Bavaria when he had the primary insight that the whole universe can be constructed of combinations of one and zero. The Burroughs family fortune which funded his excesses came from the invention of an adding machine, and it shows in his writing.
The works of William S. Burroughs may first be read as an interrogation of the four principles of Leibniz, Non-Contradiction, the Identity of Indiscernibles, the Principle of Sufficient Reason, and the Principle of Bivalence, as illuminated in the conversations of Aristotle, al Farabi, Avicenna, Aquinas, Kant, Russell, Wittgenstein, Carroll, and Korzybski, and playing the other side of the board Heraclitus, Nagarjuna, al Ghazali, and Hui Shi.
Second is the technique of juxtaposition developed from Tristan Tzara’s Dada and Monet’s principle; “Man has two eyes through which he sees the world; one looks outward, and the other looks inward, and it is the juxtaposition of these two images which creates the world that we see.”
Here with juxtaposition is a praxis of his values in the second dimension of Burrough’s thought, his context within the lineage of Romantic Idealism; Prometheus and Milton’s rebel angel, Shakespeare in The Tempest, Byron and his sources Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, and Friedrich von Schiller, then Mary Shelly’s Frankenstein, Keats, Blake, and Coleridge, Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights, Melville’s Moby Dick, and Nietzsche’s Thus Spake Zarathustra.
Third we must recognize that William S. Burroughs is primarily a mystic and Surrealist, obsessed with experiments with telepathy, precognition, shapeshifting, out of body travel to other dimensions and times, curses and psychic conflicts with malign and alien forces which reflect those of H.P. Lovecraft, and a unique and personal spiritism akin to that of voodoo which I would call Jungian shadow work. In this aspect he resembles Philip K Dick, prophet of the transhuman, Carl Gustave Jung and Vladimir Nabokov in Ada, and all of his fellow Surrealists.
Of direct influences among Surrealists we must count Djuna Barnes’ Nightwood, Rene Daumal’s Mount Analogue, Ionesco’s Rhinoceroses, Jarry’s Exploits and Opinions of Dr. Faustroll, Pataphysician, Reverdy’s The Thief of Talant, Michel Leiris‘ Nights as Day, Days as Night, and Journey to the End of the Night by Louis-Ferdinand Céline.
As to his language and style we must trace his origins in the Surrealist poets and their influences and references; Charles Baudelaire, Arthur Rimbaud, and de Lautréamont, Stéphane Mallarmé and Guillaume Apollinaire, Paul Éluard, René Char, and Phillip Lamantia.
All of William S. Burroughs’ works may be read as conceptual art representing surrealist films in the tradition of Cocteau, Artaud, Dali, David Lynch, Wim Wenders, Tim Burton, Alejandro Jodorowsky, and Guillermo del Toro.
He began along this path as a child when he became the avatar of a chthonic being conjured by his Welsh nanny in the rite of Calling the Toad; and thereafter sought transformation and transcendence in forms ever more strange. This he claimed was the toad that Nietzsche feared he must swallow, which was transferred to him as a spirit guardian and oracle of wisdom, a succession of bearership as a mystery initiation into which he inducted me through storytelling as ritual. Upon each completion we would recite together Prospero’s line in Act V, Scene 1 of William Shakespeare ’s The Tempest; “This thing of darkness I acknowledge mine”.
This canon of stories, possibly invented on the spot and told over some time intermixed with fabulous and strange versions of Grimm’s Fairytales, now seems to me similar in intent to Ted Hughes’ reimaginations of mythology attempting to construct and reawaken a lost faith. He never wrote them down, unfortunate as unlike his books they were suitable for young adults if not children and coherent in a way his novels, constructed of episodes he called turns as in vaudeville acts, are not. One day I may do so for him.
I wrote my first story, Dream of the Toad, when I was twelve and immersed in Frazier’s Golden Bough and other myths, folklore, and fairytales, inspired by the wonderful stories he told of growing up stepping back and forth between our world and a parallel, magical one, filled with living figures from fairytales and myths in delightfully bent and off-center versions of their stories, as he and my father played chess of an evening and the coals of the fire burned low, enveloping us in the gathering darkness.
To me, William S. Burroughs will always be a kindly and urbane but tormented gentleman, a Trickster figure and Guide of the Soul, bearer of hidden signs and wounds, a charming rascal and unofficial uncle steeped in classical literature he could recite from memory, full of mischief and secrets and whom you could trust with your own.
Years after his time as a figure in our home, I first read his books as a teenager immersed in the grimoires of medieval magic, James Joyce’s Finnegan’s Wake, and Ludwig Wittgenstein’s Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus as guides to universal principles of creating ourselves through language, when I discovered the stunning vistas of his transgression and disruption of gender, as he had never said or signaled anything inappropriate within my sight or hearing as a child. So also with his anarchism and reimagination of Marx in fiction as the Algebra of Need.
He always liked my Dream Labyrinth wall, a floor to ceiling collage of Hieronymus Bosch and other strange images opposite my bed which I changed and elaborated constantly throughout my teenage years. Bizarre drawings like cinematic storyboards would be found added after his mysterious arrivals and departures. He loved illusions, grand entrances and ghostly exits, and above all humor, by which to keep the world off balance and step nimbly by its obstacles.
His books are also a Dream Labyrinth, which together form maps of the unknown and of possibilities of human meaning and being, as well as topologies of transformation as a Hall of Mirrors.
William S. Burroughs remains an important vehicle of transmission of the whole western mystery tradition, indebted as he is to Philippe Soupault for his interpretation of William Blake and to Georges Bataille for his interpretation of Nietzsche and Freud.
One can also speak of Burroughs the magician of poetic vision and ecstatic trance in terms of Dionysius and Orpheus, and the literature of ceremonial magic as was Jung, immersed in Gnosticism, Theosophy, Rosicrucian occultism, Egyptian mythology, shamanism, tarot as he gave me my first deck of cards which I have to this day and taught me their use, I Ching, Kabbalah, alchemy, and all of this through Aleister Crowley whom he claimed as a source of discipleship and interpreted through his direct model, H.P. Lovecraft, of whom he once said; ”I wish Lovecraft wrote fiction. Some truths are too terrible to invoke by their names.”
Burroughs’ conspiracy of Venusian insects to conquer humankind through drug addiction as a metaphor of capitalism, summarized in his formulation of Marxism as The Algebra of Need, is an appropriation of Lovecraft. The master and his disciple were also both serious scholars of the occult obsessed with dark magic, who saw in mysticism a tradition of counterculture and dissent, as with the martyrdom of the Templars and the heroic Jacques DeMolay. In the words of the character John Constantine in the telenovela Legends of Tomorrow; “Magic lets you break the rules.”
Naked Lunch is a masterpiece and classic of literature; Junky and Queer are among his other autobiographical novels modeled on those of Jean Genet. Like those of Genet, his stories are parodies and subversions of sacred rituals intended to liberate us from authority and free the creative imagination to forge an authentic humankind.
The Nova Trilogy: The Soft Machine, The Ticket That Exploded, and Nova Express, further explores addiction as a metaphor of social control and the destructive nature of capitalism. His idea of the Ugly American as a malign intrusive alien entity and force which must be exorcised parallels and is referenced by Malcolm X’s personification of heroin addiction as a White Man who must be cast out.
One of the most accessible of his works is his book on the gangster Dutch Schultz, a dialectical journal in the classical form of a Jesuit report recording the actual last words of the gangster in one column and Burroughs’s commentary in the other- complete with cinematography notes.
America, a trilogy including Cities of the Red Night, The Place of Dead Roads, and The Western Lands, a triumph of Surrealism in epic form and a masterpiece, has a clarity of prose and the imprint of a master artist at the summit of his powers. As a prank I once switched them for the actual American History textbooks in a high school class; strangely no one objected as I had hoped and I had to go right on teaching through the semester with it as myths of national identity. I think we had more fun with this subject than is usual.
The Revised Boy Scout Manual is a brilliant parody and a manual of anarchist revolt and the overthrowing of governments. Along with T.E. Lawrence’s Seven Pillars of Wisdom it is among the finest classics of direct action and guerrilla warfare one might consult.
The Cat Inside is a delightful and precious allegory of freedom and rebellion, a meditation on values which extends Nietzsche’s analysis of master- slave psychology to a philosophy of anarchist liberation, which references Nietzsche’s interpreters Karl Jaspers, Maurice Blanchot, C.G. Jung, and Gilles Deleuze.
The Wild Boys envisions feral youths in rebellion against the Authority that created them, a dystopian future in which man’s animal nature has been betrayed by civilization but which also has the power to redeem him, the final part of his Anarchist trilogy which extends his recurrent theme of werewolves as symbolic of our essential wildness and unconquerable nature and a type of Nietzschean Superman; beyond good and evil. As he wrote it during the period of his visits, I have often wondered how much of it was drawn from my father’s ideas and the claim of our family history that we are not human but werewolves, and had been driven out of Europe for that reason; Martin Luther referred to my ancestors as Drachensbraute, Brides of the Dragon, and we were driven out of Bavaria in 1586 at the beginning of a forty-four year period of witchcraft persecutions. He was writing it during the Stonewall Riots, which may be a more direct context as a fictionalization of the witness of history. It is also filled with episodes from the glory days of his youth and set in Mexico and Morocco as imaginal realms.
When I asked him, at the age or nine or ten, if I was in his book and what he was writing about, he said; “Freedom, nature as truth and civilization as addiction to wealth and power and theft of the soul, and how our pasts get mixed up with our futures.”
The Wild Boys reimagines The Egyptian Book of the Dead, of which fellow Surrealist and poet Philip Lamantia was a scholar, also the subject of his final novel The Western Lands as is H. P. Lovecraft’s The Dream Quest of Unknown Kadath, references Octave Mirbeau, Bataille, Genet, and extends de Sade and Rousseau’s ideal of the natural man as uncorrupted by civilization and unlimited by its boundaries, as truths immanent in nature and written in our flesh, in a reversal of Freud’s ideology of civilization as restraint of our nature. David Bowie created his character of Ziggy Stardust based on The Wild Boys; Anthony Burgess’s A Clockwork Orange and H.G. Wells’ The Island of Doctor Moreau here mingle and intertwine.
The Black Rider: the casting of the magic bullets, a theatrical collaboration with director Robert Wilson & the magnificent Tom Waits, is a can’t miss.
Exterminators collects thirty short stories, the Collected Interviews 1960-1997 edited by Lotringer are fascinating, as is The Adding Machine: essays.
Interzone is a travel journal, but only on the surface to the Marrakesh of Beatnik glory, as it also recounts the Lovecraftian plot to enslave humanity through heroin by fascist insects from Venus.
All the works of William S. Burroughs are masterpieces of Anarchist liberation and transgression, Surrealism and occult mysticism, even if difficult because they are told in collages of random and nonlinear episodes, with an iconography that is bizarre and obscene. In spite and possibly because of this, they remain among the great classics of world literature, revealing endless chasms of darkness and infinite possibilities of rapture and illumination.
All true art defiles and exalts.
Go ahead; swallow the toad.
Thereafter follows a chance encounter of my university years which became decisive in the direction of my life, Susan Sontag who was a kind of muse and provocateur.
One unforgettable afternoon, as a young university student lingering in museum, I found myself standing before an incomprehensible painting lost in thought when I became aware of someone very close behind me, out of sight, also silent.
Several minutes must have passed before the presence spoke, asking “What do you see?” I forget how I answered, but as I moved to turn away and find something easier to behold (it may have been I need something easier) hands delicately lighted on my shoulders, almost not there, but fixing me in place, pinioned before my subject.
And she said, “Look again”.
This was Susan Sontag, who remained the afternoon to discuss art and other subjects, shifting topics without warning to unrelated fields, epigrammatic statements, bizarre quotations, and somehow bringing it all together in devastating insights, a dazzling and bewildering conversation, with eyes that could see right through a thing to its heart, intimate and not a little terrifying.
She spoke as if she were a hyperdimensional being, unbounded by time and space and assembling collages of meaning from disparate realms. I’m not surprised people had difficulty following her narratives, but it was always worth the effort to understand.
For she will always be with us, a presence just out of sight, saying “Look again”.
This, the moment of our first encounter, occurred sometime after her 1980 publication of Under the Sign of Saturn, by some measure a final and apex achievement of her revisioning of humankind, and before my September 1982 conversations over strawberry crepes at breakfast with Jean Genet, in Beirut after my spring semester of gourmet travel studying the culinary arts, mainly in France and Italy, became a summer of resistance to the Israeli invasion and siege.
In Susan Sontag I discovered a fellow in the adoration of Wagner and the opera in general but also of David Bowie, and in the uncommon vice of being both a classicist and a radical postmodernist influenced by French theory in apprehension and inclination regarding literature and the arts, academic tribes often siloed and unable to comprehend or discuss works beyond their own specializations. Susan transgressed boundaries, curious about everything as was I, and there never was a better companion with whom to solve unknowns or parse meaning from the shock of the new, whether in art, music, film, or literature, than Susan Sontag, for unlike Nietzsche she said yes to life, and refused nothing.
She it was who signaled for me a reframing of dialectical struggle in humanistic terms; the self is literally a persona or theatrical mask, and the first revolution in which we all must fight is the struggle between the masks we make for ourselves and those made for us by others.
Susan Sontag referred to the differences between a thing and its image as the creative potential between bounded realms, a theme which runs through all her works and accounts for her interest in pop art and photography. I describe this as Chaos or the adaptive range of the system of self and society.
Could I but wield the power of wishes I would grant us all her transparency of insight and the ability to transform ourselves and our world through imaginative vision, to make of life a work of art. Each of us must find this for ourselves.
Her collections of essays, which source Georges Bataille and Maurice Blanchot for her aesthetics and ideology of Art, especially in the reinterpretation of Nietzsche, include Against Interpretation, Styles of Radical Will, Under the Sign of Saturn, Where The Stress Falls, and the monumental On Photography, together a superb introduction to American arts & letters, as I think they shall remain for some time.
Less known are her novels, which I now review.
The Benefactor is a masterpiece which explores homosexuality as both identity and desire and describes coming out as an escape from a Dream of Mirrors. A deconstruction of Freud by way of Gaston Bachelard and others, it provides a tour of critical theory and applies the methods of Derrida and Foucault, the philosophy of Sartre and de Beauvoir, and the aesthetics and mystical dream quest of Surrealism to issues of gender, sex, and power.
Death Kit is a metafictional novel of polyphonous layered images, cleaving tightly to the model of Camus, and references Maurice Blanchot as he faced mock execution by the Nazis in 1944 as an existential crisis.
The Volcano Lover presents literary history as an unfolding of intention through the lives of its characters. Time, memory, history, and the struggle for meaning and self ownership are among the interdependent constellation of themes which echo those of Vladimir Nabokov, and like his explorations of them Susan Sontag’s works can be read as teleological questioning of the nature of being, of the cosmic fate and order of the universe and its meaning, and of our place in it.
In America explores possible reinventions of ourselves and our nation. Read it together with its companion work, Philip K. Dick’s alternate universe puzzle The Man in the High Tower; they are metaphysical and ideological topologies which Janus-like present very different faces of the same Surrealist quest.
An icon of the magisterial arbiter of culture as well as the literary rebel and a type of the New York Intellectual, arguably the last of her kind in the latter case as she seems to have overthrown herself and the authority of her own class, Susan Sontag is a universal reference known to all as the woman who monkeywrenched hierarchies of aesthetic value and leveled high art with pop culture, legitimizing Warhol’s Factory among other revolutionary acts.
And she argues that the historical memory from which identity grows is undergoing a massive transformational change from a literary-linguistic to a photographic-visual basis, from words to images, and represents a shift in human consciousness comparable to the invention of language. She wrote at the dawn of a new humanity as its Pythian seer, and like the original mythic figure was not always understood or believed.
As to the painting, an abstraction of a classical Japanese koi pond, my answer at second look was “Movement- these forms are in a series of states of transition, with the symbols alongside, not ideograms but where one might expect a poem, acting as time marks like in a musical score. This is an allegory of change.”
To which she said, “Yes it is! Who are you? Oh, I’m Susan.”
I reached out to shake hands during introductions; she took my hand, and did not let it go.
Finally there was Jean Genet who swore me to the Oath of the Resistance during the Siege of Beirut in the first of many Last Stands.
As I wrote in my celebration of his birthday; Among the great iconoclasts and poets of liberation, Jean Genet became himself a figure of the Rebel so anointed by Sartre; but also he is a Saint and mystic whose fictionalized autobiographies are filled with Catholic, Gnostic, and Classical symbolism and themes, Jungian archetypes, and references to Romantic Idealism and Surrealism.
As did Keats, he chronicles a voyage of discovery in search of Love and Beauty as Platonic Ideals which are both transcendent and immanent in nature; passions which transport us beyond our limits as ecstatic vision and their values and hidden principles which are truths written in our flesh.
His was the red flag of revolution; Jean Genet directly worked with the Black Panthers, the anticolonialist rebels of Algeria, Communist and other Antifascist groups in America and Europe, and for the freedom of the Palestinians. In many ways both his career as a revolutionary and his literary works parallel those of Albert Camus.
But interdependent with his political work as an agent of change is that of a visionary whose mission is to regenerate the world. In the Surrealist works of Jean Genet do the forces of conservatism and revolution intertwine like the twin serpents of Asclepius, god of healing dreams.
The Thief’s Journal is a classic of world literature and a universal reference, the usual entrance to his world of ideas. Jean Genet describes herein his youthful wanderings throughout Europe, his burglaries constructed as parodies and inversions of Catholic religious rituals and of authorized Ideals. Both his homosexual relationships and his crimes against class and property are transgressive acts of revolutionary liberation in a grand subversive campaign of freedom.
Yet concealed within this contextual glove is a heroic quest for meaning and a rebellion in the Romantic tradition; to smash through the mask of illusions and seize the true and naked Infinite in its splendor. As did Ahab, Victor Frankenstein, Milton’s rebel angel, and Prometheus, Jean Genet sought to cast down false idols and rekindle the sacred fire.
All of these figures, images, myths, and sources of iconography appear throughout the early Great Books of Jean Genet, along with themes and ideas from Blake, Coleridge, Virginia Woolf’s Orlando; a symbology and thematic system which reveals a deeply learned scholarship.
In this quest Jean Genet enacts and references Nietzsche’s Zarathustra and an immersion in the ecstatic Dionysian principle from The Birth of Tragedy, his interpretation of which is informed by Carl Gustave Jung’s lectures published as Nietzsche’s Zarathustra from the 86 seminars he chaired over 11 university terms on the great poem, and on the nuanced and erudite revisioning of Nietzsche by Maurice Blanchot.
Of his numerous influences and references, his works await the great scholar who will annotate them and restore their place among the canon of literature and their relevance to our lives; so also with the geniuses who were influenced by him, including among them William S. Burroughs with whom he is intertwined like a secret twin or the faces of Janus.
Our Lady of the Flowers, a prison journal which is also a descent into a Dantesque underworld narrated by his alter-ego, a female identified character named Divine, for whom the muse of John Waters named themself, who is both Beatrice as guide of the soul and the pilgrim figure as holy spirit and Bride of God. It is a Gnostic-Jungian text full of medieval symbolism and classical references, which describes parallel narratives of Persephone’s myth and the alchemical regeneration of the fallen world through the sapientia dei. In short, it is an unheralded masterpiece which draws ideas from the Divine Comedy and reimagines the whole western tradition of occult religious mysticism as a unified system of thought, and a map of the rebirth of civilization and the human spirit.
Of his plays, The Balcony is a stunning satire of power structures as ritualized role playing in a brothel’s hall of mirrors, and The Blacks explores race and identity as a game of masks in a furious condemnation of white privilege.
Treasures of the Night: collected poems is both beautiful and wonderfully subversive and dangerous, a call of beckoning sirens. Who among us has not heard that call, and ventured forth into the ravishing darkness?
The Declared Enemy collects his political essays, while Fragments of the Artwork does the same for his writings on art.
Prisoner of Love is a memoir of the two years he spent in Palestinian refugee camps in 1970-72, as well as the Beige of Beirut, and a final meditation on being an Outsider and the meaning of rebellion. Though he doesn’t mention me in the book, as apparently I am utterly forgettable in such a life of adventures, I will never forget our conversations at breakfast during the Fall of Beirut to the Israeli siege in the last days before his capture, for this is where he swore me to the oath of the Resistance and set me on my life’s path of struggle for liberty against tyranny and autocracies of state force and control, for equality against racist injustice, and against the fascism which combines both tyranny and white supremacist terror.
I have been engaged in revolutionary struggle, in the resistance to fascism and tyranny, and in the quest for our liberty and democracy, since the summer of 1982 when my culinary explorations were so rudely interrupted by the Israeli invasion of Lebanon and the Siege of Beirut, and I will resist injustice til the end. To all masters and tyrants in all worlds now and yet undreamed, I say with Ahab; “To the end I will grapple with thee.”
With the streets suddenly filled with Israeli soldiers running amok in a sack of murder, arson, and other vileness of terror and inhumanity, and the discovery of our only weapon being the bottle of champagne we had just finished with our strawberry crepes, I asked my breakfast companion if he had any ideas. To this he replied with an apologetic shrug and another question, “Fix bayonets?”
We laughed, and he elaborated; “When all hope is lost, we are free to do impossible things, glorious things.” This advice I find necessary to recall from time to time, and which I recommend to you all.
Then he asked, “Will you surrender?’
To which I replied, “No.”
“Nor I,” he said, standing. “As I share with you now, pass to others at need; this is an oath I devised in 1940 from the one I took as a Legionnaire, for the resistance to the Nazi occupation. It may be the finest thing I ever stole.”
And so I offer to all of you the Oath of the Resistance as it was given to me by Jean Genet in a burning house, in a lost cause, in a time of force and darkness, in a last stand and an act of defiance beyond hope of victory or survival; “We swear our loyalty to each other, to resist and yield not, and abandon not our fellows.”
Among our last words to each other were these; I asked ; “What do I do with my life, when everything we think we know is untrue? How do I live, when the world is a lie?”
To which he replied, paraphrasing his famous line in Miracle of the Rose; “Live with grandeur.”
So for the informing, motivating, and shaping forces which forged me as I grew up and became who I chose to be, like all humans a self created being who has assimilated qualities through direct transmission and successorship from those who offered aspirational selves and identities.
Are we not the stories we tell about ourselves, to ourselves and others?
Edward Albee, a reading list
Stretching My Mind: The Collected Essays of Edward Albee, Edward Albee
Primal fairytales and narratives of revolutionary intent; Margaret Atwood is a goddess of Liberty who comes bearing ax and torch to free us from our cages.
While teaching her books I always referred to her as the greatest writer of the 20th century because her novels recapitulate and transform the whole history of civilization, though in this she is not unique.
Working from the deepest stratum of our collective psyche, Margaret Atwood’s reimaginations of Grimm’s fairytales and other sources offer a Socratic criticism of the forces operating from those texts, an art of protest and of empowerment.
If you need a wrecking crew to smash the patriarchy, Margaret Atwood’s novels should be in your toolkit. Let’s unpack her sources and references a bit; for greater detail see Sharon Rose Wilson’s The Fairytale Sexual Politics of Margaret Atwood.
Cat’s Eye presents a narrator, Elaine Risley, who is a trapped Rapunzel in a world of ghosts, witches, cruel stepsisters, vanishing princes, and a merciful fairy godmother. The story draws ideas mainly from Anderson’s Snow Queen and Grimm’s Rapunzel, secondarily from Anderson’s Ice Maiden and Grimm’s Girl Without Hands.
Fearful door images echo Grimm’s Fitcher’s Bird; Risley’s dreams and visions are filled with images from medieval art, paintings of the Annunciation, Ascension, and the Virgin. The Hobgoblin’s fragmented mirror in The Snow Queen provides a metaphor of Atwood’s vision; mirrors, cameras, things that reflect but also capture and distort.
Of her characters, Cordelia from Shakespeare’s King Lear is among her finest; Mrs. Sneath is a cannibal goddess who resembles Baba Yaga and is linked to the figure of cat-headed Maat in this story. Maat is a dual aspected Egyptian goddess of motherhood but also a lioness and fierce hunter in her form as Sekmet.
Thematically Cat’s Eye is an investigation of the Rapunzel Syndrome; the wicked witch who imprisons her, the tower she is trapped in, a rescuer. Margaret Atwood’s driving conflicts are female-female, though her plots foreground sexual power and its political reflections.
Life Before Man offers The Wizard of Oz, The Nutcracker ballet, Anderson’s Snow Queen, a host of tales from Grimm including The Girl Without Hands, Rapunzel, Cinderella, Little Red Cap, Fitcher’s Bird, and The Robber Bridegroom. Secondary intertexts include Wilde’s Salome, Dante’s Inferno, Ovid’s Metamorphosis, Coleridge’s Kublai Khan, Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland, Irving’s Sleepy Hollow, and Mother Goose rhymes, mainly Little Miss Muffet. It’s a sort of Grand Tour of our civilization and the history of our private inner space and the disastrous and grotesque ways we collide with each other. Also, wonderful and illuminating reading.
Interlunar reimagines Cocteau’s Orphee, the ballet Giselle, both the Grimm and Anne Sexton version of The White Snake, and the paintings of Hieronymus Bosch. Motifs include death, pestilence, filth, eating, power, the journey, healing, hands, blindness and vision. Themes of guilt and shame, love, destruction, sacredness, creation, fertility, and metamorphosis are to be found in this richly imagined novel. I have used it as a sacred text and source of ritual immersion in dreams and poetic vision for our modern Orphic festival on Mad Hatter Day, not entirely as satire.
The Edible Woman is a linked text with The Handmaid’s Tale; do read both together. Herein the main embedded stories are Hansel & Gretel, The Gingerbread Boy, Goldilocks, Alice in Wonderland, Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, and Rapunzel, and her protagonist Marion plays all of these roles as well as those of Little Red Cap, the Robber Bride, and Fitcher’s bride.
The Handmaid’s Tale gives a voice to Bilhah, the Biblical Handmaid, revisions Little Red Riding Hood as an extension of Angela Carter’s The Company of Wolves, and tells the story of the Christian disempowerment of the Goddess and thew civilizational shift to Patriarchy as a theocratic system of oppression at the dawn of mass slave agriculture, priest-kings, and city-states following the Maria Gimbutas theory as presented in the great film The Red Shoes.
Margaret Atwood’s parodies of Grimm operate on three levels; thematic, images and motifs, and narrative structure. In The Handmaid’s Tale, we have themes of family and especially female-female conflict, gender and sexual power asymmetries, and the initiation and heroic journey. Motifs and images include dismemberment, cannibalism, fertility, labyrinths and paths, and all manner of disturbing sexual violence. Plot devices include a variety of character foils, doppelgangers, disguises and trickery of stolen and falsified identity.
Among Margaret Atwood’s Great Books, The Handmaid’s Tale is a universally known reference both because it has been taught for over a generation in every high school in America as a standard text and because of the extraordinary television series, arguably the most important telenovela ever filmed. We teach it for the same reasons the show is popular; a visceral and gripping drama with unforgettable characters, a mesmerizing plot of liberation struggle, and an immediate and accessible story which empowers and illuminates.
It depicts the brooding evil and vicious misogyny of Christianity and Fascism as two sides of the dynamic malaise of authority as patriarchy and tyranny, sexual and racial terror institutionalized as religion and state, as drawn directly from Arthur Miller’s The Crucible and Hawthorne’s Scarlet Letter, but also from contemporary culture as it contains satires of identifiable public figures, organizations, and events. Serena is based on Phyllis Schlafly, and Gideon is the nation of Pat Robertson and the fundamentalists who seized control of the Republican Party in 1980 around the time of the novel’s writing; Margaret Atwood’s motive in part was to sound an alarm at the dawn of the Fourth Reich and the coming Age of Tyrants as threats to global democracy.
It remains to be seen whether the forces of tyranny or of liberty will prevail in the end. Each of our lives is a contest between these forces, our private struggles reflected in the society and human civilization we share.
And this is the great lesson and insight of Margaret Atwood; each of us is both a Handmaid and a Serena, trapped within the skin of the other. She locates the primary conflict within ourselves, and transposes the Jungian conflict with the Shadow in terms of sex, gender, and power.
Margaret Atwood carries forward the pioneering work of Angela Carter in the feminist revisioning of fairytales and restoring history’s silenced female voice which founded one of the most exciting and diverse subgenres of literature, as the standard bearer of a generation of authors.
Her subversion and provocation of Authority in her chosen role as the Jester of King Lear, Promethean guardian of humanity and thief of the sacred fire is magnificent and epic; through her politicized literary performances and rebellions she became a figure of the goddess of Liberty who by the seizure of power restores the balance of the world.
These are fine and meritorious victories to have won; future generations of girls who expect to be the heroes of their own stories and become women who bear the torch of freedom in their turn may count Margaret Atwood among the ancestors and protectresses who first discovered a way through the Labyrinth to a self-owned and self-creating identity. But to me her greatest achievement is neither literary nor political, but in her third sphere of action; that of psychology.
In works which parallel those of the classicist James Hillman, she reimagines Jungian archetypal psychology in ways which treat persons as stories, a complex and shifting dynamism of motivating and informing sources, as texts which shape our histories and ourselves and become the key relation between memory and identity. And she does this while questioning the second-order relations, sociopolitical forces and structures.
So, a radical new psychology of liberation which operates by poetic and mythic rules, stewardship of a new literature which describes those rules and provides stories as case studies, and a praxis or action of her values which formulates the political consequences of her ideology as a holistic system of Humanist philosophy which extends that of Simone De Beauvoir. Her triadic configuration of psychology, politics, and literature, each reinforcing and interdependent with the others, is a unique, brilliant, and powerfully transformational theory of identity, art, and the meaning and value of being human.
The Handmaid’s Tale series trailer
Moments in History That Inspired The Handmaid’s Tale
Among my treasures where live the voices of my cherished companions through life which rest bound in leather or cloth, gilded and illustrated and written in strange inks or simply printed on creamy paper and smelling of vanilla and old saddles, histories of our conversations across vast gulfs of time and space awaiting the moment I need them again, lies brooding a symbol of the unknowability of the Infinite and the Conservation of Ignorance, the Sefer ha-Zohar or Book of Splendor.
Heart of the Kabbalah written by Moses de Leon in Spain and first published about 1275, I discovered this single volume edition in our family library, wedged between Encyclopaedia Britannica and the University of Chicago’s Great Books of the Western World series as a teenager while reading through both in their entirety over several years, and claimed it as my own.
This was during an enthusiasm which began as a high school Freshman for Ludwig Wittgenstein’s Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus and his disciple James Joyce’s attempt to reinvent humankind through a new universal language in Finnegans Wake, and I recognized immediately that Kabbalah was a project of like intent, within the context of Tikkun Olam or Repair of the World.
Written in a secret language? And filled with bizarre and utterly ambiguous symbols and metaphors? Of course I loved it.
That it was a forgery written for profit by a charlatan and reimagined by a madman just made it better in my eyes. This is the real book fictionalized by Lovecraft as the Necronomicon.
But like the visions of the Infinite and the alam al mythal it contains, the Book of Splendor remained beyond my grasp, dancing in and out of my awareness like a shifting fire of darkness and light. That which fascinated, intrigued, and compelled also warded questioning and ultimately escaped me; printed as it was written not in Hebrew for which I might have found a teacher but in a coded scholar’s cryptodialect of Aramaic and Andalusi Romance, a precursor of Spanish and Portuguese which uses Arabic script, languages which remained opaque to me. And even if translated one must be thoroughly familiar with the symbolic system it references in the Talmud and Midrash before Kabbalah becomes comprehensible. This was the only thing I ever gave up on, entangled with the Moebius Loop of language like Ahab lashed to the whale by the lines of his harpoon in his mad quest to break through the mask to the Infinite; though I read Gershom Scholem’s foundational study Kabbalah when it was published during my Freshman year of high school in 1974.
Languages allow us to think the thoughts of others, to escape the limits of our histories, authorized identities, and the flags of our skin and to create new identities which become a library of possible selves; and mine form an atlas of myself and my travels beyond the boundaries and interfaces of my maps of becoming human into unknown realms of human being, meaning, and value, also a history and archeology of my becoming human. I have often written that a full accounting of my languages becomes ambiguous and problematic; but herein I now so attempt.
Let me stipulate at the outset of this project that I now recount successive waves of languages in which I became conversant or literate as I explored our world over a lifetime, and in no way claim to have been able to think in them all at once, but only a few at any time during my studies and travels.
Languages are a hobby of mine; I grew up with three voices, English, Chinese, and French, each a mask of identity bearing the liminal force of the circumstances in which I learned them and conferring their own persona and uniqueness.
My English is influenced by the King James Bible and the local Dutch community of my childhood hometown, whose speech was full of thee’s and thou’s. This was the culture of elite hegemonies of race and patriarchy authorized by theocracy against which I rebelled in claiming Nietzsche’s Thus Spake Zarathustra as a counter-text to the Bible, a Reformed Church community aligned with the Apartheid regime of South Africa. Here as a child I witnessed a witch burning, a cross burned on the front lawn of newlyweds whose union the town referred to as a mixed marriage, he being Dutch and she a member of the minority Swiss Calvinists, and both white Protestants speaking Germannic languages; during high school my fellow students began picking up stones to throw at a teenage couple from out of town at a ball game because they were kissing without being married, a public stoning which I just barely stopped.
How did I give answer to this?
At the first assembly of the new school year the incoming class was asked to recite a poem we liked to our new peers to introduce ourselves. I figured that I was going to get into a lot of fights, and had chosen to recite Invictus as the terms of struggle. Unconquered; the only title worth having, an idea which has continued to inform, motivate, and shape me since I first discovered it in a poem by William Ernest Henley, Invictus, as a high school Freshman.
Here was my prefacing speech to my peers and to the world; “I ask nothing of anyone, nor any quarter; neither will I offer any to those who stand against me. But I will never abandon anyone who stands with me, nor will you ever stand alone.
Last summer I went to Brazil to train as a fencer for the Pan American Games, and stayed to defend abandoned street children from the bounty hunters whom the rich had set on them, and this is how we survived against police death squads with only our hands and whatever we could steal; by standing together regardless of our differences.
This is what I ask now, of all of you. I’m hoping we can be friends.
The poem I’ve chosen to recite is Invictus, which means Unconquered in Latin, by William Ernest Henley.
“Out of the night that covers me,
Black as the Pit from pole to pole,
I thank whatever gods may be
For my unconquerable soul.
In the fell clutch of circumstance
I have not winced nor cried aloud.
Under the bludgeonings of chance
My head is bloody, but unbowed.
Beyond this place of wrath and tears
Looms but the Horror of the shade,
And yet the menace of the years
Finds, and shall find, me unafraid.
It matters not how strait the gate,
How charged with punishments the scroll,
I am the master of my fate:
I am the captain of my soul. “
After a long and terrible silence, the auditorium erupted in cheers.
None who are human are beyond redemption. Sometimes all we need do to conjure the redemptive power of love is offer others entrance into our world, to reveal our pain and our fear, our loneliness and hope of love, the wounds and flaws of our humanity which open us to the pain of others.
Here I wish to make clear that my family were never part of any church whatsoever; we lived there because that was where my father got a job teaching English language and literature, Drama, and Forensics at the high school, where he also coached the Fencing and Debate clubs, and was my teacher in all of these. I describe my formative years growing up in Ripon California because it is helpful in understanding me to know that I grew up in a premodern world, the world the Enlightenment and its political form the American Revolution overthrew, though the Revolution remains incomplete in its realization and universalization both in America and throughout the world. This is what being an American means to me; to be a bearer of the Promethean Fire of liberation from Authority and from systems of unequal power, especially institutions of tyranny as church and state, where ever men hunger to be free.
Herein the question of home language as source identity becomes determinative; mine was English, though I inherit through my father the possessing ghosts of ancestors who were driven out of the Black Forest in 1586 at the start of decades of witch hunting hysteria. Drachensbraute, Brides of the Dragon, my ancestors were called by Martin Luther, whose fame for grand defiance of Church law eclipsed his infamy as a witch hunter and brutal torturer of women. By modern constructions of race this makes me Bavarian, though my ancestry in the patriarchal line is equally Shawnee, from the marriage of Henry Lale and Me Shekin Ta Withe or White Painted Dove during the American Revolution.
My paternal grandmother was Italian; of the Noce family whose stilt house in Bayou La Teche Louisiana was built from the ship they sailed from Genoa in the wake of the Napoleonic Wars, the Jacobin Revolt of 1797 bringing the new revolutionary state into the Napoleonic Empire, its navigable approach guarded by ancient canon. My mother wrote a journal of a family visit with them in 1962; there was Quiller, a giant who could carry a railroad tie in each hand, all day long, the Silent Man who sat in his rocking chair for three days without saying anything, then whipped out a shotgun and fired into the swamp, and after several minutes of rocking declared; “Water moccasin,” a deadly poisonous snake. The women all wore pointy hats like cartoon witches, and I’ve never found any credible reference which might identify the ethnicity to which it belongs nor the origin of the pointed hat as a witch symbol. They claimed to be hereditary priestesses of Dread Persephone, Queen of the Underworld and the Dead, though this may have been a joke.
Beyond this I am a direct patrilineal descendent of the ally of Scipio Africanus that Cicero wrote his treatise on friendship about, Laelius de Amicitia, in 44 B.C. We briefly ruled what is called the Gallic Empire in the mid second century A.D., what is now France, Spain, and the British Iles; my ancestors include a deified Roman general and shapechanger, origin of the Berserkers, for whom the Bear Dance is still performed in Romania.
I once described myself to the wife of a poetry professor as Roman with the words; “I am a citizen of the Roman Empire; that it has not existed for fifteen hundred years is irrelevant.” This was Anne Rice, whose poem about the revenge of the broken dolls will haunt my dreams forever, and who modeled the character of Mael in her novels on me as I was in the early 1980’s. Her idea of Those Who Must Be Kept came from a reference of mine to the classics of western civilization and the Dead White Men of our history; “We are all bearers of those who must be kept and those from whom we must escape, and if we are very lucky they are not always the same.”
In the line of matrilineal descent I am a direct successor to my great grandmother, whose story I told in my post of May 9 2023, A Legacy of Freedom Shared By Us All: Jewish American Heritage Month; Because the personal and the political are interdependent, and we are made of the stories we tell about ourselves, to ourselves and to others, I offer here a story from my family history as told to me by my mother of how Jewish people saved our family, when no one else would, and without whom none of us would have ever lived.
Upon the docks of America arrived a nine year old girl, alone and without a penny to her name or a word of English. A stranger, with no one waiting to meet her, no family, no friends, nothing. My maternal great grandmother Apollonia this was, with flaming red hair like my mother’s, whose family had put her on a ship to escape from Austria as their home burned, the sole survivor of her whole town so far as we now know.
She wandered the port of Seattle asking for help, in her five languages and in descending likelihood of recognition; French, Austrian, Hungarian, Serbo-Croatian, and finally, in despair and fear that the reaction would be far worse than being abandoned to starve and freeze to death lost and alone among strangers, Yiddish.
This like a magic spell summoned a crowd, by happy chance not one armed with torches and axes. So a stranger was taken in and raised by Jewish people, a family of whom I know nothing, and thus our family’s survival is owed to the entire Jewish community and people.
This happened in 1873, year of the glorious Vienna World’s Fair but also the stock market crash in the wake of the Franco-Prussian War which began a twenty year Depression in Europe and the Jewish persecutions as they were blamed for it; also conflicts between the Russian and Ottoman Empires in their borderlands.
She it was who owned her own rifles and horses by the age of sixteen when she began her career as a hunting guide, and died in the saddle at the age of 95, rifle in her hand, having shot the bear that attacked her horses and killed her. The Indians buried her like the Huns buried Attila, on her horse and with her rifle, like a warrior princess.
I was born within days of her death, and as with all ancestors I bear her onward, literally as DNA and the stories which possess us as the ghosts of other lives; incarnated truths written in our flesh.
Historical context and the fact that my ancestor in the maternal line knew Yiddish makes it possible that under Jewish law we are Jews, and she was raised as a member of the Jewish community, though my mother never claimed so and moreover was a radical atheist who raised us with no religious traditions at all. In so doing the family faith she liberated herself from was Catholicism, an artifact of her Austrian paternal line who were exiles of the 1919 fall of the Hapsburg Empire after 600 years.
My mother’s speech was permeated with Yiddish words and phrases, a legacy of my maternal great grandmother; my maternal grandfather was the source of the family German, actually Wienerisch or the Viennese dialect of Austro-Bavarian, combined with the French-influenced Schönbrunner Deutsch of the imperial court. This was the home language of my mother’s family, though grandpa knew Latin, taught himself English, and to various degrees knew other languages of the Austrian Empire including Hungarian, Romanian, Ukrainian, Croatian, the Romance language Venetian and its Triestino dialect, and could speak Russian and Polish well enough to do business in their communities here in America.
As a teenager immersed in Holocaust literature while working through the trauma of a near death experience in Brazil the summer before high school, my execution by a police death squad while rescuing abandoned street children they were bounty hunting having been prevented by the Matadors, and conversations with my mother as she wrote her study of psychosomatic muteness from the Soviet medical records and childhood therapy journal of Jerzy Kosinski which he fictionalized as The Painted Bird, I once asked her directly, Are we Jews?
To this she replied; “Everyone is a Jew. Everyone is someone’s Jew, someone’s scapegoat, someone’s Other. The great task of becoming human is to overcome our fear of otherness, while embracing our uniqueness.”
My Second and Third Voices from the age of nine were Chinese and Japanese; Traditional Chinese inkbrush calligraphy, the Standard Cantonese of Hong Kong, and the Wu Dialect of Shanghai. During my decade of formal study of Taoism and Zen Buddhism, Chinese and Japanese martial arts, and the game of Go I studied in both Chinese and Japanese.
My Japanese developed over the years from its context in Zen and martial arts to literary ones, becoming a greater passion at university when I was obsessed with Japanese poetry to the extent that I walked some of the Basho Road to see where he had written his masterpieces, and I claimed Zen as my religion on official forms through my twenties.
This was through Sifu Dragon, who also spoke a very British English full of Anglo-Indian words and phrases which shaped my English through our conversations; my great teacher of martial and other arts he was, with whom my father arranged for me to study after I had retaliated against my fifth grade class for putting gum on my chair by poisoning everyone, only by chance without causing any harm to anyone beyond a brief nausea. Horrified that I might have become a nine year old mass murderer when my fellow students began throwing up, I told my father about it that night, to which he said; “You have discovered politics. Politics is the art of fear, and fear is the true means of human exchange. Fear precedes power. Fear is a terrible master and an untrustworthy servant. So, whose instrument will it be? What you need is a way to use fear and power that restores balance instead of imposing dominion, and when confronted by enemies you must demonstrate you do not fear them in order to take their power.”
My Fourth Voice from the seventh grade is French, a legacy of having been sent to six years of French classes at the high school because I was beyond grade level in English, which I enthusiastically embraced along with Surrealist film and literature. I began to write poetry, and thought of myself primarily as a poet through my twenties, with Rimbaud and Baudelaire my direct models.
This Defining Moment bears interrogation; during seventh grade I took the AP English test given to high school seniors for university credit and tested out of English classes through senior year of high school. This was among tests arranged by my parents and teachers who conspired to force me into high school two years early, and had tried with math the previous year, which I absolutely refused but for one class, where I traded seventh grade English for Freshman French literature and language, a chance I fell upon with ravenous delight.
The French teacher was a blonde goddess, and here imagine the reporter Rita Skeeter played by Miranda Richardson who corners Harry Potter in the broom closet in The Goblet of Fire, who motivated her students by offering a trip to Paris, with her, after graduation from high school for the best senior French student each year; competition for this honor was fierce, and I was a very, very good student. Thanks for the soft landing in high school, Miss Starring.
Fifth I learned some conversational Brazilian Portuguese from the summer before I began high school, Sao Paulo being the scene of my first Last Stand during the weeks of my campaign to rescue abandoned street children from the police bounty hunters and the trauma of my near-execution, in which I find echo and kinship with that of Maurice Blanchot by the Gestapo in 1944 as written in he Moment of My Death and Fyodor Dostoevsky by the Czarist secret police in 1849 as described in The Idiot, from which I was saved by the Matadors, who welcomed me into their fearsome brotherhood with the words; “You are one of us; come with us. We can’t save everyone, but we can avenge.”
Though Arabic is my Sixth Voice, it has long become a natural language for me since first learning some Levantine Arabic in the summer of 1982, during the Siege of Beirut. This was when Jean Genet set me on my life’s path by swearing me to the Oath of the Resistance he had created in Paris 1940 from that of the Foreign Legion, in a burning house, in a lost cause, in a Last Stand beyond hope of victory or even survival; “We swear our loyalty to each other, to resist and yield not, and abandon not our fellows.” And he gave me a principle of action by which I have now lived for over forty years; “When there is no hope, we are free to do impossible things, glorious things.”
My Seventh Voice is Spanish, as fast upon my Baccalaureate graduation came the horrific Mayan Genocide and other atrocities of the monstrous Reagan regime, and the heroic Resistance of indigenous peoples to America’s imperial conquest of Central America which collapsed with the Iran-Contra Scandal. This theatre of revolutionary struggle includes that of the Zapatistas in the Yucatan; though later I formally studied Spanish from Argentine professors in one of my many graduate school programs, Spanish is a second or trade language for the people with whom I aligned myself, mostly speakers of Yucatec in Mexico or Quiche in the Guatemalan Peten among the Mayan group of over twenty languages, who were rebelling against the Ladino or Spanish speaking elites. So while I am literate in Spanish, I am conversant in two forms of Mayan.
Russian is my Eighth Voice, being the language of international solidarity at the time and of the Soviet advisors and special operations forces with whom I sometimes worked in revolutionary struggle. I had some familiarity with it from my sister Erin, who began high school when I began teaching it, and used Russian as I had Chinese; as a second soul into which to grow as a self-created being, free from the legacies of our history. She studied for four years in high school with Lt Col Sviatislav Shasholin, USAF, who translated during the Nixon-Brezhnev talks and handled Soviet defectors, then went to UC Santa Cruz where she studied Russian language and Soviet Foreign Policy, graduating as Valedictorian of the Oaks International Studies School, then went to live in Kaliningrad in the Soviet Union and became Pushkin Scholar at Moscow State Institute of International Relations where the revolutionary vanguard from all over the world came to learn the arts of making mischief, a couple years before the Fall of the Soviet Union. Her first languages beyond English were Old Norse, Gothic, and Old Welsh, which she taught herself in seventh grade while researching Tolkien’s invented languages, so she could write poetry in them.
I currently write and publish in English, Chinese, Japanese, French, Arabic, Hebrew, Spanish, Portuguese, German, Zulu, Hindi, Urdu, Persian and since the invasion in Ukrainian, Russian, Polish, and recently Italian and Dari, Afghanistan’s major language and like Urdu derived from Persian, all three of which are mutually intelligible. This list changes ceaselessly, as do human identities; ephemeral, impermanent, performative and a ground of struggle.
Including dead languages with no broad communities of native speakers but of scholars of ancient literatures, those of my Buddhist and Islamic scholarship include Classical Tibetan from my time as a monk of the Kagyu Vajrayana Order of Buddhism in Kathmandu, Nepal, where I waged a revolution against the monarchy, and from my studies as a member of the Naqshbandi Order of Sufis in Srinagar, Kashmir, where I fought for independence against the invasion by India; Classical Persian, Ottoman Turkish, and the exception to the dead languages of scholarship classification as a universal language of Islamic faith in which one must be literature to be considered fully Muslim, Classical Quranic Arabic.
So, my literacy includes twenty three languages if we count Latin, which I’ve taught in high school; basic Latin is crucial if you are a new student in America whose native language is not English, especially for university-bound students and solving unknown scientific and technical terms. If you know Latin root words and conjugations, you will master English twice as fast.
My languages of conversational proficiency serve also as an atlas of my travel history; as Sir Richard Francis Burton says; “Where ever you go, learn the language; it’s the key to everything else.” We now leave the regions of literacy and explore the Atlas of my journeys in terms of conversational level proficiency.
During the 1980’s I was involved in liberation struggle against Apartheid in South Africa, which ended with the great victory in the Battle of Cuito Cuanavale in Angola in 1988, in which I fought in my usual role of scout or reconnaissance. Here I learned some Zulu and Afrikaans, a fascinating Dutch hybrid language invented by the Cape Malay community using Jawi Arabic script, which incorporates elements of indigenous Khoisan and Bantu African languages and influenced by the Malay-Portuguese trade language Kristang.
From my time behind the Iron Curtain with the Romani my languages include Vlax Romani, the major Romani language and that of its heartland in Transylvania and Eastern Europe, and its origin or relative Vlachs or Aromanian, a Romance language created by the historical migrations and transformations of cultures in the borderlands between the Habsburg, Ottoman, and Venetian Empires, and influenced more by Greek than Slavic as a disambiguating characteristic from modern Romanian, a related language also originating in the Latin of the Roman Empire and its long centuries of disintegration and change.
Many Romani whom I knew spoke Vlax, Vlachs, Romanian, and Hungarian interchangeably as code switching, and also spoke Hochdeutsch which is the second language of Hungary and of Germany, Austria, and Switzerland as Standard German. During this time I made mischief with a crew led by Bluey, an Irish gypsy from London who spoke English laden with Cockney rhyming slang, 16th century Thieves Cant, and the hybrid Irish Gaelic-Traveller cryptolanguage Shelta, a complex patois he and his crew, who were from everywhere, used as a secret language.
From my time in the Golden Triangle and Shan States I learned Thai, Shan, S’gaw Karen, the Singpho language of the Kachin Confederation of northern Burma and India, and the Sino-Tibetan language of the Konyak Naga. This charts the midcourse of my original Great Trek across Asia; one day I was driving to work in San Francisco and realized that I was going to live the same day I had more times than I could remember, that I was living in Nietzsche’s Hell of Eternal Recurrence, and I broke the pattern and took a wrong turn. I found myself at the airport and bought a ticket for an unknown destination; I just asked for a flight to the other side of the planet.
This I discovered upon landing was Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia; on day three I realized everyone in its elegant business district was doing things I could have done at home in San Francisco if I had wanted to, so I decided to do what no one else was doing. I found a bus station with a map where all the roads ended in the Cameron Highlands, rode a bus nine hours into the empty spaces on the map, got out when the road became a dirt trail into the jungle, and began my journey. I crossed from Malaysia into Thailand, Burma, and India before coming to live alternately in Nepal and Kashmir for some while.
In Nepal my role as a monk of the Buddhist Kagyu Vajrayana order required literacy in Classical Tibetan, conversational Gorkali or Nepalese as it is the official language and spoken by half the population, Newari which is the language of Kathmandu Valley where I lived, Gurung which is a tribal language of the Annapurna region and a major language of my key allies the Gurkha military and the horse nomads with whom I operated across the border between Nepal and Kashmir, and some Hindi.
In Kashmir my scholarship of Sufism required literacy in Classical Quranic Arabic, which I had been studying for years already, Classical Persian, and Ottoman Turkish; the official language Urdu which is Hindi written with a Perso-Arabic script and influenced by Classical Persian, and conversational use of the Kashmiri language Koshur.
This period in the early 1990’s coincides roughly with the Siege of Sarajevo of which I am a witness, where I learned some Croatian written in Latin script, mutually comprehensible with Bosnian as they evolve from the same source.
From my voyages and treks in South Asia on a later journey, where I sailed out of Georgetown on the island of Penang as a home port, I Iearned Malay in which I am literate and so count among my Voices, this being the major language of the region, of sailors, and of my initial scholarship of Naqshbandi Sufism which is a pan-Islamic warrior brotherhood synonymous with the martial arts of silat, and Buginese which is the language of the Bugis people of the Sultanate of Sulawesi who are the primary shipbuilders and navigators of South Asia, where half of all shipped freight is still by sail, and of the pirates with whom I waged an antislavery campaign led by our Captain Starfollower.
Then came the Minangkabu of Sumatra where I studied the martial art of Raja Harimau, briefly I learned what I could of one of the many languages of the Mentawai Islands where I was castaway in a storm at sea and with an indigenous tribe built an outrigger or Oceanic Proa over a couple months to sail ten hours across open seas to the mainland of Sumatra at Padaung, Iban which is a language of the indigenous Dayak peoples of Borneo, and Hokkien Chinese in its Penang and Singaporean variants which is understood throughout the Peranankan or Straits Chinese communities.
Of windows into the other ways of being human I count twenty four languages of conversation, including Hokkien Chinese, Iban, Mentawai, Minangkabu, Buginese, Croatian, Koshur, Gorkali, Newari, Gurung, Thai, Shan, S’gaw Karen, Singpho, Naga, Vlax, Vlachs, Romanian, Hungarian, Shelta, Afrikaans, Yucatec, and Quiche, and twenty seven of literacy, a total of fifty one.
Thus far I have learned much about human diversity as well as the things which unite us, but nothing whatever of a great key which will unlock our infinite possibilities of becoming human, and as I hope birth a United Hamankind.
Yet in the questioning of our languages as tools of creating our identities, of human being, meaning, and value, and of emergence from the legacies of our history and systems of oppression, we may transcend our limits and transform our boundaries of otherness and belonging into interfaces of exchange, and become exalted.
Will the next language offer the clues needed to decode the secrets of our liberation and self ownership, of our reimagination and transformation of ourselves and how we choose to be human together? As my mother used to say to students who asked for some pronouncement or authorization, juggling possibilities with her hands; “Maybe, maybe not”.
This I wrote originally as a Postscript to my essay of September 8 2023, International Literacy Day: What is a Library For?
It became its own work when I realized I had never tried to fully count my languages nor assess the meaning of languages as having multiplicities of selves as masks to perform in reserve at any moment, nor as revolutionary acts which may change boundaries into interfaces.
May all the Voices of your languages build bridges and not walls. But how precisely can we do that?
Is there a universal language behind all our languages and personae, a code like DNA in our consciousness and a meta-grammar or innate rules as Chomsky argues by which we create and order human being, meaning, and value?
What truly lies beneath the surfaces of our illusory and impermanent selves, images like ephemeral jetsam which conceal a unified field of being, a sea of consciousness Infinite in extent and embracing us all? Can learning languages truly allow us to operate directly on our own consciousness and seize ownership and control of our own evolution, to inhabit the imaginal souls of others, abandon our divisions and pathologies of disconnectedness, and become exalted in our participation in the being of others and of all humankind?
What becomes of us, when we transcend ourselves through immersion in what Ibn Arabi called the alam al mythal, Coleridge the Primary Imagination, Jung the Collective Unconscious, and the ancients called Logos?
I am a man who has many souls, one for every language I am literate in, in which I can think and dream and compose, and like James Joyce I have discovered few answers, but many questions regarding our possibilities of reimagination and transformation of ourselves and humankind.
For this mad quest to become human, to breach the event horizons of our culture, the legacies of our history, and the limits of our authorized identities, obeys the principle of the Conservation of Ignorance, in which the Infinite remains vast and unknown regardless of what we know or how much we learn.
Only this I have learned; it is not the kinds of thoughts we are able to have which make us human, but how we use them in our actions toward others, to harm or heal.
Among all of these voices of possibilities of becoming human stands the Zohar in its silence, voice of the Infinite, and it says; “I bear secrets; open me.”
And I with Ahab reply; “To the end I will grapple with thee.”
First, the book through which I fell down the rabbit hole of language in the mad quest to be able to think the thoughts of the Infinite and discover or create the secret grammar by which we construct human being, meaning, and value, universal principles of becoming human able to transcend the limits of our flesh and forge us all into one humankind beyond divisions of authorized identity and fascisms of race, faith, and nationality, and discovered Joyce, Wittgenstein, and the Kabbalah;
Science and Sanity: An Introduction to Non-Aristotelian Systems and General Semantics, Alfred Korzybski
A “Finnegans Wake” Lextionary: Let James Joyce Jazz Up Your Voca(l)bulary, Riverrun to Livvy: Lots of Fun Reading the First Page of James Joyce’s “Finnegans Wake”, by Bill Cole Cliett
Like the spiral chambers of a seashell, we each of us are made of stories which extend ourselves into the material world as processes of growth and adaptive change; systems of history, mimesis, and identity which I call Defining Moments.
How shall I count mine?
By Last Stands, in which I defied unanswerable and overwhelming force beyond hope of victory or survival.
First among them is the grand adventure and disruptive trauma of my first solo foreign travel, the summer before my freshman year at high school, to Brazil to train for the Pan American Games with fellow fencers.
Let me place this in context; Brazil was my first grand adventure, flying to Sao Paulo when I was fourteen to train with a group of fencers for the Pan American Games which were planned to be held there; I was the San Francisco Bay Area champion in saber and foil in my age division, as I was through high school. I had some newly learned conversational Portuguese, an invitation to stay at the home of a boy I knew from the fencing tournament circuit with whom I could discover the local mischief, and visions of beach parties.
So it was that I entered a world of courtly manners and white-gloved servants, gracious and brilliant hosts who were local luminaries and threw a magnificent formal ball to introduce me, and a friend with whom I shared a mad passion for martial arts and sports, but also a world of high walls and armed guards.
My first view beyond this illusion came with the sounds of rifle fire from the guards; when I looked from my balcony to see who was attacking the front gate I discovered the guards were firing into a crowd of beggars, mostly children, who had mobbed a truck carrying the morning food supplies. That day I made my first secret excursion beyond the walls, and I have been living beyond the walls ever since.
Remembering this Defining Moment now, the day I looked beyond my limits and transgressed the boundaries of the Forbidden to discover and question the basis of my own privilege and reach across divisions of authorized identities of class and race in solidarity with those who do the hard and dirty work for the rest of us and create our wealth, and to whom we have exported the true costs of production and excluded from its benefits as our de facto slaves, what fixes my imagination is that I lived an allegory of Awakening which recapitulates the story of the Buddha and has become a world myth as the Prince in the Golden Cage. I had no charioteer to answer my questions and create order and meaning from my trauma of witness; I had a whole tribe of them, the Matadors. We’ll get to that part shortly.
What truths are hidden by the walls of our palaces, beyond which it is Forbidden to look? It is easy to believe the lies of authority when one is a member of the elite in whose interest they claim to wield power, and to fail to question one’s own motives and position of privilege. Terrifyingly easy to believe lies when we are the beneficiaries of hierarchies of exclusionary otherness, of wealth and power disparity and inequalities systemically manufactured and weaponized in service to power, and of genocide, slavery, conquest, and imperialism.
Always pay attention to the man behind the curtain. For there is no just authority, and as Dorothy says in the Wizard of Oz, he’s “just an old humbug”, and his lies and illusions, force and control, serve no interests but his own.
Being a naïve American boy, I felt it was my duty to report the incident; but at the police station I had difficulty making myself understood. They thought I was there to place a bet on my guard in an ongoing monthly contest for which police officer bagged the most street children; there was a chalkboard on the station wall for this, and a jar of tagged ears. Another betting game called “the Big One”, was for which policeman kicked the most pregnant girls in the stomach and ranked among the top ten causes of death in Brazil for teenage girls, invariably living within slum zones containing the most impoverished and most Black of citizens; this in a city founded by escaped African slaves as a free republic.
I learned much in the weeks that followed; that fully ten percent of Brazilians were abandoned and orphaned street children on whom bounties had been placed as a solution, that a quarter of the population lived in shantytowns, that life expectancy for 80% of the people was 35 years, that 350,000 children died before the age of five each year and only 13% finished primary school, that nearly half the people were illiterate.
And yet it was a rich nation; the Brazilian gold boom of the 1700’s created Europe’s industrial revolution, and at this same time of pervasive and systemic poverty and racism Brazil was the worlds number one coffee, sugar, orange, and gasohol producer, #2 cocoa, and #3 timber and beef producer. But over half of the wealth was owned by less than two percent of its people, like the family who were my gracious hosts.
Above all I learned who is responsible for these inequalities; we are, if we buy the products of an unjust system, remain silent as witnesses of history to injustices, or abandon our duty of care toward others when evil unfolds before us and by a mission of action we may safeguard others from harm. This is the true purpose and design of elite hegemonies of wealth, power, and privilege; to disrupt our interdependence and the solidarity of our universal brotherhood as a precondition of unequal power.
During the nights of my adventures beyond the walls and actions to help the bands of child beggars and obstruct the police bounty hunts I had a second near death experience, this time similar to though not as formal as those of Maurice Blanchot’s mock execution by the Nazis in 1944 and Fyodor Dostoevsky’s by the Czar’s secret police in 1849; fleeing pursuit through a warren of tunnels with an injured child among others and trapped in the open by two police riflemen who took flanking positions and aimed at us while the leader called for surrender from beyond the curve of a tunnel. I stood in front of a boy with a twisted leg who could not run while the others scattered and escaped or found hiding places, and refused to stand aside when ordered to do so. This was my Ring of Fire and the first of more Last Stands than I can now clearly remember, and I find hope for us all in the instinctive duty of care of the young boy I once was to whom it never occurred to run, to surrender, or to abandon a stranger to harm, and like Wagner’s great hero Siegfried chose instead the fire.
With all of the horrors I have witnessed in a life lived in the unknown spaces of our maps of becoming human marked Here Be Dragons, beyond the limits of the human and the boundaries of the Forbidden, through wars and revolutions as a maker of mischief for tyrants and a monster who hunts other monsters for the chance to salvage something of our humanity, though in this I often fail as I did in Mariupol from March 22 to April 18 2022 and at Panjshir in Afghanistan from the last week of August til September 7 2021, regardless of the brokenness of the world and the flaws of our humanity, something in us refuses to submit to the abjection and learned helplessness of authoritarian systems and reaches toward exaltation and freedom. Whether such hope is a gift or a curse remains for each of us to discover in how we live our lives.
In the end all that matters is what we do with our fear, and how we use our power.
Siegfried walks through the fire and becomes human. There’s a good retelling of it in Buffy the Vampire Slayer’s musical episode, Once More With Feeling.
When the disembodied voice of my executioner reached out from the darkness of the purgatorial labyrinth in which we were trapped to order my surrender, with the life of a stranger in the balance, I asked how much to let us walk away, and he ordered his men to fire. But there was only one shot instead of a demonstration of crossfire, and that a wide miss; he had time to ask “What?” before falling to the ground.
And then our rescuers revealed themselves, having crept up on the police from behind; the Matadors, who might be described as vigilantes, a criminal gang, a revolutionary group, or all three, founded by Brazil’s notorious vigilante and criminal Pedro Rodrigues Filho, who had been arrested the previous year. Into this fearsome brotherhood I was welcomed, and in the streets of Sao Paulo that summer I never again stood alone.
From the moment I saw the guards of the aristocratic family with whom I was a guest firing on the crowd of homeless children and beggars swarming the food supply truck at the manor gate, naked and skeletal in starvation, scarred and crippled and misshapen with diseases unknown to any people for whom healthcare and basic nutrition are free and guaranteed preconditions of the universal right to life, desperate for a handful of food which could mean one more day of survival; in that moment I chose my side, and my people are the powerless and the dispossessed, the silenced and the erased.
As one of my rescuers phrased it; “Come with us. You are one of us. We can’t save everyone, but we can avenge.”
May we all be granted the gift of vision of our interdependence and the universality of our humanity, and wounds which open us to the pain of others.
Eight years later, and after spending much of my high school years working through the trauma of these events and choosing the origins of evil as my field of study, came my second Last Stand, which fixed me on my life’s path in Antifascist action and revolutionary struggle as a member and inheritor of the Resistance.
During the summer of 1982 before my senior year of university in San Francisco, I had set out on a culinary Grand Tour of the Mediterranean, learning to cook the food I loved, and was in Beirut when Israel invaded Lebanon and trapped me in a city under siege. Feral bands of soldiers were roaming the streets, committing atrocities; one such unit of the Israeli Defense Forces set some children on fire, laughing and making bets on how far they could run screaming before they fell into pools of blackened ruin and their screams became silent. I found myself fighting them; others joined me, and more joined us. From that day forward I was part of the defense of Beirut against the siege.
A fabulous café that had the best strawberry crepes in the world lay on the far side of a sniper alley, which my friends and I made an extreme sport of dashing across to reach breakfast while the occasional bullet impacted the wall behind us. One day we arrived in our usual high spirits when an elegant gentleman sat at my table, and speaking in French began a conversation with, “I’m told you do this every day, race against death for breakfast.”
To which I replied, “Moments stolen from death belong to us, and set us free. Possibly this is all we truly own. It’s a poor man who loves nothing worth dying for.”
He smiled and said, “I agree”, and so began our conversations at breakfast in the last days before his capture, unforgettable days for this is where he set me on my life’s path of struggle for liberty against tyranny and autocracies of state force and control, for equality against racist violence and injustice, and against the fascism which combines both state tyranny and racist terror.
He introduced himself as a former Legionnaire by the name of Jean, was mischievous, wise, immensely learned in classical scholarship and possibly had once been educated as a priest, and filled with wild stories about the luminaries of modern European culture. I was stunned when I discovered days later that my strange new friend was one of the greatest literary figures of the century. I had quoted The Thief’s Journal in refutation of something he said, which he found hilarious, while we were discussing Maurice Blanchot’s interpretation of Nietzsche’s Thus Spake Zarathustra as compared to that of Jung, a conversation which remained unfinished as he couldn’t stop laughing. Eventually he sputtered, “I myself am Jean Genet.” To me he remains a Trickster figure and part of my historical identity and personal mythology.
With the streets suddenly filled with Israeli soldiers running amok in a sack of murder, arson, and other vileness of terror and inhumanity, who had set fire to our cafe and other buildings and were calling for surrender and blindfolding the children of those who did and using them as human shields, and the discovery of our only weapon being the bottle of champagne we had just finished with our strawberry crepes, I asked my breakfast companion if he had any ideas. To this he replied with an apologetic shrug and another question, “Fix bayonets?”
We laughed, and he elaborated; “When all hope is lost, we are free to do impossible things, glorious things.” This advice I find necessary to recall from time to time, and which I recommend to you all. I have lived by it for thirty-nine years now.
Then he asked, “Will you surrender?’
To which I replied, “No.”
“Nor I,” he said, standing. “As I share with you now, pass to others at need; this is an oath I devised in 1940 from the one I took as a Legionnaire, for the resistance to the Nazi occupation. It may be the finest thing I ever stole.”
And so I offer to all of you the Oath of the Resistance as it was given to me by Jean Genet in a burning house, in a lost cause, in a time of force and darkness, in a last stand and an act of defiance beyond hope of victory or survival; “We swear our loyalty to each other, to resist and yield not, and abandon not our fellows.”
Five years after the Siege of Beirut, I fought in the Battle of Cuito Cuanavale, the largest battle ever fought in Africa, even more vast than El Alamein.
In a massive campaign which broke the grip of Apartheid on South Africa and liberated Angola and Namibia, involving over 300,000 Cuban volunteer soldiers between December 1987 and March 1988, in coordination with Angolan and other indigenous forces, international volunteers like myself, and with Soviet aid and advisors, defeated the far larger and technologically superior South Africa and their UNITA and American allies and mercenaries in the Battle of Cuito Cuanavale, an Angolan military base which South Africa had failed to capture with five waves of assaults. The results included the independence of Namibia, the withdrawal of South African troops from Angola, the replacement of the racist Prime Minister Botha by de Klerk in South Africa and his negotiations with the African National Congress, the release of Nelson Mandela from prison, and the end of apartheid.
While the spectacle of this grand final battle in a decades long liberation struggle was unfolding, I was making mischief behind enemy lines in the bush. Here I discovered a lost unit, mainly Zulu, which was encircled by Apartheid forces. After reporting what I knew of the area to the command group and a brief conference in several languages, an old fellow who had heretofore been silent stood up from the shadows of the tent, whose shirtless form displayed a fearsome and magnificent scar from a lion’s claws, and said; “We are surrounded and outnumbered with no ammunition and worse, no water, and no one is coming to help us. We must attack.”
The sergeant smiled at this as if he had been given a marvelous gift, strode outside, and gave the order which if you are lucky you will never hear; “Fix bayonets!”
And the men about to die erupted in song. “Usuthu! Umkhonto wami womile!” “My spear is thirsty”, that last.
Like the generations of struggle which liberated South Africa from Apartheid and colonial slavery, this nameless fight in the enormous Battle of Cuito Cuanavale was won against impossible odds because of things common to any liberation struggle; solidarity of action, the embrace of death as seizure of power, and the definition of victory as refusal to submit.
For the great secret of force and control is that it is hollow, brittle, and shatters when confronted with disobedience, and the great secret of authority and legitimacy is that it is an illusion of smoke and mirrors which vanishes utterly when disbelieved.
Believe nothing which is untested, for there is no just authority.
Always pay attention to the man behind the curtain.
Strategies of division along lines of faith, race, and national identity are a primary weapon of fascism and tyranny in the subjugation of a population in whose name authority claims to act and speak, in the centralization of power, and in the manufacture of consent through abjection, despair, and learned helplessness, as well as in the creation of hierarchies of belonging and exclusionary otherness, and these processes and systems of oppression are universal to humankind.
Yet war and ruin are not inevitable, for the chaos which seized South Africa as revolutionary struggle is also universal; the use of social force obeys the Third Law of Motion and creates its own counterforce. As both an existential threat to ossified and failing systems, structures, and institutions, here a three-part harmony of failed political, economic, and social systems, and also as a window of opportunity for revolutionary struggle and transformative change.
Chaos is not simply disorder; chaos destructures order and creates new possibilities of adaptation. Chaos is a force of revolution and liberation, and a measure of the potential for change of a system.
Guillermo del Toro, in his magnificent epic of migration and racial equality Carnival Row, has a scene in which two young successors to leadership of traditionally rival factions find themselves in love and in need of allies in a subplot which reimages Romeo and Juliet; the rebellious hellion Jonah Breakspear asks his Machiavellian lover Sophie Longerbane, “Who is chaos good for?” To which she replies, “Chaos is good for us. Chaos is the great hope of the powerless.”
Leveraging Chaos for change defines revolutionary and liberation struggle, but why is it necessary to bring the Chaos to restore balance to systems of unequal power as a fulcrum of change?
Those who abandon all laws and all limits may hide behind none. When carceral states of force and control, tyranny and terror, reach the stage of totalization of power to authority and become engines of dehumanization, they enter my world, beyond the boundaries of the Forbidden, and it is on this ground we must resist them.
All Resistance is war to the knife. Because the choice is between freedom as refusal to submit or abandon others, and the surrender of our universal human rights and of the limitless possibilities of human being, meaning, and value.
We resist tyranny and terror and all systems of oppression not to enforce virtue, but as each other’s guarantors of our human rights that we may each be free to find our uniqueness; and to claw back something of our humanity from the darkness.
As I wrote in my post of May 27 2026, A Memorial Day Retrospective of My Forlorn Hopes, Last Stands, and Lost Causes; During the celebrations of this year’s Memorial Day, when families visit the graves of the sacred dead, I am aware of the numberless comrades I have lost who have no graves to visit, no memorials, and often no one to remember and mourn their passing or weigh the liberty their lives have won for us against our own actions on behalf of others who cannot stand alone; the powerless and the dispossessed, the silenced and the erased, all those whom Frantz Fanon called The Wretched of the Earth.
Their brooding presence gathers close, as stories written in our flesh and histories which inform, motivate, shape and define us; silences like living brands of fire. What do they ask of us, to pay forward the inheritance of our freedom?
In Syria, after throwing open the gates of Damascus for her liberators, I hunted Assad’s torturers through the warrens of underground prisons, fortresses, and the laboratories and factories of a bioweapons program founded by fugitive Nazis at the dawn of the Assad dynasty; and was here reminded of Elie Wiesel’s principle Silence Is Complicity, for the darkness of the tunnels resounded with the stolen voices of the damned and the forgotten.
This is why we must bear witness and remember, and why we must Resist; because the boundary which defines the limits of the human is far too easy to cross, and the way back to our humanity treacherous and uncertain, ambiguous, ephemeral, full of illusions and relative truths.
Always the genie of fear, power, and force whispers to us is our despair and helplessness, our horror and abjection when confronted with atrocities beyond our understanding, and it offers us power as the arbiter of good and evil and the enforcer of moral virtue, saying; “Set me free, and I’ll make you powerful.”
And to this we must say, Never Again!
In my very long life of such struggles defined by many Last Stands, I think of two among them which represent the limits of the human in their horror and atrocities; Sarajevo and Mariupol. Only the Israeli genocide of the Palestinians exceeds these in the scope of its depravities, for it is now ongoing as the terminal phase of an ethnic cleansing and imperial conquest which is over seventy years old, in which we Americans are all complicit as our taxes buy the deaths of children. Here too I have made Last Stands; during the defense of the worshippers at Al Aqsa May 10 2021 in one night alone I was shot, bayoneted, blown up, and set on fire.
The Russian genocide and erasure of Mariupol was characterized by its organized mass murders, rapes, and tortures of civilians, the mobile factories of cannibalism which turned people into army rations, the use of a new hyperbaric terror weapon as crematoriums to hide their crimes, and the abduction and enslavement of children. All of this the world and I have seen before and doubtless will again; nor was I truly disturbed by being buried in a tunnel collapse under bombardment and crawling out for several hours, through the remains of the dead and among the lost voices of the dying whom I could not help. But I spent a few days throwing up and working through the stages of shock when I discovered what the Russian Army and their partners, a crime syndicate called the Butterfly Collectors, were doing with some of the stolen children and young girls brought into special facilities on military bases far way in Russia; torture brothels whose spectacles were broadcast to the world on the dark web in shows which I hope you cannot imagine.
Of Sarajevo I shall speak here not of the monstrous acts of those who would be conquerors, nor of the courageous resistance of their intended victims who held true to their faith and to each other in the face of death and torture, nor even of the valor and compassion of the volunteers of the International Brigade who placed themselves between hammer and anvil, but of a small horror which has come to symbolize for me the unimaginable horrors of war; the Jar of Eyes.
On the desk of a commander of death squads sat a jar full of eyes, and beside it an ice cream scoop which he would toy with, stroking its stainless smoothness with an absentminded and sensual languor while interrogating prisoners.
He said he got the idea from the Byzantine Emperor Basil the Second the Bulgar Slayer, who Christianized Bulgaria by blinding the army he defeated and leaving one man in ten with eyes to guide the others home, as a warning to crush resistance by terror.
How do I know this, and what were we to each other, this monster and I? Herein I recall and speak as a witness of history a Defining Moment in which we played a game of chess with the life of a prisoner of his as the prize.
As a jailbreak this was to my knowledge unique; I had asked the guards at the gate to see the commander, bearing gifts I knew he wanted greatly in trade for a prisoner whose value he did not know; making a game of it was his idea, which became several days of conversations. I think he was lonely.
Within the jar the eyes would float randomly, hypnotic, reflective, capturing ones will to resist with a Medusa-like gaze of objectification and dehumanization appropriated from their tormentors, a talisman of transference of power. A jar of silent screams, erased lives, and the lost witness of history; how can we accuse our destroyers when we have no mouths?
Here among the dragons, where the rule of law cannot reach and our maps of meaning and value have given way to tantalizing empty spaces which beckon with the siren call of the Forbidden, where the only currency is fear and the only relationships those of power and dominion, we challenge and define by their absence and contrary the limits of what is human.
For we are all trapped in the Jar of Eyes, and if we are to reawaken and assume our true forms we must find a means of escape.
Herein I wish to end this interrogation of my Last Stands as Defining Moments not with abjection, despair, and horror, but with a message of hope and the possibilities of beauty, truth, and love regardless of our circumstances or the imposed conditions of struggle.
As I wrote, rather quickly in the minutes of preparing to enter the underground labyrinth of the torture chambers beneath Damascus upon learning of a bioweapons threat that could kill everyone, in my post of December 16 2024 An Underworld Journey in Damascus, Hunting Monsters; Be not afraid of unknowns, for they hold both beauty and horror, and are spaces of free creative play wherein we may reimagine and transform ourselves and our ideas of human being, meaning, and value. Always go through the Forbidden Door, as have I in the forty two years I have lived among the Dragons of the Unknown, and do so now in the hells below Damascus.
Here I search for the perpetrators of crimes which have no names, and for the bioweapons network of laboratories, torture chambers, and factories designed originally by Nazis seeking to transform some of us into a posthuman species of elite supermen while annihilating the rest of us, a programme of human extinction moderated only by the need for slaves and thought control technology. The infamous Alois Brunner was not alone in creating the state of Syria under the Assad regime as an instrument of the Nazi vision of a master race, nor is Syria alone in this role as host and profiteer of Nazi terror among nations.
I, monster and hunter of monsters, wish to inscribe upon the memory of humankind and hurl in defiance into the chasms of our darkness this one true and possibly final witness; our humanity is not an imposed condition of being nor is our biology, genetics, hormones, and the morphology of our form destiny, but processes of becoming human shaped by our prochronism or the history of our choices and adaptations across vast epochs of time as a continuum of being, not national identity, nor race, nor gender, nor class, nor of any fascisms of blood, faith, and soil, not of hierarchies of elite belonging and exclusionary otherness of any kind, but our embrace of love over hate, hope over fear, faith in each other as solidarity over division, and of mercy, empathy, and compassion over cruelty and the pathology of our disconnectedness.
Let us go forth and meet the unknown with joy.
Here is my theme song for Last Stands, which I posted as I crossed into Afghanistan after the Fall of Kabul to defend Panjshir and before joining the fight at the Azovstal Steelworks in Mariupol.
Inglourious Basterds: Shoshanna Prepares for German Night
Other Songs of Liberation Struggle, Resistance, and Forlorn Hopes
Becky G – Bella Ciao (From the Netflix Series “Casa de Papel”)
Walk Through the Fire, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, episode Once More With Feeling
Michael Sheen performs ‘Do not go gentle into that good night’ by Dylan Thomas
Kenneth Branagh’s Henry V: St. Crispin’s Day Speech
This Day We Fight; Aragorn’s Speech at the Black Gate
Last Stands of Recent Years
A lot of activity for a man in his sixties, this. I cannot stand aside when we are made complicit in horrors by a captured state and leaders who have betrayed us in abandoning the principle of universal human rights and our duty of care for others.
I can’t abide it; can you abide it? So goes the immortal line in the film Inglorious Basterds, and in an America under the Fourth Reich of the Trump regime it is a question to which we all must give answer.
I have chosen to go down fighting.
Let us fight our corner, friends. Are we a Band of Brothers still? Who do we want to become, we Americans, we human beings; masters and slaves, or a free society of equals who are guarantors of each other’s humanity?
The Battle of Portland 2020, a retrospective of my writing
A History of the Third Intifada of 2021, a retrospective of my writing
May 9 2026 Tomorrow’s Anniversary of the Third Intifada of 2021, Now Ongoing In the Tenth Theatre of World War Three Which Contains and Supersedes the Gaza War, in Palestine, Lebanon, Iran, and the Middle East
April 20 2026 Anniversary of My Speech to the Volunteers At Warsaw, and of the Reorganization of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade of Ukraine For Liberation Struggle in Russia in the Wake of Our Escape From Mariupol
The Battle of Los Angeles 2025, a Retrospective of my writing
June 7 2026 In the Shadow of the Battle of Delaney Hall, the First Anniversary of the Battle of Los Angeles For the Soul Of America and the Freedom of the World: ICE Versus The People
June 9 2026 Why We Fight: Authorized Versus Chosen And Ambiguous National Identities As a Ground of Struggle, Symbolized By the Mexican Flag In the Battle of Los Angeles One Year Ago
June 10 2026 The Fall Or Rebirth of America Will Be Decided Not In the Courts Or In Congress, But In the Streets: Anniversary of The Battle of Los Angeles Day Five
Herein I question and remember family as a primary informing, motivating, and shaping force of identity; which in my case includes my life partner Dolly, my mother, father, and sister Erin.
For most of us our partners come after our birth family in terms of influence, but for myself this is not true as Dolly and I met the day my mother brought me home from the hospital as a newborn and placed me in her arms, and here we are sixty seven years later in the home we built with our own hands, in sight of the hill where we first kissed. As our relationship has been co-extensive with the span of our lives and we primary shaping forces of each other, chosen rather than an imposed condition of struggle by accident of birth, I begin this retrospective with a post I wrote in celebration of her seventieth birthday last year.
October 18 2026, Why do we love? What is its purpose, and what do we mean when we say I love you? Thoughts In Celebration of My Partner Dolly McKay’s Birthday; What is this thing of rapture and despair, wonderful and terrible like immersion in the Infinite, more precious and fundamental to our humanity than any other, more dread than hope as a gift and curse which offers redemption and healing when all else fails, full of numinous powers of reimagination and transformation in the face of our nothingness, of the flaws of our humanity and the brokenness of the world?
I write in reflection on the 71st birthday of my partner Dolly (Theresa) McKay today, with our parents now gone for many years, though we still have our siblings, and primarily reliant on one another for connection to this world and the ongoing creation of meaning and value for ourselves as a sustaining function and a motivating and informing source in the performance of ourselves.
Last year she asked me to write our story, which I share here with all of you as context for my questioning of the meaning and purpose of love. And as our relationship has been co-extensive with the span of my life and she the major shaping force of who I have become, it is impossible to write in full self disclosure without reference to her.
We have known each other our whole lives; our fathers grew up across the street from each other and attended the same schools as friends since childhood, and she, being four years older than myself, was my babysitter from when I was literally a baby. She tells the story of when my mother put me in her arms on my first day home after I was born with the words; “Want to hold him?”, and Dolly gathering me in asked; “Can I keep him?” I remember this moment, she an enormous orb of light, like a bodhisattva, who I reached for and who reached out to me in return, to gather me in, where all was luminous among infinite seas of being. This was the magic spell which bound us together; I believe I imprinted on her as mate bonding or recognition from this moment, in the way of wolves. Or as we constructed this event and the mystery of our relationship together from childhood, we recognized each other from our past lives together in a bond which survives death and rebirth, and like all love transcends the limits of our form.
Our first kiss was during a hayride in the snow in a wagon driven by her father with a tractor, in the winter of 1968; I was a very precocious eight and she twelve. We can see the hill where we first kissed, Mount Baldy as it looms above her old family farm, from our own hill where we built our cottage and private park twenty four years ago, named Dollhouse Park because Dolly wanted a park. And she wanted a park that reminded her of her cherished neighborhood park in Bath England, the Royal Victoria with its sumptuous Botanical Gardens, from her two decades playing piano and residing at The Royal Crescent Hotel & Spa on rotation with a number of similar venues in Europe; the Dollhouse isn’t grand, but it suits us as a place of refuge and serenity from the world between adventures.
In the years that followed our first kiss, during visits between our families on Christmas and summer vacations as my father moved us to California when I was two to teach high school and both my parents families were in Spokane Washington as well as their childhood friends like the McKays, we discovered that we shared the same dreams, literally, and together puzzled out a chronology for our backstory full of impossibly romantic imagined lives. This was my first historical research project, identifying where and when things from dreams were real and in use, and my first writing project, a dual biography of past lives; and whether real or imagined remains irrelevant, because it was real to us and instruments through which we created ourselves as we wished and chose to be.
All humans create themselves over time and through other humans in self-construal and identity construction; we did so intentionally and with full awareness. This, too, became a basis of our bond, as we interwove ourselves with each other.
By the time I was fourteen and she eighteen, I just before my first year of high school and she just graduated from hers, ours had become a grand romance; also a secret one, though the difference in our ages is nothing now. Such was our glorious Forbidden Romance, unfolding from and energized by a secret history of incarnations together across vast gulfs of time constructed from shared dreams. We saw each other, Dolly and I; and when this is true nothing else matters.
I count our anniversary from that summer of 1974, running amok together during the World’s Fair in Spokane just before my fateful trip to Brazil, and here we are still, she in her lair downstairs in the library doing the bureaucratic judo with some fifty different governments and negotiating their legal systems as a Regulatory Affairs Director with a job title of Strategist at Takeda, a three hundred year old Japanese pharmaceutical company, me in mine in the floor above adjacent my playroom the kitchen where I pursue the culinary arts and near the theatre room with its magnificent bay windows which display the south view of the park and where Dolly and I curl up by the fire of an evening, and through a window I can see from my desk across the roofed Tiki Bar deck with a view to the terrace gardens and the secret valley to which they descend, practicing my ars poetica as revolutionary struggle; in a home we built together to engineered plans drawn by her father, oriented by Dolly as she moved a chair around the hill for days watching the sunset and the lights of the city to choose the best view.
Fifty two years of love and partnership together, now. Glorious and strange, shaping each other here beyond the boundaries of our maps of becoming human, living in the blank and unknown places marked Here Be Dragons.
Who were we then? Dolly had begun her career as a professional musician playing the 1974 World’s Fair, having discovered that while piano recitals and playing in the symphony earned union scale and a bit more for the occasional concert or television appearance, cocktail lounges paid well and hotels and cruise ships offered a free room with maid service and meals in the restaurant as well as lots of money and a good deal of celebrity. She had just lived her last year of high school in a private suite at the Davenport Hotel in Spokane with its stunning stained glass ceiling in the Peacock Lounge where she played piano, then went to Victoria British Columbia and lived at the Empress Victoria Hotel for two years, with a sailboat in the harbor for exploring. She spent the next two decades playing grand hotels and cruise ships in Europe; the Princess and Norwegian Lines and her favorite places to live being The Royal Crescent Hotel & Spa in Bath England, the Brenners Park-Hotel & Spa in Baden-Baden, and Paris playing the Ritz and Harry’s New York Bar, as well as Vegas casinos, but before all of this high living and hobnobbing with royalty and glitterati she was the girl who at the age of twelve saw the film Lawrence of Arabia at the cinema and then went home and played the entire score from memory.
Of course the rapture of her beautiful music fired my imagination and captivated my soul. We shared interests in music, but also a general enthusiasm for learning; her best memory of high school was designing rockets for a moon lander others were building, mine being carried through the hallways on the shoulders of my fellow students during my first political action at the start of my Freshman year, a victorious school walkout and strike when the local church ordered the school counselor to lose all the signup sheets for my father’s Forensics class and debate team for asking inconvenient questions about Apartheid, which the walkout forced the school to re-do. While she played piano, I wrote poetry; she once expressed our intellectual differences this way; “Music is my native language; you think in words, I think in songs.”
Above all we both bore marks of strangeness and of otherness as survivors of death or near-death experiences, myself from a moment of awareness outside of time and a vision of multiple possible human futures during the most terrible incident of state terror since the Civil War, Bloody Thursday May 15 1969, at People’s Park Berkeley, when the police opened fire on a student protest over the University of California’s investments in Israeli war industries and complicity in the Occupation of Palestine, while I held my mother’s hand and a police grenade hurled me from my body and I stood outside of time and beheld myriads of possible human futures, she from being stabbed during a home invasion by an obsessed fan, a retarded fellow high school student who had developed a jealous fixation, and left for dead, thereafter with awareness no longer limited to her form. Her thoughts can leap across the gap between the forms of others and her own as both thoughts and feelings or telepathy and empathy which she uses to read what people want and need to hear while playing music and to immerse them in such feelings and ideas like the song of a siren, where mine do the same across time and possible futures or alternate realities. I’ve spoken with others who have returned from death, and there is nothing unusual in this opening of consciousness as an effect; death is nothing more or less terrible and wonderful than freedom from the limits of our form. As I said to my mother on returning from death as a child in her arms and visions of having lived thousands of lives across millennia in a few moments of being Most Sincerely Dead and of our myriad possible futures; “Don’t be afraid. Death is nothing; nothing but Awakening from an illusion.”
We returned from death with unique angles of view in an irrational and threatening universe whose meaning we struggled to make sensible and had fallen down the special rabbit hole of magic, vision, imagination, fantasy, Surrealism, myths and fairytales, all things occult, bizarre, and strange, the Addams Family with Gomez and Morticia our models as who we wanted to grow up to be, muy romantico and festooned with weapons, both forms of armor against a hostile universe we swore to face together back to back, and together developed interests in history and writing ourselves into it. This was a secret world we shared together, and secrets are a bond like no other. We imagined an enormous backstory of our romance as serial reincarnations together across centuries, from shared dreams; this was when I began to write, from the stories we used to shape each other, though it was my father’s Beatnik friend William S. Burroughs who taught me to write with his bizarre storytelling of an evening. And the vast scope and intricate mechanisms of history began to open for me as I researched details of our dreams and charted our course across, as Dracula phrases it in the film; “oceans of time”.
As to myself in the summer of 1974, my eighth grade had been spent devouring the works of Plato and Nietzsche, with Napoleon as my hero, in my second year of studying French at the high school and some months of learning Portuguese for my upcoming trip to Brazil to train for the Pan American Games as the Northern California foil and saber champion in my age division, and as I had since the age of nine studying fencing and chess with my father and obsessively practicing martial arts, Chinese and some Japanese language and calligraphy, the game of Go, and in formal Zen study with my teacher, whom I called Sifu Dragon, and with another art and teacher, Al Moore who had just awarded me a brown belt in Ed Parker’s Chinese Kenpo Karate. Chinatown had become a community of refuge for me from the theocratic Reformed Church town I grew up in where my father taught high school, but I had also grown up among my beatnik-hippie parents circle of intellectuals, my father a director of underground theatre and my mother a political activist, and home was also Telegraph Avenue and Haight-Ashbury, bright mirrors to the darkness in which I dwelled.
No recounting of my youth can be complete without mention of William S. Burroughs, family friend and a kind of unofficial uncle, and the bizarre stories he would tell of an evening; journeys to other realities, duels with chthonic beings, the art of curses, summoning and ritual magic. In short, precisely the same kind of imaginal world in which I lived, and through which I sought meaning in an Absurd and hostile universe. I still have the Tarot cards he gave me and taught me to shape reality with; I had asked him if the cards could tell the future, and he said; ”Tarot can do so much more than that; the true art is to create new futures, new selves, journey across alternate realities and timelines, break and recreate the rules of the universe.” Direct lines of transmission and successorship can be drawn from medieval ceremonial magic to Aleister Crowley to H.P. Lovecraft to Burroughs, and in a secondary line of transmission from Friedrich Nietzsche to Georges Bataille to Burroughs in another; and both from Burroughs to myself.
During the summer before my Sophomore year of high school I traveled to Spokane to find her, but she was gone, moved to Victoria though I learned this later from a letter. We did not meet again until the summer before my senior year, when I was seventeen, in Otter Crest Oregon, and again in Seattle the following summer after my graduation, and then over ten years later in June 1989 for my father’s funeral in Spokane, that last for myself occurring during my period of making mischief with Bluey’s crew of gypsies on both sides of the Iron Curtain, and between the Battle of Cuito Cuanavale in Angola ending in March 1988 where we broke the Apartheid regime and when we brought down the Berlin Wall in November 1989.
For the acts of our story which occurred after I began high school and she the grand adventures of her career as a diva and torch singer, I refer to my post of August 21 2025, A Cave of Stories: the Archeology of My Writing Space As An Imaginarium, in which I interrogated the idea of home as a memory palace and space of reflection, serenity, refuge, and creativity in a world which can be quite terrible and offers few of any of these fine things, and also the functions of home as an instrument for creating ourselves and the kind of relationship we imagine as our best; Herein I interrogate and problematize how we construct identity through our material environment as instruments of our stories, histories, memories; in the case of the archeology of my writing space. Dolly has also asked me to tell the story of her and I, and I do so now in the context of this mimetic shell we have constructed for ourselves, our cottage Dollhouse Park.
Close by is a photo of her building a sandman; this was the summer before my senior year of high school, when I drove up to visit her when she was playing her regular summer gig at Otter Crest Oregon, at the time the hottest resort on the emerald coast, and we built a sandman together and let the tide carry him out to sea, so that the tides would always bring us back together; I believe this magic has returned me from death many times since.
Since then I have fought more Last Stands than I can count with certainty,
We would find one another once again before our different currents carried us into strange seas for a long time, in Seattle the summer after my graduation from high school in 1978, myself 18 and university bound, she 22 and a career musician in Europe playing gigs and living at her beloved primary residence in Bath The Royal Crescent Hotel & Spa, her favorite resort in the Black Forest of Germany, the opulent Brenners Park-Hotel with the Villa Stefanie spa, on Princess and Norwegian cruise ships, and at the incomparable Ritz Paris within a short walk from the Opera and her side gig playing Harry’s New York Bar. She can speak conversational French and some German as a result of years working the room gladhanding the glitterati during breaks at her gigs. Through her twenties and thirties Dolly was a kind of minor star in Europe, in a very rarefied and exclusive circuit of cocktail lounges, restaurants, clubs, and ballrooms, and once turned down a recording contract with Deutsche Grammophon because she wished to retain artistic control of her own music. She played piano and sang for royalty and other elites, and also had the chance to live like one of them with expenses paid by the venues for over two glorious decades.
When living out of suitcases on the road began to lose its charm, she returned home to Spokane as she turned forty.
Our home, Dollhouse Park, began when Dolly’s father sold the land she was living on in a mobile home out from under her to build a housing development, a somewhat extreme solution to the problem of adult children living at home. This of course was not the classic Failure to Launch, as she had lived on the road playing music for over twenty years before returning to go to university for the very first time, first to Gonzaga University in Engineering and Law where her father had founded the Engineering Advisory Group when he owned a multinational and had eighty engineers working for him, thereafter she went to Eastern Washington University in Cheney to study Chemical Geology which she taught while working on her Master’s, to work in mining, for which her field camp was at the MacKay School of Mining in Nevada where a distant relative once discovered the Comstock Silver Lode. And when the gold mines began closing she went into Regulatory Affairs at Spokane’s Hollister Stier Pharmaceuticals, a field which combines chemistry, engineering, and law; during which time she also studied Business Intelligence at Harvard Business School.
Between her family home and the old Jesuit monastery of Mount St. Michaels where her father Gene used to jog over and help in the bakery as a boy was a hill with a spectacular view of the city at night, across a wetlands and up a winding dirt road where a horse farm once stood. To this spot she brought a chair and watched the sun set for several days from different vantage points and angles of view, and then bought the hilltop, had a daylight basement dynamited out of the backside and concrete poured for the foundation, framed in steel I beams, and her mobile dragged over them and oriented just as she had chosen.
Having begun building a nest, she then had a detective track me down where I was teaching high school AP English in California, and called me. We had not spoken in over twelve years, since my father’s funeral in 1989; I had gone through yet another teacher credential program and returned to teaching to fulfill the terms of a vision I had in which she came to my classroom to claim me.
Much happened for me in the meanwhile; the Fall of the Berlin Wall, the Second Intifada, the Siege of Sarajevo, the resistance of the Karen and Shan against the ethnic cleansing campaign of Myanmar, the defense of Kashmir and my studies of Sufism as a member of the Naqshbandi order, becoming a monk and Dream Navigator of the Kagyu Vajrayana order of Tibetan Buddhism and the Revolution in Nepal, the end of Apartheid, my trek across America by horseback as a counselor for teenage felons, the Zapatista movement, sailing from Hong Kong on voyages of exploration following the routes of Joseph Conrad, establishing a home port on the island of Penang in Malaysia where I converted a row of shophouses into a headquarters and refit a traditional Phinisi schooner into a privateer, a pirate campaign to liberate enslaved sailors in the Indonesian Islands and South China Sea among other actions, learning the Raja Harimau or tiger style of silat among the Minangkabu people after being castaway in a storm on one of the Mentawai Islands and building an outrigger to sail to Sumatra, and so much more of which I am a witness of history.
The previous time I had spoken with Dolly was also by phone, after the funeral where we met again for a single night and a day over ten years after our last adventures the summer after my graduation from high school. I was living in a two level Victorian brick house in Glen Ellen near Sonoma at the foot of Jack London State Park and next to the burned out derelict of the Chauvet Hotel, once the hideout of Machine Gun Kelly and a casino of Bugsy Siegel’s, and a port for the steamboats that ran up Sonoma Creek from the San Francisco Bay when it was a navigable waterway. My view was an open wild meadow along the creek where a gypsy would park his wagon over the winter, a real wooden wagon pulled by a donkey who brayed mournfully at night, and just upstream from the Old Mill which still grinds olive oil by stone wheel.
Dolly called me just as a rascally opossum arrived on my kitchen counter to share my breakfast as he often did, quite uninvited, and impatient for the offering of leftovers I would put out on the deck, through eaves where my bats lived. He was sniffing my breakfast fry up as we said our hellos, and I turned from our conversation to yell at him “Get Out of Here!”
As she has told me, she thought I was yelling at her, and hung up.
The line went dead, and there was no caller id or callback on the old landline phones. I had no idea where in the world she was, only that she had reached out to me and believed herself rebuffed. But she was out there, somewhere, waiting for me to find her.
There were many other causes and reasons for what I chose to do next; first the death of my father, who took me to his theatrical rehearsals where I sat with him and Edward Albee listening to their conversations between director and author, taught me to fence and play chess, took me to martial arts lessons for ten years and brought me in to his theatricals of ceremonial magic staged with his Beatnik friend William S. Burroughs, was my high school Drama and Forensics teacher, theater director, and debate and fencing coach, whose death was a life disruptive event, which left me wondering who I was without these things connected with my father that shaped me, and who I was doing all this Forensics and martial arts teaching for.
Second, we had just brought down the Berlin Wall, and I thought; Why not bring down all the Walls, everywhere, my own most especially?
The third and final cause in this cascade of dominoes and the trigger event was the tragedy of the Dropped Call and missed connection; somewhere in this very large world, in which I had nothing and no one beyond my mother and sister as anchorages from which to create meaning, love was waiting for me to find.
And for love we must dare anything.
So I found myself driving to work one day, with my lunch packed beside me, and in a moment of lightning bolt illumination, to use the Buddhist term, realized that I was literally living in Nietzsche’s Hell, that I was about to have the same day as I had beyond remembering, swallowed by the sameness and the Nothing. And I thought; Why am I doing this? I don’t need to do this, and took a wrong turn, to the airport where I bought a continuous ticket for round the world travel. When the ticket agent asked where I wanted to go, I said the other side of the world.
I only discovered my destination was Kuala Lumpur Malaysia when I got off the plane, and was whisked away to the glittering business district where everyone was doing things I could have easily done at home in San Francisco if I wished. So I found a map of the bus routes, where all the roads ended in the Cameron Highlands, and decided to begin my journey there, at a bus stop across from a temple of Ganesha where I made an offering, doing what no one else was doing and where none dared go. I got off the bus at the end of the road, and walked into an unmapped jungle.
Thus began my Great Trek, wherein I crossed much of South Asia on foot and later by sail, and after many adventures returned on the tenth anniversary of my journey, because of a vision which set forth the conditions I must meet to find Dolly; I had to be teaching high school again, which required classes and recertification, and she would come to my classroom to claim me. This she did nearly three years later in 2002.
Quite wily about her plan she was; she called and ended the conversation with; “I’m coming to San Francisco to visit a Jesuit priest who was my friend at Gonzaga. Would you like to meet for coffee?” Over coffee she told me; “Really I came to see you.”
Once I moved in we began rebuilding everything, and all of it is custom work now, but the Dollhouse, so named for her, began as a mobile home for a couple who had never lived together before though we had known each other our whole lives, with a lot of dreams and very little money with which to realize them. That last bit has changed in the past few years, long after Dollhouse Park was completed, and we did most of the work ourselves with whatever we could gather, though with crucial family help.
Her father drew the plans for the house; I drew the design for the landscape based on Gertrude Jekyll’s designs for National Trust estates in England, and we hired out only the electrical box and the plumbing, with help from a number of her family’s employees and de facto family retainers, available because her brothers own Bullseye Amusements which they founded as a pinball arcade on their uncle Bob’s carnival as teenagers and now own over two thousand machines in casinos and bars in the Spokane area, and control the local gaming industry.
Our cottage is now a main house of three thousand square feet on two levels, with a Cat Tower connecting the daylight basement with the main upper floor by two flights of stairs, totaling 4,152 square feet counting the Tiki Bar Deck, plus a 1280 square foot three bay garage with a shop and storage. This means that the Dollhouse is tiny, 5,576 sf if you count the gazebo and garage but not our greenhouse or two garden sheds, with just barely enough storage room for two people and our things, but I think the grounds are the finest private park in the city.
And nothing can surpass for us the stories of ours it holds, the hopes and dreams and visions of our lifelong romance and the histories of our struggles to make them real.
So it is that a boy who wanted to be Gomez writes in celebration of a girl who wanted to be Morticia, over fifty years after a Defining Moment of realization that we dream each other’s dreams.
And this birthday of Dolly’s coincides with our ancient celebration of death and transformation as Halloween, wherein we let our demons out to play, a time of masquerades, the performance of secret identities, violations of normality and transgressions of the boundaries of the Forbidden, reversals of order, the embrace of our monstrosity, of the reimagination and transformation of ourselves, and the pursuit of new truths through ecstatic trance and poetic vision, which for us now begins with the Festival of Loki as Breaking the Silence, and includes the lunar month of the Festival of Lucifer the Rebel, Kali Puja, and our new national holiday of amok time and the celebration of love, transgression, and vision as divine madness, the Festival of the Mad Hatter, a figure of Dionysus.
The Mad Hatter acts as a psychopomp or guide of the soul in Alice in Wonderland, and Alice is a Holy Fool like Parsifal, but he and Alice are also figures of a single whole person and the story one of hierosgamos or heavenly marriage; like Beauty and the Beast or Catherine and Heathcliff in Wuthering Heights.
The genius and allure of the Addams Family is not only that they combine an iconic romantic couple as an aspirational ideal of relationships with a family which accepts the uniqueness of its members and valorizes transgression in both themes, but that they are also a pantheon, and one entirely free from the consequences of patriarchy.
Much like the figures of Morticia, who occupies the imaginal space of Lillith, Kali, Persephone, and the Morrigan as a goddess of time, death, sex, and rebirth, and Gomez, like Pluto an Underworld King of fate, luck, wealth, chaos, and mischief who subsumes elements of Milton’s Rebel Angel and Loki the Trickster. Or in our own unique ways, Dolly and myself as people who claimed these roles as children and dreamed ourselves into such shapes as best we might.
We have defined this month as a liminal time which begins with a festival of desire or eros and ends with one of death or thanos; a space of balance in which all things become possible.
Who then shall we become? Asks our self of surfaces, images, and masks which each moment negotiates our boundaries with others.
To which our secret self, the self of darkness and of passion, the self that lives beyond the mirror and knows no limits, unbound by time and space and infinite in possibilities, replies; Who do you want to become?
We can parse the meaning of the word love in terms of its origins, as does Professor Babette Babich; “The classical list, as C.S. Lewis and others detail it, is: storgē, love of the home or the family; philia or friendship, which we hear in philosophy as love of wisdom; eros which is what we’re most interested in — taking us back to the #metoo movement, including questions of men and women in love. And then there is agapē, a pure, specifically selfless love, in contrast to eros, which is anything but selfless. Agapē is anticlimactic, and even St. Augustine, praying for grace, prayed to be perfect but, as he famously wrote, not yet.
The hierarchy of kinds of love mirrors — to tell a fanciful, proto-evolutionary story — the story of our lives. We’re born into storgē, family love, the love of home and hearth. That can be conflicted to be sure, as Robert Frost reminds us: ‘Home is the place where, when you have to go there, / They have to take you in.’”
What does love do? Love sublimes us into a unitary being, erases our limits as individuals defined by our form and liberates us from the event horizon of our flesh.
Love also reveals to us our true selves; a lover has the power to see the truth of others, and to reveal to others their true selves, and models thereby an ideal of human relationships. We choose partners who can help us become the person we want to be, and who embody qualities we wish to assimilate to ourselves; a healthy relationship returns to us and helps us discover our true and best selves. To love is to transform others by the power of our vision to see who they truly are and set them free.
A lover is both a Pythian seer of truths who like Michelangelo can free us as images captive within the matrix of our bodies and our material and social context, who in naming us like Adam naming the beasts defines our truth, and an inverted figure of Medusa, goddess and monster, a victim cursed for the crimes of her abuser like Hester Prynne in The Scarlet Letter, and whose power to turn men to stone appropriates the dehumanizing and objectifying power of the Male Gaze and transforms it into the power to see others true selves and release them to be free, and to mutually assimilate the qualities of the other and transform them both.
Love is a divine madness which defiles and exalts, reveals truths and confers authenticity, and the redemptive power of love can make glorious and beautiful the flaws of our humanity and bring healing to the brokenness of the world and the pathology of our disconnectedness.
In this I speak to you of truths which are immanent in nature and written in our flesh; we must claim our truths and celebrate what Walt Whitman called the songs of ourselves as victorious seizures of power, freedom, and joy.
Love and desire are innate capacities of reimagination and transformative rebirth, which like Dorothy’s magic ruby slippers cannot be taken from us and bear the power to send us home to our heart’s desire, to restore to us the self which is truly ours.
My flesh is a map of private holocausts, written with silent screams, nameless loves, causes lost and won, ephemeral signs of our secret histories and the lies and illusions which capture and distort our images in a wilderness of mirrors and the pathologies of our falsification and disconnectedness.
We have but one escape from the limits of our flesh and the flags of our skin; and this is love. In love we transcend ourselves and become exalted; through the redemptive power of love we may heal the flaws of our humanity and the brokenness of the world.
The quality of our humanity is not fixed, but always in motion, like the turbulent systems da Vinci studied in his fountain and which later with new mathematics came to be described as chaos theory. Identity is a process which is fluid, and our emotions are instruments with which it creates itself.
We create ourselves over time, through our history of defining moments; human being is a prochronism, a history expressed in our form of how we solved problems of adaptation. What we call our self or our soul is no different in kind from the exoskeleton of an insect or the shell of a sea creature.
And we create ourselves through our interdependence with others, our relationships, friends, families, communities, and the systems of signs thereof.
Human being has in this scheme three orders of relationships; persona, history, and interdependence, and all of it is in motion, dynamic and inherently unstable.
Impermanence is the defining quality of nature and the material universe; so also is the controlling metaphor and condition of human nature, being, and identity our ephemeral, transitory, and protean forms. Nature is a mirror which reflects itself, and like the Hobgoblin’ fragmented mirror in Hans Christian Andersen’s The Snow Queen, reveals endless possibilities of becoming human; the inward and outward halves of the cosmos also create and define each other in mutual coevolution, like Escher’s Drawing Hands.
As Goethe wrote in Faust; “Let us extend our lives through our bodies in all directions possible”.
For me the origin of human evil is in unequal relationships and the Wagnerian Ring of fear, power, and force, pathologies of violence and dominion which require the renunciation of love as their price; not in the violation of taboos, the transgression of the Forbidden, or the defiance of Authority, three things I count as sacred acts in pursuit of the truth of ourselves, but in the systemic and structural injustices and inequalities of hegemonic elites, their lies and illusions which falsify us and steal our souls, and the state tyranny and terror of brutal force and control which we must resist and refuse to submit to, that we may become autonomous and free as self- created and self-owned beings; for power and force are meaningless when met with disobedience, and in the moment of our refusal to submit to authority we become Unconquered and free.
Writing of love in Letters to Milena, Franz Kafka gives us this witness; “I wish the world were ending tomorrow. Then I could take the next train, arrive at your door in Vienna, and say, Come with me, Milena. We are going to love each other without scruples or fear or restraint. Because the world is ending tomorrow.
Perhaps we don’t love unreasonably because we think we have time, or have to reckon with time. But what if we don’t have time? Or what if time, as we know it, is irrelevant? Ah, if only the world were ending tomorrow. We could help each other very much.”
Here is the true origin of Nietzsche’s idea of Eternal Return as a test and praxis of Authenticity, and it recalls to me something I once said to Jean Genet. He had sat down at my table after my friends and I made our morning race against death, crossing a sniper alley to reach a cafe in Beirut that had the best strawberry crepes in the world.
“I’m told you do this every day, steal breakfast from death.”
To which I replied, “Moments stolen from death are all we truly own. It’s a poor man who loves nothing beyond reason, and has no pleasures worth dying for.”
He smiled and said,” I agree”; this was the beginning of our conversations at breakfast in the days of the terrible siege, which would reset the path of my life.
My wish for all of us is that we may find such friends who can reveal to us our true selves and offer figural spaces into which to grow; such is my functional definition of love.
Through love and desire we pursue a sacred calling to discover our truths, truths which are immanent in nature and written in our flesh. Herein also we escape the limits of our flesh as we become sublimed and exalted in unification with others, who free our captive images from the wilderness of mirrors which falsify us. Love is an instrument with which we may liberate and empower each other and restore to one another our autonomy and authenticity.
Love and desire are forces of liberation, uncontrollable as the tides and inherently anarchic. They are our most powerful weapons against authority and tyranny; for they can neither be taken from us nor limited.
Love like you have laughed in the face of your executioner, for this is exactly what love is.
For my next act I offer you the figure of my mother, as with us all a co-equal source of identity construction with my life partner with whom together in chiaroscuro form the anima or inner idea of the feminine principle which manifests in my unconscious.
As I wrote in my post of March 11 2026, Shaping Forces of Myself: My Mother and My Partner As Instruments of Self-Construal, Identities of Sex and Gender Part Four; We men are co-created by the two great figures of our anima as informing, motivating, and shaping forces; that of our mothers and of our partners, in succession and in parallel and interdependent processes of becoming human.
Herein I offer both in juxtaposition, and the doubled chiaroscuro of these figures with each other and also relative to my nominative case self or persona as my own unconscious self which operates below the level of awareness, except in dreams, visions, ecstatic trance, and moments of oceanic supraconsciousness.
While I cannot inhabit or speak for the imaginal space of a woman, I can do so regarding the idea of woman which lives within me, offstage, but bearing historical narratives which unfold continuously in ways which may be defined and taxonomized.
What I am suggesting in this essay is that we may operate on our own unconscious selves by instrumentalizing the stories of which we are made.
Our mothers and our partners live in our mimetic spaces as archetypal figures and symbols, as idealizations of feminine beauty, but also as real women whom we have internalized in processes of self-construal, and as such can be explored as both myth and as history.
Here follow mine; do write your own personal histories of your unconscious self, for men of mothers and for women of fathers, and of the partners you have chosen to help in your self creation, whom we choose because they represent qualities we wish to assimilate to ourselves.
I used the word juxtaposition for this method, in reference to Warhol’s misaligned portraits, Tristan Tzara’s poetry of collages, and the Cut-Up Method of William S. Burroughs, and also describe my method with the word chiaroscuro, a term from art history for the contrast of darkness and light which creates boundaries and interfaces which define form, such as the shape of a human soul.
Here follow stories of my mother as an origin and as legacies of history which may for some of us be imposed conditions of struggle as well as sources of nurturance and resilience.
As I wrote in my post of January 20 2026, On the Anniversary of My Mother’s Death, and an Interrogation of Death; On a night of terrible windstorms and roaring gales, full of strange sounds both animal and unearthly in her Las Vegas neighborhood full of performers and celebrities from the casino shows and their exotic pets, of fragments of forgotten stories and conversations with the dead, my mother won her last struggle to free herself from the limits of her form, emerging from an outworn body as a transcendent and radiant being into the limitless possibilities of the Infinite unknown.
Wherever she may be, I hope there is laughter, joy, and dancing.
Dancing was the great joy of her life in retirement, teaching and her beloved students that of her professional life, and the company of her family and friends a joy always.
To all those who shared the journey of her life, I thank you and hope that in bringing joy to others you may also find your own such joys, whatever they may be.
The brokenness of the world and the flaws of our humanity is an immense sea of darkness, against which we have only the light we can give to each other.
May we all of us by our actions become such lights for each other, and find illumination, hope, and the redemptive power of love in those moments of exaltation offered by others.
These words I wrote five years ago on awakening from strange dreams to discover my mother had died, having come to help and spent some fine days with her in conversation.
In rereading my writings on this event I have come to realize it is a Defining Moment, one which I have interrogated only in terms of the trauma of death and the shape of grief process.
Years later in reflection, I am able to think of this also in terms of the joy my mother gave me and so very many others. I now have a quantitative measure of the half life of my heart as it transforms over time and my grief degrades like the forms we must all one day escape.
Like my father and myself, she was a high school English and Forensics teacher, and whenever students asked her if a thing was true or not, or asked for some pronouncement of interpretation of a book, current events, or political or religious ideologies, she held up her open hands and bounced them side to side, singing “Maybe, maybe not, Maybe, maybe not”. This was a demonstration of one of her Great Lessons, taken from a theatrical performance which included some of her students that toured America as The Reduced Shakespeare Company: The Complete Works of William Shakespeare Abridged Comedy; “We do not authorize truths, we question them. There are no absolute truths, only ambiguous and relatives truths, which change with who is telling them and why, and we must question whose power is served by any claims of truth.”
To this I wish to add; Your truths and mine will be different because we are, possessed by different histories and embedded in different informing, motivating, and shaping sources. This does not mean that one of us is right and the other is wrong, only that our uniqueness is born of different truths, both those written in our flesh and those we ourselves create.
Another such lesson regards the duty of witness and the sacred calling to pursue the truth; she would begin the first day of class each year with the story of how she asked questions about theology as a twelve year old girl in a private Catholic school until an enraged and brutally cruel nun, as they all seem to be, broke her finger with a ruler, whereupon she got up from her desk and walked out forever from the school and the Church; then she would hold up her crooked finger to the class and say; “We are not silent. We question, we demand proof, we take no authority at their word.”
To this I add, there is no just authority.
The great secret of power and authority, of force and control, is that without legitimacy it is hollow and brittle, and fails at the point of disbelief and disobedience. Therefore the Four Primary Duties of a Citizen are Question Authority, Expose Authority, Mock Authority, and Challenge Authority.
Such was her art of education, the bringing forth of truths, both those immanent in nature and written in our flesh and those we ourselves create, and of becoming human.
Who was she as a person, and a primary influence on me?
First, she was funny, imaginative, empathetic, insightful, compassionate, and fearless in her performance of the Four Primary Duties of a Citizen and action in Solidarity and Resistance to systems of oppression.
I rode on her shoulders when we seized the Palace of Justice, headquarters of the city police and courts, in San Francisco in 1968, and held her hand in the front line on Bloody Thursday 1969 in Peoples Park Berkeley when the police opened fire on the student peace protest against the Occupation of Palestine and the University of California’s investments in the Israeli war machine. We worked together in the Sanctuary and Anti-Apartheid Movements of the 1980’s and many other actions including the Liberation of Palestine and of Northern Ireland, that last being why she named my sister Erin, and she marched in protests until her final years, the very last in the 2017 Women’s March to save Roe Versus Wade and the right of bodily autonomy and to protest the inauguration of Traitor Trump and his capture of the state as a fascist theocratic patriarchy.
Her own personal joys included playing the piano as she had from childhood, Scrabble which we played together like I played chess with my father, playing bridge which she was quite good at and once won a Las Vegas championship tournament with a partner, and folk dancing which she learned at the wonderful Papa’s Taverna in Petaluma, Sunday gathering place of the Bay Area Greek community and venue for traveling musicians from Greece, and in retirement as a member of the Las Vegas Ethnic Express troupe which included show dancers and dance teachers from everywhere, who became some of her best friends with whom she traveled to Europe on dance tours. They danced at her 80th birthday party, which included a Flamenco performance by one of Spain’s greatest dancers.
She wrote jokes for comedians including Phyllis Diller, who served as a kind of alter ego of mom’s, a study of psychosomatic muteness from the childhood therapy journals and Soviet hospital records of Jerzy Kosinski which he had fictionalized as The Painted Bird, a master’s thesis on Coleridge’s Rhyme of the Ancient Mariner, and sold a short story she wrote about me, Little Bear Looks, to Maurice Sendak because I wanted to see it illustrated, which became a popular book and television series. Her full list of graduate studies included Biology, Psychology, and English Literature which she had switched to because “all the science jobs had Women Need Not Apply written on them in great big letters”. Always writing she was, and curious about everything. As a child I would ask her for stories with Oulipo-like parameters; she often spoke of my request “Tell me a story about an alligator, and make it rhyme.”
From her I learned to write, to organize political action, and to cook; she was a Chef of the French -Viennese cuisine of the old Austro-Hungarian Empire of the Hapsburgs as a family legacy, later an enthusiast of Greek and Russian cuisine, and of the wild game recipes passed down from my great grandmother Apollonia who was a hunting guide, often for expeditions which were like a royal procession and very grand. During my years as a teacher and counselor I used cooking as a reset activity to partition my work life from my personal life; chop things up, set fire to them, and eat them, and any lingering trauma from the day is consumed with them like being one’s own Sin Eater.
My love and receptivity for languages is a legacy from my mother and her family; here I must tell Apollonia’s story as told to me by my mother of how Jewish people saved our family, when no one else would, and without whom none of us would have ever lived.
Upon the docks of America arrived a nine year old girl, alone and without a penny to her name or a word of English. A Stranger, with no one waiting to meet her, no family, no friends, nothing. My maternal great grandmother Apollonia this was, with flaming red hair like my mother’s, whose family had put her on a ship to escape from Austria as their home burned, the sole survivor of her whole town so far as we now know.
She wandered the port of Seattle asking for help, in her five languages and in descending likelihood of recognition; French, Austrian, Hungarian, Serbo-Croatian, and finally, in despair and fear that the reaction would be far worse than being abandoned to starve and freeze to death lost and alone among strangers, Yiddish.
This like a magic spell summoned a crowd, by happy chance not one armed with torches and axes. So a stranger was taken in and raised by Jewish people, a family or families of whom I know nothing, and thus our family’s survival is owed to the entire Jewish community, diaspora, and people.
This happened in 1873, year of the glorious Vienna World’s Fair but also the stock market crash in the wake of the Franco-Prussian War which began a twenty year Depression in Europe and the Jewish persecutions as they were blamed for it; also conflicts between the Russian and Ottoman Empires in their borderlands.
What, there was already a Jewish community in Washington State? In 1875 Bailey Gatzert became Mayor of Seattle; in 1892 he co-founded Seattle’s first synagogue, Ohaveth Shalom. So yes there was; and Apollonia was raised as a Jew by kind benefactors who adopted her.
Not that she was terribly conventional by the standards of her time, regardless of her identity.
She it was who owned her own rifles and horses by the age of sixteen when she began her career as a hunting guide, and died in the saddle at the age of 95, rifle in her hand, having shot the bear that attacked her horses and killed her. The Indians buried her like the Huns buried Attila, on her horse and with her rifle, like a warrior princess.
I was born within days of her death, and as with all ancestors I bear her onward, literally as DNA and the stories which possess us as the ghosts of other lives; incarnated truths written in our flesh. As a child I claimed to be her reincarnation, imaginative and filled with stories I experienced as memories as if I had lived them, until I was old enough to realize how absurd this idea was, though the feeling of being shadowed by her remains with me.
Certainly I identified with her in my love of adventure travel and exploration of unknowns, a figure among the great adventuresses like Isabella Bird and Ida Pfeiffer, enchanted by my mother’s Wild West and Gilded Age stories of her. Somewhere in my twenties, between the 1982 Siege of Beirut and the 1989 victory over Apartheid at the August 1987 to March 1988 Battle of Cuito Cuanavale in Angola, her place in my imagination was taken by Sir Richard Francis Burton whose travel books I read voraciously.
Historical context and the fact that my ancestor in the maternal line knew Yiddish makes it possible that under Jewish law we are Jews, and Apollonia had been raised as a member of the Jewish community and because of this influence was clearly Jewish by faith and culture if not by ancestry, though my mother never claimed so and moreover was a radical atheist who raised us with no religious traditions at all. In so doing the family faith she liberated herself from was Catholicism, an artifact of her Austrian paternal line who were exiles of the 1919 fall of the Hapsburg Empire after 600 years.
My mother’s speech was permeated with Yiddish words and phrases, a legacy of my maternal great grandmother; my maternal grandfather was the source of the family German, actually Wienerisch or the Viennese dialect of Austro-Bavarian, combined with the French-influenced Schönbrunner Deutsch sociolect of the imperial court. This was the home language of my mother’s family, though grandpa knew Latin, taught himself English, and to various degrees knew other languages of the Austrian Empire including Hungarian, Romanian, Ukrainian, Croatian, the Romance language Venetian and its Triestino dialect, and could speak Russian and Polish well enough to do business in their communities here in America.
As a teenager immersed in Holocaust literature while working through the trauma of a near death experience in Brazil the summer before high school, my execution by a police death squad while rescuing abandoned street children they were bounty hunting having been prevented by the Matadors, and conversations with my mother as she wrote her study of psychosomatic muteness from the Soviet medical records and childhood therapy journal of Jerzy Kosinski which he fictionalized as The Painted Bird, I once asked her directly, Are we Jews?
To this she replied; “Everyone is a Jew. Everyone is someone’s Jew, someone’s scapegoat, someone’s Other. The great task of becoming human is to embrace our uniqueness as we overcome our fear of otherness.”
I find this definition an interesting solution to the dilemma of the question of Jewish identity and the claims of ethnicity or being Jewish by maternal descent and of faith or being Jewish by the Three Knots of the Infinite, of Torah, and of the diasporic community of Israel.
So, who decides how we may think of ourselves, our histories, memories, and identities? How is membership and belonging conferred? And even if it is to be ourselves alone, sovereign, self owned, and possibly self created, by what criterion shall we define our terms?
Always there remains the struggle between the masks that others make for us and those we make for ourselves. This is the defining act of becoming human, and the first revolution in which we all must fight; the struggle for the ownership of ourselves.
But this is not the end of such questions, and only a beginning; for identity is inherently ambiguous, relational, contingent, and a process in ceaseless motion as a chaotic system, an infinite Moebius Loop of being wherein we shift and change with the horizons of our imagination, the legacies of our history, and the stories we bear like warrior marks.
On this theme a final story for now; among my earliest memories is watching the burning cross my town set on fire on the front lawn of newlyweds, a Dutch Reformed Church man and a Swiss Calvinist girl, which the town was calling a mixed marriage because they were members of different churches, though both white Protestants speaking forms of German. It was like a carnival; I asked a neighbor boy who was laughing madly and running about with a torch in his hand why they were setting fires and he said “We’re punishing the bad people”.
Then I asked my mom, “Are they bad people?”
She said no, and with ferocity pointed at the crowd with torches, “These are the bad people. And they are always our enemies, yours and mine.”
My next question was, “Why are they bad?”
And she forever simplified a complex set of issues for me with her answer; “Because they want to make everyone the same.”
Now we move from anima to animus in the figure of my father.
If the time we spend with someone is a measure of their influence on who we become, my father is the most important person in my story. From long hours playing chess together from earliest childhood to the many years he taught me fencing and brought me to martial arts lessons, through my teens when he was my high school drama and forensics teacher, director of plays and debate coach, to his collaboration in running my business teaching kung fu by which I put myself through university, he was a near constant and ever present companion and mentor from childhood through the formative years of my twenties.
Among my earliest memories are those of sitting with him and Edward Albee while he directed his plays, listening intently to their conversations during rehearsals from a center front seat in the theatre, from the very young age of four, and memorizing everything as texts which overwrote my own thinking, conversations which interrogated Albee’s direct influences and references among his fellow Absurdists Samuel Beckett, Eugene Ionesco, Jean Genet, and Harold Pinter, the line of transmission of Absurdist elements in literature as it originates with Fyodor Dostoevsky, Lewis Carroll, Nikolai Gogol, and Franz Kafka, diverges from the limits of Humanism with Antonin Artaud, Eugene Ionesco, Witold Gombrowicz, Albert Camus, diverged from the main tradition as Nihilism in Samuel Beckett and Kobo Abe, and continues today in the works of Haruki Murakami, Kurt Vonnegut, and Elif Shafak.
For Edward Albee, whose works were among those I could recite verbatim at the age of four, literally as I used to sit in at rehearsals and give the actors their lines if someone forgot, the failure of order in both political and psychological terms was a symptom of Sartrean bad faith.
Here also Albee leads us through a labyrinth of mirrors, a funhouse of distorted images, both comical and grotesque, images which capture and reflect, assimilating or robbing us of our uniqueness in infinite regress to steal our souls, which through his magic of seeing our true selves becomes a Hobgoblin’s Broken Mirror as in in Anderson’s The Snow Queen, fragmented images which multiply our possibilities of becoming human.
This was the world of the imagination from which I was born and arose, and you cannot see America and the fate of humankind as I do from outside the paradigm of Absurdist theatre.
Thereafter came my father’s influence in fencing and access to martial arts training as seizures of power and healing from trauma by turning fear into an instrument of my own use to escape the recurse forces of Fear, Power, and Force as violence as a system of oppression, in the wake of Bloody Thursday May 15 1969, People’s Park Berkeley, when a police grenade tore my consciousness from my body and in a moment outside time I beheld a vision of myriads of possible futures, only a few of which did not collapse in an Age of Tyrants and centuries of horrific wars ending in human extinction.
My reaction to this was triggered by sitting on a wad of gum someone had put on my seat in class; while everyone was out playing at recess I went to the chemistry set and poured the contents of the bottles marked with a skull and crossbones down the spigot of the drinking fountain in retaliation.
That afternoon half a dozen kids were outside throwing up, and I felt not triumph but horror, because I realized I could have unintentionally killed everyone. Having by chance escaped becoming a nine year old mass murderer and profoundly shaken, I told my father about it that night.
To this my father replied; “You have discovered politics; politics is the Art of Fear. Fear as the basis of human exchange, balanced only by belonging. Most importantly, it is about the use of force.
Fear is a good servant and a terrible master; those who use it to subjugate others are motivated by fear themselves, and if you can show them you do not fear them they will be afraid of you, and you can use it as a lever to win dominance.
We must rule or be ruled, for we are surrounded by beasts. Fear is a ground of struggle. Fear precedes power. So, whose instrument will it be?
Fear, power, and the use of social force are balanced with the need to belong. Sometimes its best to do what others do to fit in, but it isn’t always best, and it can be very wrong. Best is to discover what’s best for you, no matter how different that is, and find belonging on your own terms and no one else’s. Even if you have to create that community yourself.
What you need now is a way to control fear and confront people directly when you’re upset with them that doesn’t cause more harm than it solves.”
I embraced this opportunity to learn martial arts with great enthusiasm, and began ten years of immersion in fencing, martial arts, rifle marksmanship and and combat pistol gunfighting, wilderness survival, anything I could learn that might empower me and offer security in a hostile or at best indifferent universe where everything is more powerful than we human beings.
Third in order of occurrence was my father’s role as an underground theatre director in staging his friend William S. Burrough’s magic ceremonies which opened doors of possibilities in my imagination, like a breach in the celestial sphere letting angels through, and devils.
As I wrote in my post of June 15 2026, Gods of My Father: Father’s Day Part One;
Prologue
To seize power from Authority as archetypal figure of the Father as Lawgiver and Tyrant is a primary ground of revolutionary struggle, historically and most especially in the context of theocracy as a system of oppression.
This is interdependent with Patriarchy as institutionalized sexual terror, for theocracy and Patriarchy arise together and develop as twin forces of unequal power, with the birth of agriculture, slavery, kings and priests and empires, and police overseers to keep the slaves at their work and enforce the law and order of those who would enslave us.
There are always masters in gold robes who speak for the gods, anoint kings, send Crusades and Inquisitions, and whose lies convince others to do the hard and dirty work for them. This is religion, and nothing more.
Here also is the origin of the archetypal Father as Lawgiver and Tyrant, a Saturn who devours his children in service to his own wealth and power; an origin with us still in the Horn of Plenty which resides as an altar object on our Thanksgiving tables, originally the feast of Saturn, god of the harvest.
Law serves power, order appropriates, and there is no just Authority.
To this bestial and depraved cannibal tyrant and god I say with Nikos Kazantzakis; “I hope for nothing, I fear nothing, I am free.”
Act One
My Mirror Family Portrait and Shadow Pantheon: Typhoeus and his daughters; detail from Klimt’s Beethoven Frieze
When as Nietzsche warned I gaze too long into the Abyss, and the Abyss gazes back into me, what forms does it take?
This I chose as a shadow pantheon and family portrait during my eighth grade year; who was I then?
Eighth grade was a year spent reading Plato and Nietzsche whose Thus Spake Zarathustra I adopted as a counter-text to the Bible, became the Northern California foil and saber fencing champion in the under 18 age division which I held through high school, won a poetry contest and the typewriter on which I wrote my first novel, was awarded a brown belt in Chinese Kenpo Karate by Al Moore before he left Ed Parker’s organization and rebranded his system as Shou Shu, a change in name only, and ran amok like a feral thing all over Berkeley and San Francisco.
After five years of learning Chinese and Japanese languages and other traditional arts I was reasonably fluent in them; it was also my second year of attending French classes at the high school instead of English at my grade level in the elementary school, and I was an enthusiast of Surrealist literature and cinema which aligned with my practice of magic influenced by my father’s Voodoo hybridized with the unique Chaos magic of his Beatnik friend William S. Burroughs, made of his friend Georges Bataille’s cult of Nietzsche, Acephale, Lovecraftian mythos and elements of Grimm’s fairytales, methods from Tristan Tzara’s Dada, Cut Up and other strategies of randomization based on the I Ching, a Surrealism derived from the Egyptian Book of the Dead through Philip Lamantia, Shamanic rites and sources, and traditional medieval ceremonial magic together with that of Aleister Crowley. Such were the magics I was raised with and the gods of my father; in choosing the figures of the Beethoven Frieze as a pantheon and ancestral family, I was choosing something uniquely mine.
This was also the year of two Defining Moments during the summer of 1974 between eighth grade and high school, when during Expo 74 in Spokane my relationship with my partner Dolly became a romance, and the trip to Brazil for which I learned conversational Portuguese as my fourth language, to train as a fencer for the Pan American Games which became a running street fight against police bounty hunters who were killing abandoned street children and the first of my many Last Stands.
So I was as a boy whose hero was Napoleon and found connection with Klimt’s Typhoeus as an animus figure, both of my own shadow and a kind of archetypal Ur-Father.
Here I paraphrase and annotate a description on Art Wall; “The centre wall was conceived as a pictorial paraphrase of the final movement of Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony and depicted the struggle for happiness undertaken by a knight in armour who, vanquishing the ‘hostile powers’, leads ‘weak humanity’ into the realm of the arts.
The painting represents the hostile forces which humanity must face, for myself both a pantheon and a family portait: Typhoeus, the Titan, against whom even gods fought in vain, and his daughters, the three Gorgons. The longings and wishes of mankind fly over their heads.
In the centre of the group lurks Typhoeus, a giant ape-like monster with beautiful dragonfly wings and a serpentine or dragon body, which according to mythology, is the offspring of the earth goddess, Gaia, and the god of the underworld, Tartaros. His eyes gaze back at us from the Abyss, as Nietzsche warned.
To his left side are his daughters, the three Gorgons: “Illness, Madness, and Death.”
Above the Gorgons, the skeletal female figure of Death lurks in unmatched dramatism, with nameless terrors as masklike figures crowding behind. I have wondered if this represents the demoness and ur-Mother Lilith in her Kali-like aspect and her Thousands of Myriads of children, we monsters.
Away from the crowded figures, in front of the hideous snake body and the mighty blue wings of the monster, crouches the “Nagender Kummer” (Gnawing Grief), a meagre female figure whose expressiveness is particularly striking.
On his right side, forces of life balance those of darkness as a Triple Goddess of transgression beyond all limits and the boundaries of the Forbidden: “Lasciviousness, Wantonness, and Intemperance.”
What more could a boy ask for?
Act Two
Let us claim and embrace our monstrosity, the wildness of nature and the wildness of ourselves: the Shadow as Nietzsche’s Toad
Here is a nested set of puzzles like the evils of Pandora’s Box or gateways to otherness opened by Clive Barker’s Lament Configuration, bearing wonders and terrors in equal measure, and we can never grow wise enough to truly say which is which.
Can we open the secrets of human being, meaning, and value without angels and demons, potentialities of darkness and light, reflections of each other, escaping together into our lives?
How can we explore the numinous within us, unless we embrace both dimensions of our wholeness? All true art exalts and defiles.
Herein I look to the figure of the werewolf in Burrough’s novel The Wild Boys as controlling metaphor of our wildness as beings of nature, and like nature anarchic, chaotic, and utterly free. In a universe without meaning other than that which we ourselves create, the terror of our nothingness is balanced with the joy of total freedom.
The Wild Boys envisions feral youths in rebellion against the Authority that created them, a dystopian future in which man’s animal nature has been betrayed by civilization through systems of Control but which also has the power to redeem and liberate us, the final part of Burroughs’ Anarchist Trilogy which extends his recurrent theme of werewolves as symbolic of our essential wildness and unconquerable nature, an extension of Rousseau’s Natural Man and a type of Nietzschean Superman; beyond good and evil.
He did claim to be possessed by the Toad as a chthonic spirit, identical with Nietzsche’s Toad which the author of Thus Spake Zarathustra, a novel I later adopted as a counter-text to the Bible, feared he must swallow as a symbol of our animal nature. Burroughs claimed to be Nietzsche’s successor on this basis, as avatar and priest of all that is reviled, disgusting, loathsome and bestial within us, which he identified with Lovecraft’s Tsathoggua and transferred to me as a successor and avatar.
As I never conceptualized or ascribed negative qualities to my own shadow self, this containing nothing which is not me, I experienced this simply as a seizure of power as an avatar and not as possession by a malign entity; exactly as practiced in Voodoo and in the Shaivite-Tantric cult of the Bhairav as I explored it in Nepal during my time as a monk and Dream Navigator of the Vajrayana Kagu order of Tibetan Buddhism. For myself, from childhood and in a family utterly free from the consequences of Freud’s father as lawgiver or from Abrahamic ideas of God as Authority, I imagined nature as truth and freedom, and nothing to be feared.
The magic Burroughs and my father practiced was based equally on his friend Bataille’s cult of Nietzsche called Acephale, the mythos of his model H.P. Lovecraft, and elements of shamanism, traditional ritual magic from grimoires, and the occultism of Aleister Crowley. A decade and more later, Burroughs would be claimed by admirers as a founder of Chaos Magic, and his host of invented literary methods designed to destroy systems of control represented an ars poetica which was also a personal faith, including the cut-up method, playback, dreams, out of body travel, mandalas and gates to alternate realities, ecstatic trance and vision, curses, demonology, tarot; I still have the deck of tarot cards he gave me and taught me to use.
To this my father brought the family Voodoo, werewolf mythology, ancestral history interwoven with versions of Grimm’s fairytales, and his brilliance as a theatre director.
As Burroughs wrote The Wild Boys during the period of his visits, I have often wondered how much of it was drawn from my father’s ideas and the claim of our family history that we are not human but werewolves, with the blood of ancient terrors in our veins, and had been driven out of Europe for that reason; Martin Luther referred to my ancestors as Drachensbraute, Brides of the Dragon, which we proudly adopted as a title, and we were driven out of Bavaria in 1586 at the beginning of a forty-four year period of witchcraft persecutions. He was writing it during the Stonewall Riots, which may be a more direct context as a fictionalization of the witness of history. Like much of his fiction, it is also filled with episodes both historical and imagined and set in mirror worlds of exotic locations like Mexico and Morocco transformed as Orientalist fantasies or gateways to underworld realms.
When I asked him, at the age of ten or so, if I was in his book and what he was writing about, he said; “Freedom, nature as truth and civilization as addiction to wealth and power and theft of the soul, and how our pasts get mixed up with our futures.”
The Wild Boys reimagines The Egyptian Book of the Dead, of which fellow Surrealist and poet Philip Lamantia was a scholar and a source for Burroughs, also the subject of his final novel The Western Lands as is its direct model H. P. Lovecraft’s The Dream Quest of Unknown Kadath, references Octave Mirbeau, Bataille, Genet, and extends de Sade and Rousseau’s ideal of the natural man as uncorrupted by civilization and unlimited by its boundaries, as truths immanent in nature and written in our flesh, in a reversal of Freud’s ideology of civilization as restraint or binding and limit of our nature which he called libido control. David Bowie created his character of Ziggy Stardust based on The Wild Boys; wildness as nature and freedom here mingle and intertwine.
All the works of William S. Burroughs are masterpieces of anarchist liberation and transgression, Surrealism and occult mysticism, even if difficult because they are told in collages of random and nonlinear episodes which he described as vaudeville turns, with an iconography that is bizarre and obscene. In spite and possibly because of this, they remain among the great classics of world literature, revealing endless chasms of darkness and infinite possibilities of rapture and illumination.
All true art defiles and exalts.
Go ahead; swallow the toad.
The Toad is summoned by performance of that which is loathsome to you; as embodiment of disgust, horror, degradation, and what Freud called the Uncanny. Jung described possession by the Shadow as a theriomorphic figure, the Beast, as “A manifestation of the Beast Within which seizes the soul with nameless shuddering; in that moment one becomes transformed and exalted six thousand feet beyond good and evil.”
It is a type of the Guardian of the Gates of Dreams who must be eaten or embraced to transform it into a Guide and ally or protector in underworld journeys. In the Dreaming one may assume its Battle Forms, which as a child I imagined as the Grendel-like water dragon and the chiropteran raptor as depicted in the film Dracula, and as a chthonic figure of underworld illumination confers powers of insight into others secret desires similar to Lucifer’s power in the Netflix series which fictionalizes the great question of Lacan, What do you desire?, as well as the ability to enter the dreams of others as does Freddy Kruger in the Nightmare films based so faithfully on the cult of the Bhairav in Tibetan Buddhist-Shaivite Tantric faith. I discovered much parallelism between the magic of my childhood and that of the Vajrayana Buddhist Kagyu order of monks in Kathmandu of which I was once a Dream Navigator.
Burroughs had a whole pantheon and system of magic worked out from Lovecraft and Crowley, but that is a different story. What I find interesting is that like Crowley’s mirror image angels and demons who are really the same dual-aspected beings, Burroughs’ reimagination of Lovecraft’s mythos has his Others as both good and evil, like wrathful and beneficent aspects of Tibetan gods.
In the end all that matters is what you do with your fear, and how you use your power.
Act Three
Negotiations With Masculinity, Patriarchy, and the Legacies of Our History
The monstrosity of God, the State as embodied violence, Authority as tyranny and terror; all of these recursive and interdependent systems of oppression and dehumanization originate in the dynamics of the Father as Lawgiver.
In this year of the Fall of America and the second capture of the state by the Fourth Reich as Vichy America, as the Party of Treason attempts to finalize the subversion of our democracy and impose theocratic patriarchal sexual terror and white supremacist terror on our nation under the figurehead of Rapist In Chief Traitor Trump and his Theatre of Cruelty, let us interrogate the systems of oppression of those who would enslave us and perform the Four Primary Duties of a Citizen; Question Authority, Expose Authority, Mock Authority, and Challenge Authority.
Carceral states of force and control are but the family writ large, as fear weaponized in service to power, as authorized identities and fascisms of blood, faith, and soil, and as divisions and hierarchies of belonging and exclusionary otherness enforced by elite hegemonies of wealth, power, and privilege.
All this we must Resist.
This is the first revolution we must fight, each of us as we grow up and become human as we ourselves imagine and wish to be; the struggle for ownership of ourselves.
As I wrote in my post of July 21 2020, How Patriarchy Works: Unequal Power, Identities of Sex and Gender, Autonomy Versus Authorization, Complicity and Responsibility, and the Social Use of Force; Here I began thinking about the murder of Vanessa Guillen, toxic masculinity and violence, and the military as an atavism of rape culture in tidy categories of Hegelian-Marxist history and the dialectics of revolutionary struggle, when I quickly realized that patriarchy is a spectrum disease which corrupts and subverts its victims and its perpetrators alike, and this is its true terror.
At the intersection of power asymmetries and identities of sex and gender lie issues of authorization versus autonomy, with crucial consequences for complicity and responsibility in our legal system which arbitrates the social use of force.
In her now classic work Ring of Power, Jean Shinoda Bolen interprets Wagner’s great opera in terms of patriarchal forces which dehumanize us because they cripple and steal our capacity to love. Of particular interest here is the figure of Brunhild as Daddy’s Avenger and victim of internalized oppression.
So I looked again, but this time not at the primary struggle for power and ownership between male perpetrator and female victim, but at two female monsters who are parallel figures as enablers and accomplices of sexual terror, Melania Trump and Ghislaine Maxwell.
Moreover they are characters embedded in fairytale narratives with which we are all familiar; the etiology of their disfigurement and monstrosity lies in the malign effects of inequality as a moral debasement and leprosy of the soul. For the study of such things I return to Margaret Atwood’s masterpiece Cat’s Eye, her novels Interlunar and Life Before Man, to the thematic companion volumes The Handmaid’s Tale and The Edible Woman, and to the foundational critical work by Sharon Rose Wilson, The Fairytale Sexual Politics of Margaret Atwood.
A study of Margaret Atwood is illuminating and instrumental to understanding the elements of patriarchy and the operations of its systems, especially in the context of female on female violence in secondary order power relations. Allow me to elaborate.
Cat’s Eye presents a narrator, Elaine Risley, who is a trapped Rapunzel in a world of ghosts, witches, cruel stepsisters, vanishing princes, and a merciful fairy godmother. The story draws ideas mainly from Anderson’s Snow Queen and Grimm’s Rapunzel, secondarily from Anderson’s Ice Maiden and Grimm’s Girl Without Hands.
Fearful door images echo Grimm’s Fitcher’s Bird; Risley’s dreams and visions are filled with images from medieval art, paintings of the Annunciation, Ascension, and the Virgin. The Hobgoblin’s fragmented mirror in The Snow Queen provides a metaphor of Atwood’s vision; mirrors, cameras, things that reflect but also capture and distort.
Of her characters, Cordelia from Shakespeare’s King Lear is among her finest; Mrs. Sneath is a cannibal goddess who resembles Baba Yaga and is linked to the figure of cat-headed Maat in this story.
Thematically Cat’s Eye is an investigation of the Rapunzel Syndrome; the wicked witch who imprisons her, the tower she is trapped in, a rescuer. Margaret Atwood’s driving conflicts are female-female, though her plots foreground sexual power and its political reflections.
Life Before Man offers The Wizard of Oz, The Nutcracker ballet, Anderson’s Snow Queen, a host of tales from Grimm including The Girl Without Hands, Rapunzel, Cinderella, Little Red Cap, Fitcher’s Bird, and The Robber Bridegroom. Secondary intertexts include Wilde’s Salome, Dante’s Inferno, Ovid’s Metamorphosis, Coleridge’s Kublai Khan, Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland, Irving’s Sleepy Hollow, and Mother Goose rhymes, mainly Little Miss Muffet. It’s a sort of Grand Tour of our civilization and the history of our private inner space and the disastrous and grotesque ways we collide with each other. Also, wonderful and illuminating reading.
Interlunar reimagines Cocteau’s Orphee, the ballet Giselle, both the Grimm and Anne Sexton version of The White Snake, and the paintings of Hieronymus Bosch. Motifs include death, pestilence, filth, eating, power, the journey, healing, hands, blindness and vision. Themes of guilt and shame, love, destruction, sacredness, creation, fertility, and metamorphosis are to be found in this richly imagined novel.
The Edible Woman is a linked text with The Handmaid’s Tale; do read both together. Herein the main embedded stories are Hansel & Gretel, The Gingerbread Boy, Goldilocks, Alice in Wonderland, Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, and Rapunzel, and her protagonist Marion plays all of these roles as well as those of Little Red Cap, the Robber Bride, and Fitcher’s bride.
The Handmaid’s Tale gives a voice to Bilhah, the Biblical Handmaid, revisions Little Red Riding Hood as an extension of Angela Carter’s The Company of Wolves, and tells the story of the Christian disempowerment of the Goddess as presented in the great film The Red Shoes.
Margaret Atwood’s parodies of Grimm operate on three levels; thematic, images and motifs, and narrative structure. In The Handmaid’s Tale, we have themes of family and especially female-female conflict, gender and sexual power asymmetries, and the initiation and heroic journey. Motifs and images include dismemberment, cannibalism, fertility, labyrinths and paths, and all manner of disturbing sexual violence. Plot devices include a variety of character foils, doppelgangers, disguises and trickery of stolen and falsified identity.
Among Margaret Atwood’s Great Books, The Handmaid’s Tale is a universally known reference both because it has been taught for over a generation in every high school in America as a standard text and because of the extraordinary television series, arguably the most important series ever filmed. We teach it for the same reasons the show is popular; a visceral and gripping drama with unforgettable characters, a mesmerizing plot, and an immediate and accessible story which empowers and illuminates.
It depicts the brooding evil and vicious misogyny of Christianity and Fascism as two sides of the dynamic malaise of patriarchy and authority, as drawn directly from Arthur Miller’s The Crucible and Hawthorne’s Scarlet Letter, but also from contemporary culture as it contains satires of identifiable public figures, organizations, and events. Serena is based on Phyllis Schlafly, and Gideon is the nation of Pat Robertson and the fundamentalists who seized control of the Republican Party around the time of the novel’s writing; Margaret Atwood’s motive in part was to sound an alarm at the dawn of the Fourth Reich and its threat to global democracy.
It remains to be seen whether the forces of tyranny or of liberty will prevail in the end. Each of our lives is a contest between these forces, our private struggles reflected in the society and human civilization we share.
And this is the great lesson and insight of Margaret Atwood; each of us is both a Handmaid and a Serena, trapped within the skin of the other. She locates the primary conflict within ourselves, and transposes the Jungian conflict between Anima and Animus with that of the Shadow in terms of sex, gender, and power.
So we return to our Brunhilds and twin monsters Melania Trump and Ghislaine Maxwell, who Janus-faced represent corruption and perversion, the dual spheres of action of feminine power turned against itself by the forces of patriarchy and shaped to the uses of predation and misogyny.
Melania’s message on the coat she wore to tour a migrant concentration camp, “I really don’t care. Do U?’ and Ghislaine’s self-description in Vanity Fair, “‘I do it the way Nazis did it with the Jews,” reflect the disease of power in its political and sexual contexts, and as a First Cause of both racist hate crimes and crimes of sexual terror. Unequal power is a precondition of them both.
And these are direct quotes from enablers and accomplices of crimes against humanity which define the limits of the human, and who are not marginal figures whose malign violations of our values and dehumanization of others occurred in a trailer park brothel or secret sweatshop of slave labor but at the pinnacle of our society’s ruling class. Their existence is an indictment of the flaws of our nation and of our civilization, and a measure of the distance we have yet to travel in the realization of a true free society of equals.
As Margaret Atwood said in her 2015 lecture to West Point cadets; “Nothing makes me more nervous than people who say, ‘It can’t happen here.’ Anything can happen anywhere, given the right circumstances.”
Postscript
Happy Father’s Day
Happy Fathers Day to all. Said this to my partner Dolly this morning, with the words you don’t have to be a man to be a father, it’s a role and a performance. And she said it back to me, with the words; “You’re a cat dad”.
Maybe this is where we can begin, men and women, in overthrowing systems of unequal power and oppression, the violence of poisoned masculinity and the terror of the Father as Lawgiver institutionalized in tyrannies, in the reimagination and transformation of our human being, meaning, and value, escaping the legacies of our history, and finding healing for the flaws of our humanity and the brokenness of the world; by redefining our terms.
You don’t have to have children to be a father, and you don’t have to be a man to be a father. This is a role, a performance, with lots of historical and symbolic baggage which you are free to reinvent or discard and replace.
So, find the happy.
We now arrive at the Fourth Pillar of my family as an informing, motivating, and shaping force of identity, and as a quaternity of psychic forces common to all humankind, my sister Erin.
As I wrote in my post of January 25 2026, On My Sister Erin’s Birthday; On this my sister’s birthday I celebrate her life, her genius as a poet and her interventions in our history which include the creation of an artificial intelligence as a successor species to humankind, her role in the Fall of the Soviet Union, and her scholarship and refounding of the ancient faith of the Vikings as leader of the American branch of Asatru.
As I described her in a birthday greeting of years past, which referenced some of the Defining Moments of her personal history as I remember them; I remember our family’s discovery when you were in seventh grade that you were writing poems and stories in some of Tolkien’s invented languages, had puzzled out his sources and taught yourself a working knowledge of several ancient languages in order to write in them (Old Norse, Old Welsh, Gothic, and Old English), when you gave the Valedictorian Address for the International College at UC Santa Cruz as a graduate in Soviet Foreign Policy and Russian Language, and then moved to Kaliningrad and became Pushkin Scholar at Moscow State Institute of International Relations, how your cabal orchestrated the event that brought down the Soviet Union, when Rolling Stone called your reporting on the Fall of the Soviet Union the best political writing in America, and when we celebrated your six hundredth publication. I have always been glad that in writing and the world of literature you have found your bliss.
Erin grew up as a student of mine in kung fu and of my father in fencing, and playing the family violin; in her seventh grade year we discovered that while barricaded in her room she had puzzled out the source languages of Tolkien and taught herself to write poetry in them. For four years in high school she was the sole Russian Language student of Lt. Colonel Sviatislav Shasholin USAF, who translated during the Nixon-Breznev talks and handled Russian defectors.
Our mother and I founded the Forensics program at Sonoma Valley High School because she was beginning Freshman year at a school that didn’t have one after our father who was my speech teacher and coach at a different school retired and the family moved, and we wanted her to be able to be on a debate team, that being my own most cherished and joyful experience in school.
She describes her high school years as living at my kung fu studio, which is not far off the truth as she was just as obsessive about arts of combat as was I during my teenage years; due to her natural strengths I trained her mainly in mantis and tiger, and she learned Wing Chun, in part a development of mantis, from one of my black belts, Ernie Lewis, who had learned it from a personal student of Bruce Lee’s, so she is a line holder in that art as well. She is also a superb combat shooter; we both learned to shoot as children by pinging a superball on a string with an air pistol, but after university she also trained in a number of programs which involved gunfighting, and before his death in the line of duty some years ago her partner Tom Newman, a US Army Green Beret with 27 years in special operations, used to brag that she could outshoot him with his own guns.
So, I was her teacher of both fighting and debate, and we share enthusiasms for languages and writing; but if she learned from me and we learned from our parents, I also learned from her, for she always counted her victories as finding common ground with others and turning competitions into cooperations and partnerships.
Its not only what you can do, but the gulfs of understanding you are able to cross, which measure our value and our humanity. And this too is something I learned from her.
She lives in the home we inherited from our mother in Las Vegas, where a swimming pool and jacuzzi provide solace from the terrible heat, and her many neighbors drop over for tea, which she makes a daily grand event of. In years past she owned the Science Fiction Store and operated an art collective and gallery in Las Vegas, and continues her Pagan Visibility Project, once a column in the now defunct magazine Pagans and Witches, and her editing and writing work.
Tea and fragrances have become central to her joy as of late, GLP-1 which is derived from actual Gila Monster venom and the wailing of fallen angels, enhancing the sense of smell as a side effect of its health benefits; she calls it her Gila Lizard Powers. When she first mentioned this, I thought she was having a Gila Monster bite her for medicinal purposes as a ritual of some sort; this may give you an idea of her life on the other side of the mirror from our surfaces, and hidden in the depths within the literary, knitting, and cat lady images.
Always parallel and interdependent, Maat the nurturer and Sekmet the huntress, the White and Black swans, and we are always both at once, all of us.
When I introduced her to the perfume community Fragrantica, within weeks she was creating her own scented products, using enfleurage from natural ingredients which is considered a gourmet kind of perfumery. As with everything, my sister pursues excellence and uniqueness; she’s made some bespoke items for myself and Dolly, all of which are exquisite, and labeled as Dollhouse Park products in her ebay store, which smell of black licorice, iris, and rose.
And in this a final lesson demonstrated by my sister; strive for excellence and uniqueness in all that you do, and make of your life a thing of beauty.
This brings us to an essay I wrote in conversation with my sister, an extended inquiry into the Well of Memory and Time in regard to the deep history of my family in the paternal line.
As I wrote in my post of January 25 2021, The Search for Our Ancestors and a Useful Past: Family Histories as Narrative Constructions of Identity; One of the great riddles of history is untangling the knots of meaning, often shaped by erasures, silences, lies, and misdirections, which arise from the motives of our sources.
Today is my sister Erin’s birthday; I sent her a greeting which referenced some of the Defining Moments of her personal history as I remember them; “I remember our family’s discovery when you were in seventh grade that you were writing poems and stories in some of Tolkien’s invented languages, had puzzled out his sources and taught yourself a working knowledge of several ancient languages in order to write in them (Old Norse, Old Welsh, Gothic, and Old English), when you gave the Valedictorian Address for the International College at UC Santa Cruz as a graduate in Soviet Foreign Policy and Russian Language. and then became Pushkin Scholar at a Soviet University in Moscow, when Rolling Stone called your reporting on the Fall of the Soviet Union the best political writing in America, and when we celebrated your six hundredth publication. I have always been glad that in writing and the world of literature you have found your bliss.”
Among the messages which followed Erin posted a photograph which symbolizes her search for belonging, membership, and connection through the family history of our ancestors, a typically American quest for meaning as many of us share a trauma of historical abandonment and displacement, and pathologies of identity falsification and disconnectedness from relationships with families and communities, anchorages which in traditional societies nurture wellness and growth. These maladaptive disruptions and obfuscations often result from intentional breaks with the past as liberation on the part of new immigrants who wish to create themselves in no image but their own; but often they are legacies of denial, silencing, and erasure by authority as well.
Our family history claimed Cherokee as the identity of an ancestor who we recently discovered was not a Native American but African, and probably a slave of the Cherokee, the descendants of which the tribe refuses to recognize as tribal members. As the only nonwhite General in the Confederate Army was a Cherokee, this erasure of disturbing history and inconvenient truths is unsurprising; and authorized lies can become truths when there are no counternarratives.
The truths with which authority is uncomfortable are the ones which are crucial to seizures of power and liberation, and it is to the empty spaces in our narratives of identity, the voices of the silenced and the erased, and to stories which bear the scars of rewritten history, to which we must listen most closely.
The Four Primary Duties of a Citizen are Question Authority, Mock Authority, Expose Authority, and Challenge Authority.
Erin has claimed Native American Cherokee as her racial and historical identity since childhood, enthralled with the story of an Indian great grandmother, studied traditional drumming and made pilgrimages to pow wows, learned to the point of obsession what vestiges of Cherokee language and culture she could find, and as an adult went to the tribal archives in search of our ancestor.
There she hit a wall of silence; no records of such a tribal member exist. Worse, no living speakers of Sa La Gi could be found; when asked where the native language speakers were, the curator of the tribal historical archive pointed to an old vinyl record which held the voices of the last known bearers of an extinct language. All was dust, lost on the Trail of Tears.
No crime against humanity can be more terrible than the erasure of an entire people and civilization, as the United States of America perpetrated against many indigenous peoples both on our continent and throughout the world as imperial conquest and colonial dominion. Like slavery with which it is interdependent and parallel, colonial imperialism is a central legacy of our history for which we have yet to bring a Reckoning.
Like many tribes and peoples, the Cherokee had been eaten by our systems of unequal power as human sacrifices, and had no truths or songs of becoming human to offer. Here was an unanswerable tragedy of loss of meaning and belonging, which finds echo in our modern pathology of disconnectedness.
Or was deliberate obfuscation; what didn’t they want known?
Like many Americans, Erin pursued our elusive history and ambiguous identity for decades through genealogical research and recently the Pandora’s Box of DNA testing, where she struck gold; her test revealed no discoverable Indian ancestry, but instead an intriguing African heritage. Near her fifth decade of life, suddenly she was no longer Native American and Cherokee, a discovery which must have been a life disruptive event, but one balanced with the gift of an unlooked-for membership and belonging.
More importantly as regards race and other constructions of identity, who decides? And what happens if those you claim do not in turn claim you?
For literary examples of this unreciprocated claim of belonging I look to Jerzy Kosinski, a Polish Catholic possibly assassinated by the Polish state for telling inconvenient truths about the Holocaust in The Painted Bird, and Philip Roth, a Jewish American author declared an enemy of the Jewish people by Gershom Scholem for his once-scandalous portrayal of sexuality in Portnoy’s Complaint, though a nearer parallel in the interrogation of race, history, and identity as systems of oppression and themes in literature may be found in African American authors such as Toni Morrison in The Bluest Eye and Colson Whitehead in The Underground Railroad.
Of my sister’s Non-European DNA; 1.2% sub-Saharan Africa, including: .9% Ghana / Liberia / Ivory Coast / Sierra Leone and .3% Senegambian and Guinean. There is also an Islamic Diaspora and/or Asian component; .7% North Africa, including: .2% Egypt and Levant and .5% broadly West Asia and North Africa, and .5% Central and South Asia including: .2% North India and Pakistan and .3% South India and Sri Lanka. These probably represent two different lines of descent, occurring at between five and eight generations of separation respectively.
Who were these mysterious and wonderful ancestors, and where was the cherished Native American heritage? Like much of nature, DNA is tricky; each generation is a total randomization of information potential, so you can inherit traits from ancestors anywhere in your history back to the dawn of humankind, in virtually any proportion of traits from any combination thereof.
On average, you will have a quarter from each grandparent at two generations of separation, and if grandmother only passes on 20%, grandfather must pass on 30%. Sometimes gene sequences are not passed on, so its possible for a known ancestor to be unconfirmable by a DNA test, and for siblings to have differences. I look like our mother, of Austrian family with hazel eyes and near rice powder white skin though sadly I did not inherit her glorious red hair; my sister looks like our father whose black hair fell in tight wringlets around his shoulders, and whose skin was the mahogany of old railroad ties used on the British Cape to Cairo line over a century ago.
At seven generations distance you will probably inherit less than one percent from each of the 128 ancestors in that generation, or be undetectable; the percentages are 12.5 for great grandparents at the third generation from you, 6.25 at the fourth, 3.12 at the fifth, 1.56 at the sixth, and .78 at the seventh.
DNA tests from cousins can be used with a family tree to triangulate and identify which DNA components came from which ancestors; a female cousin from one of my father’s two brothers, blue eyed and blonde, tests as 70% Northwestern Europe and England/Wales, 19% Ireland and Scotland, 6% Sweden, and 5% Norway. A male cousin from my father’s second brother, dark as was he, tests as 1% Benin and Togo and 1% Cameroon, Congo, and Southern Bantu peoples, an approximate match with my sister’s Sub Saharan Africa descent, the remainder being 47% Northwestern Europe and England/Wales, 32% Norway, 11% Ireland & Scotland, and 4% Sweden.
My sister’s European DNA tests as 44.7% French & German, and why these are scientifically identical boggles the imagination, 24.8% British & Irish, 19.5% broadly northwestern European, .2% Scandinavian, and 5.8% southern European, which includes 3.1% Italian and 1.1% Spanish and Portuguese.
Illustrative of the vagaries of inheritance are the differing proportions among three first cousins, two of whom inherit nothing from a paternal grandmother shared by all three, whose family came from Genoa Italy after the Napoleonic Wars. They were still living in an enormous stilt house in Bayou La Teche built from their ship, guarded by ancient cannon, when my mother visited them in 1962.
But the best way to discover our origins is through family history, which can be consistent over great epochs of time. So we come to the origin story of the photograph and of my family in America, well documented as Kentucky and Revolutionary War history whose dates can be confirmed precisely by public records, of how a mixed and diverse community of Revolutionary War survivors came to be living in Cape Girardeau, Missouri.
A direct patrilineal ancestor of mine, Henry, had been captured along with much of his family in the June 21 1780 British assault on Ruddle’s Fort during Bird’s Invasion of Kentucky. One hundred fifty British Regulars of the 8th and 47th Regiments, Detroit Militia, and six cannon of the Royal Regiment of Artillery, with one thousand or more warriors from the Shawnee, Huron, Lenape, and other tribal allies of Britain, compelled the surrender of the fort by cannon fire and a guarantee of status as British prisoners of war offered by Bird, who when the gates were opened broke his word and loosed the native troops to sack the fort and take slaves.
Over two hundred pioneers were killed in the attack; the remains of twenty of them were later put in iron caskets specially made in Philadelphia and sealed in a cave by a descendant of one of my family’s survivors who had moved back near the site of Ruddle’s Fort, where they remain today. The inscription on the stone archway on a cliff overlooking the Licking River reads, “Please do not disturb the rest of the sleeping dead, A.D. 1845”. I have often wondered what was so terrifying about ones own family that they needed to be entombed in iron and sealed in a cave, and why they are called “the sleeping dead’.
Near the site of the burial chamber was The Cedars, a stone home rebuilt in 1825 at a cost of $40,000 by Charles Lair, a Ruddles Fort descendant using one of the many variants of our family name. The Cedars burned in 1930; it had fifteen rooms including six bedrooms and two kitchens, a drawing room with a carved mantel, dining room, library, and a hall with a staircase.
Henry and his brothers George Jr and Peter were listed among the 49 men of the Ruddle’s Fort garrison, and many had their families with them. Survivors were marched with those of other raided forts, four hundred seventy in all, to the heartland of the Shawnee nation in Ohio and to villages of their captors along the way, though Bird still had 300 prisoners with him when he reached his base at Fort Detroit, six hundred miles from Kentucky; some were then sent another 800 miles to Montreal. Britain did not release its prisoners until fifteen years after the war, and many never found their families again.
Henry was held as a slave and/or prisoner of war until he married into the tribe four years later, making him fully Shawnee under tribal law though he was by modern constructions of race an ethnic European. His story is interwoven with that of his childhood friend and neighbor Daniel Boone, and he was among those with whom Boone discovered a route through the Cumberland Gap and explored Kentucky. I like to imagine Henry as the hero in the film Last of the Mohicans, a fictionalization of the July 14 1776 abduction and subsequent rescue of Boone’s daughter Jemima and two daughters of Colonel Richard Callaway, Elizabeth and Frances, from Chief Hanging Maw of the Overhill Cherokee, leading a mixed band of Cherokee and Shawnee.
Henry joined George Washington’s army, possibly during the retreat from the Battle of Long Island in the fall of 1776, fought in the Battles of Trenton and Princeton that December, at Brandywine on September 11, 1777, and in the victory at the Second Battle of Saratoga on October 7 1777 which nearly ended the war and brought help from France.
Among the family members at Ruddle’s Fort were Henry’s two brothers. Peter, who was killed in action, his wife Mary who was captured with their two daughters, of whom Katarina was rescued in 1786 and another is mentioned as married and living in Sandwich Canada in an open letter written by Mary published in the Kentucky Gazette on April 7 1822 to their third child Peter, who vanished after the battle and whose fate is unknown. It reads in part; ”I was taken at Fort Licking commanded by Captain Ruddle, and was brought into upper Canada near Amherstburgh (Fort Malden) where I now live having been 16 years among the Indians. Your eldest sister is now living in Sandwich, but the youngest I could never hear of. Now, my dear son, I would be very glad to see you once more before I die, which I do not think will be long, as I am in a very bad state of health, and have been this great while. I am married to Mr Jacob Miracle (fellow captive from Ruddle’s Fort Jacob Markle) for whom you can enquire.” These are the words of a woman who had been coerced into marrying one of her captors by torture and had a son by him whom she raised with her youngest daughter by a husband who died defending her and their children from capture, two of whom had vanished in the cauldron of war and whose fates she never learned, though her youngest daughter was safe with George Jr’s family.
Also present were Henry’s second brother George Jr and his wife Margaret, who were captured and later freed, and their children Johnny, George III, Eva, Margaret, and Elizabeth. Johnny, 1776-1853, four years old when captured, was raised with Tecumseh and fought at his side as a British ally through the War of 1812. He married Mary Williams in 1799; they had eight children. Of Margaret we know only that she survived to marry Andrew Sinnolt in 1793. Eva, captured when 14 years old and taken to Canada, ran the gauntlet to win her freedom after six years of enslavement and two years later in 1788 married fellow Ruddles Fort survivor Casper Karsner.
Elizabeth Lale, 1752-1832, eldest of the children at 28, escaped from the Shawnee capitol city of Piqua on the Great Miami River in Ohio and survived a solo trek of hundreds of miles through the wilderness back to the colonies, then with Washington and Jefferson planned and guided General Clark with 970 soldiers in a raid which liberated many of the other prisoners of war held as slaves at the Battle of Piqua, August 8 1780. With her was Daniel Boone, who had also been held captive at Piqua by Blackfish, Great Chief of the Shawnee, between his capture at the Battle of Blue Licks on February 7, 1778 and his escape six months later in June. In 1783 Elizabeth married John Franks; they had two children.
And George III, 1773-1853, captured when seven years old, was taken in 1781 to a camp in Cape Girardeau Missouri, base of a Shawnee trade empire from which the entire Mississippi basin could be navigated, becoming the first white pioneer in the region, near the land which in 1793 was granted by Baron Carondelet to the Black Bob Band of the Hathawekela Shawnee.
Nearby was a Spanish land grant awarded to Andrew Summers for service in the Cape Girardeau Company of the Spanish-American Militia by Governor Lorimier, during a six week campaign in 1803. Andrew Summers had married Elizabeth Ruddle, daughter of Captain George Ruddle and granddaughter of Isaac Ruddle; Andrew and Elizabeth moved with their family to their land in Cape Girardeau after the War of 1812; later her father joined them, as did George Lale III and his wife Louisa Wolff. George and Louisa’s seven children were born there; the old Summers cemetery where George III is buried lies two miles SW of Jackson Missouri.
Many of my family who survived the Revolutionary War moved to Cape Girardeau where the families of George III Lale and Andrew Summers had established a community of pioneers and former slaves of Indians, apparently both African and European, and the Indians they had fought alongside and against, been captured by and intermarried with. In the end I think they understood each other better than those who had not survived the same collective trauma and shared history.
Our great grandmother Lilly Summers could claim direct patrilineal descent from the Summers family of Fairfax Virginia, descended from Sir George Summers, who commanded the Sea Venture, one of the ships which brought over the Jamestown colony in 1607, through the first settler in Alexandria, John Summers, who lived from 1687 to 1790 and had at the time of his death four generations of descendants, including some four hundred individuals. Lilly was equally descended from her mother, M.B. Croft who is listed as Dutch which probably means German, and her father John William Summers, of English lineage but designated as Cherokee in family records, which we now know is a fiction describing descent from a probable African slave of the Cherokee.
It is also possible that this ancestry came into the Summers line from fellow soldiers who served with them during the Battle of New Orleans in the War of 1812, among them free Black militia companies which pre-existed the war, including slaves promised freedom and armed by Andrew Jackson as the first Black company of the American army, a former Spanish colonial Black militia with whom Andrew Summers had served alongside against France, and Major D’Aquin’s Battalion of Free Men of Color from Haiti who were elite professional revolutionaries and soldiers who had once been part of the French army. The origin of this DNA can be no nearer than Lilly’s paternal grandmother, at five generations separation from my sister and I.
Among the documents of my genealogy and family history research I have a daguerreotype from the 1840’s of Elizabeth Lale, named for her ferocious aunt, daughter of parents from opposing sides of the Revolutionary War, Me Shekin Ta Withe (White Painted Dove) of the Shawnee and Henry Lale.
Born in 1786, Elizabeth had four sisters and two brothers including my ancestor George Washington Lale, named for the future President with whom Henry crossed the Delaware, and whose battle cry at Trenton in 1776, Victory or Death, Henry adopted as our family motto on our coat of arms.
My sister and I are the fifth generation from Henry, and sixth from the original immigrant Hans George Lale who arrived with his family in Philadelphia in 1737 on the ship Samuel, sailing from Rotterdam.
As our family history and myth before coming to America is beyond the subject of my inquiry here, epigenetic trauma and harms of erasure and internalized oppression in the case of a phantom ancestor in the context of relations between indigenous and colonial peoples, I will question this in future essays.
Here are the generations of our family in America; my parents A.L. Lale and Meta (Austrian), Enoch Abraham Lale and Gertie Noce (Italian), Andrew Jackson Lale 1840-1912 and Lilly Summers, George Washington Lale 1790-1854 and Elizabeth Ross, Henry Lale 1754-1830 and White Painted Dove, and Hans George Lale 1703-1771 and Maria Rudes.
But its never as simple as that, each of us a link in a chain of being which encompasses the whole span of human history; migrations, wars, and the rise and fall of civilizations. Often our ideas of identity as nationality and ethnicity would have been incomprehensible to the people we claim membership with.
Take for example my family name; its original form is on Trajan’s Column in Rome, and Cicero wrote his great essay on friendship, Laelius de Amicitia, about an ancestor of mine; Gaius Laelius, whose political and military career as an ally of Scipio Africanus spans the Iberian campaign of 210- 206 BC where he commanded the Roman fleet at New Carthage, the African campaign of 204-202 commanding the cavalry at Zama, enjoyed two terms as praetor of Sicily from 196 and was granted the province of Gaul about 190, and in 160 BC met the historian Polybius in Rome, becoming his eyewitness source for the Second Punic War in The Histories.
Here I signpost that all of us are connected with the lives of others across vast millennia of history, often in surprising ways. A mere thousand years ago, we all have more ancestors than the total number of humans living at the time, at 30 generations distance; meaning many are convergent lines of descent due to pedigree collapse and that we are all interrelated ultimately. The mathematics of ancestry is interesting; somewhere around one hundred thousand to three hundred thousand years ago we reach the point of a single common ancestor. As written by Steve Olson in Nature magazine describing his research; ““No matter the languages we speak or the color of our skin, we share ancestors who planted rice on the banks of the Yangtze, who first domesticated horses on the steppes of the Ukraine, who hunted giant sloths in the forests of North and South America, and who labored to build the Great Pyramid of Khufu.”
If I accounted my identity and ethnicity as where my ancestors immigrated to America from, I would be German and not Roman, but it would not be the whole truth. We lived in Bavaria for generations until 1586, when we were driven out as werewolves and sorcerers during the start of an eighty year witchburning craze; Martin Luther called us Drachensbraute, Brides of the Dragon, which we adopted as a title. During this time we absorbed many of the pre Christian myths gathered as Grimms Fairytales, which was represented to me as a child as our family history. And still a half truth, as this tallies only my patrilineal descent, and nothing of the half of myself from my Austrian descended mother, whose stories I will tell another time.
As events become more remote in time and memory, the boundary between historical and mythopoeic truth becomes ambiguous, interdependent, and co-evolutionary with shared elements which reinforce each other. This is true for narratives of national identity as well as self-construction in the personal and family spheres, in which such processes may be studied in detail. Stories are a way of doing exactly thing; both creating and questioning identity.
Often with family history we are confronted with discontiguous realms of truth as self-representation and authorized identity, always a ground of struggle as a Rashomon Gate. Such stories are true in the sense that we are their expressions as living myths, but are these narratives we live within and which in turn inhabit us also history?
Who are we, we Lales?
Native American, yes, if to a lesser degree and from different sources than we had previously imagined as an authorized identity and historical construction, Shawnee rather than Cherokee and generations more distant.
Indian also in the sense of an ancestor from Mughal India over three hundred years ago, great grandmother of Henry the revolutionary, and that complex. Who this grand and mysterious ancestor and source of our Indian and Eqyptian-Levantine DNA was remains an open question, though she was literate in Persian and claimed to have once been a courtier of the Mughal princess and poet Zeb-un-Nissa which is another story. And in the place of the phantom Cherokee great grandmother, an African voice among the cacophony of multitudes sings of liberation.
In retrospect, that my father practiced Voodoo as the traditional family faith should have been an enormous clue to his ethnicity, what is now classified as Louisiana Creole meaning of mixed European-African-Native American ancestry. He described himself as Cajun, which means French speaking and is a cultural and historical claim.
Of my father who is my link to this history of the founding of America as a reborn Rome with all of its shifting ideas of nationality and identity, who in this our Day of the Dead I honor among my ancestors, I say this; he was my high school English, Forensics, and Drama teacher, who taught me fencing and chess and took me to martial arts lessons from the age of nine, gave me a copy of Thus Spake Zarathustra in eighth grade which became a counter text to the Bible for me, and was an underground theatre director who collected luminaries like William S. Burroughs who told fabulous stories after dinner and Edward Albee whose plays he directed while I sat beside them as a child and listened with rapt attention to their conversations. He it was who taught me the principle of action; “Politics is the art of fear”. For one day he was arguably the greatest swordsman in the world, having defeated all the national champions at an international reclassification tournament, and went on to become a coach of champion Olympic fencers. He grew up fencing and playing the treasured family Stradivarius, lost now on the seas of time like so much else, and his favorite story from childhood was how he got his nickname, Gator Bait; grandpa used to tie a rope around his waist and throw him in the swamp to splash about and attract alligators to shoot.
I once asked Grandpa Lale to tell me the story of our family, to which he replied; “Dad, your great grandfather, was a gunfighter, and one day he was practicing his quick draw with a hair trigger revolver. He slapped that hogleg and it went off, shot himself through his leg. Bled out dead in minutes. I rolled him up in a carpet, put him in a flatboat, and pushed him out into the swamp. Anything you want to know about who you are and where you come from, go ask the gators.”
So my grandfather made the alligators ancestor spirits of mine by feeding them his father’s corpse, though I doubt this was his intention as a ritual sacrifice.
My paternal grandmother was Italian; of the Noce family whose stilt house in Bayou La Teche Louisiana was built from the ship they sailed from Genoa in the wake of the Napoleonic Wars, having been members of the 1797 Jacobin Revolt in Genoa and allies of Napoleon, its navigable approach guarded by ancient canon cast before the War of 1812. My mother wrote a journal of a family visit with them in 1962; there was Quiller, a giant who could carry a railroad tie in each hand, all day long, the Silent Man who sat in his rocking chair on the front porch for three days without saying anything like a stone gargoyle, then fast as lightning whipped out a shotgun from under the blanket across his lap and fired into the swamp, and after several minutes of rocking declared; “Water moccasin,” a deadly poisonous snake. The women all wore ankle length black dresses and pointy hats like cartoon witches, and I’ve never found any credible reference which might identify the ethnicity or historical period to which it belongs nor the origin of the pointed hat as a witch symbol; my aunties claimed to be hereditary priestesses of Persephone, Queen of the Dead and the Underworld, though this may have been a joke. They did have an actual iron cauldron kept on the boil always, in my mother words “they gossiped around while the men talked politics”.
One story dad never told but his friend from the Korean War did, was that they had escaped a North Korean POW camp with three others, one of whom died in the breakout, and the four survivors carried the dead soldier all the way back to South Korea. His last years were spent in seclusion flyfishing on a remote wilderness mining claim in Montana.
Before immigration to America, we were Bavarian, generally European, and originally Roman, unquestionably; along the way from Gaius Laelius and the conquest of Carthage to myself, our family once briefly ruled what is now France, Germany, Spain, and the British Isles, in the Gallic Empire of 260-274 A.D. As a university student influenced by classical studies I responded to questions about my historical identity, nationality, and ethnicity in this way; “I am a citizen of the Roman Empire; that it has not existed for fifteen hundred years is irrelevant.”
I did so once to the wife of a poetry professor, who immediately whipped out a notebook and thereupon began taking notes on our conversations; this was Anne Rice, who based her character of Mael in Queen of the Damned on me as I was in my junior year at university, over forty years ago now, before the summer of 1982 which fixed me on my life course as a hunter of fascists and a member of the Resistance.
Its always interesting to see ourselves through the eyes of others, and how we are transformed by their different angles of view; such changes and transforms of meaning are the primary field of study in history and literature as songs of identity and a primary ground of revolutionary struggle.
Anne Rice’s idea of Mael as the caretaker of Those Who Must Be Kept came from a comment of mine about the dead white men whose books created our culture for both good and ill during a discussion of the canon of literature; There are those who must be kept, and those from whom we must escape, and if we are very lucky they are not always the same.
Who are we, we Americans, we humans?
Identity, history, memory, which includes changing constructions of race and nationality; these hinge on questions which often have no objective answers.
We are as we imagine ourselves to be; the stories we tell about ourselves, to ourselves and to others, and the groups and historical legacies in which we claim membership, and who claim us in return.
Family history is always a personal myth of identity, though it may also be history. We bear within us thousands of other lives, in multiple states of time across vast gulfs of history, possessed by the ghosts of our ancestors literally as DNA and metaphorically as stories; we are legion.
As with all history, as narratives of authorized identities and in struggle against them as seizures of power, autonomy and self-ownership, and self-creation, a Rashomon Gate of relative and ambiguous truths, the most important question to ask of a story is this; whose story is this?
Dolly and I out on the town
References In My Essay on My Partner Dolly
References
Our Aspirational Selves as teenagers, or Who We Wished to Become:
November 2 2023 Native American Heritage Month and the Hidden Costs of Unequal Power in the Falsification and Erasure of History as Authorized Identities: Day of the Dead Part Two, Case of the Phantom Ancestor
Idealizations of masculine and feminine beauty and identity live at the origins of our power of love and the forms it takes in our lives; If my female side could perform our truths on the stage of the world as songs, without any limits whatever, what would we sing?
Chilling Adventures of Sabrina | Straight to Hell Music Video Trailer | Netflix; because I love this version of Persephone’s myth. How if we must seize our power or be subjugated to that of others?
Little Red Riding Hood – Amanda Seyfried’s cover of the song; sung in a fragile voice filled with such anguish, loneliness, and the absurdity of hope.
I dare the darkness and the unknown places marked Here Be Dragons on our maps of becoming human, beyond all boundaries of the Forbidden.
Where is the wolf who can match my daring and embrace together the wildness of nature and the wildness of ourselves?
Where is my Red Hot Riding Hood, who like myself lives beyond all limits and all laws?
Each contained within the other, like a nested set of puzzle boxes bearing unknowns and the limitless possibilities of becoming human.
Wednesday dances; How if we must tell our stories, or be rewritten and falsified by others? How is we must dance our truths to free ourselves from those of others? I find it interesting that Jenna Ortega chose a queer cruising anthem for her signature dance, which confuses and conflates in ambiguous meanings the rituals of mating and hunting, as this Netflix series does as an extended metaphor and allegory of subversions of authorized identities of sex and gender
So for the anima; what of the animus? Who speaks for me in masculine register?
Lucifer’s Song of Love: Cover of Wicked Game by Ursine Vulpine & Annaca
Do we live in a world where love cannot redeem anything, as it so often seems when we look into the Abyss?
Or do figments like Beauty and The Good exist because we create them, as Keats suggests?
Hope, faith, and love remain powers which cannot be taken from us and which can liberate us as truths, inherent adaptive powers which define the human, but are also ambiguous, relative, changing, and can be ephemeral and illusory as well.
With such unreliable instruments we must create our humanity from falsifiable informing, motivating, and shaping forces of history, memory, and identity, and win our authenticity from the hungry ghosts of authorized identities as simulacra.
This is the first revolution in which we all must fight; the struggle for ownership of ourselves.
In loving others we become ourselves.
“Monster” – Imagine Dragons (cover by Runaground on youtube)
With film montage of Marvel’s Loki
Let us embrace our monstrosity and proclaim with Loki the Trickster; “I am burdened with glorious purpose.”
Like the ripples from a stone tossed into a pool, this; with second and third order consequences which propagate outward through time and the alternate universes produced by Rashomon Gate events.
In a world which is a museum of holocausts and atrocities, how do we live among the unknowns beyond the limits of the human and claw back something of our humanity from the darkness?
In refusal to submit to Authority we become Unconquered and free, but also marked by Otherness and often savaged by loneliness and the pathology of disconnectedness because we no longer truly belong. This is a problem because belonging is the only thing that balances fear as a means of social exchange. But it can also become a sacred wound which opens us to the pain of others.
How do we seize power from those who would enslave us, without becoming tyrants ourselves? To become the arbiter of virtue in an unjust world is a seductive phantasm of tyranny we must avoid, and revolutions tend to become tyrannies as a predictable phase of struggle due to the imposed conditions of unequal power and its legacies.
In the end all that matters is what we do with our fear, and how we use our power.
David Bowie sings of Resistance, beyond hope of victory or survival: Shoshanna prepares for German Night in the film Inglorious Basterds, a song I post to signal that I now begin a Last Stand; that I am about to do something from which I see no possible chances of survival. This I have done more times that I can now remember, yet I remain to defy and defend. Love too is a total commitment beyond reason, a glorious mad quest to claw back something of our humanity from the darkness.
There are some things we must behave as if are true, regardless if they ever were or can be; love can redeem the flaws of our humanity, hope can triumph over despair and the terror of our nothingness, abjection, and learned helplessness, solidarity of action and faith in each other can be victorious over division and fascisms of blood, faith, and soil, Resistance confers freedom as a condition of being and a power which cannot be taken from us by force and control, and as Rumi teaches us the Beauty that we do can bring healing to the brokenness of the world.
A cinematic kaleidoscope of memories dances before me on my birthday, spiraling back through time like the whirlpool which opened before Edgar Allen Poe and cast him into worlds unknown, wonderful and strange, fictionalized in his 1845 story A Descent Into The Maelstrom, which prefigures chaos theory, Jungian psychology, and Surrealism and references the historical literature of a universal field of being and forge of existence in dreams; the Logos of John the Evangelist and Neo-Platonic philosophy, Ibn Arabi’s Alam al Mythal, Coleridge’s Primary Imagination.
In this respect Poe like Emerson and the Transcendentalists is an American consequence of British Romantic Idealism, which unfolds from Goethe and Schiller, who harkens back to Emerson’s direct model Hawthorne to explore a world which lives behind the world we see, whose endless chasms of darkness and light are filled with ancient terrors and nameless horrors which give the lie to our fragile illusions of law and order by which we seek to control the chaos of nature and the wildness of ourselves, as well as moments of beauty and wonder made of wishes and dreams as Keats teaches us. Fascinans et tremendum, rapture and terror conjoined, as Otto Rudolf names the exaltation and defilement of immersion in the Infinite and encounters beyond the illusion of the world. “Break through the mask” as Melville’s glorious Ahab declares.
I am a child of the Nights of Falling Stars, born as our world passes through the Leonid meteor trail each year. On the palm of my right hand is a scar where an infinitesimal meteor passed through it; I had reached up to catch one, standing on the rock above a ravine on Cavedale Road overlooking Sonoma where during World War Two an artillery battery sat to defend against an invasion that never came, above secret caves inscribed with hieroglyphs from a lost antiquity, an event witnessed by friends including Jim Shafer, Jennifer Damico-Wendt, Kimberly Wine, and others, and something reached down to embrace my hand, engulfing me in a nimbus of light. Ahab’s harpoon I became in that moment, lit with St Elmo’s Fire. From this moment I have never despaired nor abandoned hope, for upon my flesh is written the signature of the Infinite.
Death has now fastened her talons hard upon my flesh, flesh become a tapestry of lamentations, lost causes, forlorn hopes, and nameless loves, nor can I escape the horrors I have witnessed in dreams wherein they live again, in whispers of disturbing truths and ghosts which shadow my joy like things out of their proper time, past and future and now all jumbled together like a snow globe shaken by unknown forces, as I become a kind of Tralfamadorian, lost in time among unknowns and the limitless possibilities of becoming human.
Such is the palace of memory, history, and identity, the Well of Memory and Time, the Labyrinth of the Gates of Dreams which is terrifyingly ambiguous with the Wilderness of Mirrors as surfaces which reflect, capture, distort, and falsify can also open as gates of the Unknown, the flaws of our humanity and these forms our bodies in which we must live as an imposed condition of struggle.
In this there is nothing to fear; as I said to my mother when I returned from death, Most Sincerely Dead from the pressure wave of a police grenade which hurled me from my body, in her arms as police opened fire on the students, Bloody Thursday 1969 Peoples Park Berkeley, and I a child of nine bearing a vision of our myriad possible futures from a moment of supraconsciousness outside of time; “Don’t be afraid. Death is nothing; nothing but Awakening from an illusion.”
And so we shall journey into the Unknown together, Death and I, singing.
I will not go quietly, old tiger that I am.
Of dreams and our possibilities of becoming human I sing, a sea of transpersonal consciousness and potentialities which in classical Platonic philosophy and its reimagination in the Biblical Book of John the Evangelist and subsequent neo-Platonism including that of Iris Murdoch is called the Logos, found strange forms in Gnosticism and the alchemical faith of the Sapientia Dei on which Jung constructed his psychology and called the Collective Unconscious, Coleridge the Primary Imagination, Ibn Arabi the Alam al-Mithal, and in Hindu and Buddhist philosophy, especially the work which I translate from Tibetan as the Book of Liberation rather than of the Dead, is called the Bardo, to name a few of the informing and motivating sources and historical lineages in which I may claim membership and represent herein.
My life has been a grand journey into such states of transpersonal being and imaginal realms of the limitless possibilities of becoming human, of which I am become a cypher shaped in the forge of Time. We each of us bear such marks without number, signs of our journeys to discover possible selves; I call these sacred wounds Defining Moments, in which we may read the history of our forging like the beautiful flowing lines of a Damascus sword or as the calligraphy of our souls, and of truths immanent in nature and written in our flesh.
Our lives are charted by our Defining Moments; history, memory, identity, the protean self in constant processes of adaptation and change, and the dynamic creative tension between the reimagination and transformation of ourselves and of humankind in titanic revolutionary struggle and seizures of power versus the boundaries of the Forbidden and the tyranny of normality and of other people’s ideas of virtue, of the masks that others make for us and those we create for ourselves.
How do I count them?
By Visions of Reimagination and Transformation, of truths which awaken and change us when realized, truths which like all true art exalt and defile us in the ecstasy of rapture and terror, fascinans et tremendum as Rudolf Otto named them.
By Last Stands, battles in which I defied unanswerable and overwhelming force beyond hope of victory or survival, by Family, by Journeys Into the Unknown and adventures of my travels, by my Library of Possible Selves as the languages which are our primary layer of identity, by Ghosts I Bear Onward, those whom I knew personally and who shaped me and left upon me their mark of strangeness, and by Songs of Myself as Walt Whitman described the intertexts which we have woven into our lives and through which we direct who we are becoming, for myself mainly books which in reading have rewritten me, do I also number my Defining Moments.
But these are different stories for other days, and herein my subject is poetic vision as a primary human act of self-creation and seizure of power, as the reimagination and transformation of ourselves and of human being, meaning, and value as an answer to the terror of our nothingness, the flaws of our humanity, and the brokenness of the world.
We are all made of these things and many more; their categories are arbitrary and relative, and change over time as do we. What matters is to recognize the kinds of things that matter to us, and to cherish and hoard them as our treasures.
Of Visions wherein I was taken up into the gaps and beheld wonderful things, terrible things; here I speak of poetic vision and the realm of the liminal.
Before all else my Awakening and Vision of Possible Futures of Humankind as a nine year old survivor of Bloody Thursday, Berkeley 1969, as the police fired on student protestors which included my mother, as she sang of peace and offered flowers to a policeman who pumped and aimed a shotgun at her in reply, saved by the sudden chaos of a grenade thrown into the crowd by the police who then opened fire, and as we fled and the pressure wave of the blast hurled me from my body I escaped the limits of my form and had a unitary moment of awareness outside of time.
Yes, by this I mean Most Sincerely Dead and without signs of life according to my mother, before my eyes refocused and fixed this world in place as an image among endless unspooling loops of possible worlds. “Don’t be afraid” I said to her; “Death is nothing, nothing but an awakening from illusions.”
In such moments we are destroyed and recreated, to reference the mad doctor’s line in The Fly; “You’re just afraid to be destroyed and recreated”. Let us embrace Chaos and our monstrosity, and not fear it. For change is ongoing always, and the trick is to use it as seizures of power, autonomy, liberation, and self-creation.
Herein I wish to signpost that when I speak of choosing between visions of our possible futures and of the Rashomon Gate Events which we pass through in myriads of branching points of our fate, that although the circumstances of my story of Awakening is integral and foundational to my identity and my uniqueness, there is nothing unique or even special about the human power of vision, which is limited only by our imagination. The difference between myself and most of us in this regard is merely that because of my personal history, I think of it as a game.
Though I have struggled to create meaning and value from the life disruptive event of my death and rebirth on that day at the age of nine, I speak to you now not as the bearer of any special wisdom tradition but merely as a man who has been dead; death is nothing more or less terrible and wonderful than liberation from the limits of our form.
So also for grief, despair, and fear, the trauma of loss, the torment of loneliness, and the guilt of survivorship; the realm of our darkest and most negative passions immerses us in atavistic states with totalizing and tidal force.
Life disruptive events can destabilize identity and realign personality, transform meanings and values, send shockwaves through our network of relationships, shift our worldview and unmoor us from the anchorages of our ideological paradigms and historical contexts.
Such traumas confront us with the unfiltered face of our shadow self as a healing process, a transformative journey filled with dangers but also with the limitless possibilities of rebirth.
Among the chiaroscuro of darkness and light of which we are shaped as negative spaces of each other, I turn now to the wisdom of our darkness.
The Dream of the Toad, Nietzsche’s Toad which he feared he must swallow and could not, a spirit which had possessed William S. Burroughs since childhood, cursed by his Welsh nanny, and been transferred to me as a lineage of succession through his storytelling as rituals of initiation and transformation, from Nietzsche to Bataille to Burroughs interwoven with a secondary successorship of transmission from Crowley to Lovecraft to Burroughs, and from Burroughs to myself, what Jung called shadow work in which I embraced my darkness and became whole. As Shakespeare said of Caliban in The Tempest, “This thing of darkness I acknowledge mine”; the quote with which Burroughs’ ended many such ceremonies.
This was the signal event of my year during eighth grade, when I read the entire works of Plato and then discovered someone who spoke for me in Nietzsche’s Thus Spake Zarathustra; years earlier through his stories the man I called Uncle Bill, among my father’s circle of counterculture artists and writers, created a personal connection for me with my chthonic Underworld guardian and guide Tsathoggua, and with its previous bearers and avatars. Together we change boundaries into interfaces, we human beings with our ephemeral persona adrift upon the endless seas and chasms of darkness of our limitless unconscious selves, as a dual or bicameral consciousness and unitary field of being which extends through the dreaming and waking realms; I who deny nothing and the timeless and oracular daemon who speaks for those truths immanent in nature and written in our flesh.
What was William S. Burroughs to me? A trusted and kind family friend who helped me to process my trauma of Bloody Thursday, in which I awakened to a highly contingent and meaningless world in which death can come at any time and for no reason whatever, and wherein Authority, especially that of the state and its instruments of force and control the police whose purpose is to protect the wealth, power, and privilege of hegemonic elites and those who would enslave us, and like the mad rapacious gods of Lovecraft, is not merely a Nietzschean one who has abandoned us or been dethroned but an existential threat of utterly alien motives.
Here also was my apprenticeship as a storyteller, for by seventh grade I had covered one entire wall of my bedroom with a collage of nightmare images from Hieronymus Bosch and others as gateways into other worlds. This was my Dream Gates wall, which functioned as mandalas for me throughout my teenage years, passages into imaginal realms I call the Labyrinth of the Gates of Dreams. Through them I explored myriads of possible universes, futures, and alternate histories as revealed to me on Bloody Thursday in the moment of my death and rebirth.
William S. Burroughs used to draw figures on it during his visits and make it even more strange and bizarre; through this art, his stories which reimagined Grimm’s fairytales as a mythology, and his ceremonial magic and demonology as an initiation cycle referencing Crowley and medieval sources, Nietzsche and his friend Bataille’s cult of Acephale, his model Lovecraft, and influences from my father’s Gordian Knot of Voodoo, lycanthropy, and family history coded as fairytales by the Brothers Grimm, he and my father together forged an Absurdist faith of Chaos. One day I intend to write a book entitled Gods of My Father: the Art of Fear.
Such was the context in which I discovered the works of my literary first love Herman Hesse during seventh grade, and his hybrid Gnostic-Buddhist faith which uses as its symbol and controlling metaphor the dual-gendered figure of Abraxas in the novel Demian, appropriated by Jung in The Red Book and systematized according to his studies of alchemy as a universal faith and psychology, and described gloriously by Virginia Woolf in Orlando. From this basis my teenage obsession with magic coalesced, and my studies of Jungian psychology at university.
Among his many useful methods, Burroughs taught me to read Tarot cards as reordering, creating, and destroying possible realities and selves; I have and greatly treasure the deck he gave me in seventh grade with the words; “With these you can see truths and futures, but you can also create them.”
So for darkness, and now for light, rapture, transcendence, illumination.
Sailing the Lake of Dreams in Srinagar, where I studied Sufism as a scholar of the Naqshbandi order which as a warrior brotherhood spread Islam and martial arts of silat throughout south Asia, was wooed by Beauty but claimed by Vision; and my Journeys through the Gates of Possibilities in Kathmandu as a Dream Navigator of the Kagyu Vajrayana Buddhist order. Here were parallel systems of dreamwork, sharing many elements, and having assimilated elements of Hinduism as yoga in Sufism and as Tantra in Buddhism, which I studied together during a sabbatical between graduate programs as I entered my thirties and began my decade long Great Trek, complex philosophies written in different languages, Classical Tibetan on the one hand and Classical Quranic Arabic, Classical Persian, and Ottoman Turkish on the other, but whose techniques could be used interdependently in the context of Jungian psychology and dreamwork.
Like the dreams to which they are akin, such visions can be read as symbols, metaphors, and allegories; they are also stories woven into our lives which connect us with the universe and with other people, and through which we create ourselves. Are we not the stories we tell about ourselves, to ourselves and to others?
I am looking at the scar on my hand from where a Fallen Star touched me one night during a meteor shower, decades ago, when I reached up to pull the stars from the heavens and something reached down to enfold my hand in a nimbus of light, and for a moment I was sublimed and exalted in the Kiss of the Fallen Star, riding the light among the spheres, the earth a vanishing orb, then lost among the solar system, a sea of stars, a whirling dance of galaxies, and return to the hill where I stood transfigured by the embrace of Infinite. Stunned not by our smallness next to a universal scale, but by the eternity and timeless immensity of Being in which we share.
If ever I need to be reminded of our true nature, of the presence of the transcendent and the immanence of truths written in our flesh, of the vast and limitless sea of being and consciousness of which we are part, I need only open my hand to see written there the signature of the Infinite Unknown and the sign of our hope, for from the moment I touched a star I have been without despair, fear, or doubt, a bearer of hope.
So many adventures down the rabbit hole that a full narrative would fill volumes; but one especially do I wish to share here.
Humans are beautiful not in spite of our flaws, but because of them. This teaching was given to me by a tribal elder while crossing the Thar desert in a camel caravan near Jaisalmer in Rajasthan, India. There was a huge clay pot given pride of place in a dark tent, unremarkable and worthless, and shown to me by these penniless nomads with the absurd claim that it was the great treasure of their people. Then someone put a lamp inside, and illuminated the thousands of hairline fractures through it, and began to recite the history of the tribe following its lines, not only beautiful and a symbol of the immanence of the Infinite as truths written in our flesh, but also, like the songlines of the Australian aborigines, a map of tribal history and migrations reaching back hundreds of years, each with its own stories, like our bodies a mnemonic instrument of oral history. I call this vision the Illumination of Our Beautiful Flaws.
From this primary insight I forged my Narrative Theory of Identity; we are the stories we tell about ourselves, to ourselves and to others. And the first question we must ask of them is; Whose story is this?
Always there remains the struggle between the masks that others make for us and those we make for ourselves; this is the first revolution in which we all must fight.
What general principles can we learn from the creative processes of poetic vision as reimagination and transformation?
First, that no matter how much we learn, the unknown remains as vast and infinite as before; this I call the Conservation of Ignorance. For further explication, see Nicholaus of Cusa’s De Docta Ignorantia, and Rudy Rucker’s magisterial study of Godel’s Theorem, Infinity and the Mind.
Second, the universe is fundamentally irrational and Absurd, and moreover is ephemeral, transitory, subjective, and relativistic, characterized by processes of change. Being, meaning, and value defy universalization and our attempts to impose order on living systems which are chaotic, uncontrollable, and wild, including ourselves.
Third, human attempts to abstract us from nature birth monsters, pathologies of control and disconnectedness. The wonder and terror of vision and immersion in the realm of the liminal and the transpersonal has inspired some of the greatest achievements of civilization and the limitless possibilities of becoming human, and some of the most fearsome terrors of our historical atrocities, madness, and degradation.
The liminal bears creative and destructive forces in equal measure, and not reductive to the interplay of darkness and light, but ambiguous, contingent, and relative. We who are its witnesses and bearers of poetic vision are the arbiters of this power among humankind and of its consequences for the material universe and the order and fate of the cosmos. Who bears the fire of the gods becomes an agent of transformation, insight, and the reshaping of human being, meaning, and value; this is true of all art and of creativity in general.
Revolutions are born of such insight, in sciences and arts of understanding and in our creation of ourselves. With this inner fire and vision we may forge new truths, and in this mission I offer guidance and warning as you sail into the unknown; transgress boundaries, violate norms, abandon limits, and seize your power to create yourself anew, for nothing is Forbidden and all Authority is illusion and lies; but always know what you are trying to achieve, for force always operates in both directions at once.
Act without fear, and in action be fearless; but with awareness of the consequences of your actions. Life and liberty, as well as good and evil, may depend on the smallest of changes in our lives and our world, both for ourselves and for others.
Best wishes, and may you find joy, freedom, healing, and love in your reimagination of yourself and our possibilities of becoming human.
In a moment of hope wherein we have turned the tides of fascist tyranny and triggered the fall of the Trump regime’s Fourth Reich in our elections and begun to claw back something of our humanity from the gathering darkness, which attends my birthday tomorrow with joy, yet shadowed still by great horror and cruelty as the ICE white supremacist terror force perpetrates ethnic cleansing in America and the federal Occupation of our sanctuary cities, and of the Israeli ethnic cleansing and genocide of the Palestinians, blood sacrifices of the innocent to state power authorized by an America made complicit as our taxes buy the deaths of children and other civilians and the institutional rape and torture of prisoners, I return to thoughts regarding hope and its role in revolutionary struggle and Resistance, such as that now unleashed in the many theatres of World War Three which include America as we battle for our liberty, Ukraine as Trump’s puppetmaster invades to shatter the unity of Europe against tyranny, and of our criminal and unprovoked war against Iran on behalf of our fortress state as she attempts to found an empire of Greater Israel on the bones of her neighbors so that Trump and Netanyahu can build a riviera of casinos for elites through the genocide of the Palestinians, a programme which also serves the Fourth Reich’s goals of abandonment of the idea of universal human rights and the extinction of mercy and compassion from humankind, by making us all complicit in the unforgiveable.
We now hold the political power to change all of this, if we can find the will to make it real.
We have made the impossible possible, for on the third of November 2026 the certainty of a global Age of Tyrants and of six to eight centuries of horrific wars fought with weapons of unimaginable horror ending with the extinction of our species was reversed, and is no longer a one hundred percent probability.
Now we must seize the momentum and use our power to heal the flaws of our humanity and the brokenness of the world.
As I wrote in my post of August 23 2022, Neil Gaiman’s The Sandman: Allegories of Hope and the Ambiguity of Love and Desire in Games of Power; Last night I saw episode five of the Netflix series The Sandman, wherein a mad god seizes a diner as its tyrant and dooms everyone in his quest for a world in which there are no lies, and only truths are spoken. A project very like my own in the valorization of truth telling, which I regard as the defining characteristic of faith as a sacred calling in pursuit of truth; but here the liberator and the tyrant are the same, and as Dream points out humans live by hope and the stories they tell about themselves, as living fictions which are not the same as lies though they share some characteristics.
I had forgotten how beautiful Gaiman’s interrogation of the necessity of hope, the ambiguity of truth, and the nature of human being as living stories is.
The ambiguity of desire as a moral force is a major theme of Gaiman’s works; all of his works. He first signifies the vast categorial differences between love and desire; both are kinds of madness which can reveal the truths written in our flesh, but where love exalts, desire can defile, objectify, brutalize as well as confer rapture as a form of poetic vision, for desire is wholly selfish, and a space of free creative play without limits.
As a thing which lives beyond the boundaries of the Forbidden, topologies of The Good, of authorized identities, of normality, and the limits of other people’s ideas of virtue, desire is a force of liberation. But it can also be shaped and motivated by the legacies of our history and by systems of oppression as imposed conditions of struggle, and so remains a primary ground of struggle between the masks we make for ourselves and those made for us by others.
Desire, like Order, appropriates; Love, like Chaos, autonomizes. Desire takes where loves gives. Love creates where Desire destroys. Both are forces of liberation and oppression, depending on how they are used.
That the Wagnerian Ring of Power, recursive forces of fear, power, and force, which he interrogates with awesome beauty and sensitivity in his fictions seems to have captured him in its maelstrom and inflicted a degeneration of his humanity exemplifies the principle that power perpetuates itself, which explains why revolutions become tyrannies as a predictable phase of revolutionary struggle, not because of an evil impulse in human beings but because of the nature of power, especially under imposed conditions of struggle determined by systems of oppression, and also turns liberators into tyrants. For there is but one power which conquers our fear, need for power and the illusion of security, and the use of social force and violence to enforce virtue as defined by whomever holds power over others; the redemptive power of love.
In The Sandman, desire is dangerous precisely because of its wildness and uncontrollability, as is freedom, and the ambiguities and conflicts between love and desire open the doors of tragedy.
“Call me master” Neil Gaiman reportedly commanded a homeless fan he had enslaved; so might Napoleon have said to Europe, Washington to America, Stalin to Russia, Mao to China, Mugabe to Zimbabwe.
Love is a redemptive force which exalts us, a negative space of the gaze of Medusa whose power appropriates that of the Male Gaze, for to love is to see the truth of others and set them free. Desire, however, is always transgressive as a glorious surrender to forces beyond ourselves, violations of boundaries of the Forbidden and the tyranny of other people’s ideas of normality and virtue.
Love autonomizes; Desire totalizes. Yet they are interdependent as creative and destructive powers of our humanity, and we cannot escape them or the consequences of their actions as motives and shaping forces.
Truths immanent in nature and written in our flesh are both forces of liberation and an imposed condition of struggle.
Just so. What unites the powers of creation and destruction is power; and seizures of power are at the root of the origins of evil in unequal power and the use of social force and violence in liberation struggle and its antithesis, tyranny.
This is why utopian idealism so often becomes authoritarian tyranny, and why it is the central problem humankind faces as we choose how to be human together.
It is doing so now, in the atrocity which is like no other called ethnic cleansing and genocide, as Israel butchers tens of thousands of civilians as if they were nothing, and more to come, and dehumanizes both their own citizens and the people they demonize as enemies. Precisely as Israel was founded to offer refuge and safety to its own people from, as they rebuild the Promised Land into a mirror of Auschwitz with themselves as the camp guards. As in America the ICE white supremacist terror forces continues its campaign of ethnic cleansing.
Why is becoming the tyrants we have overthrown a predictable phase of liberation struggle, and how can we escape the legacies of our history?
As the character of John Dee, clearly a self-portrait by Neil Gaiman, is described by Marco Vito Oddo in Collider, in an article entitled The Sandman’s John Dee Explained: Dreams Do Come True.
And so do nightmares; “After decades of heavy medication and being lied to about the Dreamstone’s existence and powers, John developed a pathological aversion to any kind of lies. Of course, as we all know, lying is part of adult life and an important tool to use in everyday life. Unable to understand this, John uses the Dreamstone to remove lies from the waking world. And that, of course, leads to humans giving into their deepest desires without thinking about the consequences, which in turn leads to a lot of destruction.
Removing every kind of lie from the world also removes dreams. So, John’s childish visions of truths and lies result in the disappearance of hope, fantasy, and wishful thinking. It’s no wonder he becomes one of Morpheus’ greatest enemies, as the King of Dreams’ responsibility is to ensure people in the waking world can keep dreaming, so that life can be bearable.”
The character of John Dee, who like H.P. Lovecraft suffers disfiguration of the soul by being raised in isolation as a prisoner of his mother to keep him safe and innocent in a childlike state, as what Jung called a puer aeternus, and unlike the Surrealist author stole the power to recreate reality and used it to free humankind from lies, especially those of authority which falsify us as theft of the soul, has been compared in the FB group Sandman to the magnificent Hannibal Lecter.
As figures of the psychopathy of the state as embodied violence and the debasement and nihilism of the Wagnerian Ring of fear, power, and force as the origin of evil and the generative engine of fascism, I would also compare him to the character of Martin Chatwin in the Netflix series The Magicians, and to his historical parallels Adolf Hitler as described in Robert G.L. Waite’s magisterial work The Psychopathic God and to Our Clown of Terror, Traitor Trump, as analyzed in Trump on the Couch by Dr Justin Frank.
Of all these figural studies of fascism and tyranny only those who define the limits of the human like Hitler and Trump, Hannibal Lecter and Gaiman’s John Dee are truly useful to us, for they are monsters in whom we can see ourselves as in a dark mirror; Hannibal because he is an avenger, Dee because he is pathetic as well as terrible, victim as well as perpetrator.
I cheered when Hannibal escaped at the end of the great film, at its premiere so many years ago, not because he is a Nietzschean superman but because like myself he is a monster who hunts other monsters, an avenger of injustice in a world which has replaced morality with law. Hannibal has as its primary theme the critique of authority written by Nikos Kazantzakis in his thesis on Nietzsche, The Philosophy of Right and the State, which interrogates the historical claim that man is evil and broken, and that without the restraining force of law devolves to a subhuman state and a world where the most ruthless wins. Its the basis for all our laws, this reimagination of the doctrine of Original Sin, and like Kazantzakis I believe this fig leaf for the centralization of power to a carceral state of force and control must be abandoned along with the use of social force.
Recall that Hannibal begins as a doctor into whose care the state has given monstrous criminals who are too wealthy and powerful to punish justly, a primary strategy of tyranny and Authority being co-optation. What William S. Burroughs called Control turns some of us into monsters to subjugate the rest of us into surrendering our power to an Authority which promises security; but security is an illusion, Law serves power and the hegemony of elites, and there is no just Authority.
So Hannibal, like Dee and so many of history’s liberators who become tyrants by seizures of power in revolutionary struggle, ventures beyond the boundaries of the Forbidden and the law in defense of the powerless and the dispossessed, the silenced and the erased; but in doing so such avengers become devoured by the power they have seized and the violence they must use. Here is a central theme of Neil Gaiman’s more fully worked out in the series Lucifer, but also present in his tales of the Sandman.
It is a dichotomy which he embodies personally, exemplar of the recursive forces of fear, power, and force, Neil Gaiman the brilliant author who champions the human transcendent and imaginal in fictions which also interrogate the consequences of violence and the nature of power, and here has set the two sides of himself in stark relief and titanic struggle to become human as Dream versus Dee with admirable self-awareness, and whose career foundered on the shoals of revelations concerning his sexual enslavement of a homeless fan.
In a final confrontation between the messianic and tragic figure of a mad god who would condemn us to be free in Sartrean authenticity and Sadeian transgression, and save humankind from its lies, illusions, falsifications, and leave us revealed in the truths immanent in nature and written in our flesh, bearer of a sacred wound which opens him to the pain of others but also creates the fatal flaw and illusion of moral equivalence of good and evil in the sacred calling to pursue the truth, the Original Lie of the tyrant that only power and fear have meaning and are real, and his adversary the Lord of Dreams, who champions the fictions by which we reach beyond ourselves, the legacies of our history, and the limits of the human, a figure of poetic vision and the reimagination and transformation of human being, meaning, and value as an inherent capacity of self-creation and the limitless possibilities of becoming human, Neil Gaiman gives us a chiaroscuro of darkness and light, truth and lies, and a dialectics of becoming human which is ambiguous, relativistic, changing, and negotiates seizures of power as revolutionary struggle between the stories we tell about ourselves and those told about us by others, between liberty and tyranny.
Are we not the stories we tell about ourselves, to ourselves and to others? Always there remains the struggle between the masks that others make for us and those we make for ourselves. This is the first revolution in which we all must fight; the struggle for ownership of ourselves.
Here I find a mirror of my conversations with myself whenever I must choose a course of action and make another Last Stand, as I did in Mariupol Ukraine April 2022, Panjshir Afghanistan September 2021, in the defense of Al Aqsa May 2021, in this summer of 2026 in Yemen and elsewhere, and in so many other times and places I cannot list them all, and will in future.
When I was fifteen I spent a Christmas break skiing with friends, Doc Hannink who had been a Forensics student of my father’s, four years older as most of my friends were and who brought me to his university events, and his friend Scott Aldred whose father owned a ski cabin in Tahoe; in the attic were piles of comics, and I read through them voraciously. One line in particular stayed with me and became my motto of action for years after, spoken by Doctor Doom, a villain I had mistaken for the hero; “Only I can bring order to this world of Chaos.” It was years before I realized this was exactly the opposite of the truth, that Chaos is the side of liberation and Order the side of tyranny.
John Dee speaks his cruel truth, in reference to de Sade, Nietzsche and Bataille, Artaud and Pirandello, Beckett and Kobo Abe; “I offered you a world where you could be yourselves without having to suffer for it, but it seems you enjoy your suffering. And if that is your truth, then perhaps your suffering will set you free.
The truth is a cleansing fire… which burns away the lies we’ve told each other… and the lies we’ve told ourselves So that love and hate, pleasure and pain……can all be expressed… without shame. Where there is no good or bad… there is only the truth.”
To which Morpheus asks; “What is it you think you’re doing?”
“Saving the world from its lies. This is the truth of mankind.”
“No. You’re wrong.”
“This is the truth of mankind. They’re lying to themselves. It’s all lies.”
“Not lies, John. Dreams. Their dreams kept them alive. But if you rob them of their dreams, if you take away their hope, then… yes, this is the truth of mankind.”
For if the fictions of those who would enslave is can capture our souls, the stories of our own creation which belong to us can make impossible dreams become real and true.
Here are some of my previous interrogations of the idea of hope, which I preface with a brief history of the praxis or action of the value of hope in my life mission to discover and engage the origins of evil and in the reimagination and transformation of myself and the possibilities of human being, meaning, and value as transgressions of the boundaries of the Forbidden, seizures of power from authority, violations of normality, and freedom from the tyranny of other people’s ideas of virtue.
As I wrote in my post of July 26 2020, Explaining Badly What I Do, For Even I Am Not Altogether Certain: a Confession; As a student of the origins of evil I studied everything, but especially the nexus of literature, history, psychology, and philosophy, and wrote, spoke, taught, and organized always, for democracy and liberation from systems of unequal power and elite hegemonies of wealth, power, and privilege, for our universal human rights and against dehumanization, tyranny, and fascisms of blood, faith, and soil, and for the values of a free society of equals; among them liberty, equality, truth, and justice. During vacations from graduate school and teaching English, Forensics, and Socratic seminars in various subjects through the Gifted and Talented Education program at Sonoma Valley High School and my private practice as a counselor I wandered the world in search of windmills that might be giants at which to tilt.
One day I crossed beyond our topologies of meaning and value and transgressed the boundaries of the Forbidden into the unknown, the blank places on the maps of our becoming human marked Here Be Dragons, and never returned. I live now where the dragons dwell, and I wouldn’t trade a moment of the life I have lived for any treasure on earth, for I am free.
It happened like this; one day I was driving from my day job teaching high school as a sacred calling to pursue the truth to my very elegant office in San Francisco where I practiced the repair of the world as a healer of the flaws of our humanity, things I loved but had begun to feel determinative of my scope of action, when the lightning of insight struck. In that moment of illumination I realized that I was literally in Hell, trapped in Nietzsche’s Eternal Return, for I had lived the same day more times than I could remember and was about to do so yet again. And I thought, Why am I doing this? I don’t need to do this.
I recalled a line of poetry from a book on the game of Go, handwritten variously in Chinese, Japanese, and English which had mysteriously been left at the front door of our home when I was in seventh grade; “This is a message from your future self; I return from living fifty thousand years rapturous in sky, to find you living in a box. Seize the heavens and be free.”
We had just brought down the Berlin Wall, and all things had become possible. So I wondered, what if we brought down all the other walls, beginning with my own?
So like Lucifer I escaped from Hell and took a wrong turn to the airport where I bought a ticket to the Unknown; the agent asked me where I wanted to go, and I said the other side of the world. I had no idea where I was flying to, and when I arrived in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, where in its glittering business district the possibilities were ones I could have explored at home in San Francisco had I wished, I once again found a Forbidden Door to the Unknown in a bus station beside a temple of Ganesha with a map that showed where all the roads ended in nothingness, an enormous empty space along the spine of the Malay Peninsula. I took a bus there and got off at the end of the road, where a dirt track led into the forest of the Cameron Highlands, and with nothing but whatever happened to be in my pockets began walking into an unmapped wilderness.
So began a journey from which I have never truly returned, which may be described with the words of Obi Wan to Luke Skywalker as “some damn fool idealistic crusade.”
Sometimes my quest found only death and loss, sometimes triumph and illumination, but the struggle itself was always a seizure of power in which something of our humanity might be wrested back from the claws of our nothingness.
Among the prizes and exhibits of my memory palace are heroes and rogues, allies and enemies of whom only I, like Ishmael, live to tell the tale; others became legends. So also with the causes for which we fought.
What if we told students what life is really like, that its full of blood and horror and in the end means nothing at all, and the best you can do is survive another day in refusal to submit and maybe save someone from the darkness before it swallows us all? I’ve looked into the darkness since 1982 in Beirut, when Jean Genet swore me to the Oath of the Resistance, and as Nietzsche warned it has begun to look back at me.
It may have begun in Mariupol when the horror was given form as I spent hours crawling through partially collapsed tunnels after artillery shelling, through the bloody piles of entrails and savaged parts of the dead among echoes of the sounds of the dying whom I could not help; this bothered me not at all, having survived far worse and more desperate chances as I will doubtlessly again, but I spent days throwing up and working through the stages of shock when later I discovered what the Russian Army was doing with some of the children it had stolen.
These days its mostly the oracle of a disembodied head that bothers me, in the wake of my expedition to Beirut from September 23 2024 to the second week of October; when a family searching for a missing child found only his head, Israel having erased the rest of him with their bombs. It feels like a pomegranate in your hands, such a tiny head, and I fear what its seeds may one day bear. In my dreams it tells me things, and I do not like the truths it speaks.
Yet I will struggle with the darkness and cease not, and so remain Unconquered in defiance of unjust authority and in refusal to submit, though I have sometimes forgotten why. At moments of doubt such as this I read again Camus’ The Myth of Sisyphus, Hemingway’s The Old Man and the Sea, Henley’s Invictus, I.F. Stone’s The Trial of Socrates; myths, stories, poetry, and history of the grandeur of resistance which confers freedom, beyond hope of victory or even survival.
Refusal to submit is the primary human act. We can be killed, tortured, starved and imprisoned; but we cannot be defeated so long as we refuse to obey. This is our victory, in which we seize ownership of ourselves and create ourselves anew, and nothing can take this from us. In our refusal to submit, disobedience, and defiance of authority we become unstoppable as the tides, for force fails at the point of disobedience and authority has no power which is not granted to it by those it claims, and once questioned, mocked, exposed, and challenged as illegitimate the illusions with which it seduces us vanish into the nothingness from which they came.
Always pay attention to the man behind the curtain.
Pandora’s Box bears a last gift which is also a curse; we cling to it when it is all we have, and because it cannot be taken from us. I have never been able to decide if this is a good thing or not. Why has this strange gift been given to us?
Maybe it’s only this; that so long as we get back to our feet for yet another last stand, there is hope.
As to my art of war and revolutionary struggle, in a very long life lived in many fields of battle, grounds of struggle, and arenas where there are no rules, I have found two truths and principles of action regarding winning fights; first, who achieves surprise wins regardless of all else, and second, never staying down also wins fights.
And so I open the Forbidden Door to the unknown and step through as I have many times before, a nameless shadow among countless others who await in welcome all those who dare to transgress the limits unjustly imposed on us, a realm of shadows and of the unconquered, and like lions we roar our defiance into the fathoms of emptiness beyond.
Such is the only possible response to the terror of our nothingness and its weaponization by those who would enslave us; the roar of defiance, as wild things who are masterless and free.
As the Oath of the Resistance given to me by Jean Genet in Beirut 1982 goes; “We swear our loyalty to each other, to Resist and yield not, and abandon not our fellows.”
Tonight the shadows dance, wild and free, bound by no rules but our own; come and dance with us.
Summer of Fire 2022 Letter to a Suicide Squad
To fascism there can be but one reply; Never Again. And to the tyranny and terror of those who would enslave us, let us give reply with the immortal words of Shakespeare in Julius Caesar, the play which Nelson Mandela used as a codex to unify resistance against Apartheid among the political prisoners of Robben Island; Sic Semper Tyrannis, Ever Thus to Tyrants.
Known as the Robben Island Bible, this copy of Shakespeare was passed around as the key to a book code for secret messages which referred to page and line; it was also underlined. On December 16th 1977, Nelson Mandela authorized direct action by underlining this passage from Julius Caesar;
“Cowards die many times before their deaths.
The valiant never taste of death but once.
Of all the wonders that I yet have heard,
It seems to me most strange that men should fear,
Seeing that death, a necessary end,
Will come when it will come.”
Tonight the shadows dance, wild and free, bound by no rules but our own; come and dance with us.
Notes on Letter to a Suicide Squad
I wrote this as guidance and general principles of Resistance to tyranny, antifascist action, and revolutionary struggle; but also as a letter to a suicide squad who had volunteered to hunt the hunters here in America and rescue their victims, in the confusion of mass action in some fifty cities which became a moving street fight with forces of repression, which the government of the United States of America used as concealment for Homeland Security death squads to abduct, torture, and assassinate innocent civilians at random as state terror to repress dissent and the Black Lives Matter movement through state terror and learned helplessness.
A state which sacrifices its legitimacy for control has doomed itself; if its actions can be exposed and its fig leaf stolen. Such is a primary goal of revolutionary struggle; but the people must also be protected, and publicly witnessed to be so, by those who would liberate them. As Shakespeare’s Henry the Fifth says; “When lenity and cruelty play for a kingdom, the gentler hand is the surest winner.”
As I wrote in my post of January 20 2021, The Turning of the Tide: With Inauguration Day Comes the Return of Hope; With this Inauguration Day comes the return of hope as a fulcrum of resilience and renewal; now begins the great work of reimagining America and ourselves.
I have a complex relationship with the idea of hope, with the ambiguity, relativity, and context-determined multiple truths and simultaneity of meaning which defines hope, that thing of redemption and transformative power which remains in Pandora’s Box after all the evils have escaped, as either the most terrible of our nightmares or the gift of the miraculous depending on how we use it.
As the Wizard of Oz said of himself it’s a humbug, but it is also a power which cannot be taken from us by force and control, and like faith of which it is a cipher holds open the door of our liberation and the limitless possibilities of becoming human.
As we believe, so we may become.
Human being, meaning, and value originate in this uniquely human capacity to transcend and grow beyond our limits as an act of transformation, rebirth, and self-creation, and as a seizure of power over our identities. Among other things it allows us to escape the flags of our skin and inhabit that of others; to forge bonds through empathy and compassion and enact solidarity, altruism, mercy, and compassion.
This is what is most human in us, a quality which defines the limits of what is human, and which we must cherish and conserve as our most priceless gift.
Hope is the thing which can restore us to ourselves and each other, unite a divided nation and begin to heal our legacies of historical inequalities and injustices, and it can be wielded as an instrument which counters fear. Hope is the balance of fear, and fear is a negative space of hope; and because fear births hate, racism, fascism, hierarchies of elite privilege and belonging and categories of exclusionary otherness, hope is a power of liberation and of revolutionary struggle.
What do I hope for now, watching the Inauguration of Joe Biden and Kamala Harris as love triumphs over hate and diversity and inclusion over racism as national policy? I hope that the ideals and values we have embraced today as symbols will in time become real.
And I hope that the peaceful transfer of power and the viability and resilience of democracy will never again be threatened or called into question by any act of treason, tyranny, or terror.
Regarding that I have a story to share with you about a previous election, during which the Cambodian refugees, who had been assigned for acculturation to my mother as a high school English teacher with a facility for languages, all vanished overnight from the town. They returned to her classroom in family groups two to three weeks later, and she asked them where they went. One of them answered; “To the hills. New President, soldiers come now.” She told them that can’t happen here, and the reply was “That’s what we thought before Pol Pot.” I imagine that’s what most of us thought, before Trump.
Like President Biden before, Harris has promised us a Restoration of democracy and our Constitution as the Rule of Law, which I hope will include universal human rights and standing with the people of Palestine against genocide by Israel through BDS, disarmament, regime change, and bringing Netanyahu and other war criminals to trial, and to work toward unity and healing the nation. In this historic cause let us work together with her to restore honor to our nation and create a free society of equals built on objective and testable truth, impartial and fair justice, liberty, equality, and a secular state.
Let us raise again the fallen cause of the American Revolution, and bear it forward into the future.
So I wrote at the dawn of what I hoped would be the Restoration of America; as it turned out, it was nothing of the kind. Yet I hope for the same now in the wake of our historic victories in the midterms; there are some things which should be true, even if they never were, and we will remain human so long as we take action to make them real.
Amanda Gorman, America’s National Youth Poet Laureate, a cum laude graduate of Harvard in Sociology, delivered a brilliant and visionary inaugural address in which hope is a major theme with her poem, The Hill We Climb. In an NPR interview she said she studied the speeches of Abraham Lincoln, Frederick Douglass, and Winston Churchill in writing it, and has signposted her references to the play Hamilton on Twitter, a poem completed on the most terrible night of our history, when Trump unleashed a mob of white supremacist terrorists under a Confederate battle flag to seize our capitol and execute our representatives in the January 6 Insurrection;
“We’ve seen a force that would shatter our nation rather than share it,
Would destroy our country if it meant delaying democracy.
And this effort very nearly succeeded.
But while democracy can be periodically delayed,
It can never be permanently defeated.
In this truth, in this faith we trust.
For while we have our eyes on the future,
History has its eyes on us.”
Her article in Harper’s articulates her major source and reference as she describes herself writing The Hill We Climb in terms of occupying the same historical space as Emily Dickenson did in writing her great meditation on hope as the Civil War began in 1861, “Hope” is the thing with feathers”; “I’ve come to realize that hope isn’t something you give to others. It’s something you must first give to yourself. This year has taught us to find light in the quiet, in the dark, and, most importantly, how to find hope in ourselves. 2020 has spoken, loud and clear as a battle drum. In 2021, let us answer the call with a shout.”
Here is the text of her poem This Place (An American Lyric):
“There’s a poem in this place—
in the footfalls in the halls
in the quiet beat of the seats.
It is here, at the curtain of day,
where America writes a lyric
you must whisper to say.
There’s a poem in this place—
in the heavy grace,
the lined face of this noble building,
collections burned and reborn twice.
There’s a poem in Boston’s Copley Square
where protest chants
tear through the air
like sheets of rain,
where love of the many
swallows hatred of the few.
There’s a poem in Charlottesville
where tiki torches string a ring of flame
tight round the wrist of night
where men so white they gleam blue—
seem like statues
where men heap that long wax burning
ever higher
where Heather Heyer
blooms forever in a meadow of resistance.
There’s a poem in the great sleeping giant
of Lake Michigan, defiantly raising
its big blue head to Milwaukee and Chicago—
a poem begun long ago, blazed into frozen soil,
strutting upward and aglow.
There’s a poem in Florida, in East Texas
where streets swell into a nexus
of rivers, cows afloat like mottled buoys in the brown,
where courage is now so common
that 23-year-old Jesus Contreras rescues people from floodwaters.
There’s a poem in Los Angeles
yawning wide as the Pacific tide
where a single mother swelters
in a windowless classroom, teaching
black and brown students in Watts
to spell out their thoughts
so her daughter might write
this poem for you.
There’s a lyric in California
where thousands of students march for blocks,
undocumented and unafraid;
where my friend Rosa finds the power to blossom
in deadlock, her spirit the bedrock of her community.
She knows hope is like a stubborn
ship gripping a dock,
a truth: that you can’t stop a dreamer
or knock down a dream.
How could this not be her city
su nación
our country
our America,
our American lyric to write—
a poem by the people, the poor,
the Protestant, the Muslim, the Jew,
the native, the immigrant,
the black, the brown, the blind, the brave,
the undocumented and undeterred,
the woman, the man, the nonbinary,
the white, the trans,
the ally to all of the above
and more?
Tyrants fear the poet.
Now that we know it
we can’t blow it.
We owe it
to show it
not slow it
although it
hurts to sew it
when the world
skirts below it.
Hope—
we must bestow it
like a wick in the poet
so it can grow, lit,
bringing with it
stories to rewrite—
the story of a Texas city depleted but not defeated
a history written that need not be repeated
a nation composed but not yet completed.
There’s a poem in this place—
a poem in America
a poet in every American
who rewrites this nation, who tells
a story worthy of being told on this minnow of an earth
to breathe hope into a palimpsest of time—
a poet in every American
who sees that our poem penned
doesn’t mean our poem’s end.
There’s a place where this poem dwells—
it is here, it is now, in the yellow song of dawn’s bell
where we write an American lyric
we are just beginning to tell.”
As written by Iana Murray in GQ, in an article entitled The Sandman’s diner episode is a disturbing masterpiece: “When David Thewlis walked into a diner in “24/7”, the fifth episode of Netflix’s latest smash hit The Sandman, fans of Neil Gaiman’s source material knew exactly the nightmare the next hour had in store. The grisly episode is the show’s masterpiece: a small-scale chamber piece that dials up the depravity slowly until it boils over. As all the best horror stories conclude, people are just as wicked as the monsters themselves.
At the beginning of the series, dream lord Morpheus (Tom Sturridge) is captured by an occultist aristocrat and has his magical artefacts stolen: a pouch of sand, his helm and a ruby. The latter lands in the hands of John Burgess (David Thewlis), the maniacal illegitimate son of Morpheus’ captor, who uses its manipulative power to control others. Settling into a diner booth, he enacts his plan to create a “more honest” world by preventing its patrons from lying for the next 24 hours. But his noble intentions only grow more corrupt when faced with the reality that the truth isn’t always pretty.
In a series of pure maximalism – in presentation and stakes – the microcosmic world of the diner is a refreshing departure back to (relative) basics. Under the control of the stolen ruby, the truth unravels without inhibition. It’s like the Stanford Prison Experiment on steroids – and rampant hormones. Secrets best kept hidden are unwittingly revealed, and then the horned-up diners hook up with each other until they meet their violent ends.
It all plays out through the eyes of Thewlis, who delivers perhaps the show’s standout performance. The actor tones down Burgess’s creepy demeanour with a gentleness that makes him unassuming. At first glance, he appears frail and vulnerable – a villain who is deceptively, frighteningly normal.
This adaptation is, admittedly, somewhat lighter – while violence doesn’t erupt until the final minutes, the comic sees John Burgess force the diners to commit increasingly horrifying acts as the hours tick by. The sex is more extreme, limbs are mutilated, and humanity is reduced to its most primal instincts. It makes it something of an outlier in a comic series that doesn’t lean so hard on horror. “What was nice is I never had to go that dark again,” Gaiman told Entertainment Weekly. “The readers always knew that I was capable of it, and that things could get dark.”
What makes “24/7” so fascinating, then, is what it achieves by eschewing the comic’s most disturbing elements, and simply exploring what happens when people can’t lie. “The truth is a cleansing fire which burns away the lies we’ve told each other, and the lies we’ve told ourselves,” John Burgess says as the diner descends into chaos. In the end, the fire is far more destructive. As time goes by, the confessions escalate in degeneracy, but even uttering those unspeakable thoughts is enough to send chills. When one regular – a snarky queer woman escaping from an argument – candidly admits she wishes her partner was dead, the cold realisation is just as disturbing as any of the actual violence. In this hour-long thought experiment, The Sandman finds that the true horror is in discovering what humans are capable of when rid of pleasantries. The truth is uncomfortable – sometimes leaving it unsaid is necessary to survive.”
In this second part of my interrogation of military service as labor exploitation wherein states feed their citizens into the machine of the wealth, power, and privilege of hegemonic elites, their lives the raw materiel of systems of oppression which benefit masters and not slaves as internal and external class war, I look to America’s ongoing wars of imperial conquest and dominion to chart the shape of our degeneration from the dream of a free society of equals which was possibly never anything but an illusion.
Our nation is fighting several wars at this moment, including what is officially classified as Operation Southern Spear or enforcement of a new Monroe Doctrine in Latin America and the Caribbean including the coup in Venezuela, the blockade of Cuba, the Occupation of Haiti, the installation of proxy tyrants Milei in Argentia and formerly Bolsonaro in Brazil, and our secret war in Mexico to destabilize its socialist government on behalf of drug cartels.
A second constellation of interdependent conflicts involves the Iran War, Yemen War and the Red Sea Campaign, Lebanon War, and Israeli Conquest of Palestine, all four theatres of the Conquest to found a Greater Israeli.
Third we have the Russian Invasion of Ukraine, in which our Trump Regime has acted as a co-conspirator by destabilizing European democracies in favor of fascism to remove them from the board of play, soften Europe for Russian invasion, and to isolate Ukraine; we have also sabotaged NATO for the same reasons. I refer to the Russian attempts to re-found her empire as World War Three, whose fronts include America as a captured state through Putin’s star agent Trump as well as Libya and vast regions of Africa, and formerly Belarus, Kazakhstan, Nagorno-Karabakh, and Syria which we liberated.
Somalia, and general global wars including the Drone Wars, War versus ISIS, and the War on Terror.
The struggle between Russia and Turkey for control of the Middle East and the Mediterranean has in recent years metastasized into a war between Israel and the Arab-American Alliance to found a Greater Israel through conquest of her neighbors versus Russia’s key all Iran and her Axis of Resistance which includes Lebanon, Iraq, and much of Yemen, Yemen being also a civil war of independence versus the American Dominion and her allies and also about solidarity with the people of Palestine against the genocide our taxes pay for. As always, the Holy Land is a Rashomon Gate of causes, motives, loyalties, and histories.
This does not tally conflicts which are primarily beyond American interests, like the civil war in Myanmar, as here I am interested in the death and horrors our government has made us all complicit in. America is a culture of death, but we hold no patent on the social use of force.
If one counts proxy tyrannies of the Trump regime, malign American global and historical influence becomes vast indeed.
In any conflict one may easily identify the side of justice, because America is nearly always on the other side.
When we begin to question why that is, we awaken to politics as the action of our values and to compassion as our duty of care for others and solidarity of action as guarantors of each other’s humanity.
Let us refuse to serve the power of those who would enslave us as their enforcers and overseers, for when states send slave armies to conquer free peoples, how if they unite to liberate each other instead of subjugating each other?
The way of the tyrant leads to mutual dehumanization of oppressors and their victims, of soldiers and police and the slaves they brutalize to keep at their work. The other path leads to a free society of equals and a society not of subjects but of citizens.
Among the many reasons for the processes of collapse and fragmentation of global democracy and a world order founded on the idea of human rights born in the Enlightenment and the renouncement of rule by priests and kings which the Trump regime and the Republican Party has attempted to return us to, and for the degeneration of humankind, is that our society and the institutions of state are built on premises of unequal power and of the use of force.
For this there is a simple fix and prescription, though making it real and true will be neither swift nor easy; abolish the social use of force, and most especially armies and police.
And if we cannot? Then as Nietzsche warned the Abyss looks back at us, and though it may begin with trivial acts of the enforcement of virtue, the Abyss always grows and becomes chasms of darkness without end.
As I wrote in my post of July 12 2026, Anniversary of the Srebrenica Massacre; Of Sarajevo I shall speak here not of the monstrous acts of those who would be conquerors, nor of the courageous resistance of their intended victims who held true to their faith and to each other in the face of death and torture, nor even of the valor and compassion of the volunteers of the International Brigade who placed themselves between hammer and anvil, but of a small horror which has come to symbolize for me the unimaginable horrors of war; the Jar of Eyes.
On the desk of a commander of death squads sat a jar full of eyes, and beside it an ice cream scoop which he would toy with, stroking its stainless smoothness with an absentminded and sensual languor while interrogating prisoners.
This he did in imitation of the Roman Emperor Basil the Second the Bulgar Slayer, who after the battle of Kleidion in 1014 Christianized Bulgaria by blinding the army he had defeated, and leaving one man in one hundred with a single eye to guide the others home and terrify the nation into submission.
How do I know this, and what were we to each other, this monster and I? Herein I recall and speak as a witness of history a Defining Moment in which we played a game of chess with the life of a prisoner of his as the prize.
Having materialized at his gate and asking to see the commander, itself unusual and a curious thing to a man with his fearsome reputation, I came bearing the gift of a recording of an opera I knew he loved and could not attend due to his duties and price on his head as a war criminal, Leoš Janáček’s House of the Dead set in a Serbian prison and based on the Dostoevsky novel, with the promise of more music in trade for a prisoner he held and did not know the value of. He agreed to the bargain, but with one condition; we would play three games of chess after dinner in the following days, and I must win or force a draw once.
We had three meetings over three days of an hour or so each, over dinner and chess, during which we conversed of the historical civilization he was fighting to defend, a fight which had made him a monster; music, philosophy, art, literature. Once a prisoner was brought in, seated and held fast by guards like a third companion at dinner whom he tortured while we sipped tea, careful that during this test my hand never trembled nor eyes looked away, and spoke of the scene between Christ and the Grand Inquisitor in Dostoevsky’s The Brothers Karamazov. I think he was lonely.
Within the jar the eyes would float randomly, hypnotic, reflective, capturing ones will to resist with a Medusa-like gaze of objectification and dehumanization appropriated from their tormentors, a talisman of transference of power. A jar of silent screams, erased lives, and the lost witness of history; how can we accuse our destroyers when we have no mouths?
Here among the dragons, where the rule of law cannot reach and our maps of meaning and value have given way to tantalizing empty spaces which beckon with the siren call of the Forbidden, where the only currency is fear and the only relationships those of power and dominion, we challenge and define by their absence and contrary the limits of what is human.
For we are all trapped in the Jar of Eyes, and if we are to reawaken and assume our true forms we must find a means of escape.
How many wars are ongoing now?
I note that Operation Southern Spear, Trump’s war to seize control of the Caribbean and South American nations including Cuba and Venezuela, is counted in neither of the two primary sources which I quote below, so I have appended a link to the Wikipedia article.
Here follows Conflict Zone’s answer to the question.
“The 4 Critical Wars in 2026
These four meet every test of full-scale war — organized armed forces, sustained high-intensity combat, and mass civilian displacement:
Russia–Ukraine War (Eastern Europe) — the largest interstate war in Europe since 1945.
Gaza–Israel Conflict (Middle East) — sustained military operations with severe humanitarian impact.
Sudan Civil War (Northeast Africa) — army versus the RSF, driving one of the world’s largest displacement crises.
Myanmar Civil War (Southeast Asia) — the military junta against resistance forces and ethnic armed organizations.
Major Armed Conflicts by Region (High Severity)
Beyond the four critical wars, 25 high-severity conflicts are active in 2026. By region:
Africa
Sahel Crisis — jihadist insurgency across Mali, Burkina Faso, and Niger
Nigeria — Boko Haram / ISWAP
Somalia — Al-Shabaab
DR Congo — Eastern conflict
Sudan–South Sudan border war
Central African Republic
Uganda — ADF insurgency
Middle East
Lebanon–Israel border escalation
Iran–Israel shadow war
Yemen War
Turkey–Kurdish PKK conflict
Asia-Pacific
Kashmir border conflict
Bangladesh–Myanmar border crisis
Manipur ethnic conflict (India)
Xinjiang Uyghur conflict
West Papua independence movement
Papua New Guinea tribal violence
Kyrgyzstan–Tajikistan border
Americas
Haiti gang war
Mexico — drug cartel wars
Colombia — ELN conflict
Venezuela–Colombia border
Brazil — gang violence (Rio / São Paulo)
Europe & Eurasia
Russian Invasion of Ukraine and NATO proxy tensions
Another 36 medium- and low-severity conflicts — frozen border disputes, simmering insurgencies, and maritime standoffs — round out the full list of active conflicts.”
What major wars of imperial conquest and dominion is America fighting now?
Here follows the story of the major ongoing conflicts America is now fighting, as told on the War Costs website;
“The Forever Wars
America’s 21st Century Military Operations
Since 1995, the United States has launched 16 military operations across 37 countries. 7 are still ongoing. 13 were never authorized by Congress. Each one was supposed to be the last.
$5T Total Cost Since 1995
720,895 Total Deaths
7 Ongoing Operations
37 Nations Involved”
“Iran War (2026)
2026–2026(255 days)
🌍 Middle East ·Iran, Israel, Lebanon, Bahrain, Kuwait, UAE, Qatar, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Oman, Cyprus, Azerbaijan
👥 50,000 troops deployed
📅 255 days of conflict
On February 28, 2026, the US and Israel launched “Operation Epic Fury” — massive joint strikes to destroy Iran’s nuclear capabilities and decapitate its leadership. Supreme Leader Khamenei killed Day 1. A 14-point MOU was signed June 19 — collapsed early July. By Day 255 (Nov 9): $8B Hormuz deal on Trump’s desk — Iran signed off, cabinet opposes. Democrats won Congress in Nov 3 midterms; Vance blamed Iran war. Task Force Iron Gate extends blockade to land borders. Oil crashed to $94/bbl. 23 US KIA, 865+ wounded. ~9,500+ total killed. $47B+ direct military, $150B+ total cost. 255 days, no congressional authorization.
“The Full Story How this conflict unfolded
The Iran strikes of 2026 represent the most dangerous escalation of American military power since the 2003 Iraq invasion – and they share the same DNA: no congressional authorization, manufactured intelligence justifications, escalating mission creep, and the unmistakable influence of a foreign policy establishment that has sought confrontation with Iran for decades. What began as targeted strikes against nuclear facilities has already expanded into a multi-front regional war with no clear objectives, exit strategy, or democratic oversight.
The path to war was deliberately constructed through manufactured crises and escalating provocations. Following massive protests in Iran during January 2026, where the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) killed thousands of demonstrators in over 100 cities, President Trump declared that the Iranian regime had “forfeited its right to exist.” On January 28, he announced a “massive armada heading to Iran” while stating that “all options are on the table.” By February 13, he was openly advocating regime change, declaring it would be “the best thing that could happen to the Iranian people.”
The immediate pretext came from Operation Midnight Hammer in late 2025 – a 37-hour campaign of strikes against Iranian nuclear facilities that cost $2.25 billion and temporarily degraded Iran’s enrichment capabilities. When Iran resumed nuclear activities at an accelerated pace and withdrew completely from the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty in January 2026, the Trump administration claimed an imminent threat that required immediate military action. Intelligence assessments suggesting Iran was months away from weapons capability were leaked to friendly media, creating the drumbeat for war.
On February 28, 2026, Operation Epic Fury began with coordinated U.S.-Israeli strikes against Iranian targets across the country. The scale was unprecedented – the largest American military deployment in the Middle East since the 2003 Iraq invasion, involving 40,000 troops, multiple carrier strike groups, B-2 stealth bombers flying 30-hour missions from Whiteman Air Force Base in Missouri, and comprehensive strikes on Tehran, Isfahan, Qom, Karaj, Kermanshah, and Tabriz in broad daylight. The opening salvo targeted over 2,500 Iranian military and government facilities simultaneously.
The first day’s casualties were staggering. Within hours of the initial strikes, Iranian state media reported that Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei had been killed in an attack on his compound in Tehran. The targeting of Iran’s supreme religious and political leader represented a deliberate escalation beyond military objectives to regime decapitation – a strategy that violated international law and guaranteed massive retaliation. Iranian officials put the day’s death toll at over 400, including at least 108 schoolgirls killed when a precision strike hit the Minab Girls’ School in Hormozgan Province.
The Pentagon immediately disputed the casualty figures and claimed the school had been used as a military command center by the IRGC. No evidence was provided, and independent verification was impossible due to the ongoing conflict. The strike, caught on security cameras and broadcast worldwide, showed a classroom full of teenage girls moments before the explosion – images that galvanized Iranian resistance and horrified international observers. Iranian officials later revised the school death toll to 168, making it the deadliest single attack on children in the conflict’s first week.
Iran’s response was swift and multi-dimensional. Within hours of the first U.S. strikes, Iranian forces closed the Strait of Hormuz using mines, fast attack boats, and anti-ship missiles, cutting off approximately 21 million barrels per day of oil shipments – roughly 20% of global supply. Oil prices spiked from $75 to over $130 per barrel within 48 hours, triggering fears of global economic recession. Iran simultaneously launched its largest ballistic missile barrage in history, firing over 500 missiles at U.S. bases and allied facilities across seven countries: Kuwait, Bahrain, UAE, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, and Cyprus.
The missile attacks achieved devastating psychological impact despite limited physical damage. The Fairmont Hotel in Dubai – a symbol of Gulf prosperity – was hit by Iranian drones, killing 12 civilians and sending shockwaves through the region’s financial centers. Kuwait’s Arifjan base, housing thousands of American troops, was struck by multiple ballistic missiles, killing 3 U.S. service members and wounding 8 others. Saudi Arabia’s crucial Ras Tanura oil refinery was damaged by drone swarms, forcing QatarEnergy to halt liquefied natural gas exports and pushing energy prices even higher.
The conflict’s scope expanded rapidly as Iranian proxy forces across the Middle East activated simultaneously. Hezbollah launched rocket barrages from southern Lebanon, forcing Israel to respond with airstrikes that killed 52 Lebanese civilians and displaced over 30,000 people. Iraqi Shia militias attacked the Green Zone in Baghdad while Iranian-backed Houthis in Yemen targeted shipping in the Red Sea. The Islamic Resistance in Syria struck U.S. positions near Damascus. What had been sold as a limited operation against Iranian nuclear facilities had become a regional war involving a dozen countries.
Americans began dying in numbers that exceeded administration predictions. By March 2, confirmed U.S. casualties reached 6 killed and 18 wounded, with more missing in action. Tragically, three American F-15E Strike Eagles were shot down by Kuwaiti air defenses in a friendly fire incident that highlighted the confusion and chaos of multi-national operations under combat stress. The pilots’ deaths underscored how quickly limited strikes could escalate into the kind of prolonged conflict the Trump administration had promised to avoid.
Intelligence failures compounded military setbacks. Reports emerged that Russia was providing Iran with real-time intelligence on U.S. military positions, potentially explaining the accuracy of Iranian counter-strikes. The alleged intelligence sharing – if confirmed – would represent a dramatic escalation in Russian-American tensions and suggest that the Iran conflict was becoming a proxy war between nuclear superpowers. Chinese diplomatic support for Iran and threats to increase military cooperation added another great power dimension to what had begun as a regional confrontation.
The humanitarian catastrophe intensified daily. Iranian Red Crescent reports put civilian casualties at over 1,332 by March 6, including hundreds of women and children. The Kurdish human rights organization Hengaw documented systematic targeting of civilian infrastructure in Kurdish areas of Iran, reporting 1,500+ total casualties including 200 civilians. International humanitarian organizations were denied access to conflict zones, making independent verification impossible and raising concerns about war crimes.
Domestic American opposition emerged immediately but proved politically impotent. Congressional Democrats and some Republicans demanded emergency sessions to authorize or terminate the strikes, but Senate Republicans blocked a War Powers Resolution by a vote of 53-47. Speaker Mike Johnson refused to schedule a House vote, claiming that criticism of the strikes during combat operations would “embolden America’s enemies.” The Constitution’s requirement that Congress declare war was again treated as an inconvenient anachronism rather than fundamental law.
President Trump’s public statements revealed the operation’s incoherent objectives. On March 1, he promised the campaign would be completed in “four weeks or less” while simultaneously demanding Iran’s “unconditional surrender” – terms that virtually guaranteed prolonged conflict. When Iranian Foreign Minister Hossein Amir-Abdollahian responded that “we will resist as long as it takes,” it became clear that neither side had developed exit strategies or negotiation frameworks that could end the fighting.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s admission on March 2 that the U.S. had attacked “pre-emptively” contradicted earlier claims that the strikes were defensive responses to imminent threats. This acknowledgment of preventive war – attacking Iran for what it might do rather than what it had done – violated international law and established dangerous precedents for other powers. The legal justification shifted repeatedly as events unfolded, suggesting the administration was improvising rather than executing a coherent strategy.
The economic consequences rippled globally as financial markets absorbed the reality of prolonged conflict in the world’s most critical energy region. Beyond oil price spikes, shipping companies suspended routes through the Persian Gulf and Red Sea, disrupting global supply chains already stressed by post-pandemic recovery. Insurance rates for Middle Eastern operations skyrocketed, while defense contractors’ stock prices surged on expectations of massive new orders.
By March 6 – day seven of Operation Epic Fury – the war showed no signs of de-escalation. U.S. and Israeli B-2 bomber strikes targeted buried Iranian missile launchers while Iranian naval forces fired anti-ship missiles at Coalition vessels in the Persian Gulf. The U.S. military claimed to have sunk over 30 Iranian warships and coastal defense systems, effectively destroying Iran’s conventional naval capacity. But Iran’s asymmetric capabilities – fast attack boats, submarines, and shore-based missiles – continued threatening regional shipping and military forces.
The most ominous development was Iran’s delayed response to Khamenei’s death. Rather than immediately naming a successor, the Assembly of Experts convened in emergency session while competing factions within the regime struggled for power. This succession crisis introduced massive uncertainty into an already chaotic situation – a leaderless Iran might be more dangerous than one under unified command, as competing factions could escalate to demonstrate their revolutionary credentials.
The Iran strikes of 2026 had already achieved the opposite of their stated objectives. Instead of deterring Iranian aggression, they had triggered the largest Iranian military response in the Islamic Republic’s history. Instead of degrading Iran’s capabilities, they had prompted maximum mobilization of Iranian resources and allied support. Instead of isolating Iran regionally, they had activated a network of proxy forces across the Middle East while potentially drawing Russia and China into closer cooperation with Tehran.
Most fundamentally, the strikes had demonstrated once again that American military power – however overwhelming – cannot achieve political objectives through force alone. The death of Khamenei, the destruction of Iranian military assets, and the imposition of enormous economic costs had not broken Iranian resistance or compelled surrender. Instead, they had created the conditions for prolonged regional warfare with unpredictable consequences for global stability, American credibility, and the constitutional balance between executive and legislative power.
As the conflict entered its second week, the pattern established in Iraq and Afghanistan was already visible: initial military success followed by strategic confusion, mission creep, civilian casualties, domestic opposition, international isolation, and the gradual realization that military force alone cannot solve complex political problems.
The second week brought dramatic escalation in both scope and cost. On March 7 – Day 8 – the combined force expanded strikes to Iranian oil production for the first time, with IDF jets hitting the Tondgouyan Oil Refinery (one of Iran’s largest) and the Shahran Oil Refinery in Tehran, along with two oil storage facilities. Satellite imagery confirmed the destruction of structures at the Khojir Military Complex. The mission had crept from nuclear facilities to military infrastructure to oil production – the classic pattern of expanding war aims that characterized every failed American intervention.
Day 9 saw the destruction of the Shahed Aviation Industries Production Facility in Isfahan – Iran’s primary manufacturer of the Shahed-136, Shahed-129, and Shahed-171 drones that had been supplied to Russia for use in Ukraine. Oil prices surged past $100 per barrel for the first time since 2022, a milestone that sent shockwaves through global markets already reeling from the Hormuz disruption.
The war’s regional consequences intensified on Day 10 when an Iranian missile set a Bahrain oil refinery ablaze, forcing Bahrain to declare force majeure on oil shipments. Iran’s Parliament Speaker Ghalibaf claimed that strikes had degraded US air defenses – a claim that, whether accurate or propaganda, signaled Iran’s determination to frame the conflict as one it was winning.
Day 11 brought the most ominous development yet: CENTCOM announced it had destroyed 16 Iranian minelayers near the Strait of Hormuz, confirming that Iran had begun laying naval mines in the world’s most critical oil chokepoint. Fewer than 10 mines had been deployed so far, but Iran possessed an inventory of 5,000+ naval mines – enough to close the strait for months. CNN reported that approximately 15 million barrels per day of crude oil plus 4.5 million barrels per day of refined fuels were stranded in the Persian Gulf. The UAE had intercepted 241 of 262 incoming ballistic missiles – a 92% rate that sounds impressive until you consider that the 21 that got through caused billions in damage. Paradoxically, Iran was still exporting 2.1 million barrels per day through the Strait, actually slightly more than pre-war levels.
On Day 12 – March 11 – the Pentagon delivered a bombshell to Congress: the first six days of Operation Epic Fury had cost $11.3 billion. That figure – nearly $1.9 billion per day, $21,800 per second – dwarfed initial estimates and put the war on pace to cost $24.5 billion or more by the end of the second week. The same day, Israeli jets struck Basij and internal security sites in Tehran’s Districts 1, 14, 15, and 16 – residential neighborhoods where the strikes killed at least 10 security personnel and an unknown number of civilians. The IAF also struck an IRGC intelligence building in northwest Iran and security sites in Marivan City, Kurdistan Province, including a border guard headquarters and three observation posts. The war had expanded from military targets to internal security forces – the clearest signal yet that the objective was regime change, not nuclear nonproliferation.
Iranian retaliation continued to reach across the Gulf: two drones struck near Dubai International Airport, injuring four people, while another drone hit gasoline storage at the Port of Salalah in Oman, starting fires at a facility in a neutral country. The UK Maritime Trade Operations reported 17 maritime incidents between February 28 and March 11 – 13 confirmed attacks and 4 suspicious approaches. A 29-year-old woman was killed when an Iranian projectile struck a residential building in Manama, Bahrain.
Day 13 – March 12 – brought the war’s first major non-combat loss: a KC-135 Stratotanker refueling aircraft crashed in western Iraq in what CENTCOM described as ‘friendly airspace,’ with rescue operations ongoing and two aircraft involved. Israel announced that top Iranian nuclear scientists had been killed – suggesting assassination operations running parallel to the bombing campaign. Oil tankers were hit in Iraq. And in the most significant diplomatic development since the war began, Tehran set three conditions for peace – the first concrete negotiating position either side had offered.
By Day 13, the war’s human toll had reached staggering proportions. Iran’s UN representative reported 1,348 killed and 17,000 injured, including 200 women and 168 children (the Minab school massacre). Fifty-five healthcare workers had been wounded and 11 killed. US casualties stood at 8 dead (7 killed in action plus 1 who died of a ‘health incident’ in Kuwait) and 18 wounded. Lebanon had suffered 687 killed including 98 children and 1,500 injured. Bahrain, Iraq, Kuwait, Jordan, and the UAE had all suffered casualties. The Gulf states alone counted approximately 17 dead.
The Iran War of 2026 seemed destined to join the long list of American military interventions that achieved tactical victories while producing strategic defeats – but at a pace and cost that exceeded even the worst projections. At $11.3 billion for the first six days, the war was burning through money faster than any conflict in American history. The mission had crept from nuclear facilities to oil infrastructure to internal security forces to assassinations of scientists. The Strait of Hormuz was being mined. Oil was above $100. And still there was no congressional authorization, no exit strategy, and no answer to the question that should have been asked before the first bomb fell: how does this end?”
“Red Sea / Houthi Campaign
2023–Present (3 years)
🌍 Middle East ·Yemen
👥 12,000 troops deployed
📅 730 days of conflict
Operation Prosperity Guardian – US-led coalition to protect Red Sea shipping from Houthi attacks after October 2023 Gaza war. The most intense naval combat the US Navy has faced since World War II. Over 200 Houthi attacks on commercial and military vessels. US/UK launched 931+ airstrikes on Houthi targets in Yemen starting January 2024. Multiple carrier strike groups deployed including USS Eisenhower and USS Dwight D. Eisenhower battle groups. $1 billion+ in munitions expended. Suez Canal traffic dropped 50%, insurance premiums tripled, and global economic disruption exceeded $100 billion. B-2 Spirit stealth bombers deployed against underground Houthi bunkers. Zero US combat deaths but multiple close calls including drone near-misses on destroyers. Cost at least $4.5 billion through 2025.
The Full Story
How this conflict unfolded
Beginning in late 2023, Yemen’s Houthi rebels launched what would become the most significant challenge to freedom of navigation since World War II – and the most intense naval combat the United States Navy has faced in 80 years. Armed with Iranian-supplied anti-ship ballistic missiles, cruise missiles, and one-way attack drones, the Houthis turned the Red Sea into a war zone, ostensibly in solidarity with Palestinians during the Israel-Gaza war.
The opening salvo came on November 19, 2023, when Houthi forces seized the Galaxy Leader, a Japanese-owned, Bahamas-flagged car carrier, by helicopter assault. The 25 crew members were taken hostage, and the ship was towed to Hodeidah port where it became a macabre tourist attraction – Houthi supporters posed for selfies on the captured vessel’s deck. The seizure sent shockwaves through the maritime industry.
What followed was an escalating campaign of maritime terror. Houthi forces launched over 200 attacks on commercial and military vessels transiting the Bab el-Mandeb strait, the narrow chokepoint connecting the Red Sea to the Gulf of Aden. Approximately 12% of global trade passes through this corridor via the Suez Canal. Within weeks, the world’s largest shipping companies – Maersk, MSC, Hapag-Lloyd, CMA CGM – suspended Red Sea transits entirely, rerouting vessels around the Cape of Good Hope. The detour added 10-14 days and $1 million or more in fuel costs to each voyage.
The economic devastation was staggering. Suez Canal traffic plummeted by 50%, costing Egypt billions in lost revenue. Maritime insurance premiums tripled for Red Sea transits. Global supply chains, still recovering from COVID-era disruptions, were thrown into chaos. The total economic disruption has been estimated at over $100 billion when accounting for increased shipping costs, delayed deliveries, insurance premiums, and cascading effects on global commodity prices.
On December 18, 2023, Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin announced Operation Prosperity Guardian, a multinational naval coalition to escort and protect commercial shipping. But the coalition was weaker than advertised – many partners contributed only staff officers, not warships. The heavy lifting fell almost entirely on the US Navy and, to a lesser extent, the Royal Navy.
The most dramatic moment came on January 10, 2024, when the Houthis launched their largest coordinated attack: 18 drones, 2 cruise missiles, and 1 anti-ship ballistic missile, all fired simultaneously. The USS Eisenhower carrier strike group and coalition destroyers intercepted every projectile in a engagement that defense officials called the most intense naval air defense action since World War II.
Two days later, on January 12, the US and UK launched Operation Poseidon Archer – direct strikes on Houthi targets inside Yemen. Over 60 targets across 16 locations were hit in the opening salvo, including radar sites, drone storage facilities, and missile launch positions. President Biden announced the strikes without seeking congressional authorization, citing Article II self-defense powers.
But the Houthis proved remarkably resilient. Despite 931+ coalition airstrikes over the following year, the attack tempo actually increased. The Houthis demonstrated the ability to rebuild launch sites and resume attacks within 24-48 hours of being struck. Their dispersed, mobile launch infrastructure proved nearly impossible to permanently eliminate.
The human cost came into sharp focus in early 2024. On February 18, a Houthi anti-ship missile struck the MV Rubymar, a UK-registered bulk carrier loaded with 21,000 metric tons of ammonium phosphate sulfate fertilizer. The crew abandoned ship, and the Rubymar sank on March 2 – the first commercial vessel lost to Houthi attacks – creating an environmental catastrophe in the Red Sea. On March 6, the True Confidence, a Barbados-flagged bulk carrier, was struck by an anti-ship ballistic missile, killing three crew members – the first fatalities of the shipping campaign.
Individual US warships became legends of the campaign. The USS Carney (DDG-64) became the most combat-active destroyer in modern Navy history, shooting down dozens of drones and missiles across multiple engagements. In one early engagement on October 19, 2023, the Carney intercepted cruise missiles and drones over several hours in the northern Red Sea. The USS Gravely (DDG-107) achieved the closest-range intercept in modern naval combat history when its Close-In Weapon System (CIWS) – a radar-guided 20mm Gatling gun – destroyed an incoming Houthi cruise missile at less than one mile from the ship. The crew had seconds to live.
The USS Eisenhower (CVN-69) conducted the longest combat deployment since Vietnam, spending over 9 months at sea. Its air wing flew hundreds of strike sorties against Houthi targets, expending munitions at rates not seen since the 1991 Gulf War. The strain on crews was immense – extended deployments with high-intensity combat operations and no port calls.
In October 2024, the US escalated dramatically by deploying B-2 Spirit stealth bombers from Whiteman Air Force Base in Missouri to strike five hardened underground Houthi weapons storage facilities. The B-2 strikes – the first combat use of the stealth bomber since Libya in 2017 – targeted bunkers that conventional strikes couldn’t penetrate. The message was clear: the US was willing to deploy its most advanced strategic assets against a rebel group in Yemen.
The asymmetric economics of the campaign were devastating. The Houthis launched drones costing a few thousand dollars each; the US responded with SM-2 missiles costing $2.1 million and SM-6 missiles costing $4.3 million apiece. A single carrier strike group costs approximately $7 million per day to operate. Over the course of the campaign, the US expended more than $1 billion in munitions alone – not counting the billions in operational costs for ship deployments, aircraft sorties, intelligence operations, and logistics. The total bill exceeded $4.5 billion.
More dangerously, the campaign depleted SM-2 and SM-6 missile stocks faster than the US could produce them. These interceptors were designed and stockpiled for potential great-power conflicts with China or Russia – not for shooting down $2,000 drones over the Red Sea. Every missile fired at a Houthi drone was one fewer missile available for the defense of Taiwan or NATO allies.
Despite zero US combat deaths, there were multiple close calls that could have resulted in mass casualties. The Gravely intercept at under one mile, multiple instances of drones passing within hundreds of yards of warships, and the sheer volume of Houthi attacks created a statistical near-certainty of an eventual hit. Naval analysts noted that the campaign represented the first time since WWII that US Navy surface combatants faced sustained anti-ship missile threats.
The ceasefire reached in May 2025 was largely on Houthi terms. They retained their attack capability, their leadership was intact, and they had successfully demonstrated that a rebel group armed with cheap weapons could hold global trade hostage and force the world’s most powerful navy into a prolonged, expensive, and ultimately inconclusive defensive campaign. The Houthis declared victory – and it was hard to argue they were wrong.”
Lebanon: America’s Proxy Front (2023-Present)
2023–Present (3 years)
🌍 Middle East ·Lebanon, Israel
0
📅 1,095 days of conflict
US-funded Israeli military operations in Lebanon from October 2023 cross-border fighting through the 2024 invasion and into the 2026 resumption. Part of $21.7B+ in US military aid to Israel since October 7, 2023 (Brown University Costs of War). The World Bank’s 2025 RDNA report estimated $14 billion in damage to Lebanon – $6.8B physical destruction + $7.2B economic losses. Lebanon was already in economic collapse before the war began.
“The Full Story
How this conflict unfolded
The story of American entanglement in Lebanon stretches back decades before the current conflict – and every chapter has ended in blood, failure, or both. Understanding the 2023-present catastrophe requires understanding the history that produced it.
**1983: The Beirut Barracks Bombing**
America’s first modern trauma in Lebanon came on October 23, 1983, when a truck bomb destroyed the US Marine barracks at Beirut International Airport, killing 241 American servicemembers – 220 Marines, 18 sailors, and 3 soldiers. It was the deadliest single-day death toll for the Marine Corps since Iwo Jima. The Marines had been deployed as part of a multinational peacekeeping force during the Lebanese Civil War, a conflict fueled by sectarian divisions, Palestinian militant presence, and Syrian and Israeli interventions. The bombing, attributed to the nascent Hezbollah with Iranian backing, prompted President Reagan to withdraw US forces – a decision that Osama bin Laden would later cite as evidence that America could be driven from the Middle East through spectacular violence. The 241 families who lost loved ones received no justice; no one was ever held meaningfully accountable.
**Hezbollah: America’s Self-Created Nemesis**
Hezbollah – the “Party of God” – was born directly from Israel’s 1982 invasion and occupation of Lebanon, which the United States supported and armed. Iran’s Revolutionary Guard helped organize, train, and fund the Shia militia that would grow into the most powerful non-state military force in the world. For four decades, the US designated Hezbollah a terrorist organization while simultaneously pursuing policies that strengthened it: the 1982 invasion created it, the 2003 Iraq War empowered Iran (its patron), and the 2006 Lebanon War turned Nasrallah into a folk hero across the Arab world. Every American intervention in the region that strengthened Iran indirectly strengthened Hezbollah.
**2006: Israel’s $1.6 Billion Lesson**
The 2006 Lebanon War – 34 days of devastating Israeli bombardment following a Hezbollah cross-border raid – was a preview of everything that would follow. Israel dropped an estimated 7,000 bombs on Lebanon, destroying bridges, power plants, and entire neighborhoods of Beirut’s southern suburbs. Over 1,191 Lebanese were killed (the vast majority civilians), 4,409 injured, and 1 million displaced – one quarter of Lebanon’s population. The US provided Israel with precision-guided munitions during the conflict and blocked UN ceasefire resolutions for weeks, allowing the bombardment to continue. The war cost Israel approximately $1.6 billion in direct military expenditure, plus billions in economic disruption. But the strategic result was a Hezbollah victory: the militia survived, rebuilt, and emerged with vastly greater political legitimacy and public support. UN Security Council Resolution 1701, which ended the fighting, was supposed to disarm Hezbollah south of the Litani River. It never happened. Hezbollah rearmed to an estimated 150,000 rockets and missiles by 2023 – ten times its 2006 arsenal.
**2020: The Beirut Explosion and Lebanon’s Collapse**
On August 4, 2020, 2,750 tons of improperly stored ammonium nitrate exploded at the Port of Beirut, killing 218 people, injuring 7,000, leaving 300,000 homeless, and causing $15 billion in damage. The explosion – one of the largest non-nuclear blasts in history – devastated half the capital and became a symbol of the corruption, negligence, and state failure that defined modern Lebanon. The ruling elite, including Hezbollah-allied politicians, blocked investigations into the blast. By 2023, Lebanon was already a failed state: the currency had lost 90% of its value, banks had frozen deposits (wiping out the middle class), GDP had contracted by 58% from 2019 levels, and basic services including electricity, water, and healthcare had collapsed. Into this catastrophe, war arrived.
**October 2023: The Solidarity Front Opens**
Hours after the October 7, 2023 Hamas attack on Israel, Hezbollah began launching rockets and anti-tank missiles at Israeli positions along the Blue Line border. Hezbollah Secretary-General Hassan Nasrallah called it a “solidarity front” with Gaza – a calibrated escalation designed to pin down Israeli forces without triggering a full-scale war. Through late 2023 and most of 2024, the border zone became a grinding battlefield: daily exchanges of fire displaced approximately 60,000 Israelis from northern communities and over 100,000 Lebanese from southern villages. The tit-for-tat escalated steadily – Israeli strikes gradually moved deeper into Lebanon while Hezbollah launched increasingly sophisticated drones and precision munitions.
**September 2024: The Pager Bombings and Nasrallah’s Assassination**
On September 17-18, 2024, Israel executed one of the most audacious and controversial intelligence operations in modern history: the simultaneous detonation of thousands of pagers and walkie-talkies used by Hezbollah operatives across Lebanon. The devices – intercepted and rigged with PETN explosive during manufacturing – detonated in homes, shops, hospitals, and on streets. Forty-two people were killed and over 3,500 injured, many of them civilians who were merely standing near a Hezbollah member when the device exploded. Children were killed. Medical workers lost hands and eyes. The operation, while tactically brilliant, raised profound questions about the laws of war: is it legal to turn civilian communication devices into anti-personnel weapons that detonate indiscriminately in civilian spaces?
Nine days later, on September 27, 2024, Israel assassinated Hassan Nasrallah in a massive airstrike that dropped over 80 bunker-buster bombs on Beirut’s Dahiyeh suburbs, leveling an entire city block and killing an unknown number of civilians alongside the Hezbollah leader. Nasrallah had led the organization for 32 years. His death decapitated Hezbollah’s leadership but also eliminated the one person who had maintained a calibrated restraint on the organization’s actions.
**October 2024: The Ground Invasion**
On October 1, 2024, Israeli ground forces crossed into southern Lebanon – the first ground invasion since 2006. What followed was devastating: white phosphorus deployed on residential areas, UNIFIL peacekeeping positions attacked (injuring UN peacekeepers from multiple nations), seven or more journalists killed covering the conflict, and entire villages in south Lebanon systematically destroyed. By the November 27, 2024 ceasefire, 1.2 million Lebanese had been displaced – in a country of 5.5 million that was already hosting 1.5 million Syrian refugees, the most refugees per capita of any nation on Earth. The death toll reached 4,047 killed and 16,638 injured in Lebanon.
**American Funding: The $15 Billion+ Pipeline**
Every phase of this destruction was enabled by American money. The United States has provided Israel with $15 billion or more in military aid directly relevant to the Lebanon front since October 2023, as part of the $21.7 billion total (Brown University Costs of War estimate). The $8.7 billion supplemental approved by Congress in April 2024 funded Iron Dome interceptors (at $40,000-$50,000 each), David’s Sling missiles, precision-guided munitions, and the very bunker-buster bombs that killed Nasrallah. The US provided real-time intelligence sharing, diplomatic cover at the UN Security Council (vetoing ceasefire resolutions), and the political legitimacy that allowed Israel to conduct operations that killed over 4,000 people in a country that posed no direct threat to American security.
**The $14 Billion Bill**
The World Bank’s 2025 Rapid Damage and Needs Assessment documented $14 billion in total damage to Lebanon – $6.8 billion in physical destruction of infrastructure, housing, agriculture, and industry, plus $7.2 billion in economic losses from tourism collapse, trade disruption, and displacement costs. This was inflicted on a country with a GDP of just $18 billion – meaning the war destroyed the equivalent of 78% of Lebanon’s entire annual economic output. Combined with the pre-existing economic collapse, the damage may have set Lebanon back not years but decades.
**2025-2026: Ceasefire Violations and Resumption**
The November 2024 ceasefire was violated by Israel almost daily – reconnaissance flights, ground incursions into southern Lebanon, targeted assassinations, and the continued occupation of Lebanese territory. For 15 months, the international community watched Israel systematically hollow out the agreement. When the broader Iran war erupted in late February 2026, Hezbollah launched retaliatory strikes on Israel, citing both the assassination of Khamenei and the 15 months of daily ceasefire violations.
The Lebanese government made extraordinary efforts to stay out of the wider conflict: banning Hezbollah military activities, arresting 12 members, expelling 150+ Iranian nationals. It didn’t matter. Israel struck anyway. The 2026 phase brought renewed horror: a strike on Nabi Chit killed 41 people while reportedly searching for remains of Ron Arad, an Israeli pilot missing since 1986. A Ramada hotel in Beirut was destroyed, killing 5 IRGC Quds Force commanders. Cluster munitions – banned by 111 countries – were used. White phosphorus was deployed on the village of Yohmor. Three UNIFIL peacekeepers were injured. Father Pierre al-Rahi, a Maronite Christian priest, was killed in a double-tap strike. The toll of the 2026 phase alone: 634 killed, 1,586 injured, 816,000 displaced.
**Civilian Displacement: A Nation Uprooted**
The cumulative displacement is staggering. In the 2024 phase, 1.2 million Lebanese were forced from their homes. In the 2026 resumption, another 816,000 fled. In a country of 5.5 million people already hosting 1.5 million Syrian refugees, these numbers represent a humanitarian catastrophe of the first order. Schools became shelters. Hospitals were overwhelmed. Families who had fled south Lebanon moved to Beirut, only to find Beirut itself under bombardment. Some crossed into Syria – refugees fleeing into a country that had produced its own refugee crisis.
**The Historical Pattern**
The 1983 barracks bombing killed 241 Americans. The 2006 war killed 1,191 Lebanese with American weapons. The 2023-2026 campaign has killed nearly 5,000 Lebanese with American weapons and American money. Each iteration is more destructive, more expensive, and less strategically coherent than the last. Lebanon has never threatened the United States. It has never attacked American territory. It has never possessed the capability to harm American interests beyond the troops America chose to place in harm’s way. Yet American taxpayers have spent tens of billions arming the forces that have repeatedly devastated this small Mediterranean country of 5.5 million people – a country whose cedar tree appears on its flag as a symbol of peace.”
Yemen War (Saudi Support)
2015–2026 (11 years)
🌍 Middle East ·Yemen, Houthi rebels
👥 500 troops deployed
📅 3,650 days of conflict
The Yemen War (2015-present) represents the most consequential and least understood American military involvement of the 21st century. Since March 2015, the United States has served as the primary enabler of a Saudi Arabian-led coalition bombing campaign that has killed an estimated 377,000 people – 60% from indirect causes including famine, disease, and lack of medical care – and created what the United Nations has called the world’s worst humanitarian crisis. American involvement includes 4.6 billion in arms sales to Saudi Arabia and the UAE, mid-air refueling of Saudi bombers (until November 2018), sharing of targeting intelligence, maintenance of Saudi aircraft, naval support for the coalition’s blockade, and diplomatic cover at the United Nations Security Council. U.S.-manufactured bombs and aircraft have been documented striking hospitals, schools, weddings, funerals, water treatment facilities, and a school bus carrying 40 children. Despite bipartisan congressional opposition – including passage of a War Powers Resolution to end U.S. involvement that was vetoed by President Trump – American support has continued through four presidential administrations (Obama, Trump, Biden, and Trump again). The war has no congressional authorization, serves no vital American national security interest, and has demonstrably violated U.S. laws prohibiting arms transfers to countries that systematically target civilians.
“The Full Story
How this conflict unfolded
The Yemen war is the definitive case study in how the United States enables catastrophic violence while maintaining the fiction of non-involvement. For nearly a decade, American-manufactured weapons dropped from American-built aircraft, guided by American intelligence, refueled by American tankers, and maintained by American contractors have killed tens of thousands of Yemeni civilians and created the worst humanitarian crisis on earth. Yet the war is barely known to the American public, has never been authorized by Congress, and continues through multiple administrations of both parties.
The war’s origins lie in Yemen’s failed political transition after the 2011 Arab Spring. When the Houthi movement, a Zaidi Shia revivalist group from northern Yemen, seized the capital Sana’a in September 2014 in alliance with forces loyal to former President Ali Abdullah Saleh, Saudi Arabia viewed it as an intolerable expansion of Iranian influence on its southern border. On March 26, 2015, Saudi Deputy Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman – 29 years old, with no military experience – launched Operation Decisive Storm, projecting a campaign lasting “a few weeks.”
The Obama administration immediately signed on as the Saudi coalition’s indispensable partner. Within days, the Pentagon established a joint planning cell at Saudi Arabia’s air operations center in Riyadh, embedding American military personnel who assisted with target selection and intelligence. U.S. Air Force tankers began refueling Saudi F-15s before bombing missions. American-manufactured precision-guided munitions, cluster bombs, and general-purpose bombs flowed to Saudi Arabia through expedited arms sales. The State Department approved billions in weapons transfers with minimal scrutiny.
The decision to support the Saudi war was made without public debate, congressional authorization, or strategic justification. Yemen poses no threat to the United States. The Houthis, while receiving some Iranian support, are not an Iranian proxy in any meaningful sense – they are a Yemeni movement with Yemeni grievances. The primary U.S. motivation was maintaining the Saudi relationship and the massive arms sales that sustain it. Between 2015 and 2024, U.S. arms sales to Saudi Arabia totaled approximately 4.6 billion – a revenue stream that creates powerful corporate and bureaucratic constituencies for continued support regardless of humanitarian consequences.
The human cost has been beyond anything the euphemistic language of “supporting our allies” can capture. The Saudi coalition’s air campaign has systematically struck civilian infrastructure: hospitals, schools, water treatment plants, sewage facilities, bridges, power stations, food storage, and ports. These are not collateral damage from strikes on military targets – multiple investigations by the UN, Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, and journalists have documented a pattern of deliberate or recklessly indiscriminate targeting of civilian facilities.
The individual atrocities are numbing in their frequency and horror. In October 2016, coalition aircraft conducted a double-tap strike on a funeral in Sana’a, killing 140 mourners and wounding 500. In August 2018, a coalition bomb hit a school bus in Dahyan, killing 40 children – the bomb was identified as a U.S.-manufactured MK 82 made by Lockheed Martin, sold through a State Department-approved deal. MSF-supported hospitals were struck at least five times despite the coalition having GPS coordinates for every facility. Wedding parties, markets, residential neighborhoods – the bombing has been relentless and indiscriminate.
The blockade has been even more lethal than the bombing. Yemen imports 90% of its food, and the Saudi-led coalition’s naval and air blockade has systematically restricted imports through the port of Hodeidah, through which 70% of Yemen’s supplies flow. The result is the world’s worst famine: an estimated 85,000 children under five died of starvation between 2015 and 2018 alone. The destruction of water infrastructure triggered the largest cholera epidemic in recorded history – over 2.5 million cases. The UN estimates that 377,000 people had died by the end of 2021, with 60% of deaths from indirect causes: starvation, disease, and the collapse of the healthcare system.
The Khashoggi murder in October 2018 briefly pierced the wall of American indifference. The Saudi regime’s assassination and dismemberment of Washington Post columnist Jamal Khashoggi inside the Saudi consulate in Istanbul – personally ordered by MBS according to U.S. intelligence – forced a reckoning with the character of the ally the U.S. was arming. But the reckoning was short-lived: the Trump administration declined to impose meaningful consequences, and arms sales continued.
Congress, to its credit, attempted to assert its constitutional authority. In March 2019, both chambers passed a War Powers Resolution directing the president to withdraw U.S. forces from the Yemen conflict – the first successful invocation of the War Powers Act since its passage in 1973. Trump vetoed the resolution. Congress failed to override. The episode demonstrated the constitutional impotence of the legislative branch in matters of war: even bipartisan majorities cannot halt presidential war-making when the executive is determined to continue.
Biden’s February 2021 pledge to end U.S. support for “offensive operations” in Yemen was carefully crafted to change the rhetoric while preserving the substance of American involvement. The U.S. stopped providing aerial refueling (which had actually ended under Trump in 2018) and suspended some precision-guided munition sales. But intelligence sharing continued. Aircraft maintenance and spare parts contracts continued. “Defensive” arms sales – including the systems that enable the bombing campaign – continued. The distinction between “offensive” and “defensive” support is a legal fiction: you cannot separate the bullets from the gun.
The war’s strategic futility is now undeniable. Nearly a decade of bombing, at a cost of hundreds of billions to the Saudi treasury, has achieved nothing. The Houthis control more territory and possess more military capability than when the war began. Their 2023-2024 attacks on Red Sea shipping demonstrated the ability to project force across an entire region – something they could not do in 2015. The U.S. and UK are now bombing Yemen directly, having created the conditions for the very threat they claim to be addressing.
The 4.6 billion in U.S. arms sales that fueled the war dwarfs the humanitarian aid provided to address the catastrophe those weapons created. Lockheed Martin, Raytheon, Boeing, and General Dynamics have profited enormously from the conflict. The Saudi relationship – built on petrodollars, arms sales, and geopolitical convenience – has proven more valuable to American policymakers than the lives of Yemeni children.
Yemen reveals the structural incentives that make American war-making so difficult to stop. The arms industry profits from weapons sales. The executive branch values the Saudi alliance. The military provides support as a matter of institutional routine. Congressional opposition is structurally insufficient to overcome a presidential veto. The American public is largely unaware of the war and its consequences. Each element of the system has its own logic; together they produce a machine that enables mass killing with no mechanism for accountability or restraint.
The 377,000 dead, the 85,000 starved children, the 2.5 million cholera cases, the generation of traumatized and malnourished survivors – these are not the unintended consequences of American policy. They are the predictable and predicted results of a deliberate decision to arm and support a military campaign against one of the poorest countries on earth, made by officials who understood exactly what would happen and chose to proceed because the Saudi relationship was deemed more important than Yemeni lives. That is not a failure of policy. It is the policy working as designed.”
Somalia (AFRICOM Operations)
2007–Present(19 years)
🌍 Africa ·Somalia
👥 900 troops deployed
📅 6,935 days of conflict
Ongoing U.S. military operations against al-Shabaab and ISIS-Somalia since 2007, conducted primarily through AFRICOM drone strikes, special operations raids, and ‘advise and assist’ missions. The U.S. has conducted over 280 airstrikes in Somalia since 2007, killing thousands of militants and an unknown number of civilians. Approximately 900 U.S. troops rotate through Somali bases including Baledogle Airfield and compounds in Mogadishu. Five U.S. service members and three U.S. military contractors have been killed. The campaign has oscillated wildly between escalation and withdrawal – Trump dramatically increased strikes then withdrew troops; Biden redeployed them. Al-Shabaab remains the most powerful militant group in Africa, controlling significant territory and conducting devastating attacks, despite nearly two decades of U.S. military operations.
“The Full Story
How this conflict unfolded
The United States never really left Somalia. After the humiliating 1994 withdrawal following the ‘Black Hawk Down’ disaster that killed 18 American soldiers, U.S. forces quietly returned in the 2000s under the banner of the Global War on Terror. What began as occasional airstrikes against suspected al-Qaeda operatives has metastasized into a nearly two-decade military campaign that has survived four presidential administrations, produced no strategic victory, and demonstrates the self-perpetuating logic of the ‘forever war’ better than perhaps any other U.S. military operation.
THE ORIGINS: BLOWBACK FROM BLOWBACK
The current Somalia campaign is rooted in a cascade of unintended consequences. In 2006, the Islamic Courts Union (ICU) – a coalition of sharia courts – seized control of Mogadishu and much of southern Somalia, bringing the first semblance of order to the country since the 1991 collapse of the Siad Barre government. The ICU was hardly a progressive force, but it reopened the Mogadishu airport and seaport, cleared checkpoints, and reduced piracy – accomplishments that 15 years of international intervention had failed to achieve.
The Bush administration, viewing any Islamist governance through the post-9/11 lens, backed an Ethiopian invasion in December 2006 to oust the ICU. The intervention succeeded militarily – Ethiopian forces captured Mogadishu within weeks – but the political consequences were catastrophic. The ICU’s radical youth wing, al-Shabaab (Arabic for ‘The Youth’), broke away and launched a ferocious insurgency against the Ethiopian occupation and the internationally backed Transitional Federal Government.
Al-Shabaab’s rise was textbook blowback: U.S.-supported military intervention radicalized a population, destroyed a flawed but functional governance structure, and created the exact security vacuum that enabled an extremist group to thrive. The group grew from a few hundred fighters in 2007 to an estimated 5,000-9,000 by 2010, fueled by anger at the Ethiopian occupation, clan grievances, and al-Shabaab’s ability to provide rough justice and social services in areas under its control.
THE DRONE WAR: ESCALATION WITHOUT STRATEGY
U.S. airstrikes in Somalia began in January 2007 with AC-130 gunship attacks on suspected al-Qaeda operatives. The strikes – conducted without congressional authorization, public debate, or even widespread public knowledge – established the template for the next 19 years: classified operations, disputed casualty counts, and a target list that grew year after year without ever producing decisive results.
The Obama administration treated Somalia as a laboratory for the ‘light footprint’ counterterrorism model – small numbers of special operations forces, drone strikes, and support for local partner forces (primarily the African Union’s AMISOM mission). Obama authorized approximately 36 airstrikes in Somalia over eight years, killing several al-Shabaab leaders including Ahmed Abdi Godane in 2014. But each leadership decapitation was followed by rapid replacement, and the group’s overall capability was barely dented.
The Trump administration dramatically escalated the air campaign, treating Somalia as a free-fire zone. Trump designated Somalia an ‘area of active hostilities’ in March 2017, loosening the rules of engagement and giving field commanders authority to order strikes without White House approval. The results were immediate: 35 strikes in 2017, 47 in 2018, 63 in 2019 – more in three years than Obama conducted in eight. Trump conducted more airstrikes in Somalia than in any other country during his first term.
The escalation produced no strategic breakthrough. Al-Shabaab lost some urban territory to AMISOM offensives but retained control of vast rural areas, continued its bombing campaign, and demonstrated its resilience with devastating attacks including the 2017 Mogadishu truck bombing that killed 587 people – one of the deadliest terrorist attacks in history.
THE MOGADISHU TRUCK BOMBING: THE ATTACK NOBODY NOTICED
On October 14, 2017, al-Shabaab detonated a massive truck bomb at the K5 intersection in Mogadishu, killing 587 people and wounding over 300 – more than the 2004 Madrid bombings, the 2005 London bombings, and the Bataclan attack combined. Entire buildings collapsed. Bodies were carbonized beyond recognition. The blast crater was over 50 feet wide.
The attack received minimal Western media coverage. No world leaders changed their social media profile pictures. No hashtags trended. No buildings were illuminated in Somali colors. The disparity in attention between terrorism in Western capitals and terrorism in African cities revealed the implicit hierarchy of human suffering that undergirds the War on Terror: some victims matter; others don’t.
The attack also undermined the central premise of the U.S. campaign – that airstrikes were degrading al-Shabaab’s capability. The group that the U.S. had been bombing for a decade carried out one of the deadliest terrorist attacks in modern history, demonstrating that air campaigns alone cannot defeat a deeply rooted insurgency.
U.S. BASES AND COMPOUNDS
The U.S. military presence in Somalia operates from several key installations. Baledogle Airfield, located 90 kilometers northwest of Mogadishu, serves as the primary base for drone operations and special forces staging. The facility has been significantly expanded with American investment, including runway improvements, aircraft hangars, and living facilities for rotating forces.
In Mogadishu, U.S. personnel operate from fortified compounds near the international airport, co-located with AMISOM headquarters and the Somali government’s Villa Somalia complex. Additional U.S. presence exists at forward operating locations across south-central Somalia, though the exact locations and numbers remain classified.
Camp Lemonnier in Djibouti – 800 miles north – provides strategic support, serving as the hub for MQ-9 Reaper drone flights that transit to Somali airspace. The drone flights require overflight permission from Ethiopia, which has occasionally been complicated by regional politics.
AMERICAN CASUALTIES: THE COST OF A ‘LOW-FOOTPRINT’ WAR
The U.S. has suffered at least 8 fatalities in Somalia operations since 2007:
– Staff Sergeant Alexander Conrad, killed by al-Shabaab mortar fire in the Jubaland region on June 8, 2018 – the first U.S. combat death publicly acknowledged in Somalia since 1993. – Specialist Henry Mayfield Jr. (U.S. Army), killed in the January 5, 2020 al-Shabaab attack on Manda Bay Airfield in Kenya. – Two U.S. military contractors (Department of Defense civilians) also killed in the Manda Bay attack. – Additional casualties in classified operations that have not been publicly attributed.
The Manda Bay attack was particularly significant because it struck a facility used by U.S. forces in Kenya – demonstrating that al-Shabaab could target American personnel across borders and that the ‘commuter’ model of remote operations offered no safety advantage.
THE WITHDRAWAL-REDEPLOYMENT CYCLE
Trump’s December 2020 order to withdraw approximately 700 troops from Somalia was presented as fulfilling his promise to end ‘forever wars.’ In reality, the troops simply relocated to Kenya and Djibouti, continuing operations through ‘commuter’ deployments – flying into Somalia for specific missions and then returning. Airstrikes continued at roughly the same pace. AFRICOM publicly described the arrangement as ‘inefficient and unsustainable.’
Biden reversed the withdrawal in May 2022, redeploying approximately 500 troops to Somalia and authorizing the Pentagon to target al-Shabaab leaders – essentially restoring the status quo ante. The withdrawal and redeployment accomplished nothing except demonstrating the bipartisan consensus on perpetual military engagement: the details change, the mission continues.
AL-SHABAAB: AN ENEMY THAT GROWS DESPITE BEING BOMBED
Al-Shabaab’s resilience defies the logic of military attrition. Despite 280+ U.S. airstrikes, dozens of special operations raids, and leadership decapitation strikes, the group in 2024 remains Africa’s most powerful and well-funded militant organization. Key factors explain this resilience:
Revenue: Al-Shabaab generates an estimated $100-180 million annually through a sophisticated ‘taxation’ system – extorting businesses, taxing agriculture, controlling charcoal exports, and levying fees on livestock and imports. This revenue exceeds the Somali government’s domestic revenue, giving al-Shabaab a financial advantage that no amount of airstrikes can address.
Governance: In areas under its control, al-Shabaab provides courts (applying sharia law but perceived as less corrupt than government courts), conflict resolution, and basic services. Many Somalis, while not ideologically aligned with al-Shabaab, prefer its governance to the corrupt, clan-based politics of the internationally backed government.
Recruitment: Each U.S. airstrike that kills civilians becomes a recruitment tool. Al-Shabaab’s narrative – that foreign powers are bombing Somalia – resonates in communities where people have experienced drone strikes firsthand. The group draws from a population where 70% of people are under 30, unemployment exceeds 60%, and legitimate economic opportunities are virtually nonexistent.
Clan dynamics: Somalia’s clan system provides al-Shabaab with a recruitment base and protection network that outsiders cannot penetrate. The group has embedded itself in clan structures, making it impossible to eliminate through military means alone.
THE CIVILIAN TOLL
Civilian casualties from U.S. operations in Somalia are poorly documented and almost certainly significantly underreported. AFRICOM claims that its strikes are ‘precision’ operations with minimal civilian harm. Independent monitors – Airwars, Amnesty International, and the Bureau of Investigative Journalism – consistently report higher civilian death tolls.
Amnesty International’s 2019 report ‘The Hidden US War in Somalia’ documented 14 strikes that killed at least 17 civilians (five of them children), concluding that some strikes may constitute war crimes. The report found that the U.S. military’s assessment process was fundamentally flawed – relying on post-strike intelligence that was often incomplete, biased, or deliberately minimized.
The psychological impact of drone warfare on Somali civilians extends far beyond the direct casualties. Communities living under drone surveillance – hearing the constant buzz of Reapers overhead – report pervasive anxiety, sleep disorders, and behavioral changes. The fear of strikes disrupts markets, schools, and social gatherings, effectively punishing entire populations for the actions of militant groups over which they have no control.
THE LIBERTARIAN ANALYSIS
The Somalia campaign is the perfect illustration of the GWOT’s self-perpetuating logic:
1. U.S. intervention destabilizes a country (backing the 2006 Ethiopian invasion) 2. Destabilization creates an extremist group (al-Shabaab emerges from the ruins of the ICU)
3. The extremist group is used to justify more intervention (airstrikes, special operations)
4. Intervention creates civilian casualties that fuel recruitment for the extremist group
5. The strengthened extremist group justifies further escalation
6. Return to step 3
This cycle has operated continuously since 2007 with no strategic endgame. The 2001 AUMF – written to target those responsible for 9/11 – now justifies strikes in a country that had nothing to do with 9/11, against a group that didn’t exist on 9/11, in a war that most Americans don’t know is happening. The approximately $5 billion spent on Somalia operations since 2007 has produced no measurable progress toward defeating al-Shabaab, while the group’s revenue, territory, and attack capability remain formidable. This is not a war America is winning slowly – it is a war that has no definition of winning.”
War Against ISIS
2014–Present(12 years)
🌍 Middle East ·Iraq, Syria
👥 5,000 troops deployed
📅 4,380 days of conflict
Operation Inherent Resolve – US-led coalition against ISIS/ISIL after they captured Mosul and declared a “caliphate.” Over 34,000 airstrikes. ISIS territorial caliphate defeated by 2019 but insurgency continues. 2,500 US troops remain in Iraq and 900 in Syria as of 2026.
“The Full Story
How this conflict unfolded
The war against ISIS (2014-present) is the ultimate story of American foreign policy blowback – the U.S. created the conditions for the Islamic State through the catastrophic 2003 Iraq invasion, then spent $115 billion and five years destroying the monster it had birthed, only to see ISIS evolve into a global insurgency that continues to claim lives worldwide.
ISIS emerged from the ashes of al-Qaeda in Iraq, founded by Abu Musab al-Zarqawi in 2004. But the group’s transformation into a proto-state began with Obama’s Syrian intervention and the collapse of Iraqi governance under Nouri al-Maliki. When Paul Bremer disbanded the Iraqi military in 2003, he created 400,000 unemployed soldiers with military training, weapons expertise, and burning grievances against the United States. Many became the military backbone of ISIS – particularly after Maliki’s sectarian government systematically purged Sunni officers and politicians from 2006-2014.
ISIS burst onto the global stage in June 2014 with a shock offensive that captured Mosul, Iraq’s second-largest city, with just 1,500 fighters routing 30,000 Iraqi soldiers. The Iraqi army – built over 11 years at a cost of $25 billion in U.S. training and equipment – dissolved in 72 hours. Soldiers abandoned uniforms, weapons, and vehicles in the streets, fleeing in their underwear. ISIS captured $429 million from Mosul’s banks, thousands of vehicles, and enough heavy weapons to equip a conventional army.
On June 29, 2014, ISIS declared a ‘caliphate’ stretching from eastern Syria to western Iraq – an area the size of Great Britain controlling 8 million people. Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, the self-proclaimed caliph, imposed a regime of medieval savagery: public beheadings, mass executions, crucifixions, sex slavery, forced conversions, and the systematic destruction of ancient cultural heritage. ISIS militants used sledgehammers and explosives to destroy 2,000-year-old artifacts in Palmyra, bulldozed the ancient city of Nimrud, and blew up the tomb of the prophet Jonah in Mosul.
ISIS perfected the art of terror as propaganda. The group’s slickly produced execution videos – featuring the beheadings of American journalists James Foley, Steven Sotloff, and aid workers Peter Kassig and Kayla Mueller – shocked the world and forced Obama’s hand. The sight of orange-clad prisoners being burned alive in cages, thrown from buildings, or drowned in swimming pools was designed to terrorize enemies and recruit followers. It worked: ISIS attracted 40,000 foreign fighters from 110 countries, more than any jihadist group in history.
The U.S. response, Operation Inherent Resolve, began with humanitarian airdrops to trapped Yazidis on Mount Sinjar in August 2014. But the campaign quickly escalated into the largest U.S. military operation since the Iraq War. Over 34,000 Coalition airstrikes were conducted against ISIS targets across Iraq and Syria from 2014-2019, supported by 5,000 U.S. troops, Kurdish Peshmerga forces, Iraqi security forces, and Syrian Democratic Forces.
The battle for Mosul (October 2016 – July 2017) epitomized the campaign’s brutal arithmetic. Iraqi forces, supported by U.S. airpower and special operations advisers, fought a nine-month urban battle that reduced much of the city to rubble. An estimated 9,000-11,000 civilians died in the fighting – more than the total number of ISIS fighters in the city. Entire neighborhoods were flattened by Coalition airstrikes and Iraqi artillery. By the time Mosul was ‘liberated,’ it looked like Stalingrad after the Nazis.
The destruction of Raqqa was even more complete. The Syrian Democratic Forces, backed by 4,000 U.S. airstrikes, systematically demolished ISIS’s de facto capital. The city was 80% destroyed, with civilian casualties in the thousands. Coalition forces fired 35,000 artillery rounds and dropped 20,000 tons of explosives on a city of 200,000 people. Raqqa was ‘saved’ by being annihilated.
The human cost of the anti-ISIS campaign is staggering and poorly documented. Airwars, an independent monitoring group, estimates that Coalition strikes killed between 8,000 and 13,000 civilians in Iraq and Syria. The Pentagon acknowledges only 1,400 civilian deaths – a ten-fold discrepancy that reveals either systematic undercounting or willful blindness. Iraqi government forces, Kurdish militias, and Syrian groups supported by the U.S. killed thousands more civilians in ground operations.
By March 2019, ISIS had lost its last territorial stronghold at Baghuz, Syria. The caliphate was destroyed, al-Baghdadi was killed in a U.S. special operations raid, and the group’s territorial ambitions were crushed. But ISIS didn’t disappear – it evolved. The group now operates as a decentralized insurgency across Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan, the Philippines, West Africa, and the Sahel. ISIS-affiliated attacks in Iraq alone killed over 1,000 people in 2023.
The libertarian analysis is devastating: the United States spent $2 trillion destroying the Iraqi state in 2003, creating the conditions for ISIS to emerge. It then spent $115 billion more destroying ISIS’s territorial caliphate, killing thousands of additional civilians in the process. ISIS still exists as a global insurgency, Syrian and Iraqi cities lie in ruins, millions remain displaced, and 3,400 U.S. troops remain indefinitely deployed across Iraq and Syria with no exit strategy. This is the ultimate expression of the military-industrial complex: the U.S. government created a problem, spent vast sums ‘solving’ it, and then maintained a permanent military presence to ‘manage’ the consequences. The war against ISIS proves that American military intervention creates more problems than it solves.”
The Global Drone Campaign (2004-present) represents the most significant transformation in American warfare since the nuclear bomb: the development of a permanent, worldwide apparatus for extrajudicial killing by remote control. Operating across at least seven countries – Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, and Libya – the United States has conducted over 14,000 drone strikes since 2004, killing an estimated 8,858-16,901 people including 910-2,200 civilians and 283-454 children (Bureau of Investigative Journalism estimates). The program, conducted jointly by the CIA and the Pentagon’s Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC), operates under the legal authority of the 2001 Authorization for Use of Military Force – a 60-word resolution passed to authorize action against the perpetrators of 9/11, now stretched to cover killings in countries the U.S. has never declared war on, against organizations that did not exist on September 11, 2001. The campaign has included the deliberate killing of American citizens without trial, the use of “signature strikes” targeting unidentified individuals based on behavioral patterns, and the systematic undercounting of civilian casualties through the classification of all military-age males in strike zones as combatants. Zero American military personnel have been killed in drone operations, making it warfare without political cost – and therefore warfare without democratic accountability.
“The Full Story
How this conflict unfolded
The Global Drone Campaign is the most morally consequential military program in American history since the atomic bomb – not because of the scale of killing, which is modest by the standards of America’s major wars, but because of what it represents: the routinization of extrajudicial execution as a permanent instrument of state policy, operated without meaningful oversight, accountability, or democratic consent.
The program began almost accidentally. In the aftermath of 9/11, the CIA armed Predator surveillance drones with Hellfire missiles, creating a weapon that could find, track, and kill a human being from the other side of the world with the press of a button. The first successful strike killed al-Qaeda commander Mohammed Atef in Afghanistan in November 2001. By 2004, the CIA was conducting strikes in Pakistan’s tribal areas. By 2009, the program had expanded to Yemen and Somalia. By 2020, a drone was used to assassinate a senior military official of a sovereign nation – Iranian General Qasem Soleimani – at a civilian airport.
The evolution from targeted killing of identified al-Qaeda leaders to the routine execution of unidentified individuals based on behavioral patterns occurred gradually, without public debate, congressional authorization, or judicial review. The two most consequential innovations were “signature strikes” and the redefinition of “combatant.”
Signature strikes, introduced around 2008, authorized the killing of people whose identities were unknown but whose behavior, observed through drone cameras from thousands of miles away, fit patterns that analysts associated with militant activity. Loading a vehicle, traveling in a convoy, gathering in a group – these “signatures” could trigger a Hellfire missile. The people being killed were frequently unknown to their killers. In one five-month period in Afghanistan (Operation Haymaker), 90% of those killed were not the intended targets.
The redefinition of “combatant” was even more insidious. The Obama administration adopted a policy of counting all military-age males (roughly 16-65) killed in a strike zone as combatants unless posthumous evidence specifically proved otherwise. Since the dead cannot protest their innocence and investigations in remote tribal areas are nearly impossible, this classification method effectively guaranteed that civilian casualties would be systematically undercounted. Official U.S. government casualty figures were, by design, fiction.
The Pakistan campaign was the most intensive theater of drone warfare. Between 2004 and 2018, the CIA conducted approximately 430 strikes in Pakistan’s Federally Administered Tribal Areas, primarily in North and South Waziristan. The Bureau of Investigative Journalism estimates these strikes killed between 2,515 and 4,026 people, including 424-969 civilians and 172-207 children. The strikes peaked under Obama, averaging one every three days in 2010.
The human cost in Pakistan’s tribal areas was devastating beyond the raw casualty numbers. Stanford and NYU’s “Living Under Drones” report (2012) documented the psychological terrorism inflicted on civilian populations who lived under the constant buzz of surveillance drones. Children were afraid to go to school. Families were afraid to attend funerals (which were targeted by “double-tap” strikes). Communities were afraid to gather for tribal meetings (jirgas) – a March 2011 strike on a jirga in Datta Khel killed 42 tribal elders meeting to resolve a mining dispute. The report concluded that drones had created “a pervasive atmosphere of fear and anxiety” among civilians who had no connection to militancy.
The Yemen campaign, conducted by both the CIA and JSOC, targeted al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) and later the Houthi movement. Between 2002 and 2023, the U.S. conducted approximately 400 strikes in Yemen, killing an estimated 1,100-1,700 people including 130-230 civilians. The most legally and morally consequential strikes occurred in 2011: the deliberate killing of American citizen Anwar al-Awlaki on September 30, and the killing of his 16-year-old son Abdulrahman two weeks later.
The al-Awlaki killings represent the most extreme assertion of executive power in American history. Anwar al-Awlaki was an American citizen, born in New Mexico, who became an al-Qaeda propagandist and was involved in operational planning. He was undoubtedly dangerous. But he was never indicted, never charged with a crime, and never given any opportunity to surrender or contest the evidence against him. His killing was authorized by a secret Justice Department memo, reviewed by no court, and carried out by CIA operatives in a foreign country. When the ACLU filed suit challenging the program, the government argued that the president’s authority to kill American citizens was a “political question” beyond judicial review – effectively claiming that the executive branch has unreviewable power over life and death.
The killing of 16-year-old Abdulrahman was even more disturbing. Born in Denver, the teenager had no known involvement in terrorism. He was killed while eating dinner at an outdoor restaurant. The government offered no coherent justification, and when pressed, White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs suggested the boy “should have had a more responsible father.” In 2017, the al-Awlaki family’s suffering was compounded when 8-year-old Nawar al-Awlaki, Anwar’s daughter, was killed in a Navy SEAL raid in Yemen authorized by President Trump.
The Somalia campaign, conducted primarily by AFRICOM under both CIA and military authority, targeted al-Shabaab militants. Between 2007 and 2023, the U.S. conducted approximately 280 strikes in Somalia, killing an estimated 1,200-2,100 people including 15-70 civilians (though these figures are likely significant underestimates due to the difficulty of monitoring strikes in Somalia’s remote areas). Trump dramatically escalated strikes in Somalia, declaring portions of the country “areas of active hostilities” that allowed field commanders to authorize strikes without White House approval.
The rivalry between the CIA and JSOC drone programs created a parallel killing bureaucracy with different rules and oversight structures. The CIA’s program, as a covert action, was subject to congressional intelligence committee notification but not public disclosure. JSOC’s program, as a military operation, operated under different legal authorities and targeting procedures. In practice, the existence of two parallel programs meant that if one had restrictions, targets could be passed to the other. This bureaucratic competition actually expanded the killing – each program had institutional incentives to demonstrate its value by conducting more strikes.
The technology of remote killing also created a new form of psychological injury. Drone operators, sitting in climate-controlled trailers at Creech Air Force Base in Nevada or other installations, watched their targets for days or weeks through high-resolution cameras – observing their daily routines, their families, their children – before pressing the button that killed them. Then they watched the aftermath in real-time video: the explosion, the body parts, the survivors stumbling through the rubble. At the end of their shift, they drove home to have dinner with their own families. Studies found that PTSD rates among drone operators were comparable to those of combat troops – the intimacy of killing from a screen, combined with the bizarre normalcy of commuting to and from assassination, created a unique form of moral injury.
The strategic failure of the drone campaign is now well-documented. Multiple studies – by Stanford University, NYU, the Stimson Center, and former military and intelligence officials – have concluded that drone strikes are counterproductive in the long term. Every civilian killed creates a family with legitimate grievances against the United States. Every mistaken strike on a wedding, funeral, or tribal gathering radicalizes communities that had no previous hostility toward America. A retired general told the Stanford researchers: “Drone strikes are like mowing the grass. You kill the leaders, and new ones grow back – often more radical than the ones you killed.”
The numbers tell the story of strategic failure: despite killing thousands of suspected militants over two decades, the organizations targeted by drones have generally grown rather than shrunk. Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula was more dangerous in 2015 than in 2009 despite hundreds of drone strikes. Al-Shabaab controlled more territory in 2020 than in 2011. The Taliban won the war in Afghanistan. The drone campaign has been tactically effective at killing individuals while being strategically irrelevant to the conflicts it was supposed to resolve.
Perhaps the most consequential legacy of the drone campaign is the precedent it sets for other nations. The United States established that a government can kill anyone, anywhere, without trial, evidence, or accountability, based on secret intelligence reviewed by no independent authority. China, Russia, Turkey, Iran, and dozens of other nations are now developing or have developed armed drone capabilities. The norms the U.S. established – that sovereignty is no barrier to assassination, that “signature” behavior can justify killing, that transparency is optional – will be invoked by every authoritarian government that acquires this technology. The world the drone campaign created is one where everyone lives under the shadow of potential execution by remote control – a dystopia pioneered by the world’s oldest democracy.”
Beyond the major wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, and Syria, the United States conducts counterterrorism operations in at least 78 countries spanning every continent except Antarctica. U.S. Special Forces have deployed to 149 countries – 75% of the world’s nations. These operations include training missions, intelligence operations, drone strikes, special operations raids, ‘advise and assist’ deployments, secret detention and interrogation programs, extraordinary rendition flights, signals intelligence collection, and the construction of a vast network of military bases and lily-pad outposts across Africa, Asia, the Middle East, and Southeast Asia. The ‘Other Operations’ category encompasses the full scope of the Global War on Terror beyond the named conflicts – a shadow war fought largely in secret, authorized by a single 60-word sentence passed three days after 9/11.
“The Full Story
How this conflict unfolded
The ‘Global War on Terror’ – the umbrella term for America’s post-9/11 military campaigns – expanded far beyond Afghanistan and Iraq into a shadowy, globe-spanning network of military operations that touches every inhabited continent. Under the 2001 Authorization for Use of Military Force (AUMF) – a 60-word sentence passed three days after September 11 in a moment of national trauma – the United States has conducted military operations in at least 85 countries, deployed special forces to 149 nations, and built a counterterrorism infrastructure that would make George Orwell blanch.
This entry covers the ‘other’ operations – the ones beyond the named conflicts, the ones most Americans don’t know exist. They include the Combined Joint Task Force – Horn of Africa (CJTF-HOA), operating from Camp Lemonnier in Djibouti with 4,000+ personnel conducting strikes and surveillance across East Africa. They include the Trans-Sahara Counterterrorism Partnership, spending $100 million annually across 10 West African nations to train local militaries that frequently overthrow their own governments (as Niger demonstrated in 2023). They include Operation Enduring Freedom – Philippines, where 600+ Special Forces spent over a decade hunting Abu Sayyaf in the jungles of Mindanao. They include scores of smaller deployments, training missions, and intelligence operations that collectively constitute the largest sustained military enterprise in human history.
THE LEGAL FRAMEWORK: A BLANK CHECK FOR GLOBAL WAR
The foundation of the entire enterprise is the 2001 AUMF, which authorizes the president to use “all necessary and appropriate force against those nations, organizations, or persons he determines planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001.” This 60-word sentence has been interpreted by four successive administrations to authorize military operations against groups that didn’t exist on 9/11 (ISIS, al-Shabaab, ISIS-K, AQIM), in countries that had nothing to do with 9/11 (Somalia, Niger, Libya, Philippines, Yemen), using methods never contemplated by Congress (drone assassination of American citizens, indefinite detention without trial, extraordinary rendition to torture states).
Only one member of Congress voted against the AUMF: Representative Barbara Lee of California. She warned it was a “blank check” for endless war. She received death threats and was called a traitor. Twenty-five years later, she has been proven prophetic beyond her worst fears.
THE SECRET PRISON AND TORTURE PROGRAM
One of the darkest chapters of the GWOT was the CIA’s Detention and Interrogation Program – a network of secret prisons (‘black sites’) where terrorism suspects were subjected to what the government euphemistically called ‘enhanced interrogation techniques.’ The 2014 Senate Torture Report documented the full horror: waterboarding (simulated drowning), rectal feeding and rectal rehydration (sexual assault), sleep deprivation for up to 180 hours (over 7 days), stress positions causing permanent physical damage, confinement in coffin-sized boxes, mock executions, threats against detainees’ families, and ice water immersion causing hypothermia.
The black sites operated in Thailand (‘Cat’s Eye’), Poland (Stare Kiejkuty), Romania (‘Bright Light’), Lithuania, Afghanistan (‘Salt Pit’ and ‘Cobalt’), and other undisclosed locations. At the Salt Pit in Afghanistan, detainee Gul Rahman was chained to a concrete floor in freezing temperatures and died of hypothermia. No one was prosecuted.
The extraordinary rendition program was equally horrifying. The CIA operated a fleet of aircraft through front companies (Aero Contractors, Jeppesen Dataplan), flying prisoners to countries known for torture – Egypt, Syria, Morocco, Jordan, Uzbekistan – where they were interrogated using methods even the CIA wouldn’t employ directly. Over 136 individuals were rendered between 2001-2005. Some were entirely innocent – Maher Arar, a Canadian citizen, was rendered to Syria based on faulty intelligence and tortured for a year before being released without charges. Khaled El-Masri, a German citizen, was kidnapped in Macedonia, rendered to Afghanistan, tortured for five months, and then dumped on a roadside in Albania when the CIA realized they had the wrong man.
The Senate Torture Report concluded that the CIA’s techniques produced no actionable intelligence that couldn’t have been obtained through legal interrogation methods. The program’s architects – psychologists James Mitchell and Bruce Jessen, who were paid $81 million to design the torture program – faced no criminal consequences. CIA Director Gina Haspel, who oversaw the Thailand black site, was promoted.
THE HORN OF AFRICA: CAMP LEMONNIER AND CJTF-HOA
Camp Lemonnier in Djibouti – a tiny nation strategically located at the mouth of the Red Sea – became America’s most important African military installation. Established in 2002, it grew from a small outpost to a sprawling base hosting over 4,000 personnel, serving as the hub for the Combined Joint Task Force – Horn of Africa (CJTF-HOA). From Lemonnier, the U.S. conducts drone strikes in Yemen and Somalia, surveillance across East Africa, special operations raids, and training missions for partner forces across the region.
The base’s $1.4 billion expansion transformed it from a temporary counterterrorism outpost into a permanent military installation – a de facto American colony in Africa, leased from the Djiboutian government for $63 million per year. Djibouti also hosts military bases from France, China, Japan, and Italy – making it the most militarized patch of real estate on earth relative to its size.
CJTF-HOA’s Area of Responsibility covers 20 countries across East Africa and the Arabian Peninsula. Its operations range from visible humanitarian missions (well-drilling, school construction) to classified strikes and intelligence operations. The task force has been instrumental in the drone campaigns against al-Shabaab in Somalia and AQAP in Yemen – campaigns that have killed thousands, including hundreds of civilians, with minimal public awareness or congressional oversight.
THE TRANS-SAHARA COUNTERTERRORISM PARTNERSHIP
The Trans-Sahara Counterterrorism Partnership (TSCTP), launched in 2005 as an expansion of the Pan-Sahel Initiative, represents America’s attempt to prevent the Sahara-Sahel region from becoming the next Afghanistan. The program spans 10 countries – Mali, Niger, Chad, Mauritania, Nigeria, Senegal, Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, and Burkina Faso – providing training, equipment, intelligence sharing, and joint exercises to partner militaries.
The irony is brutal: TSCTP-trained officers have led military coups in Mali (2012, 2020, 2021), Burkina Faso (2022), Niger (2023), and Guinea (2021). Captain Amadou Sanogo, who overthrew Mali’s democratic government in 2012, was trained by U.S. Special Forces. The U.S. literally trained the soldiers who destroyed the democracies the program was supposed to protect. The pattern is consistent: American military training strengthens armies that then seize power, creating the instability that justifies more American involvement.
After the 2023 Niger coup – which expelled U.S. forces and handed a $110 million drone base to Russian Wagner mercenaries – the entire Sahel strategy collapsed. Mali, Burkina Faso, and Niger formed a new alliance, expelled French and American forces, and turned to Russia for military support. Twenty years and billions of dollars in American investment produced nothing – less than nothing, since the region is now aligned with Moscow.
OPERATION ENDURING FREEDOM – PHILIPPINES
Operation Enduring Freedom – Philippines (OEF-P) was one of the GWOT’s earliest and most sustained secondary fronts. From 2002 to 2015, 600+ U.S. Special Forces operated in Mindanao and the Sulu Archipelago, targeting Abu Sayyaf Group (ASG) – a Moro separatist-jihadist organization responsible for kidnappings, bombings, and the 2004 SuperFerry 14 bombing that killed 116 people.
The Philippines operation was initially considered a success story – Abu Sayyaf was degraded from 1,200+ fighters to a few hundred, key leaders were killed or captured, and the U.S. maintained its relationship with Manila. But the operation also demonstrated the GWOT’s whack-a-mole problem: as Abu Sayyaf weakened, elements pledged allegiance to ISIS, and in 2017, ISIS-affiliated militants seized the city of Marawi, triggering a five-month battle that killed over 1,100 people and displaced 360,000.
The Philippines deployment cost an estimated $6.4 billion over 13 years and involved direct combat (despite the ‘advisory’ label) – including the 2002 rescue mission for hostage Martin Burnham (who was killed during the rescue) and numerous firefights in the jungles of Mindanao and Basilan.
THE SURVEILLANCE STATE
The GWOT’s most pervasive domestic legacy is the surveillance apparatus revealed by Edward Snowden in 2013. Programs like PRISM (collecting data from Google, Facebook, Apple, Microsoft, and other tech companies), UPSTREAM (tapping undersea fiber optic cables), XKeyscore (searching nearly all internet activity in real-time), and BOUNDLESS INFORMANT (tracking metadata collection) demonstrated that the U.S. government had built the most comprehensive surveillance system in human history – monitoring the communications of billions of people worldwide, including millions of American citizens.
The legal framework for this surveillance was Section 215 of the PATRIOT Act and Section 702 of FISA Amendments Act – laws passed in the GWOT’s panic that were interpreted secretly by the FISA Court to authorize mass collection far beyond what Congress intended. The NSA collected metadata on every phone call made in the United States, tracked email and internet activity globally, and shared intelligence with Five Eyes partners (UK, Australia, Canada, New Zealand) to circumvent domestic legal restrictions.
The surveillance state outlived every other aspect of the GWOT. While troops withdrew from Afghanistan and Iraq, the surveillance infrastructure remained – and expanded. The capabilities developed to track terrorists are now used for immigration enforcement, drug investigations, and domestic law enforcement. The GWOT built a surveillance architecture that the Founders’ nightmares couldn’t have imagined.
THE COST
The full financial cost of the ‘other’ GWOT operations is impossible to calculate precisely because much of the spending is classified, spread across multiple agencies (DoD, CIA, NSA, DIA, State Department), and deliberately obscured in budget documents. Brown University’s Costs of War project estimates total post-9/11 spending at over $8 trillion – including direct military operations ($2.3 trillion), veteran care ($2.2 trillion), interest on war borrowing ($1.1 trillion), Homeland Security ($1.1 trillion), and increases to the Pentagon’s base budget ($900 billion).
The ‘other operations’ – everything beyond the named conflicts – account for an estimated $80-100 billion in direct costs. But this figure is misleading because these operations are deeply intertwined with the broader GWOT infrastructure. Camp Lemonnier supports operations across multiple conflicts. SOCOM’s 70,000 personnel rotate through dozens of countries. The intelligence community’s $80+ billion annual budget serves all operations simultaneously. The true cost of America’s global counterterrorism enterprise is embedded in the Pentagon’s $900+ billion annual budget in ways that resist accounting.
THE HUMAN TOLL
Brown University estimates that post-9/11 wars have directly killed over 940,000 people and displaced 38 million – more than any conflict since World War II. The ‘other operations’ have killed thousands: drone strikes in Pakistan (2,500-4,000), Yemen (1,500+), Somalia (1,200+), and Libya (500+). Special operations raids have killed hundreds more. Extraordinary rendition and torture programs destroyed dozens of lives even among those who survived. And the indirect deaths – from destroyed healthcare systems, displacement, malnutrition, and the cascading effects of destabilization – number in the hundreds of thousands.
The U.S. military’s own casualty figures for ‘other operations’ are deliberately understated. The 65 deaths and 150 wounded listed here represent only acknowledged combat casualties in named operations outside the major war zones. The true figure – including training accidents, classified operations, and contractor deaths – is significantly higher.
THE PERPETUAL WAR MACHINE
The most profound consequence of the GWOT’s ‘other operations’ is institutional: the creation of a self-perpetuating war machine that generates its own justification. The pattern is consistent across every theater: U.S. intervention destabilizes a region → destabilization creates extremism → extremism justifies more intervention → intervention creates more destabilization. This cycle has operated in Somalia, Yemen, Libya, the Sahel, Pakistan, and the Philippines for over two decades with no end in sight.
The 2001 AUMF provides the legal lubrication for this perpetual motion machine. Each new group – al-Shabaab, ISIS, AQIM, ISIS-K, Jundallah, Boko Haram – is declared an ‘associated force’ of al-Qaeda, bringing it under the AUMF’s umbrella regardless of any actual connection to 9/11. The authorization has metastasized from a response to a specific attack into a general license for global war – exactly the kind of permanent military establishment the Founders warned against in every major founding document.
The libertarian critique is devastating: the United States government has used the shock of 9/11 to construct a permanent warfare state operating across the globe with minimal oversight, no democratic accountability, and no defined enemy, battlefield, or objective. The ‘war on terror’ – like the ‘war on drugs’ and the ‘war on poverty’ – is a war against a concept, which means it can never be won and therefore never needs to end. It is the perfect war for those who profit from war.”
May 8 2026 On this Victory Europe Day Celebrating Liberation From the Nazis, As World War Three Rages in Ukraine, Palestine, and Iran, and the Captured State of Vichy America Is Riven By Tyranny and Resistance, Let Us Liberate All of Humankind From Fascisms of Blood, Faith, and Soil, From Imperial Conquest and Dominion, and From the Bureaucratic Terror of Tyrants and Their Carceral States of Force and Control
February 26 2026 How It All Began; World War Three, the Capture of America and the Subversion of Democracy by Traitor Trump and the Fourth Reich, the Russian Invasion of Ukraine, and the Fall of Civilization
This is a day which recalls to me not the heroism of our veterans in battle on foreign shores nor the endless roll call of our sacred dead who have fallen in such distant and oft-forgotten places, but of those whose struggles to survive here upon returning home have been met not with brotherhood and solidarity but with abandonment and brutal repression.
Veterans Day has always been a family day of remembrance for us as with most Americans, so many of us having personal connections with veterans. Both my father and my partner Theresa’s father Gene to begin with, Navy and Army respectively and having grown up together until pulled apart by service in the Korean War. My father escaped a North Korean POW camp with three others, one of whom was killed in the breakout; they carried the body all the way back to the South. Then there are her uncles, four of her father’s older brothers who served in the Second World War, among them Tom having been shot 70 times in the Pacific and returned to build a sawmill and homestead in the mountains near Sherman Pass for rehabilitation; my uncles Sargent John Weeks US Army who was a Bataan Death March survivor and after that fought in the Battle of Okinawa and in the Korean War, Commander Robert Eigell USN who was instrumental in the development of the Navy’s EOD service during World War Two, and Captain Terry Baker US Marines who flew close support planes in the Korean and Vietnam conflicts and later the U-2. As today is the 250th anniversary of the Corps, Happy Birthday, Marines.
I remember also my sister Erin’s partner Tom Newman, who began as a US Army Ranger LT, changed his MOS to Intelligence and earned the Special Forces patch, then vanished into the special operations community for 27 years of service, til he died of covid as a federal agent assigned to Hong Kong. Erin says the Army played the Ballad of the Green Berets at his funeral, on bagpipes, and never was there a more mournful wailing.
But its never the whole story, the glorious heroes who won for us all our liberty; there are also those whose lives were lost or destroyed.
A lovely green light will be cast on Spokane’s fairytale castle of a city hall tonight in honor of our veterans, called Operation Green Light, which is a nice gesture of remembrance, but I wish we could feed, house, and provide healthcare for all of us, including the countless veterans living and dying forgotten in our streets right now. A boy whom my partner Dolly raised in part over some years as he was often neglected or abandoned by his father who refused to let her adopt him is or was one of Spokane’s two thousand homeless veterans, he returned from Iraq addicted to oxycontin prescribed to him in a military hospital after being wounded in action, and insane; he thinks he’s Jesus and gives sermons to the pigeons. It’s been over a decade since anyone has seen or heard of him, vanished as if he had never been, and I wonder how many are there like him, used and thrown away like the waste products of the system of wealth and power of other people to whom they are nothing?
When Trump called our servicemen “suckers and losers” in a visit to their graves in France, and asked his handlers; ”Why did they do it? What’s in it for them?” he gave voice to the contempt of his whole class for the service of others, something beyond his understanding.
It has always been thus, the poor fed into the machine which creates and enforces hegemonic elites, their lives the raw material of their master’s wealth, power, and privilege. Military service in particular subjugates us to authority through fictitious illusions of honor and of loyalty as identitarian nationalism.
As written by Eugene V. Debs in Jacobin, in an essay entitled The Exploitation of Veterans Day: How should we observe Veterans Day? By working to eradicate war and the economic system that helps produce it.; “I have just returned from a visit over yonder, where three of our most loyal comrades are paying the penalty for their devotion to the cause of the working class. They have come to realize, as many of us have, that it is extremely dangerous to exercise the constitutional right of free speech in a country fighting to make democracy safe in the world.
I realize that, in speaking to you this afternoon, there are certain limitations placed upon the right of free speech. I must be exceedingly careful, prudent, as to what I say, and even more careful and prudent as to how I say it. I may not be able to say all I think; but I am not going to say anything that I do not think.
I would rather a thousand times be a free soul in jail than to be a sycophant and coward in the streets. They may put those boys in jail — and some of the rest of us in jail — but they cannot put the socialist movement in jail. Those prison bars separate their bodies from ours, but their souls are here this afternoon. They are simply paying the penalty that all men have paid in all the ages of history for standing erect, and for seeking to pave the way to better conditions for mankind.
If it had not been for the men and women who, in the past, have had the moral courage to go to jail, we would still be in the jungles.
They tell us that we live in a great free republic; that our institutions are democratic; that we are a free and self-governing people. This is too much, even for a joke. But it is not a subject for levity; it is an exceedingly serious matter.
The other day they sentenced Kate Richards O’Hare to the penitentiary for five years. Think of sentencing a woman to the penitentiary simply for talking. The United States, under plutocratic rule, is the only country that would send a woman to prison for five years for exercising the right of free speech. If this be treason, let them make the most of it.
Who appoints our federal judges? The people? In all the history of the country, the working class have never named a federal judge. There are 121 of these judges and every solitary one holds his position, his tenure, through the influence and power of corporate capital. The corporations and trusts dictate their appointment. And when they go to the bench, they go, not to serve the people, but to serve the interests that place them and keep them where they are.
Why, the other day, by a vote of 5-4 — a kind of craps game — come seven, come ’leven — they declared the child labor law unconstitutional — a law secured after twenty years of education and agitation on the part of all kinds of people.
And yet, by a majority of one, the Supreme Court a body of corporation lawyers, with just one exception, wiped that law from the statute books — and this in our so-called democracy — so that we may continue to grind the flesh and blood and bones of puny little children into profits for the Junkers of Wall Street.
And this in a country that boasts of fighting to make the world safe for democracy! The history of this country is being written in the blood of the childhood the industrial lords have murdered.
These are not palatable truths to them. They do not like to hear them; and what is more they do not want you to hear them. And that is why they brand us as undesirable citizens, and as disloyalists and traitors.
If we were actual traitors — traitors to the people and to their welfare and progress, we would be regarded as eminently respectable citizens of the republic; we would hold high office, have princely incomes, and ride in limousines; and we would be pointed out as the elect who have succeeded in life in honorable pursuit, and worthy of emulation by the youth of the land. It is precisely because we are disloyal to the traitors that we are loyal to the people of this nation.
Wars throughout history have been waged for conquest and plunder. In the Middle Ages, when the feudal lords who inhabited the castles whose towers may still be seen along the Rhine concluded to enlarge their domains, to increase their power, their prestige, and their wealth, they declared war upon one another.
But they themselves did not go to war any more than the modern feudal lords, the barons of Wall Street go to war. The feudal barons of the Middle Ages, the economic predecessors of the capitalists of our day, declared all wars. And their miserable serfs fought all the battles.
The poor, ignorant serfs had been taught to revere their masters; to believe that when their masters declared war upon one another, it was their patriotic duty to fall upon one another and to cut one another’s throats for the profit and glory of the lords and barons who held them in contempt.
And that is war in a nutshell. The master class has always declared the wars; the subject class has always fought the battles. The master class has had all to gain and nothing to lose, while the subject class has had nothing to gain and all to lose — especially their lives.
They have always taught and trained you to believe it to be your patriotic duty to go to war and to have yourselves slaughtered at their command. But in all the history of the world, you, the people, have never had a voice in declaring war, and strange as it certainly appears, no war by any nation in any age has ever been declared by the people.
What a compliment it is to the socialist movement to be thus persecuted for the sake of the truth! The truth alone will make the people free. And for this reason the truth must not be permitted to reach the people. The truth has always been dangerous to the rule of the rogue, the exploiter, the robber.
So the truth must be ruthlessly suppressed. That is why they are trying to destroy the socialist movement; and every time they strike a blow they add a thousand new voices to the hosts proclaiming that socialism is the hope of humanity and has come to emancipate the people from their final form of servitude.
It is the minorities who have made the history of this world. It is the few who have had the courage to take their places at the front; who have been true enough to themselves to speak the truth that was in them; who have dared oppose the established order of things; who have espoused the cause of the suffering, struggling poor; who have upheld without regard to personal consequences the cause of freedom and righteousness. It is they, the heroic, self-sacrificing few who have made the history of the race and who have paved the way from barbarism to civilization.
The heart of the international socialist never beats a retreat.
They are continually talking about your patriotic duty. It is not their but your patriotic duty that they are concerned about. There is a decided difference. Their patriotic duty never takes them to the firing line or chucks them into the trenches.
And now among other things they are urging you to “cultivate” war gardens, while at the same time a government war report just issued shows that practically 52 percent of the arable, tillable soil is held out of use by the landlords, speculators, and profiteers. They themselves do not cultivate the soil. They could not if they would.
Nor do they allow others to cultivate it. They keep it idle to enrich themselves, to pocket the millions of dollars of unearned increment. Who is it that makes this land valuable while it is fenced in and kept out of use? It is the people. Who pockets this tremendous accumulation of value? The landlords. And these landlords who toil not and spin not are supreme among American “patriots.”
In passing I suggest that we stop a moment to think about the term “landlord.” “Landlord!” Lord of the Land! The lord of the land is indeed a superpatriot. This lord who practically owns the earth tells you that we are fighting this war to make the world safe for democracy — he who shuts out all humanity from his private domain; he who profiteers at the expense of the people who have been slain and mutilated by multiplied thousands, under pretense of being the great American patriot.
It is he, this identical patriot who is in fact the archenemy of the people; it is he that you need to wipe from power. It is he who is a far greater menace to your liberty and your well-being than the Prussian Junkers on the other side of the Atlantic ocean.
War makes possible all such crimes and outrages. And war comes in spite of the people. When Wall Street says war the press says war and the pulpit promptly follows with its “amen.”
Now what you workers need is to organize, not along craft lines but along revolutionary industrial lines. All of you workers in a given industry, regardless of your trade or occupation, should belong to one and the same union.
Political action and industrial action must supplement and sustain each other. You will never vote the socialist republic into existence. You will have to lay its foundations in industrial organization. The industrial union is the forerunner of industrial democracy. In the shop where the workers are associated is where industrial democracy has its beginning. Organize according to your industries! Get together in every department of industrial service! United and acting together for the common good your power is invincible.
When we unite and act together on the industrial field and when we vote together on Election Day we shall develop the supreme power of the one class that can and will bring permanent peace to the world. We shall then have the intelligence, the courage, and the power for our great task.
In due time industry will be organized on a cooperative basis. We shall conquer the public power. We shall then transfer the title deeds of the railroads, the telegraph lines, the mines, mills and great industries to the people in their collective capacity; we shall take possession of all these social utilities in the name of the people. We shall then have industrial democracy. We shall be a free nation whose government is of and by and for the people.
And now for all of us to do our duty! The clarion call is ringing in our ears and we cannot falter without being convicted of treason to ourselves and to our great cause. Do not worry over the charge of treason to your masters, but be concerned about the treason that involves yourselves. Be true to yourself and you cannot be a traitor to any good cause on earth.
In due time the hour will strike and this great cause triumphant — the greatest in history — will proclaim the emancipation of the working class and the brotherhood of all mankind.”
So wrote the great Socialist and union organizer Eugene V. Debs of the meaning of the First World War whose ending we celebrate today, a meaning which has now become reversed in service to power as Veteran’s Day, service which I regard not as glorious but as a tragedy of labor exploitation and a system of oppression.
Today I think of the plight of our veterans, far too many of whom die by suicide or wander the streets of our cities as homeless apparitions of the failures of our democracy which include the guarantee of our universal health care, housing, and material wellbeing as a precondition of our right to life, in terms of the Armistice Day Massacre of 1919, which occurred only a couple hours drive from my home, and with which I have a personal connection through the family of my partner Theresa. Her grandfather John F. McKay, an Industrial Workers of the World organizer and Socialist, was changed by this defining moment from an ideologically motivated politician and labor activist to a leader of direct action for whom unions were an instrument not simply for fairness and the dignity of labor, but for the survival of the powerless and the dispossessed.
Her father Gene remembered when the last IWW prisoner of this incident was freed from prison and came to live with them; Ray Becker, held for twenty years because he refused to name names or give up his fellows to the police, and refused a pardon which came attached to the enormous boat anchor of recognition of the state’s right to criminalize labor unions.
Twenty years of beatings, starvation, torture, solitary confinement in a lightless box, brutal labor, and he spoke not a word which might have saved him but damned another to anyone. That’s a man I wish I had known, and can admire as a shaping force of my partner’s family history and of the idea of labor unions and of America as a Band of Brothers.
I can’t think of a better example of heroism to grow up with, and I’d like to share the story as it is known with us all.
As related in the website of the Thurston-Lewis-Mason Central Labor Council; “The trial arising from the Armistice Day massacre of 1919 in Centralia, Washington would be on many lists of the most important cases arising from labor and management clashes. It was, at the time, considered one of the most important labor management cases in the United States. The incident was on the front page of the New York Times. William “Big Bill” Haywood, head of the radical union Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), was concerned that several of his members would be found guilty and sentenced to death. It seemed to some that the case might be as notorious as the Sacco and Vanzetti case. Some felt it would rank with the famous Haymarket case of 1886 in Chicago in which four men received the death penalty and were, in fact, executed.
The county in which Centralia is located was a significant center for organized labor. At that time, seventeen unions comprised the Central Trade Council. This council in turn represented an estimated 3,000 union members. The power of organized labor was evident in the Labor Day Parade on September 1st, 1919. The unions staged a parade described as “the biggest parade ever held in Centralia.” Timber workers, coal miners, barbers, printers, carpenters, retail clerks, and railway brotherhoods all took part in the parade. Plans were announced about that time to build a new labor temple.
The Centralia case arose as a result of deaths and injuries following gunfire near the union hall of the radical labor union, the Industrial Workers of the World, whose members were called “Wobblies.” The IWW is an international union founded in Chicago, Illinois, in 1905 by a few hundred socialists, anarchists, and radical trade unionists. Its radical nature is shown by its chief goal: the abolition of the wage system and control of the workplace by the workers.
Conflict between labor and management had a violent history in the Northwest timber industry. IWW union halls were raided and pillaged again and again. Members of this radical union were frequently beaten and tarred and feathered and forced to leave town. In 1918, the IWW had a union hall which was located a few blocks from the union hall used by them in 1919. That hall was attacked and wrecked by participants in the 1918 Red Cross Parade. The members inside were maltreated and driven out of town.
The union members were thus very much aware of the dangers that the 1919 parade posed to them. Both the secretary of the local and the proprietress of the hotel in which the union headquarters was located in separate meetings sought the protection from the chief of police prior to the parade. The police chief was not at all reassuring, and both parties left the meetings feeling they would be without police protection during the parade.
Moreover, the usual turn-around point for a parade was a block and a half south of the union hall. This parade was going to turn around, according to the local newspaper, two blocks farther north, which would place the paraders in front of the union hall. Why would the parade route be changed, the members wondered, other than to raid the hall? Their attorney, Elmer Smith, had been told by a friend that the raid would occur. He advised the local union secretary accordingly.
The union was so sure that the raid would occur that it printed one thousand leaflets and delivered them door to door in Centralia. The leaflet pointed out that a raid was going to occur and asked the citizens to do what they could to try to prevent this from happening.
The IWW union members had a meeting and discussed what to do. The local union secretary consulted Elmer Smith, their attorney, who advised them that the union hall was, in a sense, their meeting place, and, to fact, a secretary of the IWW union local lived there. Many of the members spent a great deal of their time in the union hall on weekends or between jobs. Therefore, Elmer Smith said, the union members had a right to defend themselves in the hall against attack threatening bodily injury or injury to their property, even if such defense necessitated the use of firearms.
The parade was scheduled to begin in the afternoon. In the morning, Attorney Elmer Smith made a trip to the IWW hall to confer again with Britt Smith. Tom Morgan, the IWW member who testified as the state’s witness, claimed to have witnessed this conversation. He testified that he saw Britt Smith pointing to the buildings across the street where IWW riflemen were to be stationed. If true, this would mean that Elmer Smith knew, and tacitly approved of the non-legal plan for self-defense. Elmer Smith only remained in the hall a few minutes.
In the afternoon some of the IWW members left the hall to station themselves elsewhere. There were several inexpensive hotels nearby which catered to loggers who lived in the logging camps on weekdays and who regularly rented rooms on the weekend.
The seven who remained in the hall were Wesley Everest, Ray Becker, Tom Morgan, Britt Smith, James McInerney, Mike Sheehan, and Bert Faulkner. Everest, Becker, Britt Smith, and McInerney were armed with a pistol. Two groups of defenders left the hall to station themselves elsewhere. Three men armed with rifles stationed themselves on Seminary Hill over a thousand feet east of the hall. They were Loren Roberts, Bert “Curley” Bland and Ole Hanson (Hanson was never apprehended.). O.C. “Commodore” Bland and John Lamb occupied a second floor room in the Arnold on the opposite side of Tower Avenue and a little north of the hall. “John Doe” Davis went with a concealed rifle to the Avalon Hotel on the opposite side of Tower Avenue and slightly south of the IWW hall. Davis was never apprehended. There was testimony that Eugene Barnett was also in or near the Avalon, but two witnesses corroborated his testimony that he was in the lobby of the Roderick Hotel when the gunfire took place which was next door to the IWW hall.
Usually there are few spectators at the very end of the parade since it is quite some distance from the heart of the business district; but quite a crowd had gathered in the area near the IWW hall. Why was this so? There were many, according to one commentator, who remembered the raid eighteen months earlier of the old IWW hall which took place while a Red Cross parade was passing nearby. Some spectators had undoubtedly heard the rumors or seen the handbills passed out by the local IWW members. Those who wanted some excitement got more than they expected that day. Curiously, one of those bystanders near the IWW hall was the county prosecuting attorney.
Warren Grim gave the command to “Halt, close up ranks!” The Centralia Legion group had already fallen well behind the Chehalis Legion group.
Far and away the most authoritative book, and indeed the only book which treats the entire incident, is Wobbly War: The Centralia Story by John McClelland, Jr. The events in Centralia resulting in the trial are best understood by quoting extensively and summarizing the key facts from his book.
The celebration of the first Armistice Day in Centralia was planned only four days in advance. Members of the Grant Hodge post met in the Elks hall on November 7 and decided it would be “strictly a military day.” They agreed to wear their uniforms. Everyone who had an American flag was to display it. And of course there would be a parade followed by a patriotic program.
The line of march would be led by the Elks band followed by the Mexican border veterans, Spanish-American War veterans, Boy Scouts, Red Cross, Salvation Army, Elks lodges of both Centralia and Chehalis, and any others who wanted to march and show their patriotism. The Chehalis and Centralia Legionnaires would be the last of the marching groups. The parade route was north on Tower to Third Street, then back the same way to the high school, where a speaker was to give an oration.
The edition of the Chronicle reporting these parade plans contained an editorial quoting a ringing resolution adopted at the recent Elks national convention pledging “all lawful means to combat the IWW and kindred organizations.” But lawful means were lacking in Centralia, or so city and county officials decided. There remained another way, used before in Centralia when action was called for and good men with right on their side were willing to act.
Raids on IWW halls in the Northwest were so numerous and effective that by the fall of 1919 few were left. In the war on Wobblies the opening of a hall in Centralia was regarded as a setback and so it was a surprise to no one, including the IWW, when plans to do something about it were openly discussed and reported. Unless law officers intervened, a raid was sure to come. It was only a question of when.
Raids were easy. No weapons were necessary. Raiders simply kicked in the door if it was locked, pushed any Wobblies on hand out into the street, then took everything that could be lifted or burned or smashed it. With a small hall like the one on Tower Avenue a raid could be over in minutes.
But when should it take place? The fact that the parade route was unprecedentedly long—all the way to Third Street before turning around, a route which would cause the parade to go past the IWW hall, located between Second and Third, going and coming—was often cited as evidence that Legionnaires decided in advance that a quick raid on the hall could be accomplished as a part of the patriotic events of Armistice Day. Parades in prior years had turned at First Street.
In any planning that was done, Legion leaders were in the forefront. Dr. Livingstone, the Legion commander, was the chairman of the Citizens Protective Association and held the office of leading knight in the Elks lodge. Warren Grimm, who succeeded Livingstone as commander of the Legion post, was a committee chairman in the protective association. Leslie Hughes, the police chief, was chaplain of the Legion, and C.D. Cunningham was historian.
It was clear that the law was not going to provide any protection. If a mob attacked, the Wobblies would have to provide their own defense, if there was to be any.
As Armistice Day neared, the men discussed their plight, and their courage improved. They convinced themselves that the hall had to be defended. Furthermore they felt challenged. The protective association, with its bold meetings reported in the press, seemed to be announcing its intentions to make an assault.
On Saturday night, the Wobblies gathered in their hall to talk about what they were going to do.
On Sunday a general meeting, open to all was held. After the meeting those who remained talked again about defense of the hall. The defense strategy was to catch them in a cross fire. Some defenders would station themselves in upstairs rooms of the rooming houses in the neighborhood where they could get a clear shot at anyone attacking the hall from the front. The Arnold and the Avalon were the closest. The Wobblies decided they had better be ready when the parade came by. Britt Smith quoted Elmer as saying, “’Britt, they are going to raid the hall. What are you going to do about it?’ I said that if they started to raid the hall, we were here, and by that I meant we were going to protect the place.”
Seven Wobblies chose to stay where the action would be, if there were any—in the hall itself. Four of these were willing to fight with guns if need be. . .Britt Smith had to stay in the hall. It was his home. And as the paid secretary of the local IWW unit, he was regarded as the chief of the local Wobblies. He had a revolver. Bland and Lamb, walking home after the Sunday night meeting, made their decision. The hall ought to be defended and they would help. They rented a room in the Arnold, almost directly opposite the hall, and went there on Armistice Day. Bland took a rifle. Lamb went unarmed.
Jack Davis was to be in the Avalon Hotel.
Ben Casagranda, an enlisted man, had come back from service overseas and opened a shoeshine parlor. He married and was living in an apartment on Center Street. His wife said she wasn’t feeling well on November 11 and didn’t intend to watch the parade. “You’d better go,” her husband said. “This may be the last time you will see me.” Then he kissed her goodbye and left. Mrs. Casagranda recalled that “afterward, when I thought over what Ben had said, I became worried and finally decided to go downtown and ask him not to march in the parade. I hurried down Tower but I was too late. The parade was going by and I found that Ben was among the marchers.”
By two o’clock the parade was moving—the band, the Boy Scouts, the color bearers, the Elks wearing their jaunty blue caps, a contingent of ex-marines and sailors, the Chehalis Legionnaires and finally the Centralia unit with Lt. Warren Grimm marching at the head. At the end, behind the Legionnaires, were several open cars carrying nurses, Red Cross workers, and citizens who just wanted to be in the parade.
A hand held high. A shouted order. These set in motion the tragedy of Armistice Day, 1919, in Centralia. All of the parade was past the Wobbly hall except the Centralia contingent and several cars bringing up the rear. The Centralia group had fallen behind and a wide gap separated it from the Chehalis Legionnaires marching ahead. But when he reached the intersection of Tower and Second, with the men he led directly in front of the hall, Warren Grimm turned, held up his arm, and called out: “Halt, close up ranks!” The rest of the parade was moving on and the space between them and the Chehalis marchers was widening rapidly.
Because of what happened within seconds after the order was given, the intent of the halt seemed to be to give the Centralians a chance to drop out of the parade, make a quick assault on the Wobbly hall, then resume the march, perhaps catching up with the rest of the parade before it reached the reviewing stand.
Some of the men talked about a raid as they marched south on Tower. One of these was Dr. Frank Bickford, at forty-nine a mature and respected medical doctor who was in the front ranks. When the order to halt was given, he decided that right then was a good time to do something about the Wobblies. He turned to others near him, volunteered to take the lead, and started for the hall. When he looked back and saw no one was following him, he hesitated. Then he heard “a commotion and hollering among the platoons in the rear.” Bickford moved on and saw others from the ranks just opposite the hall running ahead of him. They reached the hall’s entrance before he did. Faulkner, standing at the window inside the hall, heard shouts of, “Let’s go get them! Grab them! At them—get them!”
“A man at my right put his foot against the door,” Bickford later testified, “and pushed it partly open.” The gunfire from the hall signaled the other defenders. Davis from the second-story vantage point in the Avalon took aim. With his first shot, probably, he picked off Warren Grimm.
The three men stationed on Seminary Hill heard the popping of gunfire below and began to shoot. O.C. Bland, in the Arnold, didn’t get into the action. As men ran toward the hall, Bland jumped up from his seat on the bed and shoved his rifle through a window, and a piece of glass slashed a cut in the back of his hand so deep his friend Lamb was sickened by the sight.
The ex-soldiers who stormed into the hall found the front part of it empty. The firing, done only by Everest and Becker, while intense and rapid, was brief.
Everest, in a high state of excitement when he reached the alley behind the hall, turned south, and when he came to the alley’s entrance on Second Street saw two men in uniform running toward him. He fired at both. Casagranda, shot through the stomach, fell on the sidewalk. Watt was hit by a bullet that penetrated his midriff. Everest then turned and started north.
Everest’s route was through three residential blocks and many vacant lots, stables, and sheds, along the alleys, four-tenths of a mile between Second Street and the Skookumchuck River, flowing swiftly just before it converged with the Chehalis [River].
Dale Hubbard was able to find someone who handed him a pistol. He grabbed it and continued the pursuit, but when he caught sight of Everest and tried to fire, the pistol wouldn’t work.
The fleeing Everest did not try to hide. He would pause, crouch behind a shed or fence and fire a shot at his pursuers, then run on. In a few minutes he came to the bank of Skookumchuck, thick with trees and underbrush. He saw at once that he was trapped unless he could cross the river. He could not. The river was too swift and deep and he was burdened with heavy logger’s clothes and boots. Everest crouched behind a stump near the water’s edge and waited, gun in hand.
Hubbard moved out ahead, leveling the pistol that would not fire, and shouted at Everest to surrender. Everest responded with “defiant curses” and, when Hubbard kept coming, raised his gun and shot. Hubbard fell. Everest shot him again, and then again. That emptied his gun. Seeing him trying frantically to reload, the others rushed up. Everest reached for a long knife strapped to his belt in the back, but before he could draw it Barner was on him, grabbing his arms. Others followed, one kicking him in the head hard enough to draw blood.
Pulled to his feet, Everest, still defiant, resisted efforts to make him move. One of his captors took off his belt and looped it around the Wobbly’s neck, using it as a leash on the long walk to the city jail nearly a mile away. Hubbard lay where he fell, gravely wounded but not dead. Soon a car and driver were found and he was taken to the Scace Hospital, the last of the Wobbly gunfire victims to receive medical attention.
A trail of blood on the sidewalk leading past the Roderick to the corner at Second Street verified reports that one of the paraders, who was seen stumbling south away from the hall, bent over with his hands over his stomach, was shot in front of the hall.
Others among the ex-servicemen who escaped being hit poured into the IWW hall and the Roderick lobby to finish the raid.
They found no one in the front portion of the hall. There was some hesitation. The ex-servicemen, inside the hall, could hear the shots in the alley.
Eugene Barnett, in the lobby of the Roderick when the raid started, threw off his coat, intending to join the fight. But when the shooting began, he stayed where he was. He was still in the lobby when the uniformed men came in. He recognized William Scales as one and afterward said that another, a navy man, was carrying a gun. He said he wanted him to be careful with the gun because there was a woman—Mrs. McAllister—in the back. Barnett was not recognized then as a Wobbly and was not seized. He walked away unmolested and went uptown in time to see Everest brought in.
Once the building had been thoroughly searched, the Legionnaires proceeded to complete what had been their original objective—the destruction of the hall. Records from Smith’s desk, including the local IWW membership list, were handed to Prosecutor Allen, who happened to be standing across the street, watching.
It was about a mile from the banks of the Skookumchuck to the jail on Maple Street, and as Everest and his captors moved along, the crowd following them grew. The story spread quickly. This was the Wobbly who shot Dale Hubbard in cold blood out on the riverbank.
A rope was tied around Everest’s neck and the end thrown over a spike on a telephone pole in the alley in back of the Chronicle office, near the jail. Dr. Livingstone, just arrived on the scene after leaving the hospital where he watched as his friend Grimm died, was as angry as any at the Wobblies, but could reason well enough to know that a daytime lynching would be bad. He began to clamber up the foothold spikes of the pole where he began shouting to make himself heard above the clamor of the mob. “Don’t hang him. Not here,” he yelled. “Don’t do something foolish.”
The appeals were almost too late. Everest was lifted by the neck and his feet were off the ground before Livingstone’s frantic appeal to reason was heeded and he was let down. Quickly he was hustled across the street and pushed into a jail cell out of reach of the mob eager for a lynching. In the jail were the others who were seized in the rear of the Roderick.
Smith was found in his office, standing with his raincoat on, beside his desk. When Smith saw the crowd outside, he took off his coat and went to the door. They wanted him to go down to the police station and give an account of himself.
Finally Smith agreed to surrender his gun and go along.
By this time anyone suspected of anything in connection with the Wobblies was being seized and held. The Wobbly horrors rapidly escalated into Wobbly hysteria. Smith was locked up.
The mob around the jail continued to grow and the intensity of its temper increased. The anger intensified as the events of the afternoon became more widely known.
As the crowd outside the jail grew to about thousand and daylight faded, the mayor and the police chief called the state adjutant general of the National Guard for help. Two officers and thirty-five enlisted men from the Tacoma company were assembled and dispatched to Centralia by special train.
About seven that night several cars drove up near the jail with their lights out. Then, the lights of the city went out for about fifteen minutes and men entered the jail and removed Wesley Everest. Everest was placed in a car, followed by others and driven to a bridge spanning the Chehalis River about a mile away on the southwest side of town. He was hanged and shot. The body remained hanging for some time. Several cars drove out to view the sight. Later, someone cut the rope and the body drifted downstream and came to rest near the river’s edge.
The train with the National Guardsmen arrived at 11:35 pm. Gradually, the calls for more lynchings died down. The crowd was aware that the National Guard was in town and was beginning to set up checkpoints. The crowds gradually became smaller as the night wore on.
Was Wesley Everest emasculated in the vehicle which conveyed him to the bridge? McClelland, the leading authority on the incident, feels that it was not simply a story perpetuated by the IWW, since IWW members were in no position to do so in the days after the lynching. Years after the event, an affidavit was signed by a purported passenger in the car in which Everest was riding, which described the event in horrifying detail.
The corpse of Everest was retrieved and brought back to the small Centralia jail where it was placed in the corridor between the rows of cells.
Eventually, a group of prisoners were ordered to bury Everest in “Potter’s Field” while being watched over by National Guardsmen.
The jails of Centralia and Chehalis were full. Eventually, the following were charged with conspiracy to commit murder in the first degree: Eugene Barnett, Ray Becker, James McInerney, Britt Smith, Bert Bland, Loren Roberts, O.C. Bland, John Lamb, Mike Sheehan, and Bert Faulkner. Elmer Smith was charged as an accessory to the crime of conspiracy to commit first degree murder.
State labor officials knew that the trial would be used by some employers to beat down the long-established, more traditional craft unions. Thus, they decided to create their own “labor jury.” “These labor jury participants,” said McClelland, “were expected to be present at the trial, and to reach their own independent verdict.” There was some disagreement within the labor union movement. As McClelland pointed out, “The Seattle Central Labor Council expressed disapproval of the methods being used by the Centralia committee—especially when it sponsored picketing in Olympia—and accused it of capitalizing on the plight of the prisoners for private ends. The Seattle Federal Employees Union also announced it was ‘voting against the IWW.’”
Despite some opposition, Northwest labor leaders felt that the Wobblies, for all their irrationality, deserved a fair trail, and so they conceived the idea of sending a jury of their own, made up of working men, to sit through the trial and render a verdict at the same time the official verdict came in.
Even though most craft union leaders and members did not agree with the radical beliefs and actions of the IWW, they realized that their unions were, in a sense, “on trial” as well. They realized that anti-union employers would seize upon the radical actions of the IWW and use that as an example of the type of union activity that they claimed was typical. That is to say, they would attempt to tar the craft unions with the same brush they used to tar the IWW.
Some unions were eager to dissociate themselves from the IWW. The union which represented many employees of the Centralia Chronicle was quick to point out through a resolution that their members decried the methods used by the IWW. Unions in the Puget Sound area were aware that something would have to be done to counteract employers’ efforts to take advantage of the Centralia massacre and attempt to turn public opinion against the labor movement in general.
Those who were selected were John O. Craft, Metal Trades Council, Seattle; Paul Mohr, Central Labor Council, Seattle; W.J. Beard, Tacoma Labor Council; T. Meyer, Everett Labor Council; William Hickman, Portland Labor Council; and E.W. Thrall, Centralia Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen. “They took their assignment seriously, sitting through every session of the long trial,” according to McClelland.
The judge at the trial explained near the beginning that this was not a trial against the Industrial Workers of the World, it was a trial against certain individuals for conspiracy to commit first-degree murder. However, there was bound to be a great deal of discussion about labor unions during the course of the trial. The attorney for the defendants, George Vanderveer, argued, for example, “that industrial unionism was superior to craft unionism because a union representing all workers in an industry, such as steel, transportation, or lumber, was stronger than similar smaller AFL craft unions.” (McClelland points out that, “This was fourteen years before belated acceptance of the industrial union principle led to the formation of what became the Congress of Industrial Organizations.”)
One case above all others must have been on the minds of the prosecution, the defense, and the judge himself. This was the famous Everett massacre IWW trial, a nine week trial which took place in early 1917, arising from an exchange of gunfire between IWW members and law enforcement officials. As a result, two law enforcement officials and at least five IWW members or sympathizers were killed.
The gunfire took place on the waterfront of the city of Everett, a mill town located about about thirty miles north of Seattle. Seventy-four men were held for months before charges were finally filed against a few of them, and an actual trial was started against one of the seventy-four. The reason that the IWW became interested in Everett was due to a shingle weavers’ strike, which had many more members in the American Federation of Labor than in the IWW; however, the IWW had long found it profitable to “fish in troubled waters.” IWW members began to gather in Everett and made public speeches on behalf of the strikers. Some members of the business community countered by encouraging the sheriff, Donald R. McRae, to name approximately two hundred special deputy sheriffs whose job it would be to turn back IWW members who were trying to come into town.
The IWW members had done this in several cities or towns prior to this, and were not dissuaded by the show of force by the sheriff. The IWW opened a hall and became active. An official of one of the local lumber companies provided much of the leadership within the business community. It is important to note that the IWW members were usually not breaking any law when the newly sworn in deputies forced them to turn back. The sheriff and his deputies checked very carefully on nearly everyone entering the town to learn whether they were members or sympathizers of the IWW. Of course, attempts were made to evade the sheriff’s deputies. A group of IWW members and sympathizers went by train to the small town of Mukilteo, seven miles south of Everett. They then took a small vessel to Everett, but were intercepted by the sheriff and some of his deputies. Those aboard were hauled aboard the vessel the sheriff was on and taken to the jail for nine days.
Once again, a group of forty or so IWW members boarded a steamer on October 30, 1916 for Everett in an attempt to make speeches and agitate in favor of the strikers. A hundred or more deputies were waiting for them. The IWW members were transported a few miles south of the city to an area known as Beverly Park. The deputies formed a double line and forced the IWW members to run a gauntlet while they were beating at them with clubs or rifle butts. This presented a horrible scene with men bleeding and shouting and cursing. Eventually, the victims managed to board the interurban train, which ran between Everett and Seattle.
One can imagine how the other train passengers were shocked by seeing all of these bleeding and injured men stumbling aboard the train. The IWW did not give up, even after such a gross invasion of their civil rights under color of authority. The IWW chartered a vessel in Seattle called the Verona. Some of the men who boarded the Verona and a smaller accompanying steamer, the Calista, were armed because of what had taken place on their previous attempts to enter the city.
As the vessel approached the dock, they were accosted by three men: Sheriff McRae, Lieutenant Charles C. Curtis of the National Guard, and one of McRae’s deputies, Jefferson Beard. Sheriff McRae shouted, warning the passengers that they could not land in Everett. Shouts of disagreement came back from the passengers. Then a shot was fired.
It has been debated whether the first shot came from the dock or from the Verona. Sheriff McRae had a large number of uniformed men stationed back a slight distance from the edge of the dock to be used in the event the men defied the sheriff and actually attempted to disembark from the steamer. There was much gunfire coming from both directions. Sheriff McRae himself had a bullet strike his leg and his foot. The gunfire caused the passengers to rush to the side of the ship away from the dock, and this in turn caused the steamer to list so much that some passengers not only rolled across the deck, and through the railing and into the water. The Verona’s captain got the engines into reverse and freed the lines on the dock and was soon out of gun range. The passengers managed to warn those on the smaller vessel, the Calista, to turn back.
Two National Guard companies were sent to Everett. (One was Company M from Centralia.) It is possible that more people were killed since several passengers were in the water, but only five bodies of the IWW members and sympathizers were recovered. On shore, both Deputy Sheriff Beard and Lieutenant Curtis were killed. Law enforcement officials were waiting for the steamboat when it returned to Seattle, and seventy-four men were arrested. The two attorneys for the defendants were Fred H. Moore from Los Angeles and George F. Vanderveer of Seattle, the attorney who was now defending the Centralia Wobblies.
The Snohomish County prosecutor must have had a difficult time preparing his case for trial, because of the number of parties involved and the knowledge that there would be much contradictory testimony. It would unduly lengthen this discussion to go into detail about where people were standing and where the shots were fired from, but it was controversial. The point is that this was no longer a simple matter of giving a businessman a badge and a gun and a club and telling him to beat someone. This was a first-degree murder case, and the prosecutor’s presentation would be countered by two unusually able attorneys. As it turned out, the trial took about nine weeks, and it is difficult to imagine a nine week trial being required for each of the other 73 defendants. It would tie up the court system for years.
The trial was moved to King County, and the judge appointed was J.T. Ronald. Judge Ronald was very liberal in allowing testimony with regard to the events leading up to the Everett Massacre. Not only did much testimony come in about the episode of IWW members being forced to run the gauntlet in Beverly Park, but at a later time the judge actually had the jurors transported to Beverly Park so that they could see the actual scene where this took place. They were also transported to the very dock where the massacre occurred, and the Verona was navigated into the same position it was in when the shooting took place. The jury undoubtedly began to form opinions about the lines of sight from the steamboat to the dock, and whether it was possible for a person in a certain position to fire at the men on the dock. They were shown where the sheriff and the deputies claimed to be standing when the shooting took place.
It should be emphasized that when first-degree murder has been charged, the defense is usually given considerable leeway in the introduction of evidence.
After all of the weeks of trial, and after the testimony of countless witnesses, the jury deliberated for less than 24 hours to find the defendant not guilty. One can imagine the shock that this acquittal caused the business community and the lumber interests.
As will be seen, the case arising from the Centralia Massacre was also a case in which the defendants were charged with first-degree murder as a result of conspiracy, or, in the case of Elmer Smith, being an accessory. Unlike the Everett case, however, it was difficult or impossible for the defense attorney, Mr. Vanderveer, to introduce evidence which tended to show a conspiracy on the part of some members of the parade, including Warren Grimm. Again and again, his attempts to introduce such evidence were objected to and the objections were sustained by the judge. It seems very probable that the reason for the restrictive approach to the attempted admission of evidence by the defense to show a conspiracy by the Legion members arose from the acquittal involved in the Everett case. Judge Wilson and the prosecution were not going to follow the path of Judge Ronald in the case that arose in Everett.
Not surprisingly, the prosecution did what it could to discredit the labor jury, even before it rendered a “verdict.” One of the members of the “labor jury” was called as a witness by the defense counsel to corroborate some testimony of another witness. The state revealed by cross-examination that this member of the labor jury, the one from Centralia, had located at least one witness useful to the defense. There was an attempt to show partiality as a result of this action. It could, however, be argued that although it would be highly improper for a real jury member to suggest a witness for either side, these men were, in fact, not genuine jurors, but ordinary citizens, and each citizen has not only the right, but the duty, to provide the name of a witness which he feels would be necessary to do justice in the case involved. A labor juror was asked by the press if he felt the trial was fair, to which he replied in the affirmative. This was allegedly changed by the newspaper to read that the entire labor jury found the trial fair so far, even though it was the opinion of a single member. Nevertheless, the “labor jury” did render its “verdict” at the close of the case at about the same time that the official verdict came in. “The labor jury found the defendants not guilty.”
C.D. Cunningham had the opportunity to interview witnesses, interview the prisoners, and to consider what exhibits would be necessary to build the prosecution’s case. He was faced with a very interesting situation. After a few days, he must have realized that Warren Grimm was killed by the rifle shot fired from the Avalon Hotel, and that “John Doe” Davis was probably the one who fired that shot. He also knew that John Lamb and O.C. Bland both went to the room in the Arnold Hotel, and that O.C. Bland had the rifle, and that Lamb was unarmed. He must have also known that no shots were fired from the Arnold Hotel, since Bland seriously injured his hand at the time he broke the window, presumably in an effort to fire the shot. It was a very serious wound. No shells were found on the floor, apparently, and no shots were heard by the proprietor of the hotel. He also knew that the three riflemen on Seminary Hill, over a thousand feet away, all fired their weapons and that the type of bullet which killed McElfresh was fired by Loren Roberts, and Loren Roberts alone. Burt Bland is not known to have struck anyone with his rifle shots.
Ole Hanson, of course, got away and was never apprehended. He was certain that Dale Hubbard was killed by Wesley Everest, and that Everest killed Ben Casagranda as well when he first left the union hall and at first started to run south. Ironically, the knowledge did not help him to the extent that it should, if his goal was to convict all participants of first-degree murder. The one who killed Grimm was gone, Everest had been lynched, and Loren Roberts might well be judged insane. Undoubtedly, the object of C.D. Cunningham was to convict everyone with attorney Elmer Smith thrown into the bargain. The question was, how to do it?
The plan that C.D. Cunningham devised was to charge all of the defendants except Elmer Smith with conspiracy to commit first-degree murder. This would have the advantage of subjecting the seven Wobblies who were in the IWW hall actually defending themselves to a first-degree murder charge even if the raid on the hall preceded the pistol fire by defenders inside. It would also make prosecution easier against John Lamb and Burt Bland. The difference is you are not charging anyone except the perpetrator with the actual murder of Grimm, but you were charging the bunch of them, with the exception of Elmer Smith, with partaking in a conspiracy to wrongfully murder Warren Grimm, whether such person be in the Arnold Hotel, the Avalon Hotel, or on Seminary Hill, or in the union hall itself. Elmer Smith would be charged with being an accessory to first-degree murder.
The law enables one to defend one’s own home, and this would include not only Britt Smith but also the other IWW members who had a right to be there and assemble there and treated as a home away from home. If someone invaded the union hall and threatened either themselves or union hall property, they have a right to resist such an attempt by the use of force. There is a requirement that the threat to the person or property must be in the presence of the defendant. This would obviously exclude those on Seminary Hill and in the nearby hotels, since it would not be possible to argue that the threat to the union hall was “in their presence.” The state would only need to prove that one of them did actually murder Warren Grimm, and that such murder was done pursuant to a plan or scheme and that the others participated in it, even if they did not fire a shot.
The opening argument was given by Prosecutor Herman Allen. He stated that the case about to be tried would be one of the most important in the state’s history. George Vanderveer, in a brilliant move, interrupted Prosecutor Allen, and asked whether the prosecution would stand or fall on the contention that there had been no attack on the IWW hall before the firing began. Even though Prosecutor Allen was the one addressing the court, attorney Abel leaped to his feet and said, “We surely will.” He had fallen into Vanderveer’s trap. Under the state’s theory of the case, it did not matter whether the shooting was first or whether the charge to the hall was first, since the entire conspiracy was based on an illegal use of self-defense. Vanderveer had no right to interrupt the opening argument of the prosecutor, but decided to do so in hopes that someone would “take the bait.” Vanderveer no doubt felt that as the testimony developed, he would probably be able to show that the attack on the hall occurred prior to any shooting.
According to jurors’ statements, one of the first votes that was taken by the jury was on the question of whether the hall was attacked first or whether the shooting took place first. A majority decided that the attack on the hall took place first. This, of course, had no legal relevance, but Vanderveer, as a good trial lawyer, was aware that juries are not made up of lawyers, and want to deal a sort of “rough justice,” and that this might be important to them in making their decision, regardless of any instructions from the judge. (Except to appear once briefly as a witness, Prosecutor Allen was not heard from again during the entire lengthy case.)
In his opening statement he set forth what he expected to prove. The prosecution planned to bring several witnesses to prove that the person who murdered Warren Grimm was Eugene Barnett. They also planned to show that there was a scheme for firing at the paraders from hotels on the opposite sides of the street, as well from Seminary Hill. Several witnesses were later called in an attempt to identify Eugene Barnett with varying results. Two of the witnesses were not too sure whether Barnett was, in fact, the person who had the gun near the Avalon Hotel. The third witness, Charles Briffett, who was the superintendent of schools of Port Angeles, Washington, seemed quite sure of himself.
It is significant that none of the witnesses picked Mr. Barnett from a photo array. They were, apparently, shown photographs of Eugene Barnett or taken to the jail and it is not known whether Eugene Barnett was specifically pointed out to them. One of the witnesses seemed unsure to the extent that the witness did not point out Mr. Barnett in court. There were several witnesses who testified that the shooting from the hall started before there was any break in the ranks of the paraders. One of those who testified was Clyde Tisdale, who was sitting in a car parked on Second Street at the southwest corner of the intersection with Tower Avenue. He too indicated that the shooting started before there was any break in the ranks. Years later, he signed an affidavit admitting that he had committed perjury by so stating. In fact, he stated in the affidavit that there was a break in the ranks before there was any shooting from the hall.
The prosecution got the statement (termed confession by the newspapers) of Loren Roberts. The statement of Roberts was read to the jury, but the judge stated that Roberts’ statement should be used only with regard to him, Roberts, since insanity was an issue in the case. Tom Morgan, one of the men in the hall, agreed to testify as a state’s witness. Morgan stated that the shots were fired in the hall before the paraders broke ranks. The state attempted to prove by Morgan’s testimony that there was a prearranged plan which involved stationing riflemen in nearby hotels. Morgan testified that on the morning of the parade, Elmer Smith came to the hall and discussed the defense of the hall with Britt Smith. Morgan stated that he saw Britt Smith gesturing across the street toward the Avalon and Arnold Hotels in an effort to indicate that attorney Smith was aware of the plan that would be used to defend the hall.
Towards the end of the state’s case, T.H. McCleary testified that he carried a rope in the parade. He stated he found it in the street between Pine and Main Street, and that he picked it up and Mr. Rhodes took hold of it and it came apart. “We had no idea to hang anybody with the rope,” he added.
At the close of the state’s case, Vanderveer asked that the charges be dismissed against Sheehan, Becker, Faulkner, and McInerney, as well as Elmer Smith. This had previously been denied, but the motion was renewed by Vanderveer. Judge Wilson did grant the motion with regard to Faulkner. From that point on he was no longer a defendant, and was free to go. “Go take a seat in the audience with your mother,” said Vanderveer. Finally, the last of the 147 witnesses for the prosecution was called, and the state rested.
Attorney George Vanderveer stated in his opening statement that he would prove the following facts: First, that Eugene Barnett was not in the Avalon Hotel. Second, that Loren Roberts was insane (and therefore any statements made by him could not be used against any of the other defendants.) Third, that Mike Sheehan was not in the hall before Monday night, and therefore took no part in planning for the defense of the hall. Fourth, he would prove that a raid on the hall was planned a few days before by Commercial Club members and other businessmen, and that the IWW members were fully justified in expecting the raid, and were entitled to make preparations to defend themselves. Finally, that the raid on the hall started before any guns were fired, and that Warren Grimm was one of the raid’s leaders.
The trial was unusual in that all of the defendants testified except for Loren Roberts, who was supposedly insane, and Ray Becker. Eugene Barnett himself led off for the defense and denied that he was in the Avalon Hotel at any time. He stated that he was in the hotel adjoining the union hall with the hotel owners, Mr. and Mrs. McAllister. He was present there when the raid on the hall took place. He claimed he knew nothing about the proposed defense on the union hall, and took no part in it. Other witnesses were called to back up Barnett’s version.
At this point in the trial, something very unusual occurred. On March 1st, eighty fully equipped soldiers arrived from a train and set up a campsite in the open space near the city hall. Prosecutor Herman Allen stated that the troops were there pursuant to a request he had made to Governor Hart. Attorney Vanderveer registered an objection in the strongest terms possible to the presence of the soldiers, claiming that they created an atmosphere which tended to indicate that the IWW constituted a threat to the jurors and to the legal system. Judge Wilson took no action on the matter despite the strong objections of defense counsel.
A number of other defendants testified as well as other witnesses who emphasized that the raid on the hall started before any shooting began. Mrs. McAllister, the proprietress of the union hall, pointed out that she had sought protection from the chief of police after she had heard of the danger of a raid. Mr. McAllister also testified as to the presence of Eugene Barnett at the Roderick Hotel, which adjoined the union hall.
One of the important witnesses of the defense was Dr. F.J. Bickford. He admitted that the attack on the hall had begun before he heard any shots fired. Bickford was one of the uniformed paraders, and he admitted actually rushing toward the hall and heard gunfire coming from the hall after someone ahead of him had pushed hard on the door to the hall. His testimony was particularly significant because it repeated the statement he had given at a coroner’s inquest shortly after the massacre and before there was time to “cook up” testimony later on.
By the end of the trial, the defense admitted that the shot which killed Warren Grimm had come from the Avalon Hotel. However, the only person who was in the Avalon Hotel, according to the defendants, was “John Doe” Davis, who had never been apprehended. Two of the witnesses testified to the effect that Warren Grimm or someone resembling him was actively either rushing the union hall or was injured and holding his stomach and running away from the door to the union hall. In other words, they testified as to Grimm’s active involvement in the illegal rush on the hall. The prosecuting attorney’s office immediately issued warrants of arrest for the two who testified, charging them with perjury. This was done in a very public fashion. It was interpreted by Attorney Vanderveer as a trick to frighten other witnesses into not testifying. The two perjury charges were later dropped, lending some credence to this interpretation. When Attorney DeWitt Wycoff helped compose the final report of the Federal Council of Churches, he stated that the judge had the power to find in contempt anyone using improper tactics. This was a strong hint that he felt that such actions taken by the prosecuting attorney should have been punished by contempt of court.
On March 13th, the judge read the instructions to the jury and counsel made final argument. The jury, after deliberating all day, reached the following verdict:
Elmer Smith, acquitted
Mike Sheehan, acquitted
Loren Roberts, guilty, but insane
Britt Smith, guilty of murder in the second degree
D.C. Bland, guilty of murder in the second degree
James McInerney, guilty of murder in the second degree
Bert Bland, guilty of murder in the second degree
Ray Becker, guilty of murder in the second degree
Eugene Barnett, guilty of murder in the third degree.
John Lamb, guilty of murder in the third degree.
Judge Wilson refused to accept the verdict, saying that there is no such thing as “third degree murder.” Nor is manslaughter applicable, because manslaughter pertains to a death resulting from an unintentional and unpremeditated act. The jurors resumed their deliberations for a few hours more, and emerged with a new verdict. The new verdict was the same, except that it found Eugene Barnett and John Lamb also guilty of murder in the second degree. In addition, the following sentence was attached to the jury verdict: “We, the undersigned jurors, respectfully petition the court to extend the leniency to the defendants whose names appear on the attached verdict.”
As it turned out, the judge did not see fit to extend any leniency to the defendants, and sentenced the eight IWW members to twenty-five years and not more than forty years. This was considered a very harsh sentence, since the statute provides that there shall be a minimum sentence of ten years. The sentence was nevertheless legal and binding, since Judge Wilson was not required to follow the petition for leniency. The appeal by Vanderveer to the state Supreme Court was denied.
A campaign that lasted almost twenty years to free the Centralia prisoners got underway. James McInerney was still in prison when he died of tuberculosis on August 13, 1930. The remaining prisoners were freed as follows: Loren Roberts was declared sane by a jury and was the first prisoner released on August 20, 1930 after serving nearly eleven years. On May 27, 1931, Eugene Barnett became the second man to leave prison to assist and tend to his dying wife. (He was never returned to prison.) O.C. Bland was released on parole December 26, 1932. Newly elected Governor Clarence Martin paroled John Lamb on April 13, 1933, Britt Smith on June 24, 1933, and Bert Bland on July 1, 1933.
Ray Becker, the sole remaining prisoner, refused to accept parole. Finally, his sentence was commuted to time already served on September 20, 1939. Becker had been behind bars for almost twenty years. He was taken to Portland, Oregon, and treated like a labor martyr by the American Federation of Labor. Elmer Smith, who was acquitted, died in 1932 of a hemorrhaging ulcer at the age of forty-four.”
Ray Becker came to live at the home of his old IWW comrade, John F. McKay, after his release; my partner Theresa’s father Gene grew up with his example, a man who had been imprisoned for twenty years because he refused to give up the names of fellow union men to the police and refused to accept a pardon which required admission of guilt and recognition of the legitimate authority of the state.
This is who I think of when I speak of solidarity and of the Oath of the Resistance as given to me by Jean Genet in Beirut in 1982; “We swear our loyalty to each other, to resist and yield not, and abandon not our fellows.”
One of the things this means is never give up anyone to the police; another is that justice is a thing held between equals and not a relation of authority and the state to individuals and citizens, for law serves power and there is no just authority.
Gene spoke of Ray Becker as an exemplar of the brotherhood of labor as a firewall against the inherently predatory nature of capitalism, of the fragile and hollow nature of power, force, and control when met with disobedience, and of the contingency of authority and legitimacy which requires the recognition and consent of its subjects as appropriation of power or becomes nothingness when met with refusal to submit.
Here’s to you, Ray Becker, the man who refused to name names. If he can hold for twenty years of isolation and torture, can we all not stand in solidarity with our comrades, whatever the cost may be?
As written by Steven C. Beda in The Washington Post, in an article entitled
Why the massacre at Centralia 100 years ago is critically important today
Working-class radicalism once transcended nativist division — and can do so again; “
Today marks the 100th anniversary of a key event in American labor history: the Centralia massacre.
It was actually less a massacre and more a shootout between the American Legion and the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), a radical union whose members were better known as Wobblies. Taking place in Centralia, Wash., the conflict resulted in the death of four Legionnaires and the lynching of one IWW member. Although Centralia’s Wobblies claimed they had acted in self-defense, a jury convicted seven Wobblies of inciting violence at Centralia, and the federal government began a massive effort across the nation to try to wipe out working-class radicalism.
Though it happened a century ago, the Centralia massacre still has lessons for today: When fears of immigrants, outsiders and others dominates politics, violence and repression soon follow.
The Centralia massacre occurred at the tail end of the largest immigration wave in American history. Between 1880 and 1924, more than 20 million people came to the United States, mostly from Eastern European and Mediterranean countries. While these immigrants filled the hardest, lowest-paying and most dangerous jobs in America’s industries, native-born whites had little sympathy for them. Instead, native-born whites imagined all sorts of intellectual and physical differences between themselves and these immigrants that, they said, justified their economically marginal positions.
Nativist conspiracy theories also fueled anti-immigrant sentiment. Industrialists like Henry Ford and leading thinkers like Madison Grant imagined that the pope or mysterious Jewish cabals were planning to overrun America with immigrants. Even President Theodore Roosevelt worried that white Americans were committing “race suicide,” effectively allowing themselves to be outbred by more reproductively fecund immigrants.
The IWW challenged these ideas, however. Unlike most labor unions in the early 20th century, which excluded everyone except native-born, white, skilled men, the Wobblies swung their doors wide open to any and all workers, immigrant and native-born alike. The Wobblies said the entire working-class, regardless of race, ethnicity and gender, suffered equally under capitalism and had much to gain by working together to overthrow it.
The union’s anti-capitalist politics and policy of inclusion quickly earned it the ire of business magnates and politicians. Employers in the early 20th century maintained their power by keeping workers divided. As long as white workers fought black workers and immigrant workers fought native-born workers, no one was fighting the boss. Political leaders who were often beholden to America’s industrialists were just as invested in maintaining this system.
The Wobblies threatened to undo this order.
The IWW eventually spread throughout the country, but no matter where it went, conflict and violence often followed. In Utah, the famous Wobbly Joe Hill was arrested, convicted and executed by firing squad on a flimsy murder charge in 1915. Five Wobblies were killed in the Everett massacre of 1916. Seventeen IWW members were tarred and feathered in Tulsa in 1917. That same year, more than 1,000 Wobblies were rounded up, put on a train car, then taken to and left in the middle of the desert after they’d tried to organize a union in Bisbee, Ariz.
World War I only intensified native-born Americans’ disdain for the IWW. Many white Americans believed the war had been started by the sort of Eastern European radicals that the IWW was now organizing and that their continued activism threatened to bring that disorder to America’s shores. Yes, Woodrow Wilson said it was a war to “make the world safe for democracy” — but he didn’t believe immigrants should be equal participants in that democratic order. “Any man who carries a hyphen about with him,” Wilson said, “carries a dagger that he is ready to plunge into the vitals of the Republic when he gets ready.”
In places like Centralia, where the strength of the timber industry gave birth to a strong IWW presence, this heightened combination of nativism and WWI-fueled xenophobia proved deadly. Nov. 11, 1919, was supposed to be a celebration in Centralia. The town’s American Legion had organized a parade of World War I veterans through town. Yet many of Centralia’s World War I veterans were not in a celebratory mood. As they saw it, the Wobbly’s continued presence in town was an affront to their efforts in the war against outside forces of radicalism.
The Armistice Day parade through town started peacefully enough. Initially the marchers followed the intended parade route, right through downtown. But then the parade’s marchers diverted course and marched several blocks, right to the IWW hall.
Centralia’s Wobblies knew the march was probably the prologue to violence, and they’d armed themselves as a precautionary measure. For several tense minutes, Wobblies and Legionnaires traded insults and taunts. Then someone — we don’t know who — opened fire. A melee of bullets followed, and when the shooting finally ended, four Legionnaires were dead.
Local law enforcement showed up and charged the IWW hall, arresting most of the union’s members. One Wobbly, Wesley Everest, made a break for it, killing one police officer before he was finally caught and put in jail. That evening, the lights in Centralia suddenly went out. When they came back on, Everest’s dead body was hanging from a bridge in town.
That the Wobblies acted more out of self-defense than aggression didn’t matter much in the aftermath. The press told a story about the Wobblies as violent, bomb-throwing radicals intent on upending the American political and economic order. It was a story many Americans, primed by decades of xenophobia, nationalism and conspiracy theories about immigrants were willing to buy.
One of those was a young man, fresh out of law school and recently hired by the Justice Department: J. Edgar Hoover. Hearing of the massacre, he convinced his boss, Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer, that the Wobblies were driving the country into chaos and that they needed to be stopped. With Palmer’s approval, Hoover orchestrated raids on IWW halls across the country.
The Palmer Raids marked the beginning of America’s First Red Scare, a roughly two-year period when the federal government jailed Wobblies and other radical activists on contrived charges, deported immigrant radicals, and raided the halls and meeting places of several unions, all with the goal of wiping out working-class radicalism.
The raids earned Hoover esteem in the ranks of federal law enforcement, and in 1924 he became director of the FBI, where he continued to suppress radical movements, from the American Communist Party in the 1950s to civil rights activists in the 1960s and 1970s.
The Centralia massacre thus marked the end for the IWW as a major force in American politics and a new era of political repression in America. Today it should remind us that when a nation lets fear drive its politics, suppression soon follows.
But even if the Wobblies went into decline after Centralia, their message of inclusion and working-class solidarity across race, gender and ethnicity continued to inspire activists for decades to come. Union activists in the Depression era, student activists in the 1960s and anti-apartheid activists in the 1980s all evoked the memory of Centralia and the Wobblies as a reminder that their struggles were part of a rich tradition of American radicalism that, though repressed, was never eradicated.
So at the same time that we might remember the massacre today as a morality tale about the dangers that lurk behind xenophobia and nationalism, it should also remind us of the potential power people have when they unite against these forces.”
As written by Aaron Goings, Brian Barnes, and Roger Snider in Counterpunch, in an article entitled Class War Violence: Centralia 1919; “November 11, 2019, will mark the 100-year anniversary of the Armistice Day Tragedy in Centralia, Washington, a horrible event in Pacific Northwest history. On Armistice Day, 1919, a mob of American Legionaires raided the Centralia Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) hall and later lynched Wesley Everest, an IWW logger.
Many Pacific Northwest residents remain engaged in debates about the facts of the incident. Unfortunately, it’s common to hear calls for “balance” in discussions of the tragedy. Balance? Balance between the perspectives of the vigilante lynch mob and the working-class radicals fighting to form a union? Balance between the wealthy men who raided union halls and lynched Wesley Everest, and those who struggled to improve their worklives?
Those who support the employer, vigilante, and American Legion perspective are in luck. In downtown Centralia, they have a monument to the bosses who terrorized working-class radicals throughout the Pacific Northwest. Walking through downtown Centralia today, it’s difficult to miss the massive “Sentinel” statue, a tribute to the American Legion vigilantes who died while attacking the IWW hall.
Rejecting the false “balance” between working-class activist and employing-class vigilante, Brian Barnes and Roger Snider joined me in penning The Red Coast: Radicalism and Anti-Radicalism in Southwest Washington, published earlier this year by Oregon State University Press. We aimed to provide a working-class perspective on many of the labor struggles of the early twentieth century Pacific Northwest, including the Armistice Day Tragedy in Centralia. What follows is a chapter from the book entitled “Class War: Centralia 1919.”
“Around Centralia are wooded hills; men have been beaten beneath these trees and lynched from them. The beautiful Chehalis River flows near by; Wesley Everest was left dangling from one of its bridges. But Centralia is provokingly pretty for all that. It is small wonder that lumber trust henchmen wish to keep it all for themselves.” – Ralph Chaplin, The Centralia Conspiracy
The Centralia American Legion and the leading businessmen of that city had more than a parade in mind when they gathered on November 11, 1919, to celebrate Armistice Day. Apparently believing that the spectacle of political violence would enhance the patriotic experience, they concocted a plan to raid the Centralia IWW Hall. IWW halls were of great practical and symbolic importance to workers. As Wobbly activist and historian Ralph Chaplin explains, the halls were loved by workers, but despised by employers. These “churches of the movement,” as public historian Robert Weyeneth called them, represented the closest thing to a home for many wandering IWW members. Chaplin noted:
“It is here the men can gather around a crackling wood fire, smoke their pipes and warm their souls with the glow of comradeship. Here they can, between jobs or after work, discuss the vicissitudes of their daily lives, read their books and magazines and sing their songs of solidarity, or merely listen to the “tinned” humor or harmony of the much prized Victrola. Also they here attend to the affairs of their union—line up members, hold business and educational meetings and a weekly “open forum.”
So, as the parading legionnaires passed the hall for the second time, they paused, then charged the hall, only to be surprised by the spirited defense they encountered. A volley of gunfire dropped three of the attackers, but the mob continued to press home its attack, capturing the hall. One additional legionnaire was killed in pursuit of Wesley Everest, who escaped out the back but was later captured and dragged by the neck to the jail. Later that night, he joined the ranks of IWW martyrs when he was lynched at the hands of Centralia businessmen and patriots, none of whom were ever prosecuted for his gruesome murder.
The Armistice Day 1919 Centralia event is perhaps the single most written about event involving the IWW in the entire state of Washington. Analysis of the event has been extremely polarized, as interests representing the employing class and the working class have contested its meaning. And because of competing accounts, affidavits, and testimony, even some of the most basic facts of the case will probably never be established conclusively. What is perfectly clear is that the Centralia story must be understood in the context of the class struggle that had been raging on the Red Coast for over a decade and which had surfaced in Centralia since at least 1914. As all of the working-class accounts of the Centralia event note, violence and lawlessness were defining characteristics of the employers’ approach to this conflict.
The IWW served as the most logical target of employers’ violence and repression because, since its inception in 1905, it represented the most advanced, class conscious, and revolutionary element of the working class in this country. The patriotic fervor of the First World War and fear that the Russian Revolution would heighten class consciousness among American workers only intensified persecution of the Wobblies. Sensing an opportunity, employers engaged both the state and the public in their efforts to crush the hated IWW. Nationally, the federal government enforced the wartime Espionage and Sedition Acts against the IWW and other radicals to imprison and deport many. In September of 1917, the federal government raided IWW halls across the country and indicted more than 160 leaders of the organization.
At the state and local level, class warfare raged as employers mobilized both the state and the mob to lash out at class-conscious workers. Washington State was one of the great theaters of this conflict, as the teens witnessed the Grays Harbor and Pacific County Lumber Strike of 1912, multiple free speech fights, the 1916 Everett Massacre, and the 1919 Seattle General Strike.
In Centralia, this war against workers effectively merged employers’ traditional weapons—a cooperative police, a captive legal system, and vigilante citizens’ committees—with the anti-radicalism and patriotism of the American Legion, a veterans’ organization at the fore of anti-radical activities.
The American Legion described Centralia like this: “The city is the center of a rich timber district and the logging camps of the northwest are infested with bearers of the red card, who boast that in many districts membership in the I.W.W. is a requisite to employment.” The leadership of the Centralia Legion read like a roster of Centralia businessmen and the Legion became essentially a front organization, even the vanguard, for Northwest lumber bosses. In the words of Wobbly Ralph Chaplin, “The American Legion began to function as a cat’s paw for the men behind the scenes.” Indeed, there was nothing secret about the role of the Legion in the class war. The National Commander of the American Legion declared in 1923: “If ever needed, the American Legion stands ready to protect our country’s institutions and ideals as the Fascisti dealt with the destructionists who menaced Italy. . . . Do not forget that the Fascisti are to Italy what the American Legion is to the United States.”
Representatives of capital did not shy away from class conflict. An IWW organizer was run out of Centralia by the sheriff in 1914, and in early 1915 more Wobblies were “escorted” out of town by police and vigilantes. According to historian John McClelland, the local paper, the Centralia Chronicle, applauded anti-Wobbly repression and stated that it was everyone’s responsibility to keep rebel workers out of Centralia. Tom Lassiter, a partially blind newsstand operator whose stock included labor and radical papers, was victimized by the business interest on several occasions. At various times, his radical papers were destroyed, he was threatened, arrested, kidnapped, and dumped in a ditch. Yet no one was ever prosecuted for any of these acts of class violence. In Centralia, it was clear, the law was a weapon in the hands of the propertied class.
Perhaps inevitably, class conflict in Centralia came to center on the struggle to establish and defend an IWW union hall. As Chaplin notes, the “union halls were a standing challenge to their [the employers’] hitherto undisputed right to the complete domination of the forests. . . . They were not going to tolerate the encroachments of the One Big Union of the lumber workers.” In 1917, an IWW attempt to establish a hall was met with great hostility in the employer-dominated town, and the landlord evicted the Wobblies on learning of their identity. In the spring of 1918, Centralia employers targeted the town’s new IWW hall. During a Red Cross parade, prominent businessmen, including members of the Centralia Elks, and political officials attacked and destroyed it. They beat IWW members and burned hall property and records in a street bonfire. F. B. Hubbard, the most prominent of the Centralia timber barons and president of the Washington Employers’ Association, stole the desk from the Wobbly Hall and donated it to the local Chamber of Commerce. Despite the intimidation of the business leaders, the local IWW secretary, Britt Smith, opened a new hall on north Tower Avenue on September 1, 1919. It was clear for all to see that the IWW was not easily intimidated, but neither were their enemies.
In July 1919, George Russell, secretary of the Washington Employers’ Association, called a meeting of the Centralia Chamber of Commerce to find a way to destroy the IWW. F. B. Hubbard was picked to head a group designed to accomplish that objective. Although this was not the first meeting of Centralia business interests to combat the Wobbly threat, it marked a new level of organization on the part of capital that would not tolerate the affront the new IWW Hall afforded to its dominance.
Plans to rid themselves of the enemy intensified with the formation of the Centralia Citizens Protective Association, the purpose of which, according to one local paper, was “to combat IWW activities in this vicinity.” Local businessmen were members of the Chamber of Commerce, the Centralia Elks, and the American Legion; many belonged to more than one of these organizations. Although the plans called for greater secrecy as to the specific methods to rid themselves of the Wobblies, too many people were aware of the plans to keep it secret. Word began to leak out, and soon it became public knowledge that the IWW would be driven out of town. Once the Armistice Day Parade was planned, the Wobblies knew that this was the pretense to attack their hall, destroy their property, and assault them.
Initially, IWW members acted with uncommon prudence in attempting to prevent a violent attack on their hall. The owners of the Roderick Hotel, which housed the union hall and from whom the IWW rented, went to the local police with information about the planned attack. IWW members requested police protection. A trusted attorney, Elmer Smith, sought help from Governor Louis F. Hart in Olympia. The Wobblies even made a desperate appeal to the entire community. They distributed a lengthy handbill “to the law-abiding citizens of Centralia and to the working class in general,” which said, in part, “The profiteering class of Centralia have of late been waving the flag of our country in an endeavor to incite the lawless element of our city to raid our hall and club us out of town.” But Wobbly pleas to avoid violence fell on deaf ears, and the police chief declined protection.
Finally, as a last resort, the Wobblies sought legal advice from attorney Elmer Smith to determine whether they had the legal right to defend their hall with arms. Smith affirmed that they did. This was a major move on the part of the IWW. Although it had always shown remarkable restraint, the IWW was a defiant and proud group of class-conscious workers, and by November 1919 in Centralia Washington the Wobblies had had enough of the beatings, enough of the tar and featherings, enough of the destruction of their meager property, enough of the humiliation, and enough of the criminally brutal business-patriotic element. They would defend their hall, and plans for its self-defense were laid. Radical historian Harvey O’Conner opined: “Prudent men, valuing their own skins, would have closed the hall in the face of the obvious threat. But prudence was not a Wobbly trait. Rather their shining glory stood out
in audacity, courage, and stubbornness in defense of their rights, and for that they are remembered in history.”
As the Armistice Day Parade got under way on the drizzly and ill-fated afternoon of November 11, 1919, the Wobblies made ready to defend their hall. They positioned armed men inside the hall and also in three locations outside the hall: in the Avalon and Arnold Hotels on the opposite (east) side of the street, and on Seminary Hill which overlooked the street from some considerable distance away. The parade route took the marchers north on Tower Avenue past the main business district to Third Street, the next side street past the IWW Hall, in a section of town occupied by businesses catering to the working class. At Third Street the marchers reversed direction to return now southbound on Tower Avenue with the Centralia American Legion contingent making up the rear of the parade. In front of the IWW Hall, the marchers paused and then rushed the hall.
Shots rang out from the hall and then from Seminary Hill and the Avalon Hotel. Three Legionnaires—Warren Grimm, Arthur McElfresh, and Ben Cassagranda—received fatal wounds on the streets near the hall, and Dale Hubbard, the nephew of the lumbar baron F. B. Hubbard, was shot by a fleeing Wesley Everest at the edge of the Skookumchuck river. Hubbard died later that night. Several other marchers were injured, and the IWW Hall was smashed and its contents dragged to the street and burned. Wesley Everest was severely beaten and dragged back into town and thrown in a heap on the jail floor. One of the marchers who pursued Everest to the river and presumably helped drag him to the jail was Legionnaire Ed Cunningham, who was picked by the American Legion to become the Special Prosecutor in the trial against the Centralia Wobblies. According to the Legion account, “Cunningham was able to use his first-hand knowledge of the tragedy to telling effect.”
In many of their clashes with the working class, employers hired detective agencies or relied on local or state police to combat workers, but in Centralia the American Legion served as the armed guard of the employing class. As news of the event spread, the American Legion assumed control of the town, controlled the flow of information, formed vigilante groups to hunt down suspected Wobblies, and raided establishments and homes. In touting the Legion takeover, the American Legion Weekly stated, “Though the office of the Sheriff and the Chief of Police assisted as much as possible, their forces were small and their aid nominal,” and “Posses which scoured the country about Centralia in search of fugitives were made up almost exclusively of American Legion men”
That evening, two meetings were held at the Elks Club in which the murder of Wesley Everest was conceivably planned. At about five o’clock a group of men was told to go the armory for weapons and return to the Elks at six o’clock. At the six o’clock meeting, all assembled men who were not members of the Elks or the American Legion were asked to leave. In effect, this left the established business class and the Legion, those that could most be trusted to carry out a class lynching and protect those involved in it. This meeting lasted until about seven o’clock. At seven-thirty, someone visited the city’s power station and shut off all the lights in Centralia. Meanwhile, a lynching party entered the jail where Wesley Everest was held. The lynching party—meeting no opposition from the jailer—seized Everest and dragged him to a waiting automobile.
The automobile that held Everest fell in with a procession of automobiles containing Centralia’s most prominent citizens, and proceeded to the Chehalis River Bridge. Radical author Harvey O’Conner graphically described the scene:
“At the bridge Everest was dragged out and rope knotted around his neck, and his body flung over. Everest clutched at a plank; Legionnaires stamped on his fingers, and he fell. Dissatisfied with the knot, the lynchers pulled the body back up and used a longer rope, and hurled the body over again. Still dissatisfied, they hauled Everest body up a third time—by then he must have been dead—and tied a more professional knot on a longer rope and flung the body over. Then with carlights playing on the scene, they amused themselves awhile by shooting at the swaying body. Satiated at last, the mob left and darkness returned. Next morning somebody cut the rope and the body fell into the Chehalis River.”
The next day, Everest’s mutilated body was retrieved from the river, dumped on the jail floor, and left for two days in plain view of his imprisoned fellow workers. As Centralia’s authorities were no doubt complicit in the lynching, no attempt was ever made to bring the Everest’s murderers to justice. As the Legion-led posses combed the surrounding area for more Wobblies, state authorities interrogated the jailed Wobblies by day as the enraged mobs terrorized them by night. In the woods surrounding Centralia, one posse member was shot and killed when he was mistaken by another for a Wobbly. This shooting, first reported as a murder committed by a Wobbly, was later ruled an accident.
As this reign of terror continued in southwest Washington, the commercial press continued to churn out propagandistic accounts of how the Wobblies ambushed and murdered America’s finest young men in the streets of Centralia. Characteristic of this treatment was the front-page article in the Chehalis Bee-Nugget: “IWW Shoot into Armistice Day Parade in Centralia Tuesday. Warren Grimm, Arthur McElfresh, Dale Hubbard, and Ben Cassagranda Killed by the Assassins.” Authorities, businessmen, and Legionnaires combined to attack workers in other parts of the state and in neighboring Oregon. In Seattle, the Department of Justice seized the Union Record, the official organ of the Seattle Central Labor Council, and arrested its staff, including Harry Ault and Anna Louise Strong, on charges of sedition.
The passions that this class war engendered were still highly visible on January 26, 1920, when eleven Wobblies, including Elmer Smith, the attorney who advised the IWW members that they had the legal right to defend their hall, were brought to trial in the town of Montesano, the county seat of neighboring Grays Harbor County. The defense faced many obstacles in the trial, beginning with a huge resource disparity. The Wobblies were represented by George Vanderveer with occasional help from his law partner, Ralph Pierce, and attorney Elmer Smith, himself a defendant in the case. Meanwhile, Special Prosecutor Ed Cunningham led a staff of six attorneys, whom Vanderveer referred to as the attorneys for the lumber trust. The Luke May Secret Service, a private detective agency paid for by lumber company funds, aided them.
Finally, the American Legion recruited some fifty uniformed veterans to sit in on the trial by day, presumably to influence the jury. They were paid four dollars a day from funds contributed by the lumber companies and the Elks. The prosecution certainly lived up to its reputation as the counsel for the lumber trust. Special Prosecutor Cunningham was himself deeply involved in the Armistice Day violence. He was one of the members of the mob that pursued Everest to the Skookumchuck River and helped drag him to jail. He watched while the mob broke into the jail and kidnapped Everest, and was alleged to have witnessed his murder. Historian Tom Copeland observed that “as Cunningham built the case against the Wobblies, he was also shielding himself from any potential legal action for his role in the raid and lynching.”
Cunningham’s team successfully fought off a change of venue request, claiming there was no prejudice against the IWW in either Centralia or Montesano. In a clear attempt to intimidate anyone willing to testify for the defense, the prosecution had two defense witnesses arrested for perjury when they finished their testimony. The prosecution called on the governor to have troops from Camp Lewis sent to Montesano to stand guard outside the courtroom, thereby frightening the jury into thinking that an IWW attack was imminent.
The trial was, in fact, a mere extension of the class war, a political trial in which the authorities put the IWW on trial while pretending to adhere to the rule of law. The judge, John M. Wilson, insisted that he could try the case impartially, despite the fact that he had delivered an anti-IWW speech in the nearby town of Bucoda and had addressed the memorial service at the Centralia Elks commemorating the Legionnaires who had been killed during the Armistice Day Parade. Wilson rejected the defense’s request for a change of venue from Montesano, disallowed much of the evidence that Vanderveer tried to introduce during the trial, and made numerous prejudicial rulings that favored the prosecution and infuriated the defense. Vanderveer captured the trial’s essence in his closing statement. The prosecutors, he told the jury, “have told you this was a murder trial, and not a labor trial. But vastly more than the lives of ten men are the stakes in the big gamble here; for the right of workers to organize for the bettering of their own condition is on trial; the right of free assemblage is on trial; democracy and Americanism are on trial.”
“In view of such a charged atmosphere,” Albert Gunns contended, “the final verdict of the jury was moderate.” The prosecution sought a first-degree murder verdict for all of the defendants, but the jury did not agree. Elmer Smith, the Wobbly attorney, was acquitted, along with one other defendant. Seven defendants were convicted of second-degree murder, and one young defendant was judged legally insane. The jury attached to their verdict a written request for leniency in sentencing, but Judge Wilson rendered stiff sentences ranging from 25 to 40 years in the state penitentiary in Walla Walla.
Irish immigrant James McInerney, himself a veteran of the Everett Massacre and victim of torture while in the Centralia jail, died while imprisoned, “murdered,” the Industrial Worker proclaimed, “by the Capitalist class.” Most of the remaining prisoners remained incarcerated until 1933, when Governor Clarence Martin commuted their sentences.
Several jurors were clearly uneasy with their decision, believing that they were not allowed to hear all of the important evidence. “Remarkably, two years after the trial,” Robert Weyeneth concludes, “seven of the twelve jurors voluntarily repudiated their verdict.” No member of the employing class or its “cat paws” was ever charged or even investigated for Everest’s murder or the Armistice Day hall raid that ushered in the Centralia Tragedy.”
We can be killed, imprisoned, tortured, but we cannot be defeated so long as we cede nothing to the enemy. Who refuses to submit becomes Unconquered and free.
Disobey and disbelieve, for there is no just authority.
As the anarchist philosopher Max Stirner wrote; “Freedom cannot be granted; it must be seized.”
As to the meaning and value of America’s armed services and anyone who wears our flag on their uniform in all of this, and the human beings caught in the gears of a machine as the raw material of elite wealth, power, and privilege, though the relationship of any enforcer of virtue or of authority is one of loaned power and exploitation, there is grandeur and nobility of purpose in placing ones life in the balance with those of our fellow citizens and others who cannot secure their own rights but must rely on the allyship and solidarity of others, and of service to the idea of America as a free society of equals who are guarantors of each other’s rights, regardless of our flaws and the space between our ideals and our history. For only we can make it real, this mad dream of liberty, equality, truth, and justice.
In the words of Colonel Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain to the mutineers in the film Gettysburg; “This is a different kind of army. If you look back through history, you will see men fighting for pay, for women, for some other kind of loot. They fight for land, power, because a king leads them or — or just because they like killing.
But we are here for something new. This has not happened much in the history of the world. We are an army out to set other men free. America should be free ground — all of it. Not divided by a line between slave state and free — all the way, from here to the Pacific Ocean. No man has to bow. No man born to royalty. Here, we judge you by what you do, not by who your father was. Here, you can be something. Here, is the place to build a home. But it’s not the land. There’s always more land. It’s the idea that we all have value — you and me. What we’re fighting for, in the end, we’re fighting for each other.”
On this anniversary of the Wilmington Massacre of 1898, an incident of white supremacist terror of which the ICE white supremacist terror force now unleashed upon us in a mad campaign of ethnic cleansing is an echo and reflection, I find new relevance of the principle By Any Means Necessary.
For all Resistance is War to the Knife, and who respects no laws and no limits, no bonds of brotherhood, may hide behind none.
History shadows our lives, and can teach us much that remains relevant and useful; but only if we bear witness, seek the truth, question and expose authority, and remember.
For Silence Is Complicity.
We wander in a Wilderness of Mirrors; lies, falsifications, illusions, diversions, rewritten histories, alternate realities, wherein each other’s voices are the only lighthouses of warning and guidance, and we must hold our voices as fragments of ourselves which we cannot abandon while remaining human.
Let us amplify and exalt each other in solidarity, for we are all embedded in multiple systems of oppression whose objective is to dehumanize us and steal our souls.
As written by Daniel R Biddle in The Guardian, in an article entitled The Wilmington massacre of 1898: a shocking episode of racist violence:
North Carolina city marks 125th anniversary of the white-supremacist attack with a week of memorial events; “In the late 1890s, Wilmington, North Carolina, a port city between the Atlantic’s barrier islands and the banks of the Cape Fear River, became an island of hope for a new America.
Residents of the city’s thriving Black community made themselves a political force, exercising the rights of citizenship guaranteed to them after the civil war by the 13th, 14th and 15th amendments. Across the south, such activity had triggered deadly white violence against Black voters, organizers and officeholders in the decades since the war. But in Wilmington, a city of 20,000, the votes of 8,000 Black men helped a rare biracial “Fusion” alliance elect candidates of both races.
Three of the 10 aldermen were Black. The city had Black health inspectors, postmasters, magistrates and policemen, albeit under orders not to arrest anyone white. The county coroner, jailer and treasurer were Black, as was the register of deeds. Black businesspeople pooled their money in three Black-owned banks. Families a generation removed from enslavement owned their homes and read a local Black newspaper.
As modern-day Wilmingtonian Tim Pinnick, a genealogist, put it: “Things functioned the way they were meant to function as a result of Emancipation.”
Planning a coup
But if Wilmington looked to some Americans like a model for the south, powerful white leaders, including the president of Wilmington Cotton Mills Company, the editor of the Raleigh News & Observer and the chairman of the state Democratic party, could not abide it. They set out to topple what the newspaper editor labeled “Negro rule”.
One hundred and twenty-five years ago, on 10 November 1898, a shocking coup d’état was executed.
The plotters had set the stage by creating what they called the “white supremacy campaign”. They printed falsehoods about Black men preying on white women and stockpiling guns. They targeted the Fusion officeholders and the Black newspaper, summoned militias and white vigilantes known as Red Shirts, and terrorized Black voters at the polls.
“If you see the negro out voting tomorrow, tell him stop,” one of the leaders, former Confederate colonel Alfred Moore Waddell, told a gun-waving white audience on the eve of Wilmington’s 1898 election. “If he doesn’t, shoot him down. Shoot him down in his tracks.” Waddell vowed to “choke the current of the Cape Fear River” with Black bodies if he had to.
On 10 November, Red Shirts, militiamen and white mobs surged through Wilmington’s streets and massacred 60 or more Black men. “They gave their lives to vote,” said Hesketh “Nate” Brown, a retired New York City transit manager whose great-great-grandfather, Joshua Halsey, tried to flee the militiamen.
The Red Shirts torched the Black newspaper’s office, posed for pictures in front of its smoking ruins, installed Waddell as mayor, and sent hundreds of Black residents fleeing into the woods. Some ran west toward the river; others, east to the Black cemetery. Athalia Howe was 12 when her family and others took refuge in Pine Forest, a cemetery that dated back to the period before Emancipation. It was said that families sheltered next to graves of their loved ones.
Uncovering a history of racial injustice
For years no one in Howe’s family said much about those events, as her great-granddaughter, Cynthia Brown, told the Washington Post. But one day, when she was about eight years old, a distant look filled her great-grandmother’s eyes and she grabbed Brown’s wrist.
“If it ever happens again, run!” Brown remembered her shouting. “Don’t let it happen to you!”
Brown set out to discover what “it” was.
So did Pinnick, the genealogist and Black schoolteacher from Illinois who learned of the coup in recent years when he retired to Wilmington. And Nate Brown, the retired transit manager who found his great-great-grandfather’s name in an 1898 newspaper clipping about the “race war”. (The article blamed Black “aggressors”.) And Sonya Patrick-AmenRa, who counts among her ancestors four soldiers of the United States Colored Troops who helped win the civil war.
Now, Brown, Brown (they are not related), Pinnick, AmenRa and other Wilmingtonians, along with ministers, activists, authors, educators and a documentary film-maker whose ancestor aided the plotters, are helping change the historical narrative.
Over the last two decades, a school and park named after leaders who directed the murder of dozens of Black people have been renamed. Community activists have set out to learn the names of everyone who was killed and every Black Wilmingtonian who survived the 1898 massacre. They are marking the coup’s 125th anniversary, 10 November, with a week of events that include “racial-equity and trauma training”, documentary film showings and descendants’ stories.
“There is a need to focus on that horrible day to understand it,” Pinnick said. “And yet, it’s a testimony to surviving that the story should be told.”
For nearly a century the story was told falsely – in textbooks, clippings and memoirs that cast the horrific violence as a spontaneous “riot” and the plotters as heroes who restored racial order to Wilmington.
In 2006, a state-commissioned report debunked the longstanding false narratives about Wilmington’s history.
Even so, Deborah Dicks Maxwell, president of the county’s NAACP chapter, said many local residents still don’t know about it. “This is Wilmington,” she told USA Today last year. “There’s a distance to progress.”
That was evident in the unguarded words of three white Wilmington police officers in 2020, weeks after George Floyd’s killing. A routine audit of patrol-car videotapes revealed the longtime officers discussing killing “f—ing n—s”.
A civil war was coming, Officer Michael Piner said: “We are just gonna go out and start slaughtering them f—ing n—s.” The officers told investigators they had been “venting” and blamed the “stress of today’s climate in law enforcement”.
Wilmington’s first Black police chief fired them in his first week on the job.
Their words were “painful, hurtful”, Chief Donny Williams, a Wilmington officer for nearly three decades, told NPR. “Being from this community, and then working alongside these people for so long, so just hurt – and not just me.”
A legacy of political violence
The full toll of the 1898 massacre and the political legacy it created is still not known.
Estimates of the number of Black people killed range from dozens to hundreds. The state’s 2006 study described the coup in detail and blamed all levels of government for not intervening; it said Black merchants and workers “suffered losses after 1898 in terms of job status, income, and access to capital”. Black businesses moved or closed. Some 2,100 Black residents fled. Black literacy rates plunged.
By the turn of the century, southern states were using poll taxes, literacy tests and grandfather clauses to deny Black men the right to vote, which the 15th amendment had guaranteed them since 1870. Between 1896 and 1902, the number of Black voters registered in North Carolina fell from 126,000 to 6,100. Wilmington did not elect another Black candidate until 1972.
The violence in Wilmington was not unique. Historians and EJI researchers have documented at least 34 instances of mass violence during Reconstruction where scores of Black people were murdered by white mobs intent on re-establishing white supremacy and resisting Black political participation. It is a history that is not well-known but critically relevant for understanding the continuing struggle for racial justice and the many obstacles that still remain.”
Becky G – Bella Ciao (From the Netflix Series “Casa de Papel”)
The Wilmington massacre of 1898: a shocking episode of racist violence:
North Carolina city marks 125th anniversary of the white-supremacist attack with a week of memorial events
June 7 2026 In the Shadow of the Battle of Delaney Hall, the First Anniversary of the Battle of Los Angeles For the Soul Of America and the Freedom of the World: ICE Versus The People
January 23 2026 Liberty Versus the ICE White Supremacist Terror Force of the Fourth Reich In the Battle of Minneapolis: the Case of Liam Ramos and the Three Thousand Eight Hundred Stolen Children
June 12 2025 Why We Fight: Authorized Versus Chosen And Ambiguous National Identities As a Ground of Struggle, Symbolized By the Mexican Flag In the Battle of Los Angeles
April 17 2025 Trump Regime Tests Its Power to Violate the Constitution and Abduct and Imprison Without Cause Or Trial Any Random Person and All Of Us: Case of Kilmar Ábrego García
September 3 2024 Anniversary of the Assassination of Antifascist Comrade Michael Reinoehl: Violence, Responsibility, the Social Use of Force, and Our Duty of Care For Others